Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours treat their garden like a living room

429 replies

Norgernert · 17/04/2022 17:57

I realise this could be entitlement / snobbery / nimbyism, hence looking for a genuine perspective on whether IABU.

We live in a quiet, semi-rural steading conversion, so a smallish cluster of houses in converted farm buildings. We’ve lived here for 20+ years, and it has always been blissfully quiet.

2 years ago the last working farm building was sold off to someone who converted it, and now they live there - young family in their late 20s with toddlers (we are in our 40s with teenagers).

The problem is, they are so very loud Sad

Their conversion forms a courtyard, and they just treat the courtyard as another room of the house. They usually have double doors open, TV or music on, shouting from one side to the other.

It carries right through the area. There is no getting away from it, even going for a walk in the previously quiet fields.

We have had some respite in the winter when it was cold, but they are back to normal today and I just know it will be like this until autumn.

Do we just need to suck it up and accept that we have been lucky until now?

OP posts:
RachelGreeneGreep · 18/04/2022 11:08

@Runnerduck34

Nothing you can do about it but it is inconsiderate if they are making a lot of noise. I sympathise, we also live rurally. A couple of years ago next door was sold to a large family and they extended to max right up to our boundary, they have an "echo chamber" extension with bi fold doors which are always open in summer so now I can hear every conversation and hear exactly what they are watching on TV. They also have loud conversations in the garden, one of them seems to come outside of the house to talk "privately " ( but loudly!) on his mobile not realising we can hear every word ! They also have a dog they leave outside and who barks non stop whenever we are in our garden. They just seem to do everything at maximum volume. So I realise all this sounds petty but when you are used to hearing nothing birdsong in your garden it's a bit jarring. Tbh my mum lives in a town and her neighbours are a lot quieter and she can sit in her garden in peace which sadly we can now only do when they are out! So I do understand where you are coming from OP.
'Not realising that you can hear' - I would go out at the same time and hold a loud pretend conversation on my phone. Record the dog barking and play it back at them.

I feel for you. Loud and inconsiderate neighbours are dreadful.

CuddlyCactus · 18/04/2022 10:48

Or you could get a megaphone and answer every question they ask each other? Including Dom Joly man and his bowel issues "if you just hold on a minute I'll get you some haemorrhoid cream" at full volumeSmile

WimpoleHat · 18/04/2022 10:32

Also definitely please report them to planning enforcement. The planning system exists for a reason.

Agreed. If this is the cause of your problem, this is the way to resolve it. If there are other neighbours who agree, you could do it collectively.

I think with noise you have two routes if you’ve tried speaking to them about it:

  1. Phone the council noise people. Every time.
  2. Fight fire with fire. They have Peppa Pig on loudly? Play some rap music even louder. They’ve had a late, loud party? Wagner at 7am at top volume. Give them a taste of their own medicine…..
longwayoff · 18/04/2022 10:24

Speakers in the garden OP, opera broadcast loud as possible while you go out for the day. But first, just ask them if the could keep the noise down. They may not realise just how loud they are.

expat101 · 18/04/2022 10:16

Out ^

expat101 · 18/04/2022 10:15

Our area they send our sub contractors to issue a warning and then seize the equipment which owner has to pay a fine to pick up at a later date.

Northernsoullover · 18/04/2022 09:49

Ps they would investigate as its a statutory duty. Completely different department to planning.

Northernsoullover · 18/04/2022 09:48

@ImAvingOops

What can a council actually do about noise though? If the neighbour owns their house the council can't evict them. Councils don't even seem to deal with planning breaches a lot of the time
First you'd send them a warning letter. If that doesn't work an officer would try to witness the noise or might install noise monitoring equipment. If its decided that it's a statutory nuisance then they would be served a notice. If they breach the notice it might go as far as a prosecution which can result in a hefty fine.
Gonnagetgoing · 18/04/2022 09:39

@Norgernert - I’d report them for that breach.

I do think many people over the years seem to have a sod you attitude (like the NDNs who moved next door to my house) and think they can have loud parties etc whenever they like as it’s their right. No it isn’t their right! When I was a child and lived in a house where we had a large garden the normal family noise is expected but whenever we had parties we told neighbours and stopped after a certain time and kept volumes reasonable. I’ve carried this behaviour onto my living in my own properties.

I used to work for a solicitors (have said this before on other threads) and we rarely dealt with this issue but we had the knowledge of what you could do or not do legally and what recourse you could take.

I’ve known people who have lived next door to nightmare neighbours (I did once but it was only for 6 months must’ve been lucky otherwise!) and some have been worried to complain in case it makes selling their house harder. One single mum was intimidated by her neighbour whenever she left the house, snarling dogs, loud parties/gatherings with revving motorbikes etc and he eventually sold up! Her kids were a bit scared as they were both under 5.

So yes, take this seriously.

