Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this meeting is too far to travel to?

140 replies

Martha5983 · 17/04/2022 07:43

I joined a new team at work during the lockdown. The team live all over the UK.

A 2 hour face to face meeting and lunch has been arranged in May. I’m only allowed overnight accommodation in very specific circumstances- for example if I complete a site visit the following day. It starts at 11.30 to ‘allow travel on the day’. The journey will be 6 hours - meaning that to attend the meeting I’ll need to be on a train at 5:30 - probably up at around 4am. Journey home will mean I am home around 10pm. I don’t have a company car and my normal working week is 9-3 four days a week.

It’s in the middle of my daughters SATS week - so I’m not keen on an overnight for that reason.

I feel pressured to go because it’s important for team building and on the basis that I’ve worked from home and travelled minimally for the last few years. I don’t mind being flexible with my working pattern. But even before covid the max travel I’ve done in one day would have been a journey of around 2 hours.

AIBU to say that this journey is unreasonable and that I’ll join remotely or will I risk looking like I’m not a team player and miss out on the face to face contact?

OP posts:
Fuuuuuckit · 17/04/2022 11:23

@bumblingbovine49 OP herself said its 4.45 journey, so 9.5 hours altogether.

Yeah, it's a ballache. But it's a one-off. She also said she's been wfh for however long, and her nearest office is 30 mins away. Only takes a fortnight working in the office before she's hit 10h commuting time.

Hbh17 · 17/04/2022 11:12

Hire a car - will probably be cheaper than the train.

bumblingbovine49 · 17/04/2022 10:53

@BIWI

But it isn't a 12 hour round trip ...
6 hours each way is a 12 hour round trip A train journey that is close to 5 hours long can l easily end up being around 6 hours hours door to door. Doing that each way is a 11-12 hour round trip , unless I am going bonkers
theleafandnotthetree · 17/04/2022 10:42

@CaitoftheCantii

People who think their work life is ‘social’ drive me nuts. I’m there to work, not to socialise. I’ll buy some communal biscuits and pass the time of day, but I’m not treating colleagues as my ‘work family’. Especially those who turn a simple two hour meeting into a two day jolly…
Well people who treat their colleagues like an annoyance drive me nuts. It is entirely possible to do ones work well AND enjoy and benefit from the company of others and a sense of collective purpose. If you have never had that experience- I have had it in most jobs I've had - then I actually feel sorry for you.
BIWI · 17/04/2022 10:01

But it isn't a 12 hour round trip ...

bumblingbovine49 · 17/04/2022 10:01

ffs, what the hell does it matter how old the car is, I'd not want to do 12 hours of driving in one day for a 2 hour meeting, whatever kind of car it was No-one in their right mind would in my opinion

OP I completely agree that this is a completely unacceptable distance to travel in one day for work and am with you on that. I'm afraid however that if the company is willing to pay for one night of accommodation, I have the view that you should go.

I appreciate that you have things going on at home that make this difficult but I do think you should attend as it is such a rare occurrence. I would not however be spending my own money on a hotel and I would contact the company to say that unless they are willing to pay for a hotel I wouldn't be going as a 10-12 hour return journey (either via car or train) was an unacceptable length of time to travel to and from work. I'd probably offer to take the day as leave (not what I'd want to waste leave on but hey ho), unpaid leave if necessary or something else but I would hold the line at not travelling that amount of time without an overnight stay paid for, But that is just what I would do as I could afford to take an unpaid day and it would be worth it to me to miss such unpleasant day

They could then either sack me (highly unlikely though I suppose you know best if this is likely to happen in your job), pay for accommodation, let me miss the meeting either via leave or just letting me not go or letting me attend remotely.

In the end you need to decide your line and stick to it. Mine would be to attend but only of a hotel stay was provided. Yours might be to take a day of leave or to outright refuse to go. What would they d if you did that?

DropYourSword · 17/04/2022 10:01

Clearly I've lived a sheltered life as I think a 12 hour round trip for a 2 hour team meeting is bloody ludicrous!!

LakieLady · 17/04/2022 09:56

@BIWI

Just looking at the Trainline, there's a 6.04 train from Norwich that arrives into Manchester at 10.46, which is a 30 minute later start than in your OP, and a journey time of 4hr 42 mins. Unless you live 80 minutes away from the station, it's not a 6 hour journey!

TBH, having to catch at train at 6am really isn't that much of a hardship and it does all sound like you're looking for reasons not to want to go. As PP have said, do you want to be that person?!

If there's a suitably convenient train back, the OP could be home by 7-ish after a meeting that ends at 1.30, so I need to revise my vote to YABU!

It's a bastard long day, but as long as they don't make a habit of it, I think it would be best to suck it up, tbh. You don't want to be That Member of the Team, OP!

Cross country travel in this country is a nightmare imo. You could get from Brighton to Newcastle in that sort of time, because it's in and out of London.

SafelySoftly · 17/04/2022 09:51

I’d go OP. Take the more environmentally friendly option of the train. You can work both ways using train WiFi.

