Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think eating 1500 cals daily is unsustainable?

387 replies

savedbythewell · 17/04/2022 18:44

And if you disagree, how do you do it?
How do you satisfy your appetite and what weight loss is reasonable monthly, if three stone overweight

OP posts:
SausagePourHomme · 19/04/2022 00:25

[quote Eeksteek]@SausagePourHomme

Minnesota starvation experiment.[/quote]
The starvation experiment is not like me, a fat adult woman of free will, deciding to slightly limit my food intake to control my weight.

There's never been a time in history when food was so abundant and everywhere. People's calorie intake would have been restricted for all but the most wealthy. Limiting calories is nothing new, and the alternative for me is poor health and limited lifespan. I have to do it.

Its all very well saying we shouldn't have to restrict. For some people that's great, for others like me, it is necessary in order to get healthy.

Eeksteek · 18/04/2022 23:44

@SausagePourHomme

Minnesota starvation experiment.

ColdTattyWaitingForSummer · 18/04/2022 22:56

Off the back of this thread I kept a proper track today, and I came in at 1465. That’s being sensible but in no way restrictive. I had porridge with almond milk and honey for breakfast, hummus and avocado wrap for lunch, half a Kit Kat mid afternoon, fish, chips and peas for my dinner, and about half a pint of skimmed milk in coffee through the day. I feel plenty full on that. And I could cut it down without feeling hungry if I swapped for a veg heavier / carb lighter meal in the evening.

EmmaH2022 · 18/04/2022 22:30

@SausagePourHomme

exactly. I know that those numbers are scary, but knowing that it does just come down to the numbers (and energy in vs energy out) and not some intangible magic is really empowering.
Haven’t read the whole thread, will do tomorrow

But seeing the reality is what made me decide to stop trying to lose weight.

SausagePourHomme · 18/04/2022 22:26

exactly. I know that those numbers are scary, but knowing that it does just come down to the numbers (and energy in vs energy out) and not some intangible magic is really empowering.

EmmaH2022 · 18/04/2022 22:22

“ Assuming I do not much exercise I'd need to eat 800 calories a day just to lose my desired 2lb a week”

Exactly what my GP told me. Said she sees a lot of people for whom weight loss is only possible at that kind of calorie level.

SausagePourHomme · 18/04/2022 22:19

@pattish

There seem to be a lot of people on this thread who have to eat sub-1500 calories a day to lose weight. So you’re burning less than that? That’s crazy. For me, this totally proves that reducing calorie intake over time reduces your BMR so you have to eat less to stay a healthy weight.
I don't think that's true.

Let's say my tdee is 1800 (as I'm short) and I eat 1500 a day to lose weight.

You need a deficit of 3500 calories to lose 1lb of fat. That means it's going to take me more than 10 days to even lose one pound. I'm still losing - my metabolism is working perfectly, I just haven't got a big enough deficit for the noticeable weight loss that most people want when they are on a diet. To lose 2lb a week you need a 7000 calorie deficit - that's 1000 calories less per day than you're burning.

Assuming I do not much exercise I'd need to eat 800 calories a day just to lose my desired 2lb a week

Nothing to do with your metabolism being broken.

ineedsun · 18/04/2022 22:05

@CaliforniaDrumming

Will never understand why eating 3 meals a day of non processed food with plenty of fruit, protein and veg- roughly 400 to 500 calories each- plus a snack is now considered diet culture. I would call it avoiding diabetes and heart disease in your 50s culture. I do this. It is not a diet.
Yes!
pattish · 18/04/2022 21:56

There seem to be a lot of people on this thread who have to eat sub-1500 calories a day to lose weight. So you’re burning less than that? That’s crazy. For me, this totally proves that reducing calorie intake over time reduces your BMR so you have to eat less to stay a healthy weight.

peachgreen · 18/04/2022 21:38

@SexyLittleNosferatu I would truly love to be able to do that, I really would. But I'm a single parent, I'm all my daughter has in the world. I have to prioritise my health, and losing weight is the best way for me to do that. And that's not because I believe being fat is inherently unhealthy, but because evidence shows that the medical profession miss health problems in fat people because they blame all symptoms on their weight, and because I know it will be better for my mental health if I'm able to date at some point and I know that will be harder while I'm overweight, and because I need to progress in my career and we know from evidence that fat people get passed over for promotion and and and. The world is not built for fat people. And I can't change the world. But I can change me. What else would you suggest I do? (And that's a genuine question, not a snarky one.)

