Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think covid lateral flow tests should still be free...

141 replies

jobhunter7 · 17/04/2022 13:08

to think lateral flow tests should still be free...

OP posts:
jobhunter7 · 18/04/2022 11:26

After SARS in south-east asian countries, it became the norm to wear a mask if you were sniffly...

And most of the country probably has a reusable mask now... so we may as well wear use them to reduce the spread of flu and colds...

OP posts:
OnceUponAThread · 18/04/2022 11:01

I think either you remove the requirement for testing entirely or you make the tests free for those that need them. The system at the moment is shocking.

I'm pregnant and currently have to have regular scans. I have to show evidence of a negative LFT to access those scans.

I have to pay for LFTs, and the hospital is getting cross that I can't prove an official negative, because there's no way of registering the tests, because there are no NHS ones. But I can't access NHS ones. Vicious and expensive circle.

MIL is CEV. She has daily carers and is desperately unwell. We also spend a great deal of time looking after her. We could just not test before we see her, but then we could quite easily kill her. Yet more tests we're buying.

DH works in an industry that has a lot of events he has to attend. All those events require proof of a negative LFT. Work / event organisers won't provide them. If he doesn't go to the events he could lose his job. Even more tests we must buy.

Either scrap testing (e.g. for hospital appointments and work events) or provide tests for them for free. And there must be some sort of system to protect the CEV.

A total mess.

Not to mention that all the reported figures are now total BS because the vast majority of people can't register positive results 🙄

jobhunter7 · 18/04/2022 10:53

After SARS in south-east asian countries, it became the norm to wear a mask if you were sniffly...

OP posts:
Wizzbangfizz · 18/04/2022 10:37

@jobhunter7 masks hardly helped in Scotland and Wales did they? There isn't going to be any new campaigns and testing is on then way out - can't come soon enough as it is feeding hysteria and paranoia.

HardyBuckette · 18/04/2022 10:28

@Merrymouse

It's no surprise that so many people didn't follow it.

Some people couldn’t self isolate without support, but many, many who could reduced social contacts and did isolate. Measures to reduce social contact have reduced infection at all stages of the pandemic, so it’s a little silly to suggest they had no effect during Winter 2021/22

The fact that they demonstrably didn't control Omicron means arguments about future variants aren't actually applicable

See my previous point.

If you honestly think these restrictions have no effect, do you think hospitals are banning visitors and asking people to wear masks for a laugh?

Nobody said nobody followed the isolation restrictions, so that's a strawman. It was, however, an awful system, impossible to enforce and isn't coming back.

And again, if you had any actual evidence of the specific things you mentioned doing anything to control Omicron, you'd be able to post it rather than hiding behind things like silly because people question your faith. Or moving the goalposts: why do you think policies in hospitals, very restricted settings where it's possible to exert a much higher degree of control than in general life, mean something is going to curb Omicron on a population level? You haven't explained that at all.

Merrymouse · 18/04/2022 10:24

It's no surprise that so many people didn't follow it.

Some people couldn’t self isolate without support, but many, many who could reduced social contacts and did isolate. Measures to reduce social contact have reduced infection at all stages of the pandemic, so it’s a little silly to suggest they had no effect during Winter 2021/22

The fact that they demonstrably didn't control Omicron means arguments about future variants aren't actually applicable

See my previous point.

If you honestly think these restrictions have no effect, do you think hospitals are banning visitors and asking people to wear masks for a laugh?

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 18/04/2022 10:15

in other countries they just pay for it, what's the difference? Why can't the people of the UK pay for them directly?

Not if they cavy afford it, like if they are already struggling financially. The cost of living has sky rocketed recentjy.

fossilsmorefossils · 18/04/2022 10:10

@jobhunter7

By having no free tests - aren't we penalising people who care a bit and don't want to infect more vulnerable members of society?
In other countries they just pay for it, what's the difference? Why can't the people of the UK pay for them directly?
jobhunter7 · 18/04/2022 09:56

Am assuming people haven't been stockpiling too much as the flow tests have an expiry. But maybe the new advice/ad campaign could be just test if you feel like you have symptoms... so people are using far less of these lf tests...

OP posts:
HardyBuckette · 18/04/2022 09:52

@Merrymouse

You don't say what you mean by appropriate testing, but in the context of this thread it probably means widespread free at the point of use testing available to the public? And we already know that this plus masks didn't curb the Omicron wave, so it's essentially advocacy for something that hasn't worked. This is very important given the costs of the tests.

The Omicron variant is very infectious, but would have had a far higher peak without isolation and masks, so no, you are wrong to say that these measures have done nothing to curb omicron. Now numbers are increasing again and the government is playing its ‘nothing to see here’ game while schools and hospitals struggle. Even if everyone eventually catches Covid multiple times, infection rates matter.

There is no particular reason to believe that future variants will be milder.

In the short term appropriate testing certainly means more tests available for people in regular contact with people who are vulnerable, regardless of their income.

Whether universal free testing is required is another question, but the government has decided Covid is over, so testing can’t be discussed at all. Instead we have to waste time pointing out why their Rwanda scheme is bat shit crazy.

Meanwhile it’s very worrying when ministers talk about being the first country to make Covid endemic, as though that is within their control, or as though endemic diseases are harmless and require no restrictions or action.

You didn't mention isolation in the post I quoted. That being said, the system we had, where people could find themselves without money to pay basic living costs if they did isolate and criminalised if they didn't was a very bad one. It's no surprise that so many people didn't follow it.

And without any evidence, the assertion that the peak would've been higher if we hadn't done these things is just faith based. The fact that they demonstrably didn't control Omicron means arguments about future variants aren't actually applicable: the point you're making there is one in favour of interventions and policies that demonstrably work. Ie, not masks against Omicron. If there were viable options on the table to actually get such contagious variants under control, we'd be starting at a very different point from where we are now.

I've no objection in principle to more free at the point of use testing access for those in contact with vulnerable people, but no idea how we'd manage to administer something like that without it basically turning into free testing for anyone who wants it. It's not realistic to expect it would be policed in any way, so it would be expensive.

jobhunter7 · 18/04/2022 09:08

By having no free tests - aren't we penalising people who care a bit and don't want to infect more vulnerable members of society?

OP posts:
Merrymouse · 18/04/2022 09:01

You don't say what you mean by appropriate testing, but in the context of this thread it probably means widespread free at the point of use testing available to the public? And we already know that this plus masks didn't curb the Omicron wave, so it's essentially advocacy for something that hasn't worked. This is very important given the costs of the tests.

The Omicron variant is very infectious, but would have had a far higher peak without isolation and masks, so no, you are wrong to say that these measures have done nothing to curb omicron. Now numbers are increasing again and the government is playing its ‘nothing to see here’ game while schools and hospitals struggle. Even if everyone eventually catches Covid multiple times, infection rates matter.

There is no particular reason to believe that future variants will be milder.

In the short term appropriate testing certainly means more tests available for people in regular contact with people who are vulnerable, regardless of their income.

Whether universal free testing is required is another question, but the government has decided Covid is over, so testing can’t be discussed at all. Instead we have to waste time pointing out why their Rwanda scheme is bat shit crazy.

Meanwhile it’s very worrying when ministers talk about being the first country to make Covid endemic, as though that is within their control, or as though endemic diseases are harmless and require no restrictions or action.

trollopolis · 18/04/2022 08:21

It rare for flu to exceed 400 per 100k population - not ONS, but respectable figures - has happened only 6 times since the 1960s, and then only for a few weeks. We are only just down to 428 per 100k, after running much higher since the autumn. As seasonality seems to be weaker, then this is producing considerable more excess deaths

www.cambridge.org/core/journals/epidemiology-and-infection/article/lessons-from-40-years-surveillance-of-influenza-in-england-and-wales/C0D2582BC6DA0CF65D167DDE4A1EAA07

There are other graphs available if you google which look at excess deaths, and really show how much greater it has been in the covid pandemic years than in even pandemic flu years.

