Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't want more children, but I don't know if I'll forever regret not having a daughter.

206 replies

potofivy · 17/04/2022 19:14

Firstly, I know children are all individuals, and I actually can't place exactly why I want a daughter.

I have two beautiful boys whom I love dearly.

I'm pretty sure two children is the perfect number for us. I also know that even if we had a third, there's a 50/50 chance it'd be another boy.

How can I just be happy with what I've got?!

OP posts:
MurmuratingStarling · 17/04/2022 23:06

@sevencontinents my post there ^ wasn't aimed at you by the way, it was in response to what you said.. that the OP's posts are not particularly rude.

MurmuratingStarling · 17/04/2022 23:05

@sevencontinents

I don't really understand why some posters are shocked by the OP's rude response. Posters give rude responses ALL the time on MN. Am I missing something? Was this response even ruder than the norm on AIBU?
People keep banging on about the OP's response to hunderland's post, it as if she has stamped on a kitten. She doesn't need to keep being told by finger-wagging self-righteous posters that she was soooo rude to 'hunderland' FFS, all the OP said was 'good for you' in response to that poster saying she had 2 boys, and the third child was a girl...!

A few posters have come on here purely to have a go at the OP for her one response to hunderland, and have contributed nothing else to the thread whatsover. Which is VERY strange.. (I am looking at YOU @Giviningup @Sisisimone @Kittromney and @SilverSusie !)

How many more people are going to have a poke at the OP for that ONE comment? It really is looking more pathetic every time someone says something about it now. Especially those posters who have trotted on to the thread PURELY to have a dig at the OP for that one comment, and to offer NOTHING else.

And can people just stop with the passive-aggressive 'be thankful you HAVE 2 children, I only have one, and some people have none' type comments?! They are supremely unhelpful and bring nothing to the thread.

Needtogetoffmyphone · 17/04/2022 23:03

@oakleaffy
That is completely true - personality matters a whole lot more than what sex the child is.

oakleaffy · 17/04/2022 22:58

@SoggyPaper

I’ve got 3 boys. People assume I should be disappointed sometimes. I’m not. They’re great.
I was massively pleased to have a boy, too.

Girls can be wonderful, though.
Just depends of the child, their nature, rather than what sex they are.

Hankunamatata · 17/04/2022 22:52

I must be weird though as my 1st pregnancy I wanted a girl and got a boy. After that I wanted boys. Perhaps I felt I knew baby boys 🤷‍♀️. I was a bit worried/scared with pregnancy 2 and 3 might be girls. Again not sure why, perhaps I just fell in love so much with ds1

Rupertgrintismyguiltypleasure · 17/04/2022 22:45

@silentpool

There is also no guarantee of the "mother - daughter" relationship. It does happen but in a lot of cases, it's pretty fraught due to the expectations put on the daughter by the mother.
This... I have an amazing relationship with my mum, we actually live together... yes she winds me up but I wouldn’t have it any other way... however I know several people that have horrific relationships with thier mums.
Hankunamatata · 17/04/2022 22:43

3 boys and no desire for a girl. My boys are so much fun even now they are older but I'm not a girly girl who liked doing hair and talking clothes. Is much rather be out on bikes or at the trampoline park. All mine like crafts too so they sew and make things. My teen rather fancies a spa day and facial with me even though he is a big rugby player Grin

Rupertgrintismyguiltypleasure · 17/04/2022 22:43

I’m lucky I have one of each... so never felt the need for a 3rd child however there was a time I was worried about what dd would turn out to be.
DP is one of 3 boys
His older brother has 2 daughters
He’s the middle with one of each
And his younger with 2 boys
His dad is the only boy with 2 sisters
His mum only had one brother
I have 3 brothers and 2 sisters
My mum had 1 sister, one brother
And my dad had 2 brothers and 1 sister.
More boys than girls so I was convinced i would have 2 boys. Sometimes I wish I did because girls are actually harder in my opinion 🤣

Hollywolly1 · 17/04/2022 22:39

Of course you are completely delighted with your 2 boys but I'd say you'd love to experience having a baby girl and nothing wrong with that,sure if you get a boy of course you'll love him

silentpool · 17/04/2022 22:31

There is also no guarantee of the "mother - daughter" relationship. It does happen but in a lot of cases, it's pretty fraught due to the expectations put on the daughter by the mother.

Dramaticpenguin · 17/04/2022 22:29

I was told it was more like 70% chance you get the same sex again if you have the same dad. And I ignored that and am now a mum of 3 boys. I kind of knew he would be a boy, but I did allow myself hope. You have to not mind too much of you go for it. I kept my cry to the one day I found out and try not to think about the girl I'll never have too often. X

Yotrotro · 17/04/2022 22:27

My aunt and uncle had 6 girls hoping to get a boy. Unfortunately all the girls grew up knowing/feeling they didn't quite live up to their parents wants, as it was much talked about in the family growing up (mostly boys in the rest of the family).

My good childhood friend was one of 5, the last being a much tried for boy. Her mum was told having more children would be risky after no 3 but she continued to try for a boy. They struggled to fall pregnant after the 4th girl and so there's almost 20yrs between eldest and youngest. Unfortunately the mum suffered a major stroke and other ongoing issues as a result of the pregnancy/birth and will never lead an independent life as a result. There's a lot of resentment from the older girls about their quality of life as a result, and a lot of pressure on the boy to be perfect.

