Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think eating 1500 cals daily is unsustainable?

387 replies

savedbythewell · 17/04/2022 18:44

And if you disagree, how do you do it?
How do you satisfy your appetite and what weight loss is reasonable monthly, if three stone overweight

OP posts:
Eelicks · 17/04/2022 20:14

I couldn't do it. When I was going to the gym and running 3-4 times a week I ate whatever I wanted and was a toned size 8-10. Definitely ate a lot more than 1500 a day!!! Now I hardly do any exercise and eat less but I'm flabby and unfit size 12-14 (which I know isn't that big of course) but generally feel abit rubbish and have back pain due to being weak. In summary I need to get back in the gym but it's hard with 2 little ones!!!

northernruth · 17/04/2022 20:13

@PurpleDaisies

In a very short time you get used to it and can easily go till lunch.

Not everyone! I absolutely have to have breakfast. I don’t think there’s one way to eat healthily so you don’t gain weight.

Well I would have said that ten years ago - maybe it changes with age (which makes sense, as we need fewer calories as we get older). But agreed, there's not "one way". There's just suggestions that may or may not help the OP
WonderfulYou · 17/04/2022 20:12

OP as you can see on here there is a massive range in what calories people need to eat and that depends on their genes, lifestyle, job, stress, metabolism, sleep pattern etc.

If you think 1500 is way too little then you are obviously eating a lot more than that.

So instead of being overwhelmed and restricting yourself so much that you end up failing - which is the cycle we’ve all been in.

Why not work out how many calories you are eating now and then reduce this by 500 - you don’t need to eat less physical food just find alternatives that are lower in calories.

You can then add gentle exercise like walking which reduces your appetite and helps you burn more calories.

OperationMincemeat · 17/04/2022 20:12

Surely it depends on how old you are? I am 52 and eat about that, though I don't calorie count exactly. 10 years ago I ate much more, but my body needs less in menopause. I walk a lot but have a sedentary job. I am not really into going to the gym.

northernruth · 17/04/2022 20:11

@Autumndays123

Really surprised by this thread but then again perhaps that is why we have so much obesity in the UK. 1500 calories is absolutely achievable (depending on your height and lifestyle). If I ate 1500 calories a day losing weight would be impossible.

Sample:

Breakfast: Omlette with mushroom and fry light (2 eggs) - 160 Cals (approx)

Mid morning: satsuma - 25 cals

Lunch: homemade soup - 300 cals
With slice of bread - additional 100 cals

Afternoon - protein yogurt - 100 cals

Dinner - spag bol/curry/chilli with veg instead of rice/pasta - large portion can easily be done for 700 cals

Pudding/snack - 2 finger kit kat or pack of wotsits etc - 100 cals

Total = 1,485

If you are average ISH height, have an office type job and exercise moderately around 3 days a week and think you'd be 'starving' from that, then you should work on your relationship with food and food choices.

Nailed it really. We've been sold a bit of a lie about how many calories we need, and also that wine/ chocolate/ sugar are necessary to make life bearable somehow. I exercise to get my calorie requirement up, but agree that 1500 calories is easy to do without hunger.
BonesJones · 17/04/2022 20:10

It's LOOPY and a recipe for future weight gain and eating disorders. It's barely above starvation calories! The diet industry loves starvation, because of course its totally unsustainable and there's uber financial bonus for people 'falling off the wagon', gaining even more weight (of course you would, if your body thinks its starving! Biology tries to redress the balance!) and jumping into various scams and programmes to 'lose the lbs' blah blah blah. It's the 'weight loss' lies that is perpetuating, and exponentially increasing, the so called 'obesity epidemic'. It's the biggest scam/scandal since medicine shows. The biggest issue is resisting ultra processed foods / bliss point foods that are literally shoved down out throats (almost literally!) constantly. It's a total fucking farce that there's much individual control about it at all. These foods are designed to be addictive, are highly well marketed and are inescabable. Human will power is not that strong nor sustainable. And I say that as someone who has extremely low impulse control (ADHD). Listen to a podcast called 'maintenence phase' and you can see how utterly absurd, abusive and utterly dangerous the diet industry is.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 17/04/2022 20:08

1500 is basically dinner for me! BlushBlush

I would feel really knackered on that a day. And how do you make it work with socialising, family life?

