Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think eating 1500 cals daily is unsustainable?

387 replies

savedbythewell · 17/04/2022 18:44

And if you disagree, how do you do it?
How do you satisfy your appetite and what weight loss is reasonable monthly, if three stone overweight

OP posts:
yogacurl · 20/04/2022 11:25

Yeah, on its own it's awful, but cauliflower rice with some vinegar and pickled onions or pickles for flavour is lovely!

There's also a cauliflower and broccoli rice, but tbh it tastes the same as the cauliflower one.

The sweet potato rice version is absolutely delicious on its own though, I highly recommend!

Worldgonecrazy · 20/04/2022 11:20

shumway · 20/04/2022 09:41

For me personally 1500 calories is disordered eating territory.

No one who has shared their daily menu on this thread has listed anything suggesting disordered eating. Lots of healthy menus.

it’s really not that hard to eat a healthy diet with no processed foods and stick to that total. It is hard to fight the messaging of the food and diet industries and relearn what a healthy diet looks like.

I do dislike the focus on calories though. It’s entirely possible to eat a lot of calories of the right foods (low glycaemic load) and not store the excess calories as fat if insulin sensitivity is normal. The problem with those who are struggling with weight is that their insulin balance has been fucked up by years of diets that teach the wrong things - low fat/ sugar free rubbish that messes up our bodies.

why is it that counting calories doesn’t work for so many people, yet there are plenty of us on the thread saying don’t count calories, just eat a healthy low crap diet and watch the weight normalise. Unfortunately there is little profit in this approach, so the diet industry rolls on, leaving nothing but early death and misery in its wake.

JanisMoplin · 20/04/2022 10:20

yogacurl · 20/04/2022 10:02

@shumway

For me personally 1500 calories is disordered eating territory.
Why?? I mean, I circle at 2-2.5k myself but 1500 calories could be around:
  • breakfast and supper - All bran with almond milk 170 cals x 2
  • lunch - Chicken breast, carrots, peas, sweetcorn, beetroot, 300 cals
  • dinner - Salmon, broccoli, beans, peas, carrots, spinach, leek, sesame seeds, 600 cals
  • snacks - Cauliflower rice and pickles 50 cals, Apple, banana 150 cals, 5 teas with almond milk 100 cals, snacks on lettuce, cucumber, grapes

... That's a pretty filling day!

Seems like a perfectly normal diet though I draw the line at cauliflower rice. I continue to eat basmati though I eat less of it! I think as earlier pp said, people think daily meals have to be pizza or chips or nuggets or burgers They don't have to be, though nothing wrong with those once a week as a treat.

I am 5"7 and also a size 10-12 like pp, but don't look fantastic because all my excess weight is around my tummy, like most Asians. I have been told by GP that my BMI needs to be under 23 to avoid diabetes in mid-life.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 20/04/2022 10:15

For me personally 1500 calories is disordered eating territory.
Unless you're very active or taller than 5ft3 1500 is plenty for one day.

yogacurl · 20/04/2022 10:02

@shumway

For me personally 1500 calories is disordered eating territory.
Why?? I mean, I circle at 2-2.5k myself but 1500 calories could be around:
  • breakfast and supper - All bran with almond milk 170 cals x 2
  • lunch - Chicken breast, carrots, peas, sweetcorn, beetroot, 300 cals
  • dinner - Salmon, broccoli, beans, peas, carrots, spinach, leek, sesame seeds, 600 cals
  • snacks - Cauliflower rice and pickles 50 cals, Apple, banana 150 cals, 5 teas with almond milk 100 cals, snacks on lettuce, cucumber, grapes

... That's a pretty filling day!

JanisMoplin · 20/04/2022 09:58

shumway · 20/04/2022 09:41

For me personally 1500 calories is disordered eating territory.

I find this very odd. I am in my 50s and Indian, plus vegetarian. Most of my meals are therefore Indian or Asian inspired. I don't calorie count but roughly speaking:
Breakfast is an omelette or eggs in some form with a piece of toast( about 300)

lunch usually rotis and a sauted vegetable. Occ a hearty salad or a wholemeal wrap with falafel, hummus or pasta with veg chucked in ( about 400)

snacks usually nuts or fruit, occ a couple of biscuits or a bit of dark chocolate( maybe 200)
dinner usually rice, daal, vegetables and /or a raita. ( about 500)
I eat crisps, chocolate and drink alcohol on the weekend. This comes to less than 1500, I think.

