Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think eating 1500 cals daily is unsustainable?

387 replies

savedbythewell · 17/04/2022 18:44

And if you disagree, how do you do it?
How do you satisfy your appetite and what weight loss is reasonable monthly, if three stone overweight

OP posts:
5128gap · 17/04/2022 22:20

Eat a strict vegan diet, but don't use meat or cheese substitutes or ready meals. Cook from scratch only.
Eat only wholegrain carbs. Nothing white.
Don't eat crisps or other processed savoury snacks.
Never drink calories, other than alcohol on rare nights out.
Have no more than one (vegan) sweet treat food per day.

You'll be hard pushed to exceed 1500 if you follow the above.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 17/04/2022 22:19

I shuffled off more than that over about 6 months last year eating what felt like a significantly greater number of calories.

I do exercise regularly, but what I think really helped was having to stop eating gluten for medical reasons.

Now, I can't grab any old thing off the shelf in the supermarket, I can't think fuck it and order pizza or any other takeaway, I can't have a meal deal, I can't have most crisps, I can't even have oven chips 90% of the time (just why do they put fucking wheat over everything?). And where there are GF subs, they're frequently hard to find, out of stock, taste like crap or cost an absolute fucking fortune - £3.50 for a loaf of bread, anybody? And who can really be arsed to make GF pizza dough or pay a fiver for something that's likely to already be mouldy inside the sealed plastic packet Be Free I'm looking at you here and tastes predominately of sugared cardboard anyhow?

Not being able to think 'oh, fuck it' means that my carbs are around 70% rice, 20% potatoes and 10% of GF subs. I'm not limiting those, not counting the calories in meat or fish or seafood or pulses, not worrying about fat - but I have still lost weight easily, at a slower pace so that it is sustainable, sometimes faster, sometimes nothing changes for 3 weeks. And DP feels a bit 'poor Mooncup, she can't have what I'm having, so I'll put another two types of vegetable on her plate to make it look like more'.

I am not suggesting that you cut wheat out at all. But I am suggesting that possibly not having any 'fuck it, I'm tired' or 'ooh, that sounds nice' pastry, pasta, breaded, processed or takeaway meals and sauces/packets whatsoever can mean that you see weight loss without feeling bad. Because whilst you might think you don't have many, there's a very good chance that you have far more than you realise over the course of a week.

threecupsofteaminimum · 17/04/2022 22:18

Watching with interest, I think peoples bodiless work differently which makes comparisons tricky.

PurpleDaisies · 17/04/2022 22:14

Mumsnet needs an edit. My last sentence is a mess. What is meant to say was that it’s not realistic to deny that most people want to look better than they do when they’re fatter and that motivates them to lose weight.

LethargeMarg · 17/04/2022 22:14

I'm not a calorie counter but not a huge eater and exercise regularly and lose weight when stressed which I am a lot !
The idea of a carb free breakfast is so bleak to me. I've done many a diet in my younger years and any one where I had to reduce or cut out carbs made me really miserable and hungry and to knackered to exercise

SausagePourHomme · 17/04/2022 22:13

@Justcallmebebes

I disagree. You should need no more than 1200 calories a day
don't be so daft, most people will be in a large calorie deficit on this amount. if you're not actively wanting to lose weight you would not eat so few calories.

point is the amount of calories you're expending daily varies hugely from person to person. You can get a rough idea using a tdee calculator. If you wnt to gain weight, eat more than your tdee. if you want to lose weight, eat less.

PurpleDaisies · 17/04/2022 22:12

[quote lightisnotwhite]**@PurpleDaisies

If you got a broad back or large thighs or stumpy legs it’s very hard to look like a tall skinny model regardless of how thin you get. And it’s pointless because that’s not who you are.

You can change your blood sugar or cholesterol with evidence based results within weeks. That’s actually the better version of you.[/quote]
Most overweight people look better when the e lost weight. Who is talking about looking like a skinny model? I look better slimmer.