PurpleDaisies · 17/04/2022 20:07

In a very short time you get used to it and can easily go till lunch.

Not everyone! I absolutely have to have breakfast. I don’t think there’s one way to eat healthily so you don’t gain weight.

northernruth · 17/04/2022 20:05

Also I almost never have breakfast. In a very short time you get used to it and can easily go till lunch. Joanna Lumley once said "why wake the sleeping lion"!

An alternative to daily calorie counting is the Fast 800 which is a version of the 5:2, also incorporates the principles of intermittent fasting (a long period overnight without food - that's how I got out of the habit of breakfast).

CornishGem1975 · 17/04/2022 20:04

I try to average between 1500-1800 to maintain weight. To lose I need to be nearer 1200 calories which is a proper effort and slog but once I get into it it's easy enough but not something I'd want to be doing too long-term. But I am a shortarse and have a desk-based job.

It is entirely doable, I cook a lot from scratch and I use the BBC Good Food website who have recipe sections for under 400, 500, 600 calories. Saying that, I don't eat breakfast as I never feel like I need it and lunch will be light - soup (which is super low-cal and very filling) or a salad. Snacks during the day would be low-cal but not necessarily healthy. I buy multipack crisps like Wotsits (my fav) and Curly Wurly bars for a sweet treat at night.

CorsicaDreaming · 17/04/2022 20:04

@savedbythewell - I wouldn't reduce cals every day. Miserable and hard to maintain. And your metabolism can get used to it which scuppers weight loss.

I'd eat even less two days a week (800 cals or 1000 cals if you've got a lot to lose, and when you get used to it, then reduce down) and then eat "normally" the other days. So basically the 5:2 diet

This works for me. For the first days of doing it you do feel hungry, but it is one day, then normal again. And after a bit I found my body was fine with it and okay to do. I tend to just not eat breakfast and v small lunch then save up the calories for my eve meal.

But I think people go wrong by thinking "normal" on a 5:2 means you could be going to an all you can eat banquet for the other 5 days and expecting it to work.

You'd still want to be careful on those days and not eat more than the recommended 1800 for women (unless you're really physically active)

And advice re what to eat to get maximum satisfaction and satiety. from minimum calories from other PPs. Generally as little highly processed ready to go type food; as much natural fruit and veg as possible - and you are likely to lose weight.

thebear1 · 17/04/2022 20:01

I calorie count and try to come in at 1600 but can't stick to that if I eat out or have takeaway or there is something out of the ordinary, like a birthday with cakee etc.

Indoctro · 17/04/2022 20:01

Dr moseley Fast800 , you do it for 3 months and lose 3 stone

Lots of people do it and manage it fine.
At first I thought I'd be starving and unable to continue to run etc

I was still managing to run 20 miles a week on it.

Loads of Facebook groups for it. Have a look.

northernruth · 17/04/2022 20:00

God looking at these comments, no wonder so many people struggle to lose weight. I'm 54 and 10 stone 8, and my basic daily calorie requirement is 1600 calories. If I eat more than that and don't exercise I will put on weight; If I want to lose weight then I need to exercise and or/ create a calorie deficit. We have lost all perspective on what a normal amount of food is. OP, if you want to lose weight through calorie counting on that number of calories a day, then look at high protein low carb. If you balance your diet you won't be hungry and it is sustainable. Longer term it's best to incorporate some exercise into your routine (my calorie burn goes up to 2000 when I walk to work or go for a run, for example). Good luck with it.

Choopi · 17/04/2022 19:59

If you can only eat 1200 cals a day without putting on weight would you not just move more? Surely at 5'7 you must be rooted to the couch to not burn more than that on a daily basis. I hate this focus on size, it should be about health too. Being so sedentary that you have to eat like a bird to maintain a healthy weight is surely not healthy in itself?

trancepants · 17/04/2022 19:58

@pinkprettyroses

That's very little for a fully grown adult.

Of course you'll get the typical mumsnetters telling you they are full up on 1200 calories and eat 800 a day.

If you feel this is unsustainable up your calories and Include more low impact exercise.