You think this is disordered eating? It's just not eating processed junk or binge eating. I am not denying myself anything.( except meat). My husband does eat chicken and fish and still manages to stay under 1500 with roughly the same diet.

shumway · 20/04/2022 09:41

For me personally 1500 calories is disordered eating territory.

Octomingo · 20/04/2022 09:18

1500 really isn't a diet though. It's just not eating shit, or snacking between meals.

Greek yog breakfast
Oatcakes or similar and soft cheese lunch
Quorn chicken and bean mix in pitta with salad for tea

Darbs76 · 20/04/2022 07:46

On a diet I think 1500 is ok, once you’ve done the first week it’s easier. Choose high protein meals to fill you up. I have 1200 on a diet as my TDEE is lower as I’m only 5ft 1 with less than a stone to get to my ideal.

pattish · 20/04/2022 06:46

BigYellowTaxiT · 19/04/2022 15:38

This is a link to an interesting recent piece of research on very low calorie ketogenic diets for obese people. It found that the resting metabolic rate was not significantly decreased using this method of weight loss. The key appears to be ensuring lean mass is preserved by consuming 0.8 - 1.2 g per kg of ideal body weight of protein.

So if your ideal body weight (according to NHS guidelines) is 10 stone (63.5kg) you would need to consume at least 51g of good quality protein a day whilst doing your low calorie diet according to this research. This would be for sedentary obese people just starting out with gentle exercise, not active, healthy weight or slightly overweight people, though you could potentially extrapolate the results.

nutritionandmetabolism.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12986-018-0249-z

This is interesting. It backs up what I and others have been saying about protein, and that it doesn’t just matter how much you eat, but WHAT you eat. It also backs up the importance of strength training to preserve muscle mass during weight loss.

And for those who don’t believe standard low-calorie dieting affects your BMR - read the first bit!

pattish · 20/04/2022 06:34

hepaticanobilis · 19/04/2022 10:39

@pattish

There seem to be a lot of people on this thread who have to eat sub-1500 calories a day to lose weight. So you’re burning less than that? That’s crazy. For me, this totally proves that reducing calorie intake over time reduces your BMR so you have to eat less to stay a healthy weight.
The problem is more our sedentary lifestyles. When I started WFH, I was shocked to discover I barely get 2000 steps a day if I have a day when I just stay at home and work. If I go for a 30-40 minute walk, I can increase this to around 5000-6000 steps which is still a low level of activity compared to someone with a more physical or active job. Obviously I try my best to be more active than this but it's not easy for various reasons (time, cost etc.)

When food packets say most women need 2000 calories a day, they are not talking about the middle aged 5ft2 tall desk workers who definitely don't need anywhere near 2000 calories a day.

Look up the Hadza tribe research. Again, so many of our ideas about what makes the West fat are wrong.

pattish · 20/04/2022 06:32

fairycakes1234 · 19/04/2022 14:59

[quote JollyWilloughby]@Autumndays123

I would be starving on that amount of food and unhappy. I maintain on 3000 calories a day, I’m 5 foot 7 and a size 10-12. I have plenty of muscle and I personally think I look great.

I have no desire to be smaller and eat nutritious foods on a daily basis.[/quote]
@JollyWilloughby

Well you certainly have the confidence anyway :)

Yes! Good for her! She eats real food and isn’t sitting there desperately reading the back of the packet. THIS is what a healthy relationship with food looks like.

EveSix · 19/04/2022 21:57

TulipLover, I agree it is weird imagining our former sylphlike selves. Where I come from, the formula for calculating a woman's ideal weight is: height in cm - 110 = target weight in kg (eg 175 cm - 110 = 65 kg). I was always spot on my target weight before DC, but looking at old clothes, I can't quite believe it was me Confused Like you, I have given old favourites to pre-teen DD!

