Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you feel about this

44 replies

secretsqizzle · 16/04/2022 21:04

Next door neighbour but one is 62.. his wife is in a nursing home. She has early onset dementia. She knows him sometimes: but not always.

He has met a lady at the home . Visits her husband daily (as does he) .. there is definitely something between them.

They are both married.

I am a good friend of his . He is torn . Believed in 'till death do we part '

Overcome with loneliness. His wife has been in care for 4 years... real chance of possible love and compassion. With new woman

Should s/he. ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PinkSyCo · 17/04/2022 05:24

I think he should go for it, but he will need to be very sensitive to their DC’s (if there are any) feelings if he does.

Fraaahnces · 17/04/2022 04:29

I would be much more concerned about the gossipy neighbours and their opinions. You know the old saying equating opinions and arseholes…

jokalyn · 17/04/2022 04:28

@SD1978 I've recently watched my grandma decline over a few years with dementia and it does get to a point it is worse than death. She became a different person, basically like a toddler again, but I know doe a fact if she had the choice she would have opted out 4 years ago. Same as I would or anybody I know. No body wants be become bedridden, mind messed up, can't actually live anymore you just survive. It's inhumane how dementia can take over but no one would choose that life

jokalyn · 17/04/2022 04:21

@HELLITHURT me and my husband have already discussed the idea of divorcing and what's best. Because I don't want to be in a home using up all our savings that I had planned for the kids and grandkids, and him watching me become a person that's not me. I would rather he moved on and I could see him happy and carry on living. If I was dying in a nursing home I couldn't stand my family dying with me.

HELLITHURT · 17/04/2022 04:05

@SD1978

Dementia is crueller than death in some ways. The person who you loved physically is still there, and yet all your shared history isn't. I would never judge, and I'd be shutting down anyone who did to me about anyone else's circumstances
Agreed , there are things worse than death.
SD1978 · 17/04/2022 04:01

Dementia is crueller than death in some ways. The person who you loved physically is still there, and yet all your shared history isn't. I would never judge, and I'd be shutting down anyone who did to me about anyone else's circumstances

redbigbananafeet · 17/04/2022 03:37

I'd wish him all the happiness in the world with his new companion and I hope they bring much love and comfort to each other

HELLITHURT · 17/04/2022 03:32

@secretsqizzle

That is exactly what I think. ! some neighbours have commented that 'until death do is part' means just that ...
Tell them to walk a mile in your neighbours shoes, then comment!
NowNowDermot · 17/04/2022 03:12

@secretsqizzle

That is exactly what I think. ! some neighbours have commented that 'until death do is part' means just that ...
What a shame if they miss their chance of happiness due to other people's judgement Sad
BobbyRhude · 17/04/2022 02:26

Yes he should, I worked in care for a number of years and seen several men/women who have cared for a spouse with dementia (not necessarily even in a care home) but also had relationships for support and otherwise outside the marriage. It's bloody hard looking after someone with dementia, no matter how much you love and respect them, seeking companionship is natural and healthy.

WildCoasts · 17/04/2022 02:13

In this situation I'd have sympathy for both of them and not judge at all. The situation with their respective spouses is very tough and having each other for support is golden. As long as they continue to be the same partner to their spouses who they married in sickness and in health.

Runliketheclappers · 17/04/2022 02:09

Yes, it’s another chance at happiness for them.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 17/04/2022 02:05

Yes I think they should
Although their partners are still alive, in body, their minds are not
I'd never judge anyone in this situation

boronia · 17/04/2022 01:01

I know of a similar situation: she's a widow, his wife in care with dementia ( wife doesn't really know who he is).
The new couple are both grieving and it's lovely that they've found each other.
Widow's children know, the man's children do not ( couple live separately in the same aged care facility).
No one's business except theirs.

IDontHaveAnOutingHobby · 16/04/2022 23:04

@TabithaTittlemouse

Why are all of his neighbours discussing this?
This is Mumsnet, they also discuss how much each earns and their favourite sexual position
SGChome20 · 16/04/2022 23:02

I would have no issue at all if this person was a friend, colleague, brother etc but as their child I would struggle with it which should be a consideration for both sides. I'd want my dad to be happy but it would be very difficult and wouldn't want it thrown in my face. I completely understand the desire for romance/companionship though.

cloudylemonade13 · 16/04/2022 22:50

Yes definitely. Dementia is just the cruellest disease and the last 4 years (plus those before she went into the home) will have been a lonely nightmare for him.

BadHairDayExpert · 16/04/2022 22:46

They both should take the opportunity to have intimacy, support and healing within each other but continue to visit their spouses without ever mentioning it i.e. offloading guilt or asking permission in their partners' more lucid moments.

PlasticineMeg · 16/04/2022 22:44

Yes. It’s a sad situation all round but we have to find happiness where we can in dark times

WimpyKidYouNot · 16/04/2022 22:43

Anyone who is caring for someone with dementia needs all the support/friends they can get.

Sounds like a v gossipy neighbourhood which is actually not nice and whatever is going on (or isn’t) is no one’s business but theirs.

Candleabra · 16/04/2022 22:41

Yes. Anyone who has lived through a dementia diagnosis know just how terrible it is. And how complicated your feelings for your loved ones are. But most people will say no publicly. They don’t understand. People are very judgemental.

TabithaTittlemouse · 16/04/2022 22:40

Why are all of his neighbours discussing this?

LadyLolaRuben · 16/04/2022 22:36

@TheHoleNineYards

Yes. He can still care for her, and his (prospective) partner can still care for her husband, but they can love each other to.
This. Yes he can do both. No one can get hurt. They can be the best versions of themselves for their partners and be content in a loving companionship or whatever it is at home
VyeBrator · 16/04/2022 22:35

@secretsqizzle

That is exactly what I think. ! some neighbours have commented that 'until death do is part' means just that ...
I think he should too

But what he shouldn't be doing is blabbing about his private life to his neighbours.

At least let his wife have some dignity.

Thedogscollar · 16/04/2022 22:32

Definitely yes. They can understand the devastation of this illness and if any happiness can come from this then why not?