Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The heat or heat statment.

120 replies

Heiionwheels · 17/04/2022 15:11

I am aware that ( totally apart from rising food and petrol costs and other general cost of living costs or any medical or age related need for heat) a few of my more elderly friends are actually agast at all the reactions about the 'need 'to be warm in the house.
They have sèen that younger family members have got used to / seem to feel it the norm/ entitled to being able to walk round indoors in shorts and t shirts.
Wereas when they were younger they only heated one room ,wore jumpers, used hot water bottles as normal life. There wasnt all this talk of hypothermia and i live in a old house.
They seem to think believimg that you need a hot / warm house is actually a quite spoilt entitled stance and refelective of a pampered generation in some ways ,one who cannot cope with putting on an extra jumper, watching the pennies,being frugal .
They think that the tears on tv, the talk of getting ill due to cold reflects todays attitides of unability to get on with things and expectation of what is actually luxery not really such a hardship( apart from above type ofgrounds as outlines) .
Many many people have managed without warm houses and they want to know why this is seen as a right amd essential when really its a modern day thing. Likewise people have lived thro many things and have had to live frugally.we can do it too .
I see their point in some ways.

OP posts:
WonderingWanda · 17/04/2022 17:42

People may have survived with less heat and probably look back with rose tinted glasses, saying things like 'it didn't do me any harm' and 'it's character building' but lets be honest, at the time, if those people had the option of cheap and instant gas heating throughout the house then don't you think they would have had it? Yes, it is more luxurious but so are most things in modern life when compared to the past....thinking washing machines vs hand washing, going to the supermarket vs growing all your own food. Everything we have is luxury, doesn't mean we can't be sad about not being able to afford it anymore.

Quackpot · 17/04/2022 17:40

Poverty doesn't stop being poverty just because it used to be worse.
Would you suggest we go back to families in one room of a back to back house with a tin bath? Collecting water from a fountain on the street? Sharing a bread bun and some dripping between 6?

FourTeaFallOut · 17/04/2022 17:38

Well they are idiots. They should take a look at the excess winter deaths during and following very cold weather and multiply that figure by the staggering rise in the number of people who are now living with fuel poverty. But don't let actual figures get in the way of a good old rant bitching at the poor.

Hallyup89 · 17/04/2022 17:29

@Theunamedcat

My son is naked heat or no heat he has sensory issues and will freeze before putting clothing on
Yep, unless people have experience with disabilities, they have no right to assume. My autistic daughter will only wear shorts and t-shirt. We need to heat her room, at least.
FairyCakeWings · 17/04/2022 17:20

I agree they have a point OP.

I think similar when I hear about people ‘skipping meals’ because I don’t eat three meals a day in the first place. Most people want and have far more food than their bodies actually need.

Obviously I’m not saying it’s ok for people to be genuinely hungry and unable to eat.

1forAll74 · 17/04/2022 17:11

You just have to get used to some things. as not much heating, you just wear more clothes, and try and get your beds a bit warm, with hot water bottles.. you will get used to things, if there are no other options to keep warmer. You can eat decent meals quite cheaply, if you don't buy junky stuff or takeaways and the like.

Chewchewaboogiw · 17/04/2022 17:10

It has occured to me also that the elderly people did not mean no heat at all but that people should not feel deprived if they have to comprimise. No heating the house like a furnace. No expectation of wearing t shirts in winter.
Maybe they were meaning cut your cloth. Dont be expecting all the time.
Work out your priorities.
This would of course not apply to people unable cut their cloth as its already cut .

lemmein · 17/04/2022 17:07

[quote Lunar27]@lemmein

I would definitely buy into fuel rationing and an equal distribution for all. Ultimately it's not ok for some to have whilst some don't and that applies to all sorts of basics.

But sadly this is what some of us voted for (not me btw) and I'm still stunned that this government can let poorer people choose to eat or heat.[/quote]
Well that I can agree with - your posts seemed in agreement with the 'fuck the poor' posters with your 'luxury' comment. I understand what you mean now though and agree - if it's a choice between rationing depleting resources, or ramping up the costs so only the poor ration (or go without completely) I agree with the first option!

