Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think eating 1500 cals daily is unsustainable?

387 replies

savedbythewell · 17/04/2022 18:44

And if you disagree, how do you do it?
How do you satisfy your appetite and what weight loss is reasonable monthly, if three stone overweight

OP posts:
lightisnotwhite · 17/04/2022 21:45

@PurpleDaisies The motivation matters quite a bit.

If you are losing weight to meet some sort of ideal it’s very easy to give up when you don’t get a thigh gap or flat stomach after a month or two.

If someone says you’re going have to do blood tests and take medication everyday or your bottom itches because of all the sugar, it’s much easier to change habits.

FairyLightPups · 17/04/2022 21:45

[quote EssexLioness]@FairyLightPups do you have a recipe for the almond flour pancakes please? They sound really nice[/quote]
Here you go! I just buy ground almonds from tesco, and they work well. If you're not eating lower carb (I'm insulin resistant because of my PCOS so have to eat low carb), I'd advise adding a fruit syrup and a bigger portion of frozen berries.

www.delish.com/cooking/recipe-ideas/recipes/a58712/keto-pancakes-recipe/

nokidshere · 17/04/2022 21:43

I eat between 1200-1300 cals a day. I'm rarely hungry on this and I have lost 21lbs since mid Jan. I'm disabled though with very limited mobility.

I always have protein (eggs, bacon, with mushrooms) for breakfast around 11am

Mid afternoon I have celery, apple & peanut butter or crackers/cheese

Normal evening meal like spag Bol, or fish with vegetables/rice.

I snack on wotsits and aero choc mousse.

It's slow going but I always lose a lb or two each week.

FairyLightPups · 17/04/2022 21:43

[quote northernruth]@FairyLightPups so glad you're finding something that works for you and is making you feel good. My weight fluctuates within a narrow band but when it creeps up that's a red flag that I'm not eating healthily and usually coincides with a period of stress or low mood. Sorting the eating usually makes me feel a lot better in myself as well as shifting a few pounds[/quote]
Yes, and I think one thing that gets conflated with weight loss is calories taking a bigger precedent than the nutrition. People don't eat enough vegetables and don't meet their nutritional goals and that matters a lot more than eating incredibly low calorie but not even eating an apple.

People don't feel full because their bodies aren't getting the nutritional things they need. Because they're eating things their bodies reject. If you're going to eat carbs on carbs or fat on fat of course your body isn't going to be happy. Variety is so important and a good variety/balance will often mean you're eating lower calorie anyway.

EssexLioness · 17/04/2022 21:43

@FairyLightPups do you have a recipe for the almond flour pancakes please? They sound really nice

JollyWilloughby · 17/04/2022 21:42

@MissyCooperismyShero

It is true it’s how I lost 4 stone. I didn’t reduce my calories but I did make changes to the quality of my diet. I stopped all my cardio, reduced my stress levels, got good sleep and started a weight training programme 2-3 times a week.

Roominmyhouse · 17/04/2022 21:42

I’ve been eating 1500 a day roughly since the start of the year and have lost 12.8lbs. I actually think I can eat quite a good amount of food and don’t feel I’m starving myself. A typical day is porridge with semi skimmed milk for breakfast, a bagel thin with tuna and low fat mayo for lunch plus an apple. Mid afternoon I usually have a kvarg and then a normal dinner of 6-700 calories. In the evening I might have a snack of around 100 calories. I only really drink tea, the odd can of cherry Pepsi max and lots of water.

Mirrorball2022 · 17/04/2022 21:42

[quote JollyWilloughby]@Autumndays123

Hmm point taken but when I had that office life (and I didn’t train) I used to do silly diets and aim for 1500 and it used to make me feel nauseous and dizzy.

I think women fuck their metabolisms up so they have no choice but to eat like birds for the forseeable.

If anyone is interested in a way to improve your metabolism, lose weight and not eat like a bird please read Dr Jenkinsons book “why we eat too much”.

I lost 4 stone following these principles.[/quote]
I’m with you. I do exercise well and walk a lot aswell as having an active job. I don’t think we have to eat so low calorie I do think alot have dieted so much their metabolism is buggered onto low calories. I’ve never dieted. I’ve been a 14. Currently a 10-12. Nutrition and exercise/health mean more to me than my clothes size though.

samthebordercollie · 17/04/2022 21:41

@pattish

There are SO many threads about calorie counting at the moment. It’s so damaging.