Not saying your feelings are as extreme OP, but I think they can snowball and people can become obsessed, to the detriment of their earlier DC which is so so sad.

Soringhaze · 17/04/2022 22:26

@Twocrabs30 I agree. The last statistic I read was 80% of women using gender selection were after a girl which in itself is interesting. I think Italy, Mexico and Thailand also offer 'family balancing' gender selection.

Katya213 · 17/04/2022 22:24

@potofivy

I don't like the expectation that 'we're going to try again' just because we have two of the same sex either.

It's like people feel sorry for me or something, makes me feel like I'm missing out when in reality I know that's not the case

Lol but you’ve just asked “how can I I be happy with what I’ve got?” Now you’re saying people make you feel like you’re missing out when you know that’s not the case?
Palease · 17/04/2022 22:09

@Lavenderlid

I don't think I miss the experience of raising a girl, but I do sometimes think of life when they are adults - maybe on here too much but being the "mil" rather than the dm, and being the grandparent they don't see as much of does worry me. Of course I will try to be the perfect mil (if this happens at all) but I do think it is harder to maintain the relationship than if I had a dd. Female socialisation and all that. Plus I loved my own mum so much and I definitely kept in touch with her more than her sons.
Yes this does worry me a bit. I wonder why this happens? Is it because men are shamed if they are close to their mums? Then it’s something us boy mums need to shine a light on and educate them that it’s good to be close to their Mums. Or maybe it’s because women tend to be the one in charge in the household and men default to what their wife wants them to do. Again. We need to raise our boys to be equal players in a marriage and be confident.

Anyone else any ideas why this happens? People used say a daughters a daughter for life, a sons a son til he finds a wife.

Piglet89 · 17/04/2022 22:04

I always thought I wanted a girl. Then I suffered fertility problems and got told We would be very unlikely to conceive spontaneously.

Then it happened completely unexpectedly and we had our little boy. He’s so unlike me, honestly - as a poster upthread said - he’s into cars and trains and emergency services. He also never ever sits still and drives me mental.

But he’s perfect and I wouldn’t change him one iota.

sevencontinents · 17/04/2022 22:04

@Countdownis35
No you're not missing anything. I am not excusing the OP's response, I have just rarely seen so many posters pick another poster up on their rudeness unless the post in question is blatantly disgusting. I quite like it, actually, because AIBU can be unnecessarily rude at times.

SilverSusie · 17/04/2022 22:03

@Hunderland - OP sounds like a real gem of a woman!

Lavenderlid · 17/04/2022 22:03

I don't think I miss the experience of raising a girl, but I do sometimes think of life when they are adults - maybe on here too much but being the "mil" rather than the dm, and being the grandparent they don't see as much of does worry me. Of course I will try to be the perfect mil (if this happens at all) but I do think it is harder to maintain the relationship than if I had a dd. Female socialisation and all that. Plus I loved my own mum so much and I definitely kept in touch with her more than her sons.

phoenixrosehere · 17/04/2022 22:03

And OP clearly said she doesn’t want more children and asked for advice on how to be happy with what she has. So I can’t see how it was a useful response at all.

Agree nor do I think OP was asking for sympathy either.

felulageller · 17/04/2022 22:01

There are ways to increase the chances of having a girl. Get DH to have a sperm check.

Certain special positions and timing of sex in your cycle increase your chances.

It won't work every time but worked for me.

Palease · 17/04/2022 21:59

I have 2 boys and I often briefly consider trying for another to have a girl. Then I ask myself “what do I want a girl for?” The answer is because I want my child to be like me. DS1 likes cars and trains and isn’t interested in books reading, drawing etc like I am. However DS2 who’s still a baby might like those things.

I also know I’d probably have a breakdown if I had another baby. I cannot cope with broken sleep any more.

Someone said on another thread how she looked on it as she’d been given a gift of boys to raise who were going to make great husbands; who weren’t afraid to share their feelings, who didn’t feel burdened with toxic masculinity who would be proud of their close relationship with their mum and know terms like mummy’s boy were sexist (mummy’s girl anyone?).

needhelp34 · 17/04/2022 21:57

I was in your position and I decided to go for a third because I wanted a third child, not because I was trying to have a girl. I thought I was completely comfortable with the idea of 3 boys. I was told at an early scan it was a girl, I then found out later it was a boy. I went through the loss of the girl I had attached too. It does feel like being told it was a girl was what made that hard but maybe I would have felt that anyway. I wouldn’t swap my boys for anything, I’m glad they are who they are but I will forever feel the loss of not having a daughter.

If you did have a third you need to be 100% happy with the idea of having three boys to even consider it. Because even if you are content with that you’ll still feel the loss that you’ll never have the experience of a daughter

Twocrabs30 · 17/04/2022 21:54

@Soringhaze
I think the only other country to the US that does gender selection is Turkey, and part of Cyprus. I am of the view that if you feel especially strong about this, it is always an option.

Given for me, and many, that fertility was not a ‘natural experience’ anyway, I don’t feel particularly concerned if you wanted to add gender selection into the process.

PreschoolMum4 · 17/04/2022 21:49

@MurmuratingStarling I have all girls and get asked constantly if I’m going to ‘try for a boy’ 😅 I just smile and say I’ll wait for grandsons now!

Swipe left for the next trending thread