Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think eating 1500 cals daily is unsustainable?

387 replies

savedbythewell · 17/04/2022 18:44

And if you disagree, how do you do it?
How do you satisfy your appetite and what weight loss is reasonable monthly, if three stone overweight

OP posts:
Wrongkindofovercoat · 21/04/2022 15:40

I disagree with the advice on fasting when a person can really enjoy food once they exercise well.

I think that fasting has other health benefits that shouldn't be dismissed, most people I know who do it, combine it with the period of time when they are asleep and a bit of the day they aren't, so can still eat plenty and exercise too.

If anyone has any advice on sites that explain weight training for beginners, and more importantly what not to do, I would really appreciate it.

yogacurl · 21/04/2022 15:12

I can believe that. I've hit 3k before and not put on an ounce (just the other day actually). But for me personally it's only possible on the days when I train really hard (weightlifting, cardio, at least 30k steps) and I couldn't manage that every day.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 21/04/2022 15:01

I know what I choose. It is hard graft but the results speak for themselves.

I agree.

I disagree with the advice on fasting when a person can really enjoy food once they exercise well.

Weight training has something for everyone and burns calories at speed.

gamerchick · 21/04/2022 13:41

EmeraldShamrock1 · 21/04/2022 12:07

Weight training and the calories it burns makes me question when pp's say it is mainly diet.
It can't be.
I wouldn't have the strength or energy for heavy weight training.
My nephew aims for 4500 calories to maintain his muscular shape he hasn't an ounce of fat.
I wouldn't be able to walk if I ate 3000 calories, it proves that you can eat, exercise and maintain.
You cannot eat and not exercise.

You need more calories and protien to maintain muscle. It's surprising that hunger you get when you're training. I'm sliding into menopause, I've gone down 3 back sizes since starting the weights. My maintenance calories are 1900 (which I still struggle to wrap my head around after years of female conditioning). Before I started, if I went over 1200 I gained weight.

I know what I choose. It is hard graft but the results speak for themselves.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 21/04/2022 13:28

I wouldn't be able to walk if I ate 3000 calories,

You can eat suprising little on 3000 calories though, a large Macdonalds meal and a bottle of wine would see you at about 2,000, add in a bowl of cereal for breakfast ( not the carefully weighed out portion as reccomended on the packet ) and meal deal lunch and a couple of milky coffees and you would be there. A couple of small snacks and you definitely would be.
I very rarely eat takeaways, I am more than capable of making rubbish food at home Wink
Even at my biggest ( 20 stone) I could still do a 5 miles walk without any real bother, putting my socks on was always the hardest part !

EmeraldShamrock1 · 21/04/2022 12:07

Weight training and the calories it burns makes me question when pp's say it is mainly diet.
It can't be.
I wouldn't have the strength or energy for heavy weight training.
My nephew aims for 4500 calories to maintain his muscular shape he hasn't an ounce of fat.
I wouldn't be able to walk if I ate 3000 calories, it proves that you can eat, exercise and maintain.
You cannot eat and not exercise.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 21/04/2022 11:03

@JollyWilloughby so you are exercising a lot ?

I am interested in trying some weight training, how did you get started ?

JollyWilloughby · 21/04/2022 10:09

I’m 5 foot 7, not 10.

my unidentical twin sister is 5 foot 10 and she also eats a lot but she doesn’t train so she is around a stone heavier.

my niece is around 5 foot 5 she can also trains (she got me into the weights after years of cardio) she is a lot slimmer than me but maintains on 2500. She is 19 though!!

JollyWilloughby · 21/04/2022 10:02

I eat 3000 cals a day, but I lift weights regularly. I am in the gym a lot. This is to maintain.

my diet is healthy lots of unprocessed foods, protein, calories bumped up with lots of olive oil and butter etc.

im a size 10-12 and I am 5 foot 10. Age 33. I could be a size 8-10 if I dropped to 2000-2500 but I’m not that arsed and like my weight as it is.

my thyroid is also fine. Not too sure why that’s so hard to believe to be honest but there you go that’s mumsnet for you!

Worldgonecrazy · 21/04/2022 07:21

My family member ate 3000 calories a day whilst training for international /olympic rowing competitions. She is 6’1”.

i suspect an average female eating that amount has body dysmorphia if they don’t see obesity in the mirror, or their thyroid needs checking.

lljkk · 21/04/2022 05:55

at least 51g of good quality protein a day

what would "bad quality protein" be, I wonder. Endangered animals? rotten eggs? milk?

I have found that obese people who are also into fitness are very strong, btw! Must be, with the constant extra load on their bodies.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 20/04/2022 21:24

I would be starving on that amount of food and unhappy. I maintain on 3000 calories a day, I’m 5 foot 7 and a size 10-12. I have plenty of muscle and I personally think I look great.

I have no desire to be smaller and eat nutritious foods on a daily basis.

The thing with this statement is there is no information as to what they actually eat to make up those 3000 calories or what level of exercise they are doing. I ate 3000 calories a day and was morbidly obese and the person saying they are a 10-12 is only 1 inch shorter than me. So either they are over estimating their calorie intake, they are exercising a lot, have some sort of metabolic disorder or are just fibbing ?
The plenty of muscle thing makes me chuckle as mentioned earlier, obese people actually tend to have more muscle mass than their slimmer counterparts, this doesn't mean they are stronger per se , just that their bodies need it to move the excess weight of their bodies about, Mrs 5 foot 7 and size 10-12 doesn't have to carry 10 stone (63.5 kg) around with her all day, every day for every task she does, an obese person often does.

TheHumanExperience · 20/04/2022 20:18

I think 1800 is better unless you live on the sofa. There is a good book called How Not to Diet. It's about nutrient-dense eating for automatic weight loss, by giving your DNA and gut microbes, what they need to fully function and allow weight loss. Most 'diets' fall way short of good nutrition, which backfires in the end.