CuddlyCactus · 18/04/2022 09:24

@ImAvingOops

What can a council actually do about noise though? If the neighbour owns their house the council can't evict them. Councils don't even seem to deal with planning breaches a lot of the time

Council's issue enforcement orders if people are in breach of noise regulations or planning violations and if people don't comply then they can take them to court.
Then if people ignored it they would be in breach of court order and dealt with by court system.

Can take a long time and whether individual councils do this is another matter. Some are much more on top of planning violations than others.

Nothappyatwork · 18/04/2022 09:19

@ImAvingOops

What can a council actually do about noise though? If the neighbour owns their house the council can't evict them. Councils don't even seem to deal with planning breaches a lot of the time
Fine them in the same way as paeking violations
Courtjobby · 18/04/2022 09:13

That was meant to say "kind of sound amplification*"

Courtjobby · 18/04/2022 09:12

Sounds like the planning permission they were given may have been to prevent this know Nd of sound amplification?

ImAvingOops · 18/04/2022 09:11

What can a council actually do about noise though? If the neighbour owns their house the council can't evict them. Councils don't even seem to deal with planning breaches a lot of the time

Benjispruce4 · 18/04/2022 08:41

Depends on the music imo.

Sswhinesthebest · 18/04/2022 08:40

@milkyaqua

I think when you inform the council about the excessive noise, the polite requests ignored, and mention the (illegal) setup which is exacerbating the noise, they will do your work for you.

People who make planning permission breaches are really arrogant, stupid, and entitled and will not respond to normal requests for consideration of others.

This
Sswhinesthebest · 18/04/2022 08:40

@Feelingpoorly123

There’s nothing wrong with playing music in your garden during the daytime imo
Oh you are one of “those” as well 😡😡
Patchbatch · 18/04/2022 06:45

@Mrsmch123

Wonder if my neighbours hate me..... I always have my double doors open and play music. We have family over on nice days chatting and enjoying the sun.
Yes I expect so, the music not the chatting. I used to live next door to someone who would do the same whenever the weather was nice, horrible being subject to their crappy music when people want to also sit outside and enjoy the weather.
whiteroseredrose · 18/04/2022 06:29

@Mrsmch123

Wonder if my neighbours hate me..... I always have my double doors open and play music. We have family over on nice days chatting and enjoying the sun.
I would hate you! Chatting and bellowing not an issues but the music would be a nightmare.
milkyaqua · 18/04/2022 06:10

I think when you inform the council about the excessive noise, the polite requests ignored, and mention the (illegal) setup which is exacerbating the noise, they will do your work for you.

People who make planning permission breaches are really arrogant, stupid, and entitled and will not respond to normal requests for consideration of others.

godmum56 · 18/04/2022 05:49

@Calandor

Yes YABU. Unfortunately they can do what they want in their garden. That's what neighbours do. I understand it's annoying and different but you can't make them not play music or have the doors open with the TV on.
actually no they can't. There are laws and by laws about noise nuisance
Hopingforabagofbuttons · 18/04/2022 05:46

BoredZelda

If you didn’t want to hear neighbours, you should have gone for fully rural.

No , why should Op have to go fully rural. She was there first.
The selfish neighbours who think it’s ok to have tv and loud music blaring out in their garden, without thinking about anyone but themselves are in the wrong.
Your comment is pathetic

TigerLilyTail · 18/04/2022 05:42

Happy to accept if I am being unreasonable, but to put it in perspective I am inside with the windows closed, my kids downstairs watching TV, and I can hear the neighbours and their TV louder than what’s inside my own house.

This isn't regular noise. It's excessive!

I said before upthread but you can buy a decibel monitor for around 20 pounds and keep track of the noise. If you approach the council with decibel levels rather than just saying their TV and talking is too loud, I suspect they will take you more seriously.

expat101 · 18/04/2022 05:11

Also having support in the neighbourhood gives a sense of relief too. I work from home and had a rare meeting finish up when the aforementioned neighbour started up.

One woman leaving here was a professional associate of the landowner and could not believe her ears, I remember saying to her, do you think that's at a reasonable level? Her answer was a resounding NO!. Naturally we had been made out to be the whinging arseholes of the area.

The more people who experience what you do, and who have your back, is absolutely priceless for your sanity. It is very hard to explain to others who don't experience ongoing unnatural noise levels what it's like to live with-in your own home. It's different if someone chooses to live near a pre-existing high volume area like a main road, airport, or school, but when something comes to you, who live in a quiet area, then something needs to be done.

Momijin · 18/04/2022 04:50

I live in an estate and my garden backs on to 4 gardens. 1 has 2 young kids and another regularly has grandkids and other family. As soon as there is good weather, you hear people having bbqs music, laughter, shouting, crying. It's part and parcel of living here and it doesn't bother me.

My dad would not be able to stand it which is why they live in a very quiet area.