Obviously there are health benefits and it’s great to be motivated by those too. It’s not realistic to think that most people want to look better than they do when they’re fatter.

lightisnotwhite · 17/04/2022 22:10

@PurpleDaisies

If you got a broad back or large thighs or stumpy legs it’s very hard to look like a tall skinny model regardless of how thin you get. And it’s pointless because that’s not who you are.

You can change your blood sugar or cholesterol with evidence based results within weeks. That’s actually the better version of you.

MummaOf4Horrors · 17/04/2022 22:04

@Hankunamatata

I'm on week 6 of 800cal a day and it is tough. Had the odd day of upping to 1200. Iv found easiest way is 2 meals a day. Late breakfast and an early dinner. Lots of water.
Can I ask how much weight you have lost in this time pls x
Hi246 · 17/04/2022 22:03

I eat 1500 a day in the week and more at weekends. I do this short term for a few months every now and then.
I know it's the wrong thing to do but I don't eat breakfast as never want it, so I don't want to force food in I could have later. I have a small choc treat and small glass golf wine most days even within the 1500. I have to carefully count these in though. I drink more, eat loads of salad, meat and fruit
No carbs in day but a little potato/bread/rice with evening meal (measured though and small next to protein). Have constant squash and tea on the go all day and have these first when i feel peckish as sometimes a drink will do.
I have more like 2000 on weekend days and still loose 1 to 2 pounds a week. Once I've done a stone, I stop for a while. Honestly with healthier habits I don't think I need to go back to it, but it's tough not to slip back into sugar and carbs whenever and then I end up needing to do it again.
So in answer to your question I don't think it's doable long term, so it depends on how much you need to loose. For me it's only ever 7 to 14 pounds so it's doable.

Justcallmebebes · 17/04/2022 22:03

I disagree. You should need no more than 1200 calories a day

BunnykinsDay · 17/04/2022 22:01

I agree with @pattish

Tolose weight

1 Eat real food, mainly plants, and good quality protein. Cut out processed food, ready meals (especially low calories ones) and focus on natural, raw food, lightly cooked.

2 Stop the 'treats' - you don't need them. An apple or a few grapes, or something like nuts are far better than a packet of whatsits, or a 'diet' desert.

3 Cut out most refined carbs and swap for small portions of wholegrains- rice, bread, quinoa, oats, pasta.

FairyLightPups · 17/04/2022 22:00

@Stormchaser1502

Cut processed food out and eat clean. The weight drops off healthily and is sustainable. You’ll feel energised too and not like you’re depriving yourself
This
Stormchaser1502 · 17/04/2022 21:58

Cut processed food out and eat clean. The weight drops off healthily and is sustainable.
You’ll feel energised too and not like you’re depriving yourself

northernruth · 17/04/2022 21:58

@Bwix

I checked my BMI on the NHS website (knew I was overweight and carrying too much fat around my tummy). I was given a calorie recommendation for slow steady weight loss of around 1400 per day. So that's what I'm doing. It's not the most fun in the world, but nor are obesity related illnesses so I'm sticking to my calorie limit, and it's totally do-able.

I've had my head in the sand about my unhealthy diet in the past. The food industry is very clever at convincing us we need and deserve 'treats' and to be fair I've been quite happy to believe this, as I enjoy eating. But stopping at costa for a big milky coffee (even without all the syrup shenanigans) and normalising the consumption of huge slices of cake or shortbread or cookies... that hasn't benefited my health one bit. The fact that people used to have one Easter egg in the past and now we're awash with them: that's not benefiting us. 1400 calories is okay if you make sensible choices about the food that makes up those calories.