Worldgonecrazy · 18/04/2022 21:38

@CaliforniaDrumming

Will never understand why eating 3 meals a day of non processed food with plenty of fruit, protein and veg- roughly 400 to 500 calories each- plus a snack is now considered diet culture. I would call it avoiding diabetes and heart disease in your 50s culture. I do this. It is not a diet.
Absolutely. All that ‘protect the NHS’ bullshit with covid, when what the nation really needs to do is eat a healthier unprocessed diet (and do some exercise ) to really protect the nhs. Obesity increases risk of everything - dementia, cancer, heart disease, strokes.

If we truly learn to live ourselves we would take better care of our bodies.

Isis1981uk · 18/04/2022 19:59

I'm only 5 foot tall and 8st 11, so 1400 is more than enough for me, I don't feel hungry on that! More than 1500-1600 and I'd put weight on, and after losing 51lb a few years back I wouldn't want to do that again!

Wrongkindofovercoat · 18/04/2022 19:42

@sHREDDIES19 Pp made an excellent and correct point that under eating and going into a low calorie zone will only destroy your lean muscle rather than the fat you are trying to reduce

Would that be the case too if someone had 10 stone to lose ? People who are obese have more muscle mass anyway, they are reccommended to follow a very low calorie diet with sufficent protein and add in resistance type training. Someone who is a very fit and active 8 stone would not be given the same advice.

5128gap · 18/04/2022 15:56

@CaliforniaDrumming

I have no problem with eating Kitkats or drinking wine or eating crisps. But I don't do that daily and expect to stay healthy in my 40s and 50s. If this is diet culture I am ok with it. Beats going blind with diabetes.
I agree. I do think sometimes the idea of wanting (or being medically advised) to restrict diet for health reasons is conflated with the societal pressure to be thin. Theres no doubt that some women feel pressure to under eat to achieve a certain very slim aesthetic, but they are by no means representative of the majority of women, who need to restrict their diet to avoid being overweight. Whether they choose to or not is entirely up to them of course, but some level of dietary restriction is always going to be necessary for most of us who want to maintain a healthy weight.
Talia99 · 18/04/2022 15:45

I do 1200 when I am looking to lose weight. I try and have my first meal late about 10 or 11 (and keep it to around 250-300 calories). I then have a healthy meal with lots of vegetables for dinner which is filling for fewer calories. I make sure to include chocolate since I have a massive sweet tooth but I have one or two expensive chocolates (50 to 60 calories each) rather than a normal bar of chocolate. I fill up on tea and coffee with skimmed milk.

Generally I have no alcohol and limited bread.

It is possible but I find I need to write down everything to make sure I know how much I am eating.

Coinchend · 18/04/2022 15:35

@CaliforniaDrumming

Will never understand why eating 3 meals a day of non processed food with plenty of fruit, protein and veg- roughly 400 to 500 calories each- plus a snack is now considered diet culture. I would call it avoiding diabetes and heart disease in your 50s culture. I do this. It is not a diet.
I agree. Be interesting to know what people eat as a comparison. To me, eating lots of non processed foods can result in a lot of food for 1500 odd calories, but I imagine if you eat processed food you'd get very little and be very hungry.
CaliforniaDrumming · 18/04/2022 15:33

I have no problem with eating Kitkats or drinking wine or eating crisps. But I don't do that daily and expect to stay healthy in my 40s and 50s. If this is diet culture I am ok with it. Beats going blind with diabetes.

