Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be out as much as possible with DS(17 months)?

41 replies

Ridingonthewaves · 17/04/2022 16:26

I’m asking because to be honest no one seems to be out as much as we are and I can’t work out whether we are a bit odd or not.

DS seems to get incredibly restless at home and then it’s difficult to manage him. So he’s out a lot.

That’s fine up to a point but I’m actually wondering if this isn’t really good for him. It’s a throwback to lockdown as I hated being at home with DH there so was out a lot.

Should I be spending more time at home with him?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pixies74 · 18/04/2022 13:05

[quote Steelesauce]@underneaththeash thats a load of crap. My DD is 100x more feral then my boys. She is like a whirlwind. It's down to personality.[/quote]
Agree. My DD (6) is the endless-energy, climbing the walls type. My DS (4) is content to sit at home and play (he is soooo good at playing independently).

We do go out most days because of the benefits of nature/the outdoors.

Foxglovesandlilacs86 · 18/04/2022 10:13

I just sing nursery rhymes when they're in the bath or stick them on in the car. The wiggles do a good nursery rhyme playlist on Spotify my younger three love it.

I wouldn't overthink it really, he's 1!

Changethenamey · 17/04/2022 21:03

If you’re worried about learning, at that age (and all through childhood actually) they learn through play. When he’s in the bath name his body parts while washing ‘let’s wash your legs now, then your feet, how many toes 1,2,3,4,5 etc). He might not be saying the words but he’ll be taking it all in. And read, read, read! My one regret is not developing more of a love of books with my older 2 so I’m trying hard with my preschooler. He doesn’t necessarily want to share a book during the day but at bedtime he loves it and can recite his favourite books back to me and pretend to read it. Honestly it’s all about developing fine motor skills and talking about what you’re doing while you’re doing it. Unless you’re not speaking to him at all during your outings then I’m sure you’re doing a great job! Try to take him to a variety of places. Farms are great for learning about animals, food, plants etc. Playgroups are great for sitting and singing and messy play etc that you might not feel comfortable to do at home. At a push mine has learnt loads through blippi/tractor Ted Grin (lockdown baby!).

Seasidemumma77 · 17/04/2022 20:52

I was always out with my 4dc, in the park, on the beach or woods everyday. Also used to visit our towns little museum reguarly, and the art gallery everytime there was a new exhibition. My dc loved the outdoors, and I loved how when we were out they all got along and were great fun to spend time with. In the house they generally were hardwork and always bickering. Until they left primary school, I used to joke that the only time we spent in the house was asleep!

BakewellGin1 · 17/04/2022 20:36

DS (just 3) is off for 2 weeks now (usually does mornings in pre school.
We literally have been out of the house every single day as he loves being out and about.
Some days to Imagination Play, we have a Woodland Educational Play Centre near us and between have done various parks, farms, beaches etc.
It hasn't made him behind at all, he can count, speak full sentences and can explain a lot about what he is doing, why and asks questions.
We do story time daily and he enjoys stickers, painting etc but more then anything loves being out.

Ridingonthewaves · 17/04/2022 19:10

That’s good to know! His motor skills are really good, just obviously don’t want to get behind in language because I’m focusing too much on motor skills Smile

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 17/04/2022 19:06

@Ridingonthewaves

Well, maybe in theory but try getting a toddler to sit still and listen to a nursery rhyme in the middle of a park Smile
It may help you to know that children can't actually sit and learn (especially fine motor to write) until they've developed their gross motor skills.

So you are setting him up formal learning when the time comes honing those gross motor skills Smile

AliceW89 · 17/04/2022 18:49

To add (and not to sound smug) his language development is way ahead of what is expected, so I don’t think it’s done him any harm. Quite the opposite - we talk more and an about I think.

Geranium1984 · 17/04/2022 18:49

I have a 20mo and live in a small 2 bed flat in London. He goes to nursery 3 days a week but on weekends and my days off we are out for about 2hrs in the morning and again in the afternoon either at misic class, messy play, the park, a cafe or museums.

I find it really difficult to be in the house with him for a whole morning/afternoon stint, he is much happier outside kicking a ball. He loves reading books but we do plenty of that early in the morning, before his nap and in the late afternoon once we are home.

MermaidSwimming · 17/04/2022 18:49

I think you need a balance. If they are used to being out all the time they don't learn to amuse themselves when you have stuff to get on with. We would have either the morning or afternoon out doing things then home. They did art type things, playdough as well as toys so had sensory stuff etc

Darkstar4855 · 17/04/2022 18:48

I used to be out with mine all the time at that age. I had a rucksack carrier and used to walk miles, he loved looking around at everything that was happening. We’d stop at playgrounds or other outdoor places where he could run around a bit. In the winter I’d take him to B&Q or garden centres as he loved running round exploring. He used to get bored and restless at home and I found it much easier to get out with him.

He’s three now and we tend to stay home more as he’s old enough to be entertained by playing imaginatively with toys but we still get out quite a bit.

AliceW89 · 17/04/2022 18:46

Oh god I was out every waking minute with DS at 17 months. They have no idea how to ‘play’ at that age - they just want to destroy the house. DS would also get extremely tetchy at home. You could just see him relaxing outside. He was at his absolute happiest just exploring the car park of our estate then!