It's not just the food industry - it's all the people that want to normalise overconsumption. It's "Mummy needs gin" posts and the whole trope about "I'd rather be fat and happy than skinny and miserable". It's people who are horrified at the thought of a diet and think that it's unhealthy and unsustainable to want to be a reasonable weight. People who eat in an unhealthy manner are invested in asserting that it's normal to do so.
fffffeeeedddduupp · 17/04/2022 21:55

I'm trying to do 1200 cals plus exercise which gives me around 1400/1500

Example

Breakfast small bowl porridge with blueberry's almonds and oat milk, decaf coffee with skimmed milk , camomile tea and water
Snack low fat crisps
Lunch homemade veg soup, small brown roll and butter, blueberries and raspberries
Snack grapes
Dinner sweet potato with butter, lettuce and carrot balsamic vinegar
Drinks tea/coffee, water , camomile tea

I do that mon - Fri and have a little extra on a weekend. It's plenty filling.

Bwix · 17/04/2022 21:54

I checked my BMI on the NHS website (knew I was overweight and carrying too much fat around my tummy). I was given a calorie recommendation for slow steady weight loss of around 1400 per day. So that's what I'm doing. It's not the most fun in the world, but nor are obesity related illnesses so I'm sticking to my calorie limit, and it's totally do-able.

I've had my head in the sand about my unhealthy diet in the past. The food industry is very clever at convincing us we need and deserve 'treats' and to be fair I've been quite happy to believe this, as I enjoy eating. But stopping at costa for a big milky coffee (even without all the syrup shenanigans) and normalising the consumption of huge slices of cake or shortbread or cookies... that hasn't benefited my health one bit. The fact that people used to have one Easter egg in the past and now we're awash with them: that's not benefiting us. 1400 calories is okay if you make sensible choices about the food that makes up those calories.

BunnykinsDay · 17/04/2022 21:54

Seen quite a few posts here where posters have a 'treat' of a low cal mousse, or fizzy drink with and/ or use artificial sweeteners.

These are BAD. They are now shown to wreck your metabolism and actually cause the same changes and cravings that normal sugar does AND push you into metabolic syndrome diseases.

If you want something sweet have the real thing, not something made in a lab, but just have a small amount - ie good quality chocolate with at least 75% cocoa content.

PurpleDaisies · 17/04/2022 21:53

[quote lightisnotwhite]**@PurpleDaisies The motivation matters quite a bit.

If you are losing weight to meet some sort of ideal it’s very easy to give up when you don’t get a thigh gap or flat stomach after a month or two.

If someone says you’re going have to do blood tests and take medication everyday or your bottom itches because of all the sugar, it’s much easier to change habits.[/quote]
Motivation is such an individual thing though. What makes someone want to lose is deeply personal. It’s often a photo that kicks it off. Wanting to look better isn’t a worse motivation than wanting to be healthier. They often go hand in hand anyway.

People still find it really difficult to make changes even when they’re having health problems due to being overweight.

felulageller · 17/04/2022 21:51

I gain if I eat over 1700.

When dieting I try for 1200 and find it so hard.

I'm constantly denying myself even on 1700.

If left to eat as I please I'd eat 2500 a day.

FairyLightPups · 17/04/2022 21:51

[quote EssexLioness]@FairyLightPups thank you! I’ve never thought of using ground almonds in pancakes[/quote]
No problem, they're lush as well, don't really taste that different to regular flour!

EssexLioness · 17/04/2022 21:50

@FairyLightPups thank you! I’ve never thought of using ground almonds in pancakes

FairyLightPups · 17/04/2022 21:50

[quote northernruth]@FairyLightPups yes - plus lurching from one sugar snack to the next means much less energy and a lack of focus for work etc (for me at least). I just gave up sugar for lent and I find that a useful reset every year[/quote]
Yep absolutely. I eat 3.5g of added sugar a day (I really love my brownies lol) and I feel so much better for it.

northernruth · 17/04/2022 21:49

@FairyLightPups yes - plus lurching from one sugar snack to the next means much less energy and a lack of focus for work etc (for me at least). I just gave up sugar for lent and I find that a useful reset every year

northernruth · 17/04/2022 21:46

@Mirrorball2022 do not assume for one minute that most people exercise. I'm in my 50s and at least half of the women I know take little or no exercise, not even walking a dog etc. This is why they have a low metabolic requirement