I'm freezing with or without heating tbf 😩

IncompleteSenten · 17/04/2022 17:00

I grew up without central heating and in poverty. Yes. You coped. You coped with being hungry. You coped with being cold but it was fucking miserable. What kind of fucking idiot would think anything other than dear god I hope we don't go back to those days?

My mum used a twin tub, mangle and a manual carpet sweeper. You think I want to give up my washing machine and hoover? Fuck off.

TheSilveryTinsellyPussycat · 17/04/2022 16:59

*Women died during childbirth frequently
People died from simple infections
It wasn’t illegal to force sex on your wife

THINGS HAVE CHANGED*

What have those three things to do with house temperature?
And yes, things have changed. In particular the climate has changed.
I doubt these older people meant that people had no heating. But a pullover might mean the thermostat could be turned down without loss of comfort. Also, coal fires radiate the right wavelength of heat to warm a human being (according to a physicist I know),. Radiators actually don't heat by radiation but by convection.

What is wrong with wearing a pullover to keep warm? You surely don't think those people used to swan around the house in a tee-shirt in the winter when they were young?

Unfortunately it was the wide use of coal started climate change. And here we are Sad

ghostyslovesheets · 17/04/2022 16:59

yes I was a child of the 70's as well OP - it was such fun - ice on the inside of the window - a single paraffin heater on the landing to warm the upstairs - gas fire on only when needed - 10p for the meter - balifs at the door - my mum missing meals so we could eat - power cuts, strikes etc

we never had it so good

it's 2022 now and I like to think society has progressed so we don't accept being cold and hungry as a way of life - but that's just my opion

oh and my mum - single parent from 1974 NEVER had to use food banks - aint progress great

SilverPeacock · 17/04/2022 16:58

Cold houses make physical and mental health problems worse. We are not just talking about hypothermia but in older people it makes arthritis and mobility worse, respiratory problems, increased risk of falls etc. Increased burden on health and social care. Not that anyone seems to give a flying toss about that.

picklemewalnuts · 17/04/2022 16:56

I think it's wrong to unnecessarily heat the house to 20 degrees. I don't think it's environmentally sustainable. Most people can be safe and healthy at a lower standard temperature.

That said, there are some who need it warmer- I'm not sure though where the figures for that come from, when we're told older people or those with certain conditions need it warmer. If they are reliable, then that's what we need to aim for, for those people.

The rest of us need to get used to wearing suitable clothing or move to a warmer climate.

Lunar27 · 17/04/2022 16:56

@PurpleDaisies

When gas runs out and we've exhausted the world's resources we'll all be dying from the cold (if not from other things). When that happens come back and tell me that heating isn't a luxury.

Lunar27 · 17/04/2022 16:53

@lemmein

I would definitely buy into fuel rationing and an equal distribution for all. Ultimately it's not ok for some to have whilst some don't and that applies to all sorts of basics.

But sadly this is what some of us voted for (not me btw) and I'm still stunned that this government can let poorer people choose to eat or heat.

pigsDOfly · 17/04/2022 16:47

Well speaking as quite an old person your 'elderly friends' OP are talking bollocks and so are you for posting this.

I'm 73 and I grew up in a time before central heating was in most homes.

We had an open fire in the living room and paraffin stoves to heat the other rooms.

We would wake up to ice on the inside of the windows in the coldest parts of winter.

Trust me having central heating in not a luxury. And in our country in 2022, people having to chose between heating their homes - and yes you can get ill from being cold - and putting food on the table is a scandal.

I'm am in the fortunate position that I don't have to make that choice and am able to keep my home warm and feed myself, and no I don't walk around in shorts and a t-shirt, but talking as someone who really feels the cold, as you tend to when you get old, I can't imagine how awful having to make that choice must be whether you're old, or young.

What do you hope to achieve by your goady post?

lemmein · 17/04/2022 16:46

*The fact that so many people here think it's a god given right to be 'comfortable' is what's causing the problem.

People need heat. Absolutely. However, the way we've been doing it was never ever sustainable.*

So then, ration fuel if need be - give everyone an equal amount; why is it ok to just make the poor uncomfortable? I expect if fuel was rationed many on here would be outraged, whereas the people in fuel poverty right now would barely notice, or might even be better off.

