Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think eating 1500 cals daily is unsustainable?

387 replies

savedbythewell · 17/04/2022 18:44

And if you disagree, how do you do it?
How do you satisfy your appetite and what weight loss is reasonable monthly, if three stone overweight

OP posts:
PatientlyWaiting21 · 18/04/2022 14:43

I should add that doesn’t mean to say you should be on the same cals as me! It’ll depend on your a TDEE, height, activity levels, etc!

PatientlyWaiting21 · 18/04/2022 14:40

That’s pretty much what I eat e when I want to lose a bit of weight, i prioritise the protein, fibres and carb content, protein and fibre keeps me full. I’m pretty activity, I walk, run and strength train about 3 times a week and hit at least 70k steps for the week. Doing this I went from 136lbs to 118lbs in 6 months. To maintain the weight I aim to eat between 1800-2000 cals a day.

JustDanceAddict · 18/04/2022 14:39

I only need to eat about that much, in healthy-ish food, to not put on weight.
In fact if I need to lose I eat around 1300.
My fitness pal is great for tracking:

Plain yoghurt w blueberries/banana and low sugar granola for breakfast, w a milky coffee.

Lunch - homemade egg mayo sandwich on wholemeal w tomato/cucumber, apple, rich tea biscuit

Dinner - veggie chilli with cheese and riceuk wrap and guacamole or falafel/pita/salad/chips/houmous

If you cut down massively on carbs/sugar/processed food it’s not that hard.

jelly79 · 18/04/2022 14:28

I am trying to stick to 1500, my TDEE is 2000. I need to lose 10-14lbs and struggling

Problem is snacking!! And probably because my meals aren't enough so I'm changing that.
Also weekends are my weakness, again probably because I deprive myself mid week and then make up for it of a weekend
Temptation when I eat out etc

I have 12 weeks and want to do this healthy but it really needs to come off as nothing fits me! I exercise 6 days a week so I should be able to. It's just hard!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 18/04/2022 14:12

@gamerchick

*Meat - ballpark figure per portion. Oils/fats - ballpark figure per portion. Rice - ballpark figure per portion based on measuring cup supplied. Potatoes - ballpark figure per portion. Eggs - ballpark figure per egg. Pulses - says it on the tin/packet. Veg - fuck all per portion. Fruit - chill, it's hardly a packet of double chocolate chip cookies we're talking about*

People massively underestimate when they guess. Like a tablespoon of rapeseed is over 100 calories and so is a medium banana.

MFP has a barcode scanner to get a more accurate daily account and a big database of foods. Not all of them are right, look for the green tick against some of them

So is a single 19g triple chocolate GF cookie.

But the banana doesn't just contain fructose, it's also got protein, fibre and potassium and, combined with a slice of toasted GF bread (78kcal if you want to be really picky about it) and some crunchy peanut butter, I'm eating fewer calories, getting better nutrition and I'm not going to be hungry in thirty minutes - unlike the person who has three cookies with their tea and then goes on to have a full meal on top.

CICO works. But that doesn't mean accounting to the last atom like a dietary taxman is hovering.

In any case, I spend so much time scrutinising ingredients for whether or not they're going to make me seriously fucking ill usually yes, hence the cooking stuff from scratch almost all the bloody time, I am not devoting further mental energy to whether a banana is too thick to be really counted as a medium or if there's one more steamed new potato and an extra tablespoon of Petits Pois on the gravyless plate than somebody else thinks should be a 'portion'.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 18/04/2022 14:03

1500 is the average daily amount for a woman anywhere between 4'11 and 5'3.

I wouldn't eat over 1500 calories of food most days I've a small appetite.

