Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think eating 1500 cals daily is unsustainable?

387 replies

savedbythewell · 17/04/2022 18:44

And if you disagree, how do you do it?
How do you satisfy your appetite and what weight loss is reasonable monthly, if three stone overweight

OP posts:
PandoraP · 19/04/2022 14:58

@gwenneh, I would say you are still part of a diet culture with that pattern of eating even if you think you are not. You have just found something which works for you which is fine.

gwenneh · 19/04/2022 14:51

People who have abandoned diet culture and no longer restrict foods or count calories, may I ask, are you within a healthy BMI? And if so, what do you eat

Yes, my BMI is normal. It wasn't until I abandoned diet culture and stopped restricting foods that this happened. The rules I gave myself were simple: eat when I am physically hungry and ONLY when I am physically hungry, and nothing is off limits but mind the quantity.

What I eat in a day varies, but generally I'm not actually hungry until very late in the day. At work I'll have tea or coffee in the morning, but generally I don't need to eat until I get home and have dinner.

I eat the same things everyone else does, but on my body's own terms. And I mind portion sizes, not in terms of weight or calorie content but in terms of whether or not I am actually still hungry, or enjoying the food. If I'm still hungry, great. If I'm not and I'm eating just to eat (because I'm at the table or because everyone else is eating) then I stop. If I am not enjoying the food, I stop.

I started my first diet aged 11. I wish I hadn't waited until I was over 40 to give it up.

pattish · 19/04/2022 14:44

@SausagePourHomme

But it’s not as simple as that. Your body will learn to lay down fat when it isn’t getting enough to eat so that it keeps some reserves. This is how restrictive eating changes your BMR, so your resting body doesn’t use as many calories. That’s why people who have dieted all their lives only have to look at a piece of cake and they put on weight.

Muscle burns more energy than fat, so the solution isn’t to calorie count but to increase muscle by weight training, reduce sugar spikes which disrupt the body’s natural metabolism by eating more protein and less sugar and diversify the gut with lots of different plant foods. The result of this is that you get fewer cravings and feel more full, so you build a way of eating that allows your body to burn it off.

squiller · 19/04/2022 14:39

It’s enough for me. I’ve lost 3 stone this year by eating 1300-1500 calories a day (I use my fitness pal to track) but also exercising heavily. I got a Fitbit for Christmas and according to that I burn 3000-4000 calories a day. Some of this is just by existing (it counts calories used when asleep and sitting too) but I burn 400-800 per day through exercise like running 5k and HIIT workouts. The weight has flown off.

Roundeartheratchriatmas · 19/04/2022 14:35

Obviously I caveat by saying if I was doing an active job or regular exercise I would clearly need to eat more.

Roundeartheratchriatmas · 19/04/2022 14:28

Surely that’s a perfectly normal amount ?

I know I don’t burn much more than that when I’m desk working unless I specifically go and exercise.

DeyHuggee · 19/04/2022 13:59

People who have abandoned diet culture and no longer restrict foods or count calories, may I ask, are you within a healthy BMI? And if so, what do you eat

I count calories (not obsessively) but because intuitive eating for me means overeating and making terrible decisions, it works for many but I can't regulate my appetite and choices without some boundaries. I am a healthy bmi and have no desire to lose weight, I am just reluctant to pile it on as I know I'll never lose it. I always have the same breakfasts and similar for lunch, and probably a set of around 10 dinners that we rotate so I know roughly what I'm having without calculating it or anything; just feels like second nature now. Just anecdotally, but my friends who are a healthy weight and don't count calories or follow any particular diets have always been that way.

pinkprettyroses · 19/04/2022 13:56

@5128gap

People who have abandoned diet culture and no longer restrict foods or count calories, may I ask, are you within a healthy BMI? And if so, what do you eat?
My BMI is around 22. I eat food that makes me feel good- don't count calories, I'm pretty active. If I estimated my calories it would probably be over 2000 a day. Eat pretty much whatever I want.

