Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think eating 1500 cals daily is unsustainable?

387 replies

savedbythewell · 17/04/2022 18:44

And if you disagree, how do you do it?
How do you satisfy your appetite and what weight loss is reasonable monthly, if three stone overweight

OP posts:
Youdoyoutoday · 18/04/2022 08:11

I do 1400 calories a day.
Yoghurt, berries and seeds or omelette for breakfast, chicken salad with homemade yoghurt dressing or tuna and mixed bean salad for lunch and then something healthy for dinner.
No fizzy drinks, 2-3 litres of water.

I don't eat like this every day but 5/6 out of 7 so it's all about balance. You know what shit food and you know what good food is so it's about making better choices. I look at calorie labels and sometimes think this 'treat' isn't worth it but it's full of sugar, it won't fill me up and I'll probably regret it after anyway.

I lost 3 stone last year by plain and simple calorie counting, yes it's hard, can be tiresome but if you want to change, you have to put the effort in. I've had days where I think fuck it and delve in to the crap food but the next day, I forgive and forget and make better choices!

Good luck OP.

CaliforniaDrumming · 18/04/2022 08:03

I think most people in the UK have lost sight of what normal eating is, and I think 1500 calories per day is perfectly achievable if you are overweight, unless in a very high activity job.

NeurologicallySpeaking · 18/04/2022 08:02

Haven't RTFT but I am now doing intermittent fasting and keeping to the low calorie count is so much easier eating only two meals. I was always having unhealthy breakfasts so decided to just cut breakfast out more or less and drink loads of water.

sHREDDIES19 · 18/04/2022 07:58

Pp made an excellent and correct point that under eating and going into a low calorie zone will only destroy your lean muscle rather than the fat you are trying to reduce. This is why professionals tell you to lose the weight gradually and sensibly to ensure you are targeting the correct type of weight loss. We need our muscle mass particularly as we age. In fact, weight training and resistance work is the key to raising our basal metabolic rate and ensuring we need more calories to sustain our frame. I’m 5ft 4 and have always hovered around 8 stone but i have always been active. For those of you who have never heard the term look up the acronym NEAT in reference to exercise. Building movement into every part of your day is the key to not only a healthy and active life but also raises your calorie baseline. I personally love eating and find great pleasure in it. The thought of fastidiously counting calories and restricting intake would seriously take away the joy of eating. By all means we should all have an awareness of what a healthy and balanced diet looks like, but not to such extremes that some people appear to go to.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 18/04/2022 07:56

A lot depends on -

Age
Height
Weight
Exercise levels

There will be huge variations in all of those factors that can determine if 1500 calories is 'enough' or sustainable. What you eat to make up those 1500 calories is also hugely important.

CerealBowl · 18/04/2022 07:36

Depends on height - I'm 5'1 and 8 1/2 stone, if I eat more than 1500 then I gain weight. And that's with exercising 6 days a week.

LoudSnoringDog · 18/04/2022 07:21

If I am "in the zone" and consciously thinking about my weight then I can have 1300 calories and be reasonably satisfied. We also have Gousto and choose meals 650 Cals or less.
I'm 4ft 11. If I had over 1500 calories I would pile weight on

NumberTheory · 18/04/2022 07:05

Like a few others on this thread, when I’m a healthy weight I put on weight at 1500 calories unless I’m exercising a lot.

I sustained it for years by having days when I ate less and had very plain food (lean meat or fish and steamed veg with a v. small portion of steamed brown rice, for instance) and didn’t really think about food and then days when I ate more and could splurge a bit and did think about food. It was probably a bit like the 5/2 diet except it would be 4 days of being careful and 3 of being less careful. I weighed everything at home to track and tried to estimate honestly to track what I could when I ate out. When I ate out I often left food on my plate as portion size tend to be for bigger people, I found this tough. I almost never had desert, though I would have a fork full of DH’s. I drank a fair amount of water. I had snacks of carrot sticks, strawberries and grapes, which I love.

After a few weeks, my appetite adjusted in terms of not really feeling hungry. Though if I ate junk food it tended not to be so satisfying. But my appetite never really adjusted in terms of not wanting to eat a slice of cheesecake whenever it was on offer. It needed to make saying no a habit, which was hard.

Since having kids, it’s the social aspect of eating so little that I’ve found unsustainable (that and having willpower when exhausted). Constantly saying no with my kids around just hasn’t work for me.

PandoraP · 18/04/2022 07:02

We also use Hello Fresh and Gousto and they are brilliant for being able to choose dinners with lower calories and I also think the portions are decent but not huge. I usually choose the meals under 650 calories.
When I really want to lose weight I also fast. Usually one meal a day. I know that’s not for everyone, but works for me. The weight falls off really quickly and I feel fine doing it for a short period.

