Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to suggest a different film for 9yo DD? It started a massive argument

181 replies

HouseofPhotos · 17/04/2022 08:11

Yesterday morning, my DW suggested we go to the cinema. She loves Harry Potter and there is a new Fantastic Beasts film out.
I have a 9yr old dd, and 12yr old ds, she has a 13yr old ds.
I suggested that dd doesn't like Harry Potter, and that is quite an adult film, she very much likes cartoons and is still nice and sweet and young in that way, and that I take her to see Sonic the Hedgehog at the same time.
This created such a big argument. I was in shock at how big a deal it became. I backed down almost instantly and said sorry, didn't realise it was going to upset you, it's OK, we'll all go to see the fantastic beasts film. She was so upset we didn't go to see anything. It had created too big a drama.

Her main points were:
My double standards as I've taken dd to see star wars in the past and she's not really into that either.
I'm creating a divide in the family.
She said this is child led parenting, and since when did we start doing that. (I've never given any thought to or had any discussions about child led parenting. I don't know the pros and cons) My only answer to that was that we often involve the children in conversations about days out and get them involved.

It was a horrible atmosphere in the house for the rest of the day. DW only spoke to me when she had to, and if I spoke to her, I got 1 word answers back

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fdgdfgdfgdfg · 25/04/2022 17:04

The last few Star Wars films were 12A in the cinema too. There isn't a 12 rating at the cinema, hasn't been for 10 years or so. All 12 films are 12A, meaning Films rated 12A are suitable for children aged 12 and over However, people younger than 12 may see a 12A so long as they are accompanied by an adult. For home release (DVD, streaming etc.) it becomes a 12.

Personally, I think it's a daft system, just means that kids end up in films that aren't suitable for them.

OP, I think the issue here is that your wife feels like she's chosen a film for a choice, and you've ridden roughshod over her plans. Whether or not thats actually a valid reason to kick off depends on whether or not thats something you do frequently.

RoseslnTheHospital · 25/04/2022 16:18

There's more going on here than the actual business of what film to see. Your comment was not unreasonable and the kind of conversation I have had with my partner about our two children and what films would be suitable for them both. There's obviously some kind of resentment or built up tension over "fairness" between all the children, and how that all works as a blended family compared to when you were on your own. That's something you need to discuss when the children aren't around and when you can do so without it turning into an argument.

Quartz2208 · 25/04/2022 16:18

I agree the last Star Wars movie was very similar to the fantastic beasts - far more niche than the originals and Harry Potter and definitely not more appropriate- Star Wars have huge numbers of deaths - the Death Star takes out over a million people

the issue is @HouseofPhotos is that you apply the, to make you and your side happy not her

so should you be? That is the question with your DD

10HailMarys · 25/04/2022 16:05

In the past we've all gone to see star wars films, which probably wasn't at the top of DD preferred list. But they were appropriate in terms of content.

Can't really see what would be in Fantastic Beasts that would be less 'appropriate' than Star Wars films.

The old Star Wars films are Us and PGs (although this actually surprises me given that the first one has scenes of the charred remains of Luke's aunt and uncle and a scene where an arm gets cut off, if I remember correctly). But the recent Star Wars films all seem to be rated 12, which means they aren't suitable for under 12s at all, while Fantastic Beasts is a 12A, which means under-12s can see it if accompanied by an adult.

In general there's something slightly weird about your insistence that your 9-year-old is too 'nice and sweet and young' for Fantastic Beasts because she only likes cartoons, but you don't think she's too nice and sweet and young for light-sabres, storm troopers and malevolent aliens, and if was your DW I would find it irritating and think you were just being precious for no reason.

Overall, though, you both sound like massive drama queens.

HouseofPhotos · 25/04/2022 14:03

Update - thank you all for your comments, thought i'd share with you all what happened next.

Separate films were watched. All had a great time. Although DW was and still is not happy about it.

We've discussed it and the upset is down to me applying double standards to things.

There are various examples given.

In the past we've all gone to see star wars films, which probably wasn't at the top of DD preferred list. But they were appropriate in terms of content.

There have also been times we have gone to do activities for DS, and DD has had to come.

Mostly of these occasions have been due to there not being an option for her to do something different, logistically. I was on my own for quite a while.

I think there are times when it may seem like double standards are being applied, but that will happen sometimes when you're trying to keep everyone happy.

My DW does not see it like this. Very upset that the one time she picks a film and suggests that we all go to see it as a family, i have made it difficult.

OP posts:
EyePeeEh · 17/04/2022 22:51

There aren’t that many reviews yet, so maybe it’ll shift over time, but interesting that Common Sense Media currently say the latest Fantastic Beasts is suitable for ages 14 and up.

www.commonsensemedia.org/movie-reviews/fantastic-beasts-the-secrets-of-dumbledore

bellac11 · 17/04/2022 20:55

@Partyatnumber10

Fascinating thread, if it had been about a "dh" instead of a "dw" there would have been a flood of Ltb He is emotionally abusing you Type comments.
Absolutely and because some posters assume the OP is a man (they might be, they might not), some posters blamed the OP and others tried to make out theres something creepy or inappropriate in the 'language used'.

