Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't want more children, but I don't know if I'll forever regret not having a daughter.

206 replies

potofivy · 17/04/2022 19:14

Firstly, I know children are all individuals, and I actually can't place exactly why I want a daughter.

I have two beautiful boys whom I love dearly.

I'm pretty sure two children is the perfect number for us. I also know that even if we had a third, there's a 50/50 chance it'd be another boy.

How can I just be happy with what I've got?!

OP posts:
potofivy · 18/04/2022 03:32

@alanabennett

FWIW, my colleagues wife felt the same way as you. Two lovely boys but desperate for a girl so tried for number three.

She is now three months pregnant. With twins.

They are freaking out and need to move house and buy a bigger car within the next six months. Just to give another perspective 😀

Worst nightmare!
OP posts:
MarianosOnHisWay · 18/04/2022 03:30

@Palease

I have 2 boys and I often briefly consider trying for another to have a girl. Then I ask myself “what do I want a girl for?” The answer is because I want my child to be like me. DS1 likes cars and trains and isn’t interested in books reading, drawing etc like I am. However DS2 who’s still a baby might like those things.

I also know I’d probably have a breakdown if I had another baby. I cannot cope with broken sleep any more.

Someone said on another thread how she looked on it as she’d been given a gift of boys to raise who were going to make great husbands; who weren’t afraid to share their feelings, who didn’t feel burdened with toxic masculinity who would be proud of their close relationship with their mum and know terms like mummy’s boy were sexist (mummy’s girl anyone?).

Well, your DS might be into trains and cars now but I assume he’s under 5yo? He’s unlikely to be into trains when he’s 15 or 25 or 35 (although he might still be, of course, in a different way) and he might then get into reading and drawing and find some common ground with yourself. Don’t write off finding common interests while he is a young child.
namechangeranonymouse · 18/04/2022 03:27

Actually it's not 50/50. Statistically if your first is of one sex the second is more likely to be of the same sex and the shutdown even more likely to be a boy. Sorry. Look around. How many boy/boy and girl/girl families do you know. My friend has just had her third girl because her husband was desperate for a boy.

alanabennett · 18/04/2022 03:25

FWIW, my colleagues wife felt the same way as you. Two lovely boys but desperate for a girl so tried for number three.

She is now three months pregnant. With twins.

They are freaking out and need to move house and buy a bigger car within the next six months. Just to give another perspective 😀

potofivy · 18/04/2022 03:13

Most women I know had awful relationships with their mothers growing up,

This includes me. I think I've always wanted a girl to in some way repair the fact I've never had a good 'mother-daughter' relationship. Which is no reason to bring a child into the world anyway.

Essentially I'm sticking with two unless there is an accidental pregnancy at some point which is unlikely given our fertility issues.

My boys are absolutely gorgeous. I'll have to make sure we are still close when they're adults!

OP posts:
potofivy · 18/04/2022 03:08

Absolutely right.When you think of the women who cannot have children at ALL, for whatever reason, it seems very 'ungrateful' to be wanting a third child, when one already has two.

Be thankful for what one has.

I am grateful. We needed IVF for our second due to secondary infertility. I also suffered a miscarriage before my successful second pregnancy.

OP posts:
potofivy · 18/04/2022 02:59

OP is expecting sympathy it's a bit rich don't you think?

Am I?

OP posts:
AlternativePerspective · 18/04/2022 01:55

Is it just me who looks at the length of a thread and skips to the end to see how it’s been derailed? Never ceases to disappoint. Hmm

Back to the OP, I’ve never understood this wish for a daughter, I actually can’t get my head around it. Just what is it that people want in a daughter that a son won’t give you?

I have one DS, but IME the people with DD’s find them far more difficult. The moods/hormones as teenagers for a start, and often the hostility towards their mothers growing up.

Most women I know had awful relationships with their mothers growing up, and even if that’s different now, it usually takes an awfully long time to get there.

Plus haven’t we as women moved past all this girly crap? I mean really…

cruelladevill · 18/04/2022 01:38

Jesus this is so weird

I have 2 sons and I have never NEVER ONCE felt like I wanted or needed a girl

I've just felt content that I have two healthy children, I am very lucky for that

Strange way of thinking

CandyLeBonBon · 18/04/2022 01:11

@Siameasy

Girls seem to be almost fetishised. Apart from socialisation ie gender, the only difference is biology. Girls can like any activities/clothes they want, may or may not be close to their mums, there are no guarantees and having 3 kids is unreasonable and unnecessary imo especially when it’s obvious you are projecting gender stereotypes onto female children.
Absolutely this. My now exH absolutely treated his dd differently to our first x2 ds. He was obsessed with having a girl because his mother made it abundantly clear she'd have preferred him to be a girl.

It's had long lasting repercussions that our kids are feeling.

707smile · 18/04/2022 00:39

Do you think you'd be significantly more unhappy with three sons than two?

If not, then you would have a slightly less than 50% chance of your dream of a DD, a slightly more than 50% chance of things being fairly similar but with another baby boy so it might be worth considering. At least you wouldn't be stuck with the doubt of what could have been forever.