Thehundredthnamechange · 18/04/2022 06:56

I do intermittent fasting, so no breakfast. I drink green tea and sugar-free coffee or water throughout the day. Eat loads of veg and fruit, avoid bread/pasta/rice. It's really doable and not even especially difficult if you remove anything processed from your diet, in my experience.

3WildOnes · 18/04/2022 06:54

@Bloodybridget we quite often use meal boxes (hello fresh etc) for dinner which tell you the calories per portion. I’ve never dieted as I am naturally slim but I have added up my calories just out of curiosity. I think I eat around 1800 a day. I am short but active.
On an average day I might eat
Porridge berries and milky coffee 400cals
Banana and another milky coffee 150cals
Salad and pitta bread 400cals
Tea and a couple of biscuits 100cals
Curry and rice 750

LethargeMarg · 18/04/2022 06:54

This thread reminds me of the line in Bridget Jones diary (book) when Bridget is explaining to Tom about how she sticks to a low calorie diet and Tom says 'but don't you need 2000 a day to survive?'!
I'm definitely there for cutting out crap but eating totally clean can get obsessive. When it's hard to just grab something to eat when out and about I think it starts to go down a path which may be technically healthy but psychologically can start an unhealthy relationship with food and feelings of guilt etc

Momijin · 18/04/2022 06:47

It depends how much that person is burning. I burn about 2400 a day on average so my weight loss calories is 1900.

Bloodybridget · 18/04/2022 06:45

@NeverDropYourMooncup ok, so it's not an exact science! I think I've done it in the past, when I was much younger. I was overweight most of my life since adolescence, varying from a bit to quite a lot, and I did the yoyo dieting for years: lose 20-odd pounds, regain them. But funnily enough when I stopped being vegetarian, after nearly 40 years, I was able to keep to a healthy BMI, and then lost a lot on the cancer diet three years ago, so I'm quite slim now (always a silver lining, ha ha).
But I had decades of feeling shame and unease in my body, and that I couldn't control my eating despite being so happy at the times I was thinner; I'll never forget that and of course I really get how hard it is to maintain weight loss. Personally, a lot of the diets I read about on MN do seem odd and pretty obsessive to me, but it's not my business . .

gamerchick · 18/04/2022 06:35

Meat - ballpark figure per portion.
Oils/fats - ballpark figure per portion.
Rice - ballpark figure per portion based on measuring cup supplied.
Potatoes - ballpark figure per portion.
Eggs - ballpark figure per egg.
Pulses - says it on the tin/packet.
Veg - fuck all per portion.
Fruit - chill, it's hardly a packet of double chocolate chip cookies we're talking about

People massively underestimate when they guess. Like a tablespoon of rapeseed is over 100 calories and so is a medium banana.

MFP has a barcode scanner to get a more accurate daily account and a big database of foods. Not all of them are right, look for the green tick against some of them

yogacurl · 18/04/2022 06:27

I log food on Fitbit and guess at calories in and out that way. They have a huge food database with all the nutritional values saved in.

Once you've got all your regular foods logged, they're in your favourites or recent foods - you can also add custom foods, or whole meals with multiple ingredients on the website (not the app for some unknown reason) - so logging every day is super-quick and easy. I'd really recommend it as a lifestyle changer tool.

It's all a broad estimate of course but it tallies with my scales every time. More importantly for me, it also makes me track my health like heart rate, heart rate variability, and sleep, which helps me know if I'm overdoing it exercise-wise.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 18/04/2022 00:13

@Bloodybridget

I have no idea of the calorific value of my food, how do you work it out if you're cooking from scratch and making different dishes frequently? Do people really faff about looking up every ingredient, estimating quantities and so on?
Meat - ballpark figure per portion. Oils/fats - ballpark figure per portion. Rice - ballpark figure per portion based on measuring cup supplied. Potatoes - ballpark figure per portion. Eggs - ballpark figure per egg. Pulses - says it on the tin/packet. Veg - fuck all per portion. Fruit - chill, it's hardly a packet of double chocolate chip cookies we're talking about.
Arkestra · 17/04/2022 23:33

Oh, one other thing that may prove helpful - there are studies indicating that bodies can release up to 30 calories per day per pound of fat. That's a maximum rather than a guideline, but in practice it means that if (like I was) you are packing plenty of extra weight, your body really should be able to meet a reasonable diet deficit by burning fat without getting anywhere near this limit. Psychologically this can be helpful to know.

The problem with fat burning is it's not very rapid-response (hence the glycogen storage system bodies also have). So one way of looking at it is that a big challenge of dieting is to try and ensure the food you're eating / booze you're drinking / meal patterns you follow don't give lots of extreme blood sugar swings - meaning that the fat burning can then carry you through without your suffering hunger pangs.

