Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think eating 1500 cals daily is unsustainable?

387 replies

savedbythewell · 17/04/2022 18:44

And if you disagree, how do you do it?
How do you satisfy your appetite and what weight loss is reasonable monthly, if three stone overweight

OP posts:
RealBecca · 17/04/2022 21:21

Just reduce carbs. I'm a "typical annoying munsnetter" on 1200 calories a day and size 12.

Breakfast - usually skip or fruit and fibre or peanut butter & banana on toast.
Lunch - soup or leftovers, sometimes a sandwich
Dinner- something huge (hence I normally dont want breakfast). Load of bolognese and courgetti. chilli without rice with guacamole and cheese. Pile of veggies on cous cous with hummus. Jacket potato, salad cheese & beans. Salad (a good one, none of those shitty packet leaves). Soup & bread. 2x bowls of veggie stew. Cottage pie without a bit of roof or without. Toast pizzas. Cooked breakfast (tomato, sausages, bacon, avocado, beans, mushrooms, omelette). A junk meal a 2/3 times a week.

Often but not always have chocolate cornice cream after.

I like big portions in the evening so eat as much veg then as I can and have afters if I want it. It took me ages to lean into eating when I wanted and stopping as soon as the thought crossed my mind rather than 3x meals and clearing my plate. I exercise 3x times a week and average 5k steps a day.

If I wanted to lose weight I know 12000 steps a day works for me and I normally feel hungry enough then for 3x meals a day (usually a big lunch then too like 2 sandwiches)

And I dont buy into "fruit is healthy so eat loads". I like fruit but I'd rather eat chocolate so I dont try and make swaps like that.

CorsicaDreaming · 17/04/2022 21:21

@nahnothanks

This whole thread is just such a sad read.

Can you imagine how much time women waste throughout their lives fretting over this stuff? About how many calories are in a bloody Kit Kat?

If you want to improve your relationship with your body, step back from the diet industry. The vast majority of people who lose weight will put it back on again, and then some.

Your life’s purpose is not weight loss. There are a lot of people making a lot of money from you hating your bodies.

@nahnothanks - this argument is often put forward, but it's not helpful.

There are a lot of overweight people whose health and life would be improved by being fitter and slimmer. Many of us end up living very sedentary lives and food is available everywhere. No judgement, that's just the Western world.

When I know I need to lose half a stone (like now) I do 5:2 (having watched the tv programme for free) fast at breakfast and make lots of veggie soups for lunch...

The slimming industry aren't making anything out of that.

And it's not sad to be mindful of your health and weight.

Patchbatch · 17/04/2022 21:21

Low calorie high density foods. I eat more than that now by a fair amount, but when i was in a calorie deficit I ate a lot of stir fry and the like. Adding spices to stuff also helps as it adds flavour without loads of cals. I would personally find it challenging to stay on that amount for a prolonged period of time.

catfunk · 17/04/2022 21:20

Me too @EssexLioness lioness.

I ate only protein/ fat unprocessed yesterday (lots of chicken, eggs, salad) skipped dinner as I was still so full.

Today I had a massive roast with Yorkshire puddings, potatoes, dessert. Not ultra processed but carb and sugar heavy. I was starving again an hour after.

EssexLioness · 17/04/2022 21:17

@yogacurl

I also think if you cut out processed food, 1500 calories is suddenly a LOT of fruit and veg. It's much more filling than a higher calorie processed diet will be.
I agree with this. If I ate junk food I would often feel hungrier whilst easily consuming double the quantity of calories. However, you can eat a lot of healthy foods for a small amount of calories. I have a fairly big appetite but my main meals are between 500-600 cals and that gives a good plate full of food.
Mamabananananana · 17/04/2022 21:14

I probably eat less than that most days and have 3 meals
I eat:
Cereal skimmed milk
Tea biscuits with tea ( no sugar red milk)
Brown bagel or thins, wafer ham , low fat spread amd low fat yogurt
Dinner is 5% mince or chicken low fat sauce, smal portion , brown pasta or rice
Maybe slice of toast at supper
Occasional Freddo / milkyway as treat

Its boring, rather than unsatisfactory?
Absolutely no takeaways , cheese and rarely booze but i lost 3+ stone after mu baby was born.

Menora · 17/04/2022 21:11

I do manage it if I eat food that are water based rather than just dense hard foods. Basically if you just eat hard dry foods you get to eat a lot less of them than if you eat wetter foods. So 1500 calories goes further if it’s vegetables, eggs, lean meats

Dogknowsbest · 17/04/2022 21:11

It's sustainable if you're not very active. The secret is to measure portion sizes and limit snacks to no more than 100 kcal.

yogacurl · 17/04/2022 21:10

I agree on reframing mindsets away.

Speaking of "treats", that's when I see people really making money and profit off of others - the absolute millions poured into creating and marketing stuff which is highly processed, addictive, fattening, cheap to produce, and offers no nutritional benefit.

And there are reasons it works, because it's tasty and addictive and normalised - within just a few generations our western diets have been transformed dramatically and almost everyone is getting fatter.

(No shame on anyone who's hooked on junk food by the way - I used to be and probably could have put anyone to shame back in the day! I ate mostly bland processed stuff and Coca Cola and chocolate, and it was only sheer blinding terror of covid that made me change my diet and lifestyle.)

Newbuilddecider · 17/04/2022 21:08

I calorie count and aim for 1600. Im 5 foot 2 and slightly overweight. I walk 2 hours a day and have an active job. I run 10km 3 times a week too but eat 1800 on those days, I’ve put a couple of pounds on recently.