Typical day -
Breakfast - Greek yoghurt, granola, banana, chia seeds.
Lunch - avocado / hummus on toast / chicken or ham salad sandwich / leftovers .
Dinner - whatever I fancy. We have chilli and rice tonight made from Turkey mince, chopped tomatoes and spices, mixed beans, courgette, red onion, mixed peppers and spinach with white rice.
Snacks- if there's any cake around I'll have some with a coffee, and I normally have some dark chocolate before bed.

I find giving myself the freedom, not restricting myself or counting anything makes me focus on what food makes me feel good and therefore makes me make better choices.

5128gap · 19/04/2022 13:36

People who have abandoned diet culture and no longer restrict foods or count calories, may I ask, are you within a healthy BMI? And if so, what do you eat?

CornishGem1975 · 19/04/2022 13:07

Quite right @emmathedilemma because with a Fitbit it's on your arm, so it's not really aware of what your feet are doing...but if you're stood behind a till you're not going very far anyway.

emmathedilemma · 19/04/2022 13:04

@EmeraldShamrock1

It's also ridiculously hard to get steps in. I'm in my feet in work from 8-5 and I barely get to 5000. That doesn't sound right if you're on your feet all day, is it tracking correctly.
They might be standing still e.g. behind a shop counter all day, being on your feet doesn't necessarily mean you're walking!
EmeraldShamrock1 · 19/04/2022 12:12

It's also ridiculously hard to get steps in. I'm in my feet in work from 8-5 and I barely get to 5000.
That doesn't sound right if you're on your feet all day, is it tracking correctly.

TheMoth · 19/04/2022 11:50

It's also ridiculously hard to get steps in. I'm in my feet in work from 8-5 and I barely get to 5000. Feels like I've walked miles though (which I do at weekends)I do lots of micro movements though- lots of kids off stepping side to side, such I don't think counts.

hepaticanobilis · 19/04/2022 10:39

@pattish

There seem to be a lot of people on this thread who have to eat sub-1500 calories a day to lose weight. So you’re burning less than that? That’s crazy. For me, this totally proves that reducing calorie intake over time reduces your BMR so you have to eat less to stay a healthy weight.
The problem is more our sedentary lifestyles. When I started WFH, I was shocked to discover I barely get 2000 steps a day if I have a day when I just stay at home and work. If I go for a 30-40 minute walk, I can increase this to around 5000-6000 steps which is still a low level of activity compared to someone with a more physical or active job. Obviously I try my best to be more active than this but it's not easy for various reasons (time, cost etc.)

When food packets say most women need 2000 calories a day, they are not talking about the middle aged 5ft2 tall desk workers who definitely don't need anywhere near 2000 calories a day.

SausagePourHomme · 19/04/2022 10:33

[quote pattish]@NumberTheory

I’ve posted before that there is scientific evidence of this - a quick Google will find it. So yes, ‘proves’ in this sense is a figure of speech, but I think you know what I mean.

Why else would there be people eating fewer than 1500 calories a day (in some case sub-1000) who are still not losing weight? A personal with a healthy BMR who isn’t completely sedentary will burn more than that.[/quote]
Physics is physics. Energy has to come from somewhere. If you don't put it in your mouth you body has to use its fat stores.

Notreallyhappy · 19/04/2022 10:24

If your trying to lose weight eating 1500 calories is a decent amount. Your not going to starve as you body has enough stored.
Pick lean meats and fish, good quality carbs and plenty of vegetables some fruit plus some good fats.
For years we've lived in portion distortion. Meat should be as big as your palm, veggies like 2 cupped hands and carbs about as big as a fist.
2000 cals for a female is loads.

Squidlette · 19/04/2022 09:23

I think a lot of people graze more than they think too. Dh always comments on my chocolate habit and says he can't understand why his big belly isn't going, when he doesn't eat it.

No, but I often find him with a mouth full of cheese or whatever, if he's passing the kitchen. I know chocolate is bad for me, so I'm aware of eating it. A blob of cheese here, a slice of bread there... dh doesn't see that add up. And apparently he only eats 3 meals.

Squidlette · 19/04/2022 09:20

Just for fun, I entered my diet for the last 3 days. Easily between 1300 and 1600 each day. I eat well and healthily.