Pluvia · 17/04/2022 09:51

I regularly (once a month) had to do these kind of journeys with one of my jobs. The worst was Cardiff to Cambridge, which was the same length journey as yours and involved battling my way on the tube in rush hour. If it's just a one-off getting-to-meet-you meeting then just get on with doing it. Make sure in advance you'll get TOIL. My job was a new project and no one had thought it through properly, so they'd assumed they wouldn't have to pay me for the 10-hour+ journey. They changed their tune when I resigned. Take books, food, a flask and load an audio book on your phone. I used the time to read, sort out lots of domestic issues, send emails and have a snooze. And you get 10 hours TOIL for when you need a day or two off.

Southwest12 · 17/04/2022 09:43

I'd do that far on a train, but not that train. Some days that service is only half the carriages and really old and uncomfortable seats. Even if they send the correct train its pretty rubbish compared to the trains they run on the mainline.

Longingforsunshine · 17/04/2022 09:38

I live near Norwich. You can fly direct Norwich to Manchester. I have done that for a meeting before. Otherwise I insist on an overnight stay, that much travelling in one day would likely be against their travel policy

dropoutdoreen · 17/04/2022 09:38

Is this a regular thing or once in a blue moon? If the latter, suck it up and go

JurasicPerks · 17/04/2022 09:36

I reckon the people setting the meeting wont have factored in the rural location of your home. From just glancing at a map, it doesnt look unreasonable. But 12 hrs of travel makes for a long day.

I'd go, but investigate faster routes. The Peterborough suggestion is good. Anywhere closer with a major train station?

DH's work does this, but they rotate the major office they go to. Sometimes it's a horrible journey. Sometimes it's an hour up the road.
I'd say go, especially to the first one. If it's in Manchester everytime, and not particularly beneficial, dont go to all in the future, but do go to thus first one.

SoManyTshirts · 17/04/2022 09:29

I used to do 4 hour mostly train each way commutes for meetings every few weeks, I found 7am train for 11:00 meeting was OK and would be home about 21:40.

However, trying to catch the 6am for a 10:00 meeting just meant my brain was completely scrambled when I got there. Working the day before, no real downtime but sleep. My employers were understanding and allowed me an overnight for early ones.

CaitoftheCantii · 17/04/2022 09:28

People who think their work life is ‘social’ drive me nuts. I’m there to work, not to socialise. I’ll buy some communal biscuits and pass the time of day, but I’m not treating colleagues as my ‘work family’. Especially those who turn a simple two hour meeting into a two day jolly…

BookWorm45 · 17/04/2022 09:25

Hi OP, you're getting quite a hard time here from some posters. I sympathise with your question. Given this is a rare event, I think you would be seen as "not a team player" if you joined remotely. However , how much does that matter? Are you in a role where you need to network in person? Do you behave in a friendly team way on a normal day?
If you do decide to go, I would suggest you stay overnight before, and I feel your company should pay for this

dizzydizzydizzy · 17/04/2022 09:19

I wouldn't be worried about sats.

Yes, secondary schools do sometimes use them for streaming but your stream is not set in stone. Kids are moved up and down all the time. Secondary schools are fully aware which primaries in their area do the most coaching for SATS and therefore have the most inflated grades.

As for the meeting OP, I would just go. Either have your breakfast on the train or stay the night. Although I agree it is annoying to travel so far for a 2 hour meeting plus lunch.

Martha5983 · 17/04/2022 09:09

Thanks for all the comments - especially the ones giving me the talking to I need 😄.

@Travellingraspberry - thank you particularly for the good suggestion - it’s an hour and half from here to Peterborough by car but I think that’s a good compromise.

OP posts:
theleafandnotthetree · 17/04/2022 09:05

@CaitoftheCantii

If you spend more time/money travelling than the meeting lasts, it’s a waste of resources that could be better spent on something more productive - local government was like this. It’s a job, not a social event. Join by zoom, use the rest of the time on normal work.
But for the vast majority of people, and jobs, some element of social interaction really helps to oil the wheels in terms of doing our jobs. But apart from that, do people not welcome the opportunity to meet orhers in person, to actually get to know their colleagues even a little in person? I cannot understand this joyless notion of the job as a pure grind only to make money where meeting colleagues is seen as a chore and a nuisance.
Glamora · 17/04/2022 09:04

I would expect you to attend

TenoringBehind · 17/04/2022 09:00

I’d do it was a one off.

SATs shouldn’t be a factor in your decision. They really don’t matter for anything.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 17/04/2022 09:00

AIBU to say that this journey is unreasonable and that I’ll join remotely or will I risk looking like I’m not a team player and miss out on the face to face contact?

Deffo the latter

CaitoftheCantii · 17/04/2022 08:57

If you spend more time/money travelling than the meeting lasts, it’s a waste of resources that could be better spent on something more productive - local government was like this. It’s a job, not a social event. Join by zoom, use the rest of the time on normal work.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 17/04/2022 08:55

I would go, it's a one off and they've given you plenty of notice. Perhaps ask if they could provide a hotel room but I don't think it's too much travel for a one off tbh.