MrsAvocet · 18/04/2022 13:53

I wonder what a "normal" calorie intake was viewed as in the past? DH and I (both mid 50s)were talking about this the other day. We don't recall people talking much about the nutritional value of food or counting calories and we don't think we had particularly healthy diets as children, judged by modern standards. But portions were definitely a lot smaller. Even junk food. I remember when McDonald's first arrived locally the biggest thing on the menu was a quarter pounder. Most people would have a regular burger or cheeseburger. The only time you see those these days is in kids meals. We have definitely reset our defininitions of "normal". Most of us are brought up to clear our plates as that's polite, not wasteful etc. There's more on plates nowadays for sure - and we're still clearing them whether we really need it or not.
I don't recall being hungry as a child, but we definitely ate a lot less.
I suspect we need a lot less food than we think we do now. We've just got used to having more so it seems unsustainable to eat less. My parents remembered rationing - now that does look unsustainable and I am not advocating a return to that - but my parents say they managed ok. And of course everyone around them was in the same boat which I think makes a difference. I think it is harder to eat less when everyone else is eating more. You feel more deprived which erodes will power. I always give up chocolate for Lent and often find it hard. This year both my sons did the same so there was none in the house, nobody else to see tucking into my favourites and it was easy.
I think physically, 1500kcal is probably plenty for many people. But food isn't just about meeting a physical need, it's far more complex than that, and that's why it's hard to cut down.

WimpoleHat · 18/04/2022 11:54

I’m short (and over 40) - I don’t think I need to eat more than that on a regular basis? I’m quite slim but definitely not skinny.

FairyLightPups · 18/04/2022 11:32

@BigYellowTaxiT

There is actually research suggesting a very low calorie diet (1000 cals) and rapid weight loss is better for those significantly overweight, especially those with metabolic syndrome (obese, high blood pressure and insulin resistance). It appears to strip the fat surrounding the organs (particularly the liver) first and then moves on to the other more surface level fat.
Yup, the trials with women with insulin-resistant PCOS are showing to be incredibly successful.
Hi246 · 18/04/2022 10:59

Bunnykins no argument from me - I said what I do, and that it works, certainly not preaching it's the best thing to do.
It's no added sugar. I'm sure there are far healthier things to do .

BigYellowTaxiT · 18/04/2022 10:37

There is actually research suggesting a very low calorie diet (1000 cals) and rapid weight loss is better for those significantly overweight, especially those with metabolic syndrome (obese, high blood pressure and insulin resistance). It appears to strip the fat surrounding the organs (particularly the liver) first and then moves on to the other more surface level fat.

northernruth · 18/04/2022 10:08

@Bloodybridget

Yes *@northernruth* but I use recipes from all sorts of places - online, various books, cut out of newspapers and magazines going back decades, and usually adapt them to some extent depending on what I have or need to use up. And of course often cook without a recipe. But thanks for your response, I have noticed that BBC recipes include calories per serving.
Yep understand that and I make lots of stuff that I;ve been making for years and don't need a recipe for. But making a few calorie counted recipes helps you sort of learn inuitively what helps and what doesn't. For example, I don't normally subscribe to low fat etc but in the pinch of nom books they have some handy hacks to reduce calories using fry light sprays and low fat cream cheese instead of cream to make sauces, and that's all then adapable to other recipes that I make. Also I ALWAYS weigh carbs - pasta or rice - and adjusting the portion sizes of those takes a chunk out of calorie count. Little tweaks can make all the difference
Tulipsanddaffs06 · 18/04/2022 09:47

Surely it depends on your lifestyle? If you sit at a desk all day Mon-Fri and do no exercise then I’d say you’re in danger of putting on weight at 1500cals. (Depending on your height)

The old ‘women need 2000 cals a day’ spiel is very outdated IMO and is why we have an obesity problem in the U.K.

You don’t say whether you do any exercise. If you don’t, get out for a brisk, one hour power walk everyday and you might be able to up it to 1700-800? Or an hour run which would be more.

Two slices of toast with butter, washed down with a cup of tea is probably about 250 cals.

Mid morning snack of an apple- 90cals?

Lunch- sandwich of some description with some carrot sticks- 350 cals

That leaves you about 800 cals for dinner. Google says a portion of lasagne is about 360 cals, you could add a load of chips or some garlic bread and salad and still meet the 800 cals. This is obviously just one example dinner.