CornishGem1975 · 20/04/2022 19:16

I stuck to 1200 to get near to my goal weight. Now to maintain I might do a couple of 1200 calorie days, try and stick to around 1500 on other days and chill the fuck out if I have a couple of 2500 days at the weekend - because the other days balance it out!

That's what it's all about really isn't it, balance.

Worldgonecrazy · 20/04/2022 17:02

@Choopi i also don’t exercise to burn calories, I do it to be fit. It’s just. My iPhone/watch tell me so it is interesting to note how few calories exercise burns if it’s not something people are aware of.

I think a mistake we see quite often is people on strict faddy diets who go for a walk and then reward themselves with a piece of cake and wonder why they are still fat.

yogacurl · 20/04/2022 16:54

Yeah, it must be nice if you can entirely self-regulate. Funnily enough, these days I keep an eye on calories on Fitbit to make sure I'm definitely eating enough.

I don't always get hunger cues, or sometimes fill up too much on veg without realising it, and found I was losing weight when I didn't watch it.

So sometimes at the end of the day I need to have a couple of extra bowls of cereal or bananas or something to make sure I'm in the "red" zone of eating a bit too much.

Choopi · 20/04/2022 15:49

Worldgonecrazy · 20/04/2022 13:22

Daily intense exercise for 30 to 40 minutes will only use a few hundred calories at most. My last functional strength session of 40 minutes only burned 180 extra calories. A 5K outdoor run with hills is around 400 for me. My base rate is 1200 per day.

The calories we actually need is vastly over estimated. But if we eat the right foods it doesn’t actually matter anyway. The important thing is how much of the food we eat that actually gets turned into body fat. The better the quality of your diet, the lower this figure will be.

Lots of people just don't care though and don't exercise to burn calories but do it to be fit. I walk 2 hours a day total with the dogs, run 5k 6 days a week and do gym workouts 5 days a week and cycle most places with absolutely no idea how many calories any of that is burning because I don't care. I don't need to lose weight, I eat when I am hungry why would I care how many calories I'm burning, it wouldn't improve my life in anyway.

Some people are calorie obsessed but some of us just want to feel good.

Yogacurl · 20/04/2022 15:11

Yes and there isn't that much difference between intense cardio and a fast walk.

I find that an hour on the mini-trampoline works off around 500 calories for me - lots of jogging, kickboxing, squats, star jumps, normal jumps.

I can't recommend it enough if you find exercise tedious, I think the bouncing makes it fun Smile

Worldgonecrazy · 20/04/2022 13:22

Daily intense exercise for 30 to 40 minutes will only use a few hundred calories at most. My last functional strength session of 40 minutes only burned 180 extra calories. A 5K outdoor run with hills is around 400 for me. My base rate is 1200 per day.

The calories we actually need is vastly over estimated. But if we eat the right foods it doesn’t actually matter anyway. The important thing is how much of the food we eat that actually gets turned into body fat. The better the quality of your diet, the lower this figure will be.

Choopi · 20/04/2022 13:05

Same. I exercise a lot to stay healthy and eating 1500cals would negate that and wouldn't be healthy for me. Although I don't calorie count, I have no need to, I know my body is fit and strong and that's my priority.

Chely · 20/04/2022 12:38

Depends upon your size and activity levels. 1-200 calorie deficit is good for weight loss with the odd day of maintenance calories thrown in so your metabolism doesn't adjust to be more efficient on lower calories.

For me 1500 calories would leave me feeling very deprived. I am above average height, weightlifting 3 x a week and have a big family to run around after. For me calories is not overly important (I do not count them), I have to ensure I get plenty of protein and don't have too many carbs. I do OMAD most days with a more relaxed fasting:eating ratio at the weekend and losing around 0.5kg a week doing that.

MrsAvocet · 20/04/2022 12:33

I agree FelicityFlops
I suspect the majority of people saying 1500 calories is a tiny amount are quite young. Things definitely change as you age, especially post menopause. Until I was in my late 30s, I could eat more or less what I wanted and stay slim. And if I started to feel my clothes feeling a bit tight I could cut out snacks and reduce portion size a bit and I would shed half a stone in a few weeks no trouble at all. Now I am in my mid 50s it is a whole different ball game!
I'm not stupid. I know at this stage in life I'm never going to have my size 6 20 odd year old body again, but I don't want to be fat. I have been, and frankly it was shit so I am not going back there. And if that means I have to be a lot more careful about what I eat, then so be it.

FelicityFlops · 20/04/2022 12:04

Well my TDEE is around 1200 calories, which I reckon is about right for my age, weight, height and current level of activity. Were I to eat 1500 or (shudder) 2000 a day, I would very quickly become a porker. Not what I want.
Sadly, it is a fact of life, as you age, but I am happy to eat 1 meal a day (lunch) which is high in the protein, minerals, vitamins and fibre that my body needs. Obviously I make exceptions for special occasions and I do factor in the odd glass of whisky or wine.
However, I am not prepared to compromise on the quality of my food or "waste" calories on highly-processed rubbish. Fortunately I am in a position, financially, to be able to do this. Other are not.

JanisMoplin · 20/04/2022 11:50

Worldgonecrazy · 20/04/2022 11:44

I like cauliflower rice fried, mixed with full fat cream cheese, Parmesan and garlic, then stuffed into peppers and baked.

That honestly sounds great. Will try it. I love stuffed peppers

Worldgonecrazy · 20/04/2022 11:44

I like cauliflower rice fried, mixed with full fat cream cheese, Parmesan and garlic, then stuffed into peppers and baked.