Janedownourlane · 17/04/2022 21:08

It depends what you get used to and if you eat loads of veg which largely tends to be low cal. I have just lost a stone on 1200 cals a day, eating low cal meals and drinking lots of water. I wasnt hungry. I'm now planning to maintain on 1500. I know I will definitely put weight back on if I go over 1500. Its just how my body is and I've learned that this is what works for me.
Comparisons and competitve eating doesnt really make much sense as we are all different.

SucculentChalice · 17/04/2022 21:05

I think it would be ok if you were sedentary. If you were sporty or did an active job then I think it would be miserable and you would become quite under-nourished in a couple of months, as I doubt you could meet all of your nutritional needs.

I think its a diet designed for the NHS seemingly dream woman, the woman who barely moves and when she does so, she does so elegantly but slowly. I'm fast and muscular and I couldn't sustain it. I eat less when I want to lose weight.

ExMachinaDeus · 17/04/2022 21:04

It’s very doable, and you don’t need to feel terribly hungry.

If I need to drop a few kilos, I limit to 1500 cals per day, by eating a lot of lean protein: chicken breasts, tuna, Greek yoghurt, egg. A lot of vegetables - tomatoes, peppers, avocados, spinach - and broccoli is very filling! Pretty well NO white carbs - no rice, no pasta, no bread. Limit things like cheese and olive oil, peas and other legumes.

It’s a simple way of eating, but very healthy.

catfunk · 17/04/2022 21:04

It's probably about the right amount for lots of women who aren't massively active to maintain a healthy weight.
We're just used to eating too much or eating high GI stuff which makes our blood sugar sink making us hungry again.

Lovemusic33 · 17/04/2022 21:03

It’s totally doable and unless you exercise a lot it shouldn’t make you unwell. I aim to have 1500 when not exercising, if I am doing more than a hours exercise then I have more (1800). I’m a size 12 so not skinny. Some times I skip breakfast other days I have a small bowl of porridge, a salad for lunch and then a basic cooked meal in the evening and maybe a yoghurt or piece of fruit.

HP87 · 17/04/2022 21:01

I'm eating about 1000 calories a day and have lost 1 stone in a month, need to lose two more. But I don't do any form of exercise, during the school holidays when I've been out for the day with the kids and walking more I've been snacking a bit during the day. Like eating their leftovers and things. So nothing major but probably 200 more calories on those busy days.

ChampagneCommunist · 17/04/2022 20:59

I am doing Noom. It's quiet hard. I am constantly surprised by how many calories are in things.

I am under 5' & sedentary

TheFairyCaravan · 17/04/2022 20:59

I’m 51,5ft4 8st 3 and probably eat less than that a day but I’m disabled and don’t move a lot so if I ate more I’d pile weight on. I’m seldom hungry.

DH makes me a cup of tea with oat milk before he leaves for work.

Around midday I have Alpro plain Greek style yoghurt with berries and a banana

At 6pm I have my dinner.

I might have some fruit at around 8pm

In between times I drink water and peppermint tea.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 17/04/2022 20:59

@emmathedilemma

YANBU, I’ve been trying to do 1700 a day to loose weight and finding it impossible, I’m either starving or there’s no space for any tiny amount of “fun” or treats!
I found changing my mindset about what a treat is really helpful.

The stuff we think of as treats isn’t food. You wouldn’t treat a Ferrari to crap fuel, so why aim to do that with a body?

I will eat very dark chocolate when I want to - it’s so much healthier than biscuits/milk chocolate/cake and a little goes a very long way.

WakeyCakeyHeart · 17/04/2022 20:58

I eat 2 small meals a day, total around 1400 - 1500 cals, struggling to lose weight on this and considering dropping to 1200.
I'm 82kg and 5'2, considerably overweight for my height. 1500 is too much for me

ChocolateHoneycomb · 17/04/2022 20:58

It is what many women actually need…but it is tough to stick to indefinitely. That is why so many are heavier than they would like! I don’t think so many of us having sedentary jobs helps at all.

Eating 2000kcals per day reliably causes me to gain 0.5-0.8kg/wk. 2500kcals 1-1.3kg/wk. 5ft5 white woman now late 30s but was the same when younger.

I suffer with an eating disorder and have ‘done’ weight gain on a prescribed calorie intake quite a few times.

My two closest female relatives are always trying to keep below a size 12, with minimal success and both need way less than the magic 2000kcals per day to maintain.

BoredtoTiers · 17/04/2022 20:56

It's absolutely possible to have 3 decent meals a day on 1500 kcal (obviously that may not be enough if you're tall, heavier or very active).

I'm short and that's my maintenance calories, so I generally plan my meals around that level & then might add more depending on activity level. I'm far from perfect so there's definitely wine etc. in there, but admittedly not much in the way of junk food or other caloric drinks except on high days & holidays.

This isn't something I actually spend a lot of energy thinking about these days, but key thing for me was doing MFP to see what I was actually eating. A bit of upfront effort but I now have a bunch of fairly balanced recipes I can switch in and out to create a menu.

I do eat a lot of veg & try to ensure I'm getting adequate protein in the majority of meals.

Coinchend · 17/04/2022 20:53

That's very little for a fully grown adult

Depends on the fully grown adult. My TDEE apparently is 1554. We all have different calorie needs. It isn't one size fits all.

emmathedilemma · 17/04/2022 20:53

YANBU, I’ve been trying to do 1700 a day to loose weight and finding it impossible, I’m either starving or there’s no space for any tiny amount of “fun” or treats!

DeadButDelicious · 17/04/2022 20:52

"Your life’s purpose is not weight loss. There are a lot of people making a lot of money from you hating your bodies."

No, my life's purpose is to be there for my daughter. If I carry on the way I was I run the risk of becoming seriously ill and even dying. I'd argue that making a concerted effort to lose weight and be healthier is an act of love toward a body I have sorely abused over the years.