You definitely won’t starve on the above and your body would soon get used to it. Don’t get me wrong, I’d definitely have relaxed days where I’d have some wine, chocolate and either make up for it the next day or do extra exercise.

But no, I don’t think 1500 cals is unsustainable depending on body type/ height and activity level.

BrightonBunny · 18/04/2022 09:29

Another one here who would gain weight on 1500 calories a day unless I exercised a lot.

If I am trying to lose weight, I have to cut to below 1200.

Chickydoo · 18/04/2022 09:24

I am 5'7 mid 50's, menopausal. I weigh around 8.10. Sometimes a couple of pounds less. I have no idea how many calories I eat a day.
My TDEE is 1800. I do a 'light' exercise class 5 days a week & go to the gym maybe once or twice a week.
I have always been around this weight. ( although I lost a stone 30 years ago due to stress. 7 1/2 was not my best look, and soon put it on again) I have had 4 children & seem to maintain my weight without starving myself.
My one vice is that I stand on the scales every day. If I have gone up a pound, I just avoid eating too much that day, if I have gone down a pound I might have a bit more to eat.
I am a bit clueless with calories, however I think it's instinctive. Clearly Pizza or cake or a salad with a rich dressing etc has lots of calories. Grilled fish and veggies have less. I think I instinctively choose the lighter option much of the time.
I think maybe some peoples natural gauge might be skewed due to all the additives, sugars, sweeteners etc making are food not quite what it seems.

Cocomarine · 18/04/2022 09:21

@UsernameInTheTown

At 5"2 and the wrong side of 40 I either eat and put on weight or barely eat at all and remain a solid 10-12. It's shit.
It’s like a particularly rubbish super power, isn’t it?! If food wasn’t so damn nice, it’s be rather useful with rising prices 😭
3WildOnes · 18/04/2022 09:04

If you find 1500cals too low you could go up to 1800 but add in a brisk 45min 3 mile walk a day, which I think is equal to burning 300cals.

peachgreen · 18/04/2022 09:03

I have to be under 1200 calories a day to lose weight, ideally more like 1000. It sucks. But I make sure those calories are mostly made up of protein, good fats and vegetables/fruit and that makes it more doable. Carbs just aren't worth it for me, they don't fill me up and I only have to look at one and I put on weight.

UsernameInTheTown · 18/04/2022 08:56

At 5"2 and the wrong side of 40 I either eat and put on weight or barely eat at all and remain a solid 10-12. It's shit.

BunnykinsDay · 18/04/2022 08:46

@Hi246 You say you drink squash all day.

(As do some other posters.)

Has it got sugar in it?

No? So it will have artificial sweeteners presumably.

These are DREADFUL.

New research (been in the press) shows that this stuff is harmful partly because it makes the brain crave sweet stuff but also as it messes up gut health and both together can lead to metabolic disease (inflammation/ diabetes.)

Milomonster · 18/04/2022 08:40

Yes doable, and your body will get used to it. I am a size 8, and work out vigorously daily. I never feel short of energy. It will take time for your body to get used to, and so pace yourself if that’s what you are intending your limit to be.

Sparechange · 18/04/2022 08:27

I have thyroid disease, and despite working out 4-5 times per week (weights, running, Pilates and cycling), my TDEE is around 1400-1500
More than that, and I pile weight on

Grapewrath · 18/04/2022 08:25

Some of these comments are really worrying and sobs are bordering on toxic.
OP-most councils now offer a free well-being service to those who are overweight and can advise professionally on exercise and calorie intake. Your daily required calories an vary hugely so please make sure you get proper advice. You shouldn’t be feeling hungry

NotSonicTheHedgehog · 18/04/2022 08:24

My TDEE is coming up as just over 2000 with ‘heavy exercise’ I weightlifting 4 times a week and maintain on about 2500

fishonabicycle · 18/04/2022 08:11

I can't understand how that tdee us coming up so low for everyone? I'm 5 foot tall, 57 years old and a titch and it's giving me 1775 as daily amount