JellyBunny · 18/04/2022 00:37

All families are different and not everyone gets a daughter. Not everyone gets to have a son. Try to be happy with what you have.

Siameasy · 18/04/2022 00:32

Girls seem to be almost fetishised. Apart from socialisation ie gender, the only difference is biology. Girls can like any activities/clothes they want, may or may not be close to their mums, there are no guarantees and having 3 kids is unreasonable and unnecessary imo especially when it’s obvious you are projecting gender stereotypes onto female children.

CandyLeBonBon · 18/04/2022 00:24

The op, it seems, was ousting for support to get her over the fact that she only wants two and they're both going to be boys, and she doesn't want to try for a third because she's done, yes?

Another poster gave their perspective in a fairly innocuous way and the op was like 'yeah? Good for you!' (I'm paraphrasing'

There was no need for the op to be snippy. The pp wasn't being nasty.

I think that's where it's gone a bit wrong?

JaneJeffer · 18/04/2022 00:17

Ok. Good for you?
Was going to reply until I saw this. Why so nasty?

Isonthecase · 18/04/2022 00:11

The expectation that you're trying for a girl with a third is was worse than with two, virtually everyone I know said they were hoping we'd get a girl. I was pleased to find out that I genuinely didn't mind - I still get pangs about not having a girl but I'm genuinely pleased to be having three boys when I wasn't thrilled to be having two.

It has helped as they've got older and so clearly been their own people rather than just a specific sex so I tie a lot less importance to that. It also helps realising that most of the reason you want a girl is due to internalised sexism as fundamentally they shouldn't be that different.

oakleaffy · 17/04/2022 23:43

@bellamountain

I have 2 boys and can't get my head around this way of thinking, especially when my youngest spent a considerable amount of time in hospital as a baby. They are just so precious and you are so bloody fortunate.
Absolutely right. When you think of the women who cannot have children at ALL, for whatever reason, it seems very 'ungrateful' to be wanting a third child, when one already has two.

Be thankful for what one has.

surreygirl1987 · 17/04/2022 23:37

I don't like the expectation that 'we're going to try again' just because we have two of the same sex either.

It's like people feel sorry for me or something, makes me feel like I'm missing out when in reality I know that's not the case

I have NEVER experienced this! I am in a similar boat to you, OP - I have two boys and I have always wanted a girl. But, although I occasionally feel a little pang about not having a daughter, I do feel it is right to stop at 2. I only wanted two children, and I hate the thought of going through all that again. My little boys are delightful and I would never in a million years exchange my youngest for the girl I was hoping for - he's just the sweetest little thing in the world! When I found out at my 20 week scan it was a boy, I was pretty gutted, and I do think gender disappointment is real, but I think trying to have perspective helps a lot too. I have friends with babies with awful heath conditions or who were stillborn or serious disabled etc, and reflecting on that has made me realise how lucky I am.

MurmuratingStarling · 17/04/2022 23:33

[quote Hunderland]@MurmuratingStarling I think it's more likely they came on to say something, thought the comment to me was uncalled for and decided against it...[/quote]
Hmm maybe. Just seems a bit weird to go onto a thread purely to have a pop at the OP for one post and not contribute anything else to the thread. And FOUR people did it too which seemed odd. (to me.) Maybe one yeah, possibly even two, but FOUR? Seemed a bit weird (IMO.) Especially as they ALL referred to the same post.

And then a load more posters kept banging on at her too. There was literally nothing wrong with what the OP said to you, (IMO,) so I don't 'get' why so many people are finger-wagging at the OP and scolding her.

Anyway, I've said my piece so that's it from me.

But I genuinely was NOT accusing you of being multiple posters.(Honestly...) Smile

Countdownis35 · 17/04/2022 23:32

The irony passive aggressive Grin some people ought to look that defination up for a start!

Painiscrap · 17/04/2022 23:27

I went to school with a girl who’s df was desperate for sons! She had 5 sisters, before child number 7 turned out to be a boy. They then thought they had cracked it and had another child, hoping for a second son, but unfortunately it was another girl. So 8 children, just because their father wanted sons!

I think it was incredibly sad, that her father didn’t think his daughters were enough!

Hunderland · 17/04/2022 23:25

@MurmuratingStarling I think it's more likely they came on to say something, thought the comment to me was uncalled for and decided against it...

MurmuratingStarling · 17/04/2022 23:15

[quote Hunderland]**@MurmuratingStarling* If you're implying I'm those other posters mentioned who posted supportive comments, please do check with @mumsnet* - I can assure you I'm not.[/quote]
No I am NOT implying that at all. I just think it's strange that a bunch of posters have come onto a thread just to have a pop at the OP for ONE comment she made, and have not contributed anything else to the thread. I never MENTIONED you being those 4 posters. That never even entered my head.

bellamountain · 17/04/2022 23:13

I have 2 boys and can't get my head around this way of thinking, especially when my youngest spent a considerable amount of time in hospital as a baby. They are just so precious and you are so bloody fortunate.

Hunderland · 17/04/2022 23:11

@MurmuratingStarling If you're implying I'm those other posters mentioned who posted supportive comments, please do check with @mumsnet - I can assure you I'm not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread