Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Claiming Universal Credit, DB says I'm well off.

233 replies

Aphrael · 17/04/2022 14:07

I've been claiming Universal Credit since September, it's currently at the "Assessment Rate" of £270 per month while I'm waiting for a Work Capability Assessment to determine I'm unfit to work. I've been cleaning PIP for a few years now and I have a Motability car. My payment after this deduction is £240 per month.

So overall I receive £510 and have to pay everything like electric, gas, phone/broadband, Council Taxx2, fuel for the car before I even consider shopping and I am struggling and having to rely on the local Food Bank, although I dislike some of the items they provide.

I sometimes have asked my parents/brother for money - for context my parents receive £2,200 per month and my brother & wife receive £1,750 per month.

While my brother has been willing to provide money and/or food last night he castigated me for being greedy, selfish and behaving in an unacceptable manner. Any advice also would be great.

AIBU - They don't have to support me and don't have to supply anything.
AINBI - Supporting me is a great thing to do as I am really struggling at the moment on the assessment rate.

OP posts:
Hospedia · 17/04/2022 18:18

However more job sectors are becoming more inclusive

Always a positive thing! I'm hoping hybrid working and fully working from home stick around long term as they have enabled a lot of disabled people to find work by removing the barrier of being 100% office-based, commuting, etc.

BrutusMcDogface · 17/04/2022 18:16

I am also wondering if “receive” means that they earn it, or claim benefits. Either way, though, they aren’t exactly rolling in it themselves!

Yabu for expecting them to help you repeatedly. Once or twice when in dire straits, of course most loving parents would want to help. But it sounds like you’ve come to rely on your family bailing you out when they probably haven’t got much spare themselves.

NewBootsAndRanty · 17/04/2022 18:16

The suggestion that the OP can work if she can post on here has left me gobsmacked.

DragonOverTheMoon · 17/04/2022 18:13

If your brother and his wife made an application to UC they might be entitled to some financial support themselves. 1700 isn't much. Housing costs alone would most likely put you as having more disposal income then theirs if it was split 50/50.

I think you should go to citizens advice and see if there's anything more you could be entitled to. And give uo your car when you can. You can't afford it.

Sushi7 · 17/04/2022 18:09

@Hospedia yes unfortunately there is a lot of discrimination. However more job sectors are becoming more inclusive Smile disabilityjob.co.uk/

Hospedia · 17/04/2022 18:07

And of course the thread has gone from advice to ableism in two short pages.

Why can’t you work? I only ask because a close family member has a terminal illness (organ failure) and my closest friend also has a terminal illness and they both work.

Good for them but different disabilities have different needs and different abilities. If OP is being assessment as unfit for work then she obviously is not capable of working right now so it's none of your husiness why she doesn't work.

In addition to this, have you seen the stats on disabled people in work? Discrimination may be illegal now bit there are ways to get around it such as simply not hiring disabled people and stating that "another candidate better fit the job profile".

There are 14.1 million disabled people in the UK, 4.4 million of them work. A disabled person is twice as likely to be longterm unemployed as a non-disabled person and is more likely to live in poverty. When asked in polls, a fair percentage of disabled people still feel that they are you fairly judged due to their disability sbd that there is still a lot of discrimination, both direct and indirect, as well as covert discrimination.

Blondeshavemorefun · 17/04/2022 18:03

@Nothappyatwork

All those commenting that people shouldnt be allowed preferences if they have to use the food banks, have you seen some of the shit that’s donated? We had to have a parcel from the council during the first lockdown because we couldn’t go out and quite literally I’d run out of food. I donated it all straight back again because frankly id have rather starved.
Assume you did stave then

As went there as had no food

Then you gave it back Again

What was in the parcel

Sushi7 · 17/04/2022 17:59

Do you mean your parents earn £2k a month or do they receive that amount in benefits? That’s an insane amount of money if that’s benefits. Loads of people earn less than £24k a year.

However, you are a grown woman and your parents and brother shouldn’t have to give you money. You sound really entitled especially as you say you don’t like going to the food bank because you don’t like the food they have. Why can’t you work? I only ask because a close family member has a terminal illness (organ failure) and my closest friend also has a terminal illness and they both work.

EatSleepReplete · 17/04/2022 17:56

Not nearly enough information OP.

Gingerkittykat · 17/04/2022 17:51

Will people stop telling the OP to give up her motability car.

You need to have very severely impaired mobility to qualify for one and it is literally a lifeline to be able to interact with the world. Disabled people deserve to be able to travel to appointments, meet friends, go shopping, take part in leisure activities.