If you eat fewer and fewer calories your body will adjust its base metabolic rate and conserve them (in simple terms). This is why there are so many threads on Quora by teenage girls asking why they are not losing weight when they only eat 1000 calories a day. It’s heartbreaking.

Please stop to think what you are doing to your body.

If you want to lose weight, eat good quality protein, good fat like olive oil and avocado, lots of veg and plenty of seeds, nuts and fermented foods until you are pretty much full. Then do the same at the next meal.

At last a common sense post. It isn't just how many calories you eat, it's the quality of food and how good it is for you ( and your gut micro biome). If you eat 1500 calories of refined carbs and sugar you will be causing immense harm to your pancreas and insulin production, as well as your gut. Eat foods high in fibre, protein and good fats, don't count the calories ( you won't need to as you will feel full). And keep active.
northernruth · 17/04/2022 21:38

@FairyLightPups so glad you're finding something that works for you and is making you feel good. My weight fluctuates within a narrow band but when it creeps up that's a red flag that I'm not eating healthily and usually coincides with a period of stress or low mood. Sorting the eating usually makes me feel a lot better in myself as well as shifting a few pounds

MissyCooperismyShero · 17/04/2022 21:38

@pattish

There are SO many threads about calorie counting at the moment. It’s so damaging.

If you eat fewer and fewer calories your body will adjust its base metabolic rate and conserve them (in simple terms). This is why there are so many threads on Quora by teenage girls asking why they are not losing weight when they only eat 1000 calories a day. It’s heartbreaking.

Please stop to think what you are doing to your body.

If you want to lose weight, eat good quality protein, good fat like olive oil and avocado, lots of veg and plenty of seeds, nuts and fermented foods until you are pretty much full. Then do the same at the next meal.

Pretty much none of this is true.
JollyWilloughby · 17/04/2022 21:38

@pattish

Yes this is why I can maintain on 2500/3000. I just eat to appetite but when I have tracked it’s around that amount. If I didn’t lift weights I would probably be looking at around 2000 calories to maintain with good quality food.

You eat 1500 a day and your basic metabolic rate will just reduce and you’ll have to work harder and you WILL start gaining once you go over it.

Cherms · 17/04/2022 21:37

Doing Noom I'm sticking to 1200 most days and I'm still enjoying life. I thought it would be harder but making the right choices means a full tummy of veggies for less than 100 calories.

MissyCooperismyShero · 17/04/2022 21:37

@ZeroCaffeine

No not at all. I eat around 1400 normally, 1200 if I’m trying to lose weight and those targets are recommended going by my TDEE. I’d GAIN weight on 1500 a day
This exactly. Perhaps depends on your age op, but I would maintain weight at 1500 cals and definitely not lose anything, but then I am sixty.
SilverDoe · 17/04/2022 21:35

I would recommend losing at a slower pace so you can up your calories, and also introducing some kind of intermittent fasting programme in order for you to have a psychological break from eating low calories. So 5:2, or similar.

It is hard but I've given up on super low calorie goals and would rather lose weight at half the normal speed than give up and never lose it.

pattish · 17/04/2022 21:34

There are SO many threads about calorie counting at the moment. It’s so damaging.

If you eat fewer and fewer calories your body will adjust its base metabolic rate and conserve them (in simple terms). This is why there are so many threads on Quora by teenage girls asking why they are not losing weight when they only eat 1000 calories a day. It’s heartbreaking.

Please stop to think what you are doing to your body.

If you want to lose weight, eat good quality protein, good fat like olive oil and avocado, lots of veg and plenty of seeds, nuts and fermented foods until you are pretty much full. Then do the same at the next meal.

