Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should Mumsnet have it's own middle class section ?

313 replies

hattie43 · 16/04/2022 18:36

Reading some of these threads turning nasty it's really apparent that people have such different lives there will never be common ground . Nor does there need to be but the insults are not nice.

A thread posted by someone asking a question , to some a reasonable question being jumped on by ' the poor ' as tone deaf means legitimate conversation has been drowned out .

Should Mumsnet be divided so
' middle classes 'can discuss things the poor don't relate to and likewise ' the poor ' can discuss their issues without ' tone deaf ' comments from people who aren't financially destitute ?

The other thing I don't get is why jump on a thread you don't like why not just scroll on by and join a discussion you do like . Being a hater is never going to resolve anything .

OP posts:
Xenia · 16/04/2022 20:38

It would be a very bad idea. One advantage of MN is everyone can post although I try to stay out of topics like those not too relevant to me eg where parents with children with disabilities want to talk about that as they tend not to like outsiders butting in and I think there are rules for the black mumsnetters sections too.

Class is not to do with money in the UK. You can be rich and working class and poor and middle class.

longwayoff · 16/04/2022 20:35

Middle class and poor? Possibly. A government minister was on TV yesterday and claimed he worries about his overdraft by the middle of the month. Given that he's earning 100k plus, plus expenses, I shudder to think what he spends his money on. Not tins of beans, I think.

cansu · 16/04/2022 20:31

Given that some people identify on here as 'Judgemental and proud here. I’ll also admit to snobbishness and also a fair amount of intolerance.
But I’m not sure if it should be in middle class or not. I have WC roots but am right up there in the aspirational Ocado shopping MC wildnerness now.'. I think you could just have topic called 'Judgemental and proud'. They can then knock themselves out slagging off the masses and talking about their latest property related nightmare.

longwayoff · 16/04/2022 20:28

'A first world problems' thread? That's a redundant suggestion isn't it?

LakieLady · 16/04/2022 20:27

@SharpLily

I think there shoud be a 'we are gentle ladies' type board, for all those who are horrified because their husband accidentally let off a fart in front of them and everyone piles in with 'LT disgusting B'. Never in real life have I come across people with such delicate sensibilities and it seems far more polarising than money.
I like this idea. Then all the uptight buttock-clenchers who moan about swearing could fuck off there and leave the potty-mouths in peace.
Tubs11 · 16/04/2022 20:27

"Middle class" here and that post was absolutely tone deaf! What was even more apparent was the sheer ignorance of sustainability, empathy and self awareness. Class is irrelevant when it comes to these things so maybe a section for those with common sense and those that are lacking would be better?

DragonOverTheMoon · 16/04/2022 20:27

@Dancer47 well MN isn't a dissertation is it Grin

Pick my grammar apart all you like, I managed a first class degree with no GCSEs due to a chaotic homelife and foster care. Pat your smug self on the back for being a nit pick Biscuit

FangsForTheMemory · 16/04/2022 20:26

Weird suggestion. You can be middle class AND poor. I used to be absolutely broke the second half of each month.

Dancer47 · 16/04/2022 20:23

@DragonOverTheMoon

I'm not MC. I'm a grown up now, teenage mum who spent a good few years on benefits before going to uni and getting a decent job. I have never got bitter over those who have more than me. I really really don't understand this (seemingly new) attitude of being bitter about others being better off. I hated being broke and living on benefits, I sorted my shit out. If you don't want to be poor I really don't understand why, as an adult, you don't take responsibility for yourself and sort it out (obviously there are exceptions to this rule with disabilities ect) will probs have to name change now. Grin
You went to university, yet you abbreviate "et cetera" as "ect". NICE.
Blackmagicqueen · 16/04/2022 20:15

Anybody using the word hater who isn't a teenager is in my opinion questionable. It is very evident you are bitter about people who have less than you that you describe as 'the poor' and destitute.' Is this Robin Hood? I really think there is a lot more going on in the world to think about rather than grouping people into classes Hmm

JaneJeffer · 16/04/2022 20:14

You'd probably think I were middle class
Definitely wouldn't.

Sortilege · 16/04/2022 20:13

@Hospedia

I'm not poor and I still thought the thread in question was tone deaf.
This.