OneMoreBeloved · 19/04/2022 20:24

@Babysharkdoodoodood

I kickstarted my loss with 800 VLC for a fortnight and now fast until 2pm. Eat a light lunch such as a supermarket sushi pack, some nuts if I'm feeling peckish, then a normal dinner later.

Lost 15kg so far with another 15 to go, since Xmas.

Well done! Just wanted to say that! Keep going!
tuliplover · 19/04/2022 19:22

I just did that calculation for TDEE. I'm 5' 10" and it says my ideal weight is 146-151 pounds. I did once weigh 152 pounds at 40 but I had to exercise about two hours a day and really watch my intake. I was a uk 10/ US 8 and it was totally unsustainable. I've given a couple of my tops from back then to my very slim (and shorter) 16 year old daughter and they got her perfectly - I can't believe I was that size. I must have looked like a skinny pole. It's tdee for me is 1986. I lose weight at 1750.
I'm taking that all with a pinch of salt. I'll go with the your ideal weight times 10 to lose, 13 to maintain. I lose 1-2lb a week on that (1750).
You have to get to know what your individual body needs, and some need more or less to lose or maintain.

NumberTheory · 19/04/2022 18:27

[quote pattish]@NumberTheory

I’ve posted before that there is scientific evidence of this - a quick Google will find it. So yes, ‘proves’ in this sense is a figure of speech, but I think you know what I mean.

Why else would there be people eating fewer than 1500 calories a day (in some case sub-1000) who are still not losing weight? A personal with a healthy BMR who isn’t completely sedentary will burn more than that.[/quote]
There are a number of different reasons why people might not lose weight at 1500 calories. Starting with the fact health BMRs range we’ll below 1500.

Menora · 19/04/2022 16:03

[quote pattish]@SausagePourHomme

But it’s not as simple as that. Your body will learn to lay down fat when it isn’t getting enough to eat so that it keeps some reserves. This is how restrictive eating changes your BMR, so your resting body doesn’t use as many calories. That’s why people who have dieted all their lives only have to look at a piece of cake and they put on weight.

Muscle burns more energy than fat, so the solution isn’t to calorie count but to increase muscle by weight training, reduce sugar spikes which disrupt the body’s natural metabolism by eating more protein and less sugar and diversify the gut with lots of different plant foods. The result of this is that you get fewer cravings and feel more full, so you build a way of eating that allows your body to burn it off.[/quote]
I’m not sure that this is accurate in some ways and some of this stuff can be unhelpful for people trying to lose weight or learning how to adapt their diets

Your body just does what it does functionally, it doesn’t fundamentally change itself depending on what you are eating or doing in the way you describe that it ‘learns’ something new. It’s burning energy at different rates depending on what you put in it and what energy you burn. There is also genetics and hormones to factor in etc. you are telling it what to do. If you stop doing it, it will stop doing it. your body wants to burn carbs first while you exercise. If you eat little or no carbs, it has no choice but to burn the fat.

Everyone has muscles all over their body not only thin or fit people. Hence getting active helps you burn more energy. Your body burns energy just from being alive. You aren’t just burning ‘fat’ using these new improved muscles you are burning energy which includes carbs and fat stores.

If you get more active and eat in a calorie deficit you will lose body weight. But you do not have to build a lot of additional muscles to burn your fat. Many people do low intensity stuff like walking and it’s enough to get them to either lose weight or maintain it.

anyone selling you specific ‘fat burning’ things like PT sessions is going to probably try to get you to do some kind of HIIT, which might find horrific and uncomfortable because you are unconditioned and heavier than them and you may well hurt yourself or fall into patterns of eating back all your calories (which your Fitbit has helpfully massively over estimated). You will burn off fat (and carb stores) doing HIIT a lot faster so if you want a quick result, this is what a lot of people do. But I am not sure it’s sustainable unless they learn to love doing HIIT and people give up

You will change your metabolism by being leaner and more active, you will have a lower BMR than you did before.