FairyLightPups · 17/04/2022 21:33

I'm 5ft and massively overweight. My TDEE is 1.4k. Also trying to lose weight and eating 1.1k. When it's on a plate it feels like LOADS because it's so varied and ticks all the nutritional boxes. I'm sure if I ate 1.1k of bread or chocolate I'd feel it was unstainable but my diet is interesting and varied. Here's a breakdown:

  • Breakfast: Ground almond flour pancakes with mixed frozen berries & chia seeds
  • Lunch: Caesar salad with vegan bacon
  • Dinner: Salmon or haddock with roast sweet potato, carrot, broccoli, red onion, garlic
  • Snacks (which I usually eat with lunch): 2x marinated chicken fillet pieces, sugar snap peas, guacamole, fridge raiders, cheese marmite bites, marmite cashews, a boiled egg, 1/2 a fibre one chocolate fudge brownie
  • Drinks: Lots of water, a green tea, a lemon & ginger tea, a chamomile tea

Plus magnesium, multivitamins, probiotic, tumeric, vitamin D, and inositol.

I feel amazing. I have binge eating disorder and PCOS, and I'm eating much, much less but I've never felt so full. I look forward to eating every single day for the first time in my life. My meals and snacks are both delicious and very, very well balanced.

So yes, eating 1.5k cal is completely sustainable. Food and nutrition is never a one size fits all. Everyone will have different needs for their own body.

PurpleDaisies · 17/04/2022 21:31

@lightisnotwhite

pressed too soon… The reason for “dieting” is people want to look good.

Whereas it should be health reasons, less risk of disease.

Who cares what the motivation is? Whether it’s because you want to look better on the beach or reduce your risk of cancer/diabetes/whatever, you’ll still get the health benefits.
Hotelhelp · 17/04/2022 21:31

I always see people saying things like this and I do accept I'm completely in the minority here but 1500 is enough for three good meals a day so why shouldn't it be enough? If you can go without snacks or pick low calorie ones.

Meals out and occasions would cause issues but I think day to day it is doable!

lightisnotwhite · 17/04/2022 21:29

pressed too soon… The reason for “dieting” is people want to look good.

Whereas it should be health reasons, less risk of disease.

WouldBeGood · 17/04/2022 21:26

Calculate your daily calorie goal on the James smith academy free calculator. Aim to lose a pound a week.

Eat healthily with lots of protein to fill you up.

lightisnotwhite · 17/04/2022 21:25

@Undisclosedlocation

Unsustainable long term, which is why the vast majority of diets fail.

Weight loss at a slower rate but while forming habits that you can live with for the rest of your life is the better way imo.

It’s not unsustainable! I wasn’t hungry or deprived on 800 calories. It’s 3 meals a day, of veg and protein.

The reason for losing weight changes though. If you go back to thinking you actually rather eat whatever you like then the weight goes back on.
It’s not that 800 -1000 calories is too little ( like 10,000 steps for most people). It’s just that we live in a world full of delicious calorific crap.

The reason for “dieting”

Patchbatch · 17/04/2022 21:24

Your life’s purpose is not weight loss. There are a lot of people making a lot of money from you hating your bodies

It's unhealthy to be overweight though, it's not all vanity and buying into the media's perception of what looks good- I didn't hate my body when I was a tad overweight, but the opposite, I love my body and want to make sure it's as healthy as possible.

PurpleDaisies · 17/04/2022 21:23

And I dont buy into "fruit is healthy so eat loads". I like fruit but I'd rather eat chocolate so I dont try and make swaps like that.

Same! I’d rather have a smaller choc bar or eat it less often and enjoy it than have an apple.

Vulpius · 17/04/2022 21:23

It's entirely sustainable @savedbythewell, but it's boring. In fact, 1,500 calories is 500 calories more than necessary. I had a phase of ingesting 1,000 calories a day and lost a stone (I had an ED, so not necessarily advisable, but easily possible).

Breakfast: One Shredded Wheat with semi skimmed milk (leave the milk in the bowl).

Lunch: tuna sandwich using two thin slices of wholemeal bread. An apple.

Supper: anything, really (as the DC were still at home then so I didn't want to model disordered eating), but a very small portion of whatever it was.

A pot of chocolate pudding to satisfy chocolate cravings (80 kcal).

Drinks: black tea, black coffee, herbal teas.

And lots of exercise (not the gym, as I hate them - walking and cycling everywhere, which adds up to about 10 miles per day).

Very boring, but perfectly do-able.