I'm sorry if the term 'big lie' was a bit much. But some inaccurate information is bandied round and repeated in ways that mean it gets a currency. And that's unfortunate because it's just plain wrong

HardyBuckette · 18/04/2022 08:20

I agree, except I think ‘living with it’ means taking appropriate measures like enabling appropriate testing, mask wearing etc.

The question is, why are these measures considered 'appropriate'? You don't say what you mean by appropriate testing, but in the context of this thread it probably means widespread free at the point of use testing available to the public? And we already know that this plus masks didn't curb the Omicron wave, so it's essentially advocacy for something that hasn't worked. This is very important given the costs of the tests.

UnmentionedElephantDildo · 18/04/2022 08:11

It's rare that there are more than 30,000 flu/pneumonia deaths per annum (that's the typical 'bad season' figure). Deaths are currently about 2000 a week (down from winter peaks, lower than previous variant) but,that's over 100,000 a year.

Even with likelihood of even lower rates in the summer, this is way more than flu.

And flu deaths include with/of so it's same basis of counting

Roselilly36 · 18/04/2022 07:54

@trollopolis

the country has had many more deaths in a usual flu year

Big lie technique still going strong I see

Research the ONS figures
trollopolis · 18/04/2022 07:38

the country has had many more deaths in a usual flu year

Big lie technique still going strong I see

Roselilly36 · 18/04/2022 07:32

I agree with PP, the “free” not free testing has cost the country billions, total waste of money.

People that wanted the vaccine have had it, hospitals are coping, Omicron is proving to be mild, absolutely no benefit for providing tests.

People need to move on with their lives, I am CEV but totally fed up with all the hysteria surrounding Covid.

Something is going to kill us all eventually but given the true Covid death figures it is unlikely to be Covid, the country has had many more deaths in a usual flu year.

Covid has caused so much fear and MH issues for many.

jobhunter7 · 18/04/2022 07:20

@Morph22010

"I would however like to see something where vulnerable adults are given some of of allowance thst there can hand out to people they want to visit"

sounds a good idea...

OP posts:
Morph22010 · 18/04/2022 06:36

You need to get past the mindset that they ever were free. We were all paying for them just not directly. Unfortunately people thinking them of free has led to a lot of waste, I remember a lot of threads people taking one on day 3 or 4 when isolating just to see, or taking more than one in a day just to see. I would however like to see something where vulnerable adults are given some of of allowance thst there can hand out to people they want to visit

Merrymouse · 18/04/2022 06:31

That's the reality for many who have no choice but to understand Covid is by no means over and "living with it" really isn't a viable option .
Testing would help as it did before- but hey that'd be admitting it's still a problem and absolutely nothing the same as flu .

I agree, except I think ‘living with it’ means taking appropriate measures like enabling appropriate testing, mask wearing etc.

Currently living with it means closing hospitals to visitors unless end of life, and vital services (schools, transport) struggling to function while the government pretends nothing is happening.

Mummyoflittledragon · 18/04/2022 06:22

I think for some circumstances, yes. Not for all. People were testing daily before going away on holiday. For some families, a box will have lasted a day or two. I get the anxiety. But none of those tests should have been free.

SpookySpirit · 18/04/2022 04:49

I get them, for free still

fossilsmorefossils · 18/04/2022 04:28

Nothing is ever free. You must pay it back through your taxes or inflation. Same as all the extra money they "released" (printed) during the pandemic so people could be furloughed or whatever. Now you get to pay it back through inflation. You always pay the costs. The best thing for a country is not to try get too much cheap or for free for individuals, look at the scandinavian countries, they're wealthier and have better health care despite paying a much higher income tax. Paying more into the system works.

Boredoutmymind · 18/04/2022 02:25

maybe we should give them free to people on low income.

I used to test every time i had a doctors appointment or was unwell as to stop the spread. I stayed indoors and limited my life while others went out.
I have only just got covid cuz of some people who lack basic hygiene and coughed without covering their mouth.