Why do your kids have more right to feel comfortable?

PurpleDaisies · 17/04/2022 16:39

I didn't say I was ok with people dying from the cold. Just that heating is a luxury.

Unless you are ok with people dying from the cold, heating cannot be considered a luxury. Out is necessary to keep people alive.

We need more sustainable ways of generating heat. That is not what this discussion is about. While people cannot afford to pay their heating bills, we need to support them so they do not die. I did not think that would be a controversial statement.

Unsure33 · 17/04/2022 16:37

Why is the young man “saintly “ he is doing what he thinks is right for him in his situation. Of course it’s not the same for everyone .

My grandson has a medical condition and he needs constant baths and hot water .

Nothing is black and white .

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/04/2022 16:36

I remember my granny's house. Stone floors, no heat and it was bitter in Scotland in the winter. My feet were permanently numb. Sleep was very hard.

I also remember having no heat as a student. The whole house, including our beds, was damp and cold. I was very ill as a result. No amount of hot water bottles and solar lamps would have done anything. My granddad, who was a hardened mill worker who lived through two wars, used to put his tweed coat on to come in and thought it was barbaric. He wouldn't have wanted that for my child.

When people talk about heating or eating, their houses aren't at 22 degrees FFS.

Lunar27 · 17/04/2022 16:36

@PurpleDaisies

No, you're being overly dramatic. I didn't say I was ok with people dying from the cold. Just that heating is a luxury.

Just because you don't seem to understand the logistics of heating a home in the modern world, it doesn't make me callous.

What the hell do you think happens when you flick the central heating switch on or plug in an electric heater? Do you honestly think that we can/could do this forever? The fact that so many people here think it's a god given right to be 'comfortable' is what's causing the problem.

People need heat. Absolutely. However, the way we've been doing it was never ever sustainable.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 17/04/2022 16:36

They have sèen that younger family members have got used to / seem to feel it the norm/ entitled to being able to walk round indoors in shorts and t shirts.

This is the second time I've read this line today.

Is this a third thread inspired by the other two threads about "the poor"?

People can't afford to walk around wearing shorts and t-shirt throughout winter, maybe teenagers they don't pay the bill otherwise sane adults don't do it.

Stop trying to blame past/future generations on what is a difficult time for many people.

My DM's home was like a furness every winter.

Unsure33 · 17/04/2022 16:35

It’s not goady to have a discussion . In some European countries they are limited to the amount of power they can use at any one time so they have to adapt.
What would people do if their mortgages went up to 15% like they were in the 80s ?

I was in one of those homes with no central heating and I have no wish to go back to it at all . It was horrible. My Nan had a house with no electric and no running water . And that was in the Second World War .

None of us want to go backwards . And I totally agree that somehow we need help for the poorest families .

But the rest of us will need to also somehow cut down , think differently about our level of comfort . Because we have been taking things for granted .
Also no one has mentioned the thousands of businesses that might actually go under because they can’t afford the energy costs . What about the NHS ? We all pay for that as well .

Long term …. I think we in the UK should have one totally free UNiversity that is dedicated to energy saving research and factual weighing up of the economies of each idea and we could actually attract the best brains from all over the world just to study and develop on this one very important subject .

lemmein · 17/04/2022 16:33

@SickAndTiredAgain

There’s a big difference between walking around in shorts and a t shirt, and being freezing cold. We never ever heat our house to t shirt temperature in winter, but we are able to afford to heat it so we are warm enough with a jumper and fluffy socks, for example. Tbh (medical conditions aside) I do think heating your house so you can wear a t shirt in winter is a bit wasteful. But when people are talking about “heating or eating”, that’s not what they mean.
Exactly! I used to work at social services - it wasn't unusual to visit icy cold homes where clients wore coats at all times indoors; and this was 5+ years ago - I worry how those people are coping now.

Conflating the middle 't-shirts in winter' with those who live in fuel poverty is so disingenuous it's offensive. Or maybe people are so detached from poverty they really believe a jumper will solve the issue?

Chewchewaboogiw · 17/04/2022 16:29

AngelinaFibres.. the young man may not be being saintly as you put it... he may be trying to be resourcefull.. the problem with that is??