However, I didn't add the bank holiday ciders and large quantities of cake. So yes, it's v easy to eat that number of calories- if you don't eat treat things. As I apparently only burn 1600 calories a day, I just need to be mindful.

peachgreen · 19/04/2022 09:00

I walk 10k steps a day and lift weights 3 times a week. I still need to eat less than 1500 calories a day to lose weight. Weight loss at anything above 1200 calories is slow and so intermittent it can be undone by one birthday party or whatever.

I don't understand what the suggestion is for people like me. Maybe I have fucked up my metabolism, who knows. But it is what it is and I am where I am. What else can I do in order to lose weight? Because this - counting calories religiously and ensuring what I DO eat is mostly protein, veg and good fats - is the thing that has worked for me consistently and medium term (haven't got to long term yet!) - and I genuinely can't see that anything else would work.

pattish · 19/04/2022 08:29

And I think the refusal of some to believe that restrictive diets mess up your metabolism shows how psychologically damaging focusing on calorie counting is. It makes you obsessed with numbers and you miss the actual solution, even if it’s right in front of your nose.

pattish · 19/04/2022 08:27

@NumberTheory

I’ve posted before that there is scientific evidence of this - a quick Google will find it. So yes, ‘proves’ in this sense is a figure of speech, but I think you know what I mean.

Why else would there be people eating fewer than 1500 calories a day (in some case sub-1000) who are still not losing weight? A personal with a healthy BMR who isn’t completely sedentary will burn more than that.

Schoolpickup · 19/04/2022 07:12

@CaliforniaDrumming

Will never understand why eating 3 meals a day of non processed food with plenty of fruit, protein and veg- roughly 400 to 500 calories each- plus a snack is now considered diet culture. I would call it avoiding diabetes and heart disease in your 50s culture. I do this. It is not a diet.

Three years ago I ate 1500-1600 a day to lose weight after a stressful situation (I was in the healthy zone but upper region). I went underweight and very ill.

Eating that low was diet culture for me. I developed intolerances and allergies as a result of undereating.

I think your advice is better tweaked to three filling meals a day and wholesome, unprocessed food. By including calorie amounts in your post you’re overlooking that a lot of people eg 6 foot women like me need a lot more than that per day. What we need to learn is to eat good food, to eat what we need and stop when we’re full.

Redruby2020 · 19/04/2022 07:01

@Madre123

We have cut out carbs, sugar, processed foods etc...we now eat a balanced diet...fruit, veg, salad and meat or fish every day.....it's easy
See I like to hear other peoples take on things. As I am on a weight loss programme via the GP. And you know with the NHS, it is all about the healthy living plate. So telling you that your diet should mostly consist of fruit/veg and complex starchy carbs 🤷🏻‍♀️ With a little protein, dairy, fat, then sugary things as tiny of course. We were told the body does not need that protein if at all 🤦‍♀️ Okay, they are trying to help you build healthy habits, rather than cut out whole food groups.

But years ago after being diagnosed with PCOS, within those first few years, I was diagnosed Metformin, I used to walk a lot anyway, plus ten years younger, so makes a massive difference in terms of what you were doing in your life then and metabolism etc.
And I ate breakfast/lunch, sometimes an actual hot dinner, but I must admit I usually just ate sweet things in the eve, after work feelings, not good I know. I changed some bits around, cut things out/added in other things. Still had carbs but changed a few things. And I lost 3 stone! Plus I was trying to add more protein too, so something must of worked!

NumberTheory · 19/04/2022 01:13

@pattish

There seem to be a lot of people on this thread who have to eat sub-1500 calories a day to lose weight. So you’re burning less than that? That’s crazy. For me, this totally proves that reducing calorie intake over time reduces your BMR so you have to eat less to stay a healthy weight.
Don’t think you’ve entirely understood what “proof” is if you’ve come to that conclusion from the level of detail in the posts in this thread.
fallfallfall · 19/04/2022 01:12

my understanding of both the minnesota study and the one on prisoners of war was that there was no long term effects physically however their mental health suffered long term.
oddly there seems to be 101 youtube claims to all sorts from benefits to detriments.