What a joke some people are.

Gowithme · 17/04/2022 20:54

Has she seen the first two fantastic beasts films? If not she won't have a frigging clue what's going on. I wouldn't take her, these films are very different from the HP ones (especially the earlier HP ones).

JaninaDuszejko · 17/04/2022 20:53

I don't understand about having 'rules' around reading the books before watching films either. People don't seem to say this about Roald Dahl films, just HP.

Can't speak for others but as a general principle if I'm planning to read a book I prefer to read it before watching the film so I don't imagine the actors when reading. As far as my DC goes there is so much social pressure for young children to watch 12 rated shows, particularly around Harry Potter and MCU. Mine didn't get to watch Marvel until they were 12 (I don't like the cartoon violence) and the 'read the book before watching the film' rule for HP was a way of delaying them seeing the 12 rated films. Roald Dahl books are PG rated films so not the same need to delay.

Partyatnumber10 · 17/04/2022 20:52

Fascinating thread, if it had been about a "dh" instead of a "dw" there would have been a flood of
Ltb
He is emotionally abusing you
Type comments.

Sometimeswinning · 17/04/2022 20:38

Still nice and sweet and young. Because growing up at all would nahe her less nice.

Yes! My 6 year old is a bloody delight. My 12 year old is lovely but a bit off at times. Knows far too much and is always, always right regardless of anyone else's opinion.

SummerBluez · 17/04/2022 20:24

Sonic is hardly a stereotypical girly choice for the poster bizarrely insisting the child is being forced to stay a young girly girl.

EyePeeEh · 17/04/2022 20:16

Presumably the boys are not nice and sweet and young.
The ‘gotcha’ over this is tiresome.

The OP said that DD was ‘nice and sweet and young’ specifically in regard to her viewing preferences (basically that she does not enjoy more mature content).

The boys are older and, by the sounds of things, are more likely to enjoy a dark/disturbing movie.

OP could have worded it better but this nit-picking seems pretty unhelpful and irrelevant to the thread.

BadNomad · 17/04/2022 19:33

God. I would have left huffy bollocks at home and taken all the kids by myself to see Sonic.

But I'm guessing there is more to it than this.

SoggyPaper · 17/04/2022 19:16

Presumably the boys are not nice and sweet and young.

SoggyPaper · 17/04/2022 19:15

‘is still nice and sweet and young’

Still nice and sweet and young. Because growing up at all would nahe her less nice.

That’s telling.

Goldbar · 17/04/2022 19:12

If the film is 12A rated, it doesn't sound like it's suitable for the average 9 year old. You as your DD's parent get to decide whether it is suitable for your DD, not your wife.

BeautifulDragon · 17/04/2022 19:07

My DD who is 10 now only really stopped enjoying The Julia Donaldson books when she was 7/8, still liked Peter Rabbit

Parents want their children to read HP as young as possible so they can brag about it, regardless of how suitable it is. I never realised this until I was introduced via MN. I don't understand about having 'rules' around reading the books before watching films either. People don't seem to say this about Roald Dahl films, just HP.

I let my children choose what they watch/ read, as long as it's suitable.

Persephonegoddess · 17/04/2022 18:50

The FB film is a 12 is it even okay to take the 9yr old too? You were right to suggest, watching films is not a group activity unless you are going to talk all the way through so suggesting a split was fine.

fortifiedwithtea · 17/04/2022 18:46

@Hwory its not a trilogy. Its a 5 part series

EyePeeEh · 17/04/2022 18:45

Its a trivial thing but I find it quite worrying that this couldn't be discussed calmly and it resulted in not going and then sulking/anger the entire day.
It seems like a vast over reaction and quite honestly a red flag.
This really. Your wife’s behaviour today sounds abusive and toxic. Has similar happened previously?

bellac11 · 17/04/2022 18:43

@AchillesPoirot

I’m not implying any sinister thoughts at all.

I feel she’s being kept babyish and not allowed to just be. She has to be sweet and nice. And girly.

But I most certainly do not mean anything more than that. As I’ve said now more than once

You know this child then I take it?
Hwory · 17/04/2022 18:32

Has anyone even seen the first two fantastic beast films in your household? Are you / your DW aware that it’s the final in a trilogy?

EyePeeEh · 17/04/2022 18:31

Sounds like your wife was and is behaving like an ass. Is she often like this?

Incidentally, as an adult I’d rather watch Sonic 2 than the latest Fantastic Beasts. The former looks like disposable fun and the latter boring/grim and not a stand-alone story.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 17/04/2022 18:24

Its a trivial thing but I find it quite worrying that this couldn't be discussed calmly and it resulted in not going and then sulking/anger the entire day.
It seems like a vast over reaction and quite honestly a red flag.