It’s a tiny bit better at 2. He’s got some idea of playing with his cars or his tea set. Only lasts 30 mins or so though (and I have to be playing with him, of course Wink). We are still out twice a day on my off days - toddler group in the morning and the park in the afternoon. I’m still encouraging the in-house play so he is used to it. But there is no two ways about it, he is a total outdoor cat and his behaved is staggeringly better out of the house then in. Me and his dad much prefer to be outside doing things too though so I can’t really blame him!

Steelesauce · 17/04/2022 18:38

@nuffsaidsam exactly! I know loads of spirited boys and girls. My boys are so chilled compared to her and always have been. Some of my friends have had opposite experience. It really is just personality, nothing to do with what genitals they are born with.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 17/04/2022 18:33

We were out all the time because DS(7) has always needed loads of exercise and outdoor time to be bearable. We also did every toddler group in the borough.

I can see it would have been lovely to potter at home for those early years, but alas it is not the hand I was dealt.

Ridingonthewaves · 17/04/2022 18:29

@HardbackWriter you’re probably right - I’ve definitely been making a more conscious effort to actually show him things and talk to him. It sounds so obvious when you say it like that but yes bath time for example - I’m often just so whacked when it comes to bath I let him play with his toys but it’s a good opportunity to talk.

I do chat to him but I suppose I’m drawing a distinction between that really clear ‘this is a cat! Hello, cat! Look, a cat!’ and the ‘oh, the cat is here again’ comment I might make in passing.

So today we went to the park for an hour, then church for an hour and a half, home for lunch, nap, then out again for a walk and play.

I definitely don’t think it would be good for him to be in all the time. I’m just wondering if in my keenness to avoid that trap I’ve unwittingly fallen into another!

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 17/04/2022 18:24

[quote underneaththeash]@Steelesauce well there are obviously exceptions (to everything) but most boys need more exercising that girls do at that age. There are very few boys of that age who are content in the house all day - none of the 50 or so little boys of that age I knew would have been.[/quote]
This is complete rubbish.

Sexist rubbish.

underneaththeash · 17/04/2022 18:22

@Steelesauce well there are obviously exceptions (to everything) but most boys need more exercising that girls do at that age. There are very few boys of that age who are content in the house all day - none of the 50 or so little boys of that age I knew would have been.

LizzoBennett · 17/04/2022 18:10

I take my 17mo DS out every day and always have. We have a weekly routine in place with messy play, visiting grandparents, play dates, swimming lessons and playgroup every week plus a dog walk every day. Despite doing all this, DS still has plenty of time at home with his toys and books in my opinion. We read every day and he enjoys 'helping' with chores. He is the opposite to your DS in terms of language, understanding a lot but saying little - so that may be more down to personality.

NuffSaidSam · 17/04/2022 17:58

Children need a variety of activities, so if you're out running round the park all day, every day then yes that's probably too much.

If you're just out and about a lot, but also reading, playing, mark making etc. at home or outside then it's fine.

A parent facing buggy is great for combining talking to them/singing/naming body parts etc. with being on the move/outside.

HardbackWriter · 17/04/2022 17:58

@Lazypuppy

We've always been the opposite, happy at home playing with toys while i potter around, on weekends we maybe have 1 trip out. If we do go out its for a couple of hours or so never all day.

I've always been very aware of making sure we fon't entertain dd all the time, at home ahe gets bored and has to play with toys etc, and has done from a young age

I don't think there's anything wrong with this at all - it would drive me mad, but if it works for you all it's great and I can see it would have some real advantages - but your username did make me laugh in this context!
OnceuponaRainbow18 · 17/04/2022 17:58

I would try and stay home and let them potter daily: I was like you and out and about all day long and now my kids are 3&6 they can’t stay home and entertain themselves at all… it’s exhausting!

HardbackWriter · 17/04/2022 17:56

We're an out every day without fail family too (but then I am a out every day without fail person, with or without children to worry about - I find even a day or two without leaving the house really affects my mental health) - I think you're almost certainly worrying unnecessarily because you might be out a lot but you don't live out! You must be washing him at home for instance - a great opportunity to talk about body parts and to sing. You must be eating meals, either at home or out, and that's normally a very chatty time too. Do you read books at bedtime? You could introduce them after breakfast, too, if you want more opportunities in the day? I think you probably have a lot of time in the day talking if you stop and think about it.

Steelesauce · 17/04/2022 17:54

@underneaththeash thats a load of crap. My DD is 100x more feral then my boys. She is like a whirlwind. It's down to personality.

underneaththeash · 17/04/2022 17:48

@Lazypuppy

We've always been the opposite, happy at home playing with toys while i potter around, on weekends we maybe have 1 trip out. If we do go out its for a couple of hours or so never all day.

I've always been very aware of making sure we fon't entertain dd all the time, at home ahe gets bored and has to play with toys etc, and has done from a young age

That's because you have a DD.

We had to be out by 9.30am at the latest with both my my boys at that age, or they'd be scaling the bookcases.

DD on the other hand, was more content pottering at home.

Weewillywinkle · 17/04/2022 17:40

I was out all the time with my kids from babies onwards. They are the sort of kids who bounce off the walls if we stay in too long. In fact the eldest still is at 7yo! They are also great at running/climbing/ riding bikes compared to kids of their age as they were much more physical. It took her ages to learn to write as she wouldn't sit down.

They were also getting bored at home from 2yo so she did some mornings at a preschool.

I do see children who are happy pottering at home ( and sometimes feel jealous!), but it doesn't work for my family. Do what works for you and your baby.