But the key to it all is changing your mindset and attitude towards food and exercise. Making better choices, portion control, moderation, changes to your level of activity are more realistic and sustainable. If you find exercising that you love, then do it but if there isn’t, you aren’t a failure. It’s so easy to feel like a failure when you see all the gym wear toned people who get up at 5am but that life isn’t for us all and we have to find what does work. The idea of living on 1500 forever sucks a bit for me but it also sucks being fat so I need to decide what one sucks less

gwenneh · 19/04/2022 15:40

[quote PandoraP]@gwenneh, if you go all day without eating before the evening then you are actually fasting aren’t you? You don’t have to restrict food or count calories as it’s quite difficult to over eat if you eat within a short window unless I am mistaken and you eat all night of course. I don’t mean to pick on you, but lots of people fast and find it works for them including me. Very few adults have a completely normal relationship to food like we did when we were children I think.[/quote]
A fast would be not to eat when you WANT to eat.
If I want to eat during the day, I do. I just generally don't.

BigYellowTaxiT · 19/04/2022 15:38

This is a link to an interesting recent piece of research on very low calorie ketogenic diets for obese people. It found that the resting metabolic rate was not significantly decreased using this method of weight loss. The key appears to be ensuring lean mass is preserved by consuming 0.8 - 1.2 g per kg of ideal body weight of protein.

So if your ideal body weight (according to NHS guidelines) is 10 stone (63.5kg) you would need to consume at least 51g of good quality protein a day whilst doing your low calorie diet according to this research. This would be for sedentary obese people just starting out with gentle exercise, not active, healthy weight or slightly overweight people, though you could potentially extrapolate the results.

nutritionandmetabolism.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12986-018-0249-z

PandoraP · 19/04/2022 15:37

@gwenneh, if you go all day without eating before the evening then you are actually fasting aren’t you? You don’t have to restrict food or count calories as it’s quite difficult to over eat if you eat within a short window unless I am mistaken and you eat all night of course. I don’t mean to pick on you, but lots of people fast and find it works for them including me. Very few adults have a completely normal relationship to food like we did when we were children I think.

DeyHuggee · 19/04/2022 15:33

@CaliforniaDrumming

I am still confused as to how eating 3 full meals a day is diet culture for a person with a sedentary job and who is not exceptionally tall. It's hardly denying oneself or being joyless.
I used to think this, until I discovered really delicious meals that incorporated high quantity, low calorie foods also full of nutrients. I went from having chips with a beige side of some description which wiped out a load of cals and left me hungry to stir frys, salad wraps, vegetable curries etc. I have above 1500 as I'm 5'11 and quite active, but really understanding more about food I think really helps make it sustainable and enjoyable. I don't ever feel 'deprived' now, I enjoy a balanced diet and don't have any guilt around any food, I just don't eat them to excess anymore.
Coinchend · 19/04/2022 15:26

@CaliforniaDrumming

I am still confused as to how eating 3 full meals a day is diet culture for a person with a sedentary job and who is not exceptionally tall. It's hardly denying oneself or being joyless.
Me too. I don't understand why people don't get that some people such as the over 6 foot poster above is going to need substantially more calories than me who is over a foot shorter, especially when age comes into it. I've never been over weight or on a diet. I know I eat around 1500 because I sometimes enter meals into My Fitness Pal for protein content while being a vegetarian.

Some people can pack far more food in and of a better quality for fewer calories. You're likely to be hungry on 1500cal of ultra processed food. I would be.

CaliforniaDrumming · 19/04/2022 15:16

I am still confused as to how eating 3 full meals a day is diet culture for a person with a sedentary job and who is not exceptionally tall. It's hardly denying oneself or being joyless.

gwenneh · 19/04/2022 15:09

[quote PandoraP]@gwenneh, I would say you are still part of a diet culture with that pattern of eating even if you think you are not. You have just found something which works for you which is fine.[/quote]
How is it a diet to eat only when I am actually hungry and/or actually enjoying what I am eating?
I don't restrict foods. I don't count calories.

fairycakes1234 · 19/04/2022 14:59

[quote JollyWilloughby]@Autumndays123

I would be starving on that amount of food and unhappy. I maintain on 3000 calories a day, I’m 5 foot 7 and a size 10-12. I have plenty of muscle and I personally think I look great.

I have no desire to be smaller and eat nutritious foods on a daily basis.[/quote]
@JollyWilloughby

Well you certainly have the confidence anyway :)