Bloodybridget · 17/04/2022 23:26

Yes @northernruth but I use recipes from all sorts of places - online, various books, cut out of newspapers and magazines going back decades, and usually adapt them to some extent depending on what I have or need to use up. And of course often cook without a recipe. But thanks for your response, I have noticed that BBC recipes include calories per serving.

Arkestra · 17/04/2022 23:21

Some things I wish I'd known a while ago - now I've finally had some success with long term weight loss...

  1. How can you tell how many calories are breakeven for you?

Trying to go by standard basal metabolic rates for your height/size is inaccurate. Trying to assess how many calories you take in is inaccurate. Subtracting one from the other is often very inaccurate. But you can figure out what you need to change from your current lifestyle easily enough.

To do this, weigh yourself when you get out of bed in the morning every day for a month. Eat/exercise as normal when you are doing this. Use a website like www.fourmilab.ch/hackdiet/online/hdo.html to plot a moving average. You will then know how quickly you are gaining/losing weight on your current lifestyle.

To translate that into action, each pound/month equates to about 110 calories/day. So if you are gaining a pound a month, you need to cut out 110 calories/day from your current lifestyle to reach breakeven, and then whatever extra you need to attain your desired weight loss rate.

  1. How much of a calorie deficit should you aim for?

A general rule of thumb is that you shouldn't push weight loss rate above 2 pounds a week: doing so risks doing strange things to your body's balance, and can even result in the body burning muscle rather than fat to meet energy needs (bad news, particularly as the heart is a muscle).

Sustainable weight loss rates over long term dieting are often in the 1-to-2 pound a week range. This equates to a calorie deficit of 500 to 1,000 per day. I've been losing weight at a rate of 1.5 pounds a week (750 a day) without feeling hungry.

  1. What are good ways to cut out calories?

This will really depend on your current lifestyle and your target. Some no-brainers are reducing processed and high-glycemic-index foods, also cut out booze as far as you possibly can. All of these are killers to a diet as your body hoovers up lots of calories very quickly from all of them and then starts begging for more.

If you are constantly feeling hungry, something is wrong. Try spacing out meals more. And make sure you're not eating or drinking stuff that will get hoovered up super-quick by your body and give you a sugar crash.

You should absolutely be able to maintain at least a 500 calorie-a-day deficit (losing 1 pound of fat a week, nearly 4 stone in a year) without constantly suffering from gnawing hunger pangs. And hopefully somewhat more than that. I find 750 a day or so perfectly OK but people do vary.

  1. Don't get discouraged by "water weight"

Your body stores energy 2 ways: fat and glycogen. Glycogen is quick-release energy, and bonds lots of water. If you diet for a while, your body will be low on glycogen storage. If you then go on holiday and eat lots of chips or whatever, your weight might go up by several pounds in a week as your body snarfs this up and sticks it into your glycogen storage: people can easily hold 6 pounds or more of glycogen+water in their bodies ("water weight"). This is not fat and will go away as quickly as it came once you are back on a diet. This wrong-foots a lot of people ("all that effort, but as soon as I look at a decent meal, it all comes back on").

Anyway, good luck - I guess the main thing to bear in mind is that it is possible to lose weight without suffering - but there are traps like the kind of thing I've outlined above.

EveSix · 17/04/2022 23:16

My MFP is set to 1500. I find it works best if I 16:8 and eat mainly vegetables and protein. I eat a lot of coleslaw (heavy on the cabbage, easy on the carrot, and adding stuff like celery, cauliflower and onion) with nuts or seeds, or coleslaw with boiled eggs or cheese or coleslaw with sundry proteins. Cabbage is great for making one feel full.

northernruth · 17/04/2022 22:59

@Bloodybridget

I have no idea of the calorific value of my food, how do you work it out if you're cooking from scratch and making different dishes frequently? Do people really faff about looking up every ingredient, estimating quantities and so on?
There are many recipes that detail the calories per portion. I use pinch of nom when I'm trying to keep an eye on it, and after a while you get an idea. BBC good food generally has calorie counts
Bloodybridget · 17/04/2022 22:50

I have no idea of the calorific value of my food, how do you work it out if you're cooking from scratch and making different dishes frequently? Do people really faff about looking up every ingredient, estimating quantities and so on?

FairyLightPups · 17/04/2022 22:30

[quote northernruth]@Hi246 it's not wrong to skip breakfast. Have a look at "Breakfast is a dangerous meal" by Terence Kealy. He looks at blood sugar spikes with a focus on type 2 diabetes and argues that breakfast causes over eating later in the day[/quote]
Only if you're eating food that promote sugar spikes - which lots of breakfast foods do, but not all!

northernruth · 17/04/2022 22:26

@Hi246 it's not wrong to skip breakfast. Have a look at "Breakfast is a dangerous meal" by Terence Kealy. He looks at blood sugar spikes with a focus on type 2 diabetes and argues that breakfast causes over eating later in the day