I don’t think anyone objecting to that OP identified themselves as ‘the poor’, either. At least not on the first few pages that I could bear to read.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 16/04/2022 20:12

I don’t agree over the class thing as some middle class people have far less than some working class people and at the end of the day the cost of living crisis impacts those with less liquid cash regardless of how many degrees they have and how much quinoa they eat a week.

Nevertheless I kind of get what you’re saying. It’s got to a point where nobody can post about having anything more than the basics without people jumping down their throat. Someone posts about a holiday or a house purchase and people trip over themselves to go on to the thread (which they have the option to scroll past or hide) to complain about how they have no money and how the OP makes them feel bad and then it descends into a Four Yorkshiremen sketch.

Half the people complaining also repeatedly voted for the shower that put them in the food bank queue too which makes it even more tiresome.

DrSbaitso · 16/04/2022 20:11

@Booboobagins

You sound like a right pompous moron. Everyone has an option. The IP needs to sift through answers to find ones tgat chime/help.

What tge F are classes anyway? You know everyone even the ridiculously ricg are a few months away from being homeless? And tgat includes you and me. BTW I earn 6 figure salary have a 5 bed 3 bath 3 car house. I can though relate to low income issues because I built my career it wasn't handed to me on a plate or associated to me via marriage.

You're on six figures but would be homeless in a few months if you lost your job?

Maybe you should downsize.

Chewchewaboogie · 16/04/2022 20:11

Op which thread are you refering to please.. id like to read it .thanks

SpinningMeSoftly · 16/04/2022 20:10

I'm assuming the OP's premise here is facetious?

Barkingmadhouse · 16/04/2022 20:08

It should not be needed but I am seeing an ever increasing number of posts which show an unfortunate need for this divide. I do however agree it would be carnage with no one able to agree on what is middle class post worthy

over2021 · 16/04/2022 20:04

What even is middle class? You'd probably think I were middle class if you saw my home/family/lifestyle (plus I sound 'posh'- despite growing up on a council estate... DH who grew up in a very different very posh house sounds like Phil Mitchell Grin)

Guess what would happen if I stopped working....? Ergo, I'm working class.

5128gap · 16/04/2022 20:03

The thread was in AIBU. Some people thought she was and expressed that. Anyone who didn't was at perfect liberty to continue the discussion, they didn't have their posts removed AFAIK, so the discussion wasn't 'stifled'. To make this a social class issue and call for a separate board where 'poor' people's opinions would be absent would surely stifle discussion. Unless your idea of discussion is everyone agreeing and no one challenging anyone or offering any new perspectives. In which case maybe a board called 'The echo chamber' is more what you're looking for.

Booboobagins · 16/04/2022 20:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Smidgy · 16/04/2022 19:59

You know there are a lot of middle class people who are poor and working class people who are rich? What a weird suggestion. Segregating by class or money is a horrible idea.

Milomonster · 16/04/2022 19:57

This has to be the most ridiculous and poorly thought out question I’ve read on MN for a while…

DragonOverTheMoon · 16/04/2022 19:56

But @lameasahorse your experience is valid. Waiting a long time to conceive and the disappointment every month is an extremely valid emotion. Just because someone had it worse than you doesn't invalidate your experience.

itsgettingweird · 16/04/2022 19:55

It doesn't need different sections.

It needs people to stop jumping on with dickish comments.

All this "don't ya know there's........" to everything is just pure stupid.

People are aware there's a war in Ukraine, cost of living crisis etc.

I'm working class. I'm still working class. I've been on the bare bones of my arse and I'm comfortable now. I didn't begrudge those on MN who had stuff when I shopped in Aldi with a calculator and I still don't hold it against people who have more now.

Alightjacket · 16/04/2022 19:55

The thread you're talking about was tone deaf. It was an innocent post at first but then the further posting of the OP was obviously not. It was shamefully goady, during a cost of living crisis (CRISIS being the key word here), that started off innocently enough talking about changes they had made. Then going on to imply 'oh isn't it a lovely mindful experience?' 'So much more eco friendly' Like it's a yoga retreat! It is not a mindful experience to people genuinely living in poverty, who are going to struggle even more than they already are, some people will El inevitably die because they can't afford to eat or heat their homes. And to imply it is, is ignorant and outrageously insulting.

Disgusting you refer to 'the poor' and 'financially destitute'. It's not only 'poor' people that have empathy by the way.

Threads are there for discussion. It's hardly a discussion if everyone who disagrees scrolls on by and the whole thread is just in agreement with the OP.