5128gap · 18/04/2022 15:29

@LethargeMarg

This thread reminds me of the line in Bridget Jones diary (book) when Bridget is explaining to Tom about how she sticks to a low calorie diet and Tom says 'but don't you need 2000 a day to survive?'! I'm definitely there for cutting out crap but eating totally clean can get obsessive. When it's hard to just grab something to eat when out and about I think it starts to go down a path which may be technically healthy but psychologically can start an unhealthy relationship with food and feelings of guilt etc
I agree with this. The problem is, what's the fix? Most of us if left to eat to our appetite and preferences in this world of plentiful and tempting foods, and with our biological ability to eat a lot more than we require; would become overweight pretty quickly. For some of us our age, activity levels and body size mean that we can't get anywhere near to what and how we would prefer to eat, or we will gain weight. People who strictly monitor their diets aren't all doing so because of societal pressure to look a certain way, some of us have to do it to maintain optimal health and minimise risk of disease. I'm not disagreeing with your very valid point. But in the toss up between psychological or physical health problems, it's Hobsons choice really.
CaliforniaDrumming · 18/04/2022 15:26

Will never understand why eating 3 meals a day of non processed food with plenty of fruit, protein and veg- roughly 400 to 500 calories each- plus a snack is now considered diet culture. I would call it avoiding diabetes and heart disease in your 50s culture. I do this. It is not a diet.

SausagePourHomme · 18/04/2022 15:22

@Eeksteek

Just a word of warning that if you eat moderately low calorie long term, especially if not low carb, your body is likely to adapt your daily calorie requirements to compensate (and you may feel tired, cold and hungry if you keep at it). Then if you eat what used to be ‘normally’, you will gain weight. It’s a sensible evolutionary strategy in times of low food resource. I would urge to have days where you eat more to prevent this, because in the long run, it’s deeply unhelpful!!!
Can you cite a source on that?
BuggerOffAndGoodDayToYou · 18/04/2022 15:17

@BuggerOffAndGoodDayToYou - have you had your thyroid tested, because that seems a bit weird tbh? Is it under-active?

@CorsicaDreaming The tests showed “within normal range” but GP did put me on thyroxine to see if it helped. It’s made my skin less dry but had no effect on my weight gain.

yogacurl · 18/04/2022 15:15

If you feel freedom when you stop a diet then you were doing it wrong IMO.

I've found it to be the opposite, it's very freeing realising you don't need expensive processed stuff to live well.

Grumpyoctopus · 18/04/2022 15:06

I think it depends how tall you are, and how active you are. I'm only 5'1 and don't really exercise or have an active job, so I can stick to it without feeling hungry if I want to. It doesn't make me loose weight though, I'd need about 1200 for that.

SexyLittleNosferatu · 18/04/2022 15:00

@nahnothanks

This whole thread is just such a sad read.

Can you imagine how much time women waste throughout their lives fretting over this stuff? About how many calories are in a bloody Kit Kat?

If you want to improve your relationship with your body, step back from the diet industry. The vast majority of people who lose weight will put it back on again, and then some.

Your life’s purpose is not weight loss. There are a lot of people making a lot of money from you hating your bodies.

I'm with you on this. I find it utterly tedious. Women on MN seem to have made "being thin" their only personality trait. The freedom you feel when you step away from diet culture is overwhelming. I can't recommend it highly enough.
Eeksteek · 18/04/2022 14:47

Just a word of warning that if you eat moderately low calorie long term, especially if not low carb, your body is likely to adapt your daily calorie requirements to compensate (and you may feel tired, cold and hungry if you keep at it). Then if you eat what used to be ‘normally’, you will gain weight. It’s a sensible evolutionary strategy in times of low food resource. I would urge to have days where you eat more to prevent this, because in the long run, it’s deeply unhelpful!!!