I'm a 'full grown adult' and if I'm largely inactive, slightly less than 1200 is as much as I can eat without putting on weight. However I'm extremely active 25-35k steps a day, several hours of which is a mix of steady state and high intensity cardio. And at least 30 minutes a day on average of resistance training meaning I'm quite muscular (for a woman). With all of that I can eat just over 2000. And even with that kind of activity and 'low' food intake my BMI stays around 22.
OfstedOffred · 17/04/2022 19:58

The other thing people forget is drinks.

You have to scrap full fat cans, juices, milky coffees etc.

Peppermint tea is my go to when I'm cutting calories.

Totheweekend · 17/04/2022 19:57

According to a calorie counter app I eat around 1500 per day if I don’t eat out. Mostly due to a small breakfast I think, as I like wine.

BunnykinsDay · 17/04/2022 19:57

1500 cals is 3 x 500 meals.

You can eat a very satisfying meal for 500 cals and even more if your two other meals are only 200-300 cals.

Fill up on protein, veg and fruit, keep the carbs less, and avoid refined carbs.

user19888891 · 17/04/2022 19:57

I skip breakfast and have a small lunch to keep me going until dinner then have a normal dinner. One ‘day off’ where I eat as I feel each week. I feel hungry through the day but accept it is part of trying to lose weight and won’t be forever. It’s easier once you start to see results

ColdTattyWaitingForSummer · 17/04/2022 19:57

As a sedentary 5’3” woman my TDEE is around 1400, and to lose around 1200. I tend to think of 2/4/6, so a 200 calorie breakfast (eg a cereal bar, small bowl of porridge, or fruit and yogurt) 400 calorie lunch (eg bowl of homemade veg based soup and a small roll or a hummus and veggie wrap or a bagel thin with cream cheese and smoked salmon) and 600 calorie dinner (anything here really, the key is measuring portions, especially of carbs - a portion dried weight of pasta is 75g and rice is 60g - lean protein and plenty of vegetables, or ready meals can help as they’re calorie counted for you). Then 2x100 calorie snacks. I like small sweet treats like a two finger Kit Kat or single twix. I tend to drink sugar free squash during the day, and coffee with skimmed milk and sweeteners. If I know I’m having a bigger dinner I’ll have a smaller lunch (apple slices dipped in peanut butter or a couple of rice cakes with ham and cheese for example) or just have a brunch late morning.

OfstedOffred · 17/04/2022 19:56

It requires a huge mental shift. I'm not managing it at the moment but have done for as long as a couple of years in the past and know that if I could just do it for 3 months I could stick to it.

You have to get away from the idea that every meal has a large serving of a white starchy carb (bread, rice, pasta etc). You have to gradually reduce portion sizes. You have to swap calorie laden snacks for fruit and salary.

Initially yep, you feel hungry! Your body expects more because you have taught it to, it doesnt mean it needs more.

After about 3-4 weeks you genuinely adapt.

When I've done it successfully my menu for a day has looked like this:
Breakfast: skimmed milk porridge. 4 tbsp rolled oats & 120ml skim milk, plus blueberries or apple: 150 cals
Snack: fruit 50 calories
Lunch: sainsburys minestrone soup 600g. The pot contains two servings, 140 cals each. I actually eat both, one at about half 11, one at about half 1. I find that way it's a satisfying volume, but is less calories than a sandwich. 280cals total.
Snack: 4pm is my weakest time of day for snacking. I try and stick to salad (beetroot, carrot, celery, pepper, cucumber or tomatoes) - 60 calories or so But occasionally I give in and have biscuits etc - 120.

This leaves 900 calories for a main meal, which honestly is loads!

PortalooSunset · 17/04/2022 19:56

It depends what you're doing really doesn't it? Training for a marathon, nowhere near enough. Lying on the sofa all day and the furthest you need to walk is to the fridge then it's plenty.

Hankunamatata · 17/04/2022 19:56

I'm on week 6 of 800cal a day and it is tough. Had the odd day of upping to 1200.

Iv found easiest way is 2 meals a day. Late breakfast and an early dinner. Lots of water.

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 17/04/2022 19:55

Oooh I’ve never seen that, I’ll be looking for it now! Thanks @BigYellowTaxiT