Taxis are expensive, the last time I had to use one it cost me £17 to travel about 10 miles. Other forms of public transport may be impossible to use, either because they are inaccessible or the fact that you need to be able to walk to the bus stop/ train station and to your destination at the other end.

parisyplease · 17/04/2022 17:49

@Nothappyatwork

All those commenting that people shouldnt be allowed preferences if they have to use the food banks, have you seen some of the shit that’s donated? We had to have a parcel from the council during the first lockdown because we couldn’t go out and quite literally I’d run out of food. I donated it all straight back again because frankly id have rather starved.
What on earth was in there then that you'd rather have starved?
Whiskyinajar · 17/04/2022 17:46

@Mellowyellow222

You know many UC recipients work right?

I do.

UC is a top up which means I can pay rent, council tax, gas, electric, petrol (so I can do my job) etc…you know, the boring stuff we all have to pay.

anotheronenow · 17/04/2022 17:42

+1 for there must be more to this than meets the eye. I never think of myself as "receiving" my salary - I earn it. I don't know why you'd think of them as "receiving" their monthly income.

But now I've said that, I'm not sure there's any difference in whether they get money via jobs or benefits in relation to to your question which is whether you are BU by asking them for money.

To me, it depends. If you aren't able to get a job and you are doing everything you can, then yes your parents would BU not to help you. Your DB is a bit different = it's nice of him to help when/if he can.

Also +1 for wondering where you live (how you pay rent I mean), as well as why you talk about them as receiving money.

Hope the OP does come back. If not, I find this post a bit fishy.

Nothappyatwork · 17/04/2022 17:22

All those commenting that people shouldnt be allowed preferences if they have to use the food banks, have you seen some of the shit that’s donated? We had to have a parcel from the council during the first lockdown because we couldn’t go out and quite literally I’d run out of food. I donated it all straight back again because frankly id have rather starved.

luandacool · 17/04/2022 17:18

@Soresoresore

Even if you need transport would occasional taxis rather than a monthly cost of a car work our cheaper?

I was thinking the same.
My DD uses taxis a lot and it works out far cheaper than running a car.

Irrelevant as OP probably has at least 3 years on lease. It's a contract with notability you can't just hand back
Blondeshavemorefun · 17/04/2022 17:12

What foods are you given and what don’t you like

Your family don’t have to help you tho obv if they can it’s nice if they do

But their income whether benefits or salary isn’t that much for 2 people with prob rent bills etx

Soresoresore · 17/04/2022 17:11

Even if you need transport would occasional taxis rather than a monthly cost of a car work our cheaper?

I was thinking the same.
My DD uses taxis a lot and it works out far cheaper than running a car.

muddyford · 17/04/2022 17:10

YABVU.

XenoBitch · 17/04/2022 17:03

@Aphrael

I've been claiming Universal Credit since September, it's currently at the "Assessment Rate" of £270 per month while I'm waiting for a Work Capability Assessment to determine I'm unfit to work. I've been cleaning PIP for a few years now and I have a Motability car. My payment after this deduction is £240 per month.

So overall I receive £510 and have to pay everything like electric, gas, phone/broadband, Council Taxx2, fuel for the car before I even consider shopping and I am struggling and having to rely on the local Food Bank, although I dislike some of the items they provide.

I sometimes have asked my parents/brother for money - for context my parents receive £2,200 per month and my brother & wife receive £1,750 per month.

While my brother has been willing to provide money and/or food last night he castigated me for being greedy, selfish and behaving in an unacceptable manner. Any advice also would be great.

AIBU - They don't have to support me and don't have to supply anything.
AINBI - Supporting me is a great thing to do as I am really struggling at the moment on the assessment rate.

YABU.

Your brother and parents do not have to help you with anything. If your brother has castigated you, then it sounds like he has had enough of you expecting money and food of him all the time. It also sounds like there is a lot you are not telling us. There has to be some huge back story to this.

If you get awarded LCWRA, you will get a sum of backdated pay. Would you be offering it to your parents/brother to pay them back?

CornishGem1975 · 17/04/2022 17:03

YABU. It's not their responsibility to support you.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 17/04/2022 17:02

It's not up to your family to support you as a grown adult. If you can't afford it, drop the car, and try and get some kind of home work if you can go up your income.

Icecreamandapplepie · 17/04/2022 17:00

They aren't on high incomes themselves!

Certainly not enough to support a second household, sorry.

He shouldn't have snapped at you hut he's probably stressed at the thought of having to say no to you

Franklin12 · 17/04/2022 17:00

The OP hasn’t come back so it might be that all the family are on benefits or not. We just don’t know.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 17/04/2022 16:57

@Mellowyellow222

Is your whole family in receipt of benefits? Does anyone work?
That's not fair.

UC is paid to people who are working, but are on low wages. Receiving UC does not mean the claimant is not working.

LagunaBubbles · 17/04/2022 16:55

I'm.not sure what your aibu though?