Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should Mumsnet have it's own middle class section ?

313 replies

hattie43 · 16/04/2022 18:36

Reading some of these threads turning nasty it's really apparent that people have such different lives there will never be common ground . Nor does there need to be but the insults are not nice.

A thread posted by someone asking a question , to some a reasonable question being jumped on by ' the poor ' as tone deaf means legitimate conversation has been drowned out .

Should Mumsnet be divided so
' middle classes 'can discuss things the poor don't relate to and likewise ' the poor ' can discuss their issues without ' tone deaf ' comments from people who aren't financially destitute ?

The other thing I don't get is why jump on a thread you don't like why not just scroll on by and join a discussion you do like . Being a hater is never going to resolve anything .

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 18/04/2022 20:34

@Yourgirlfriendrachel

What’s poor though? Someone who only has £7 to last the week will be told they’ve got it good because someone else has £3 then someone in their overdraft will come on and complain about that only to be told by the next poster they’re privileged to have an overdraft. It’d be chaos.
Exactly, it's the Four Yorkshiremen syndrome so beloved of MNers.
5128gap · 18/04/2022 16:42

@stayathomer

And just for the avoidance of doubt, in my opinion, no, someone's positive experience of walking more and wasting less resources is not as valid in a discussion on the CoL crisis as someone else's experience of being hungry and cold. It serves only to dilute the perception of the impact on people who are suffering. But that op wasn't trying to change the world, they were simply talking about something positive they got out of it. One of the comments was about the people in the pandemic who were positive about the experience, cursing about how they found it acceptable to post that they were gardening and shit. I was positive on sm over the pandemic. My neighbour died, I didn't see my mum or my brothers or sister throughout, my brother has aspergers and talks to himself and bashes his head off the walls but I didn't say that, I posted about us gardening and painting and playing football and sending stuff to my mum and bro. Was that not a valid thing to do to try to keep myself and others positive? Who decides whose stuff is valid? You can well believe people would approve if I did posts about my bro and my mum but I don't.
It is a valid thing to try and keep other people positive, but if that was the OPs intention, then she made a mistake, as it didn't work. People worrying about not having enough to eat don't typically see the benefits to the environment as making it all worth while. If the OP came from a good place, but genuinely didn't realise that people had other priorities, then it's better she was told than repeat her mistake.
5128gap · 18/04/2022 16:34

[quote Lunar27]@5128gap

Thanks. To be honest I didn't interpret the post that way at all. To me the OP stated quite clearly that those were positives relating to him/her specifically, not globally. As such I didn't find it distasteful. Some did but others didn't so guess it wasn't clear cut.

Another example. Recently I posted advice that EV's could be more accessible via salary sacrifice. Clearly this isn't applicable to everyone and only to those considering a new car, but could save a small fortune if applicable. I received a response that 'accessible' is privileged as some can't even afford a new car. Accessible has many meanings relative to the context in which it's used. I didn't mean accessible for people who can't afford a new car in the first place (obviously) but for those who can but where an EV might be a stretch.

I've read a number of other threads where people have been accused of being insensitive and seems like another silencing method.

In terms of dilution I'm not sure it does. Unless people don't watch the news, TV or surf the internet, I think most are acutely aware of the increasing suffering in this country. Some forum members discussing personal issues that happen to be MC specific isn't likely to alter anything, given the less well of account for the vast majority of the population.

Perhaps given demographics a sub forum isn't a bad idea after all.[/quote]
I think those reactions to your thread were different, and they were wrong. You were asking a question about specific circumstances and there was no need for people not affected by those circumstances to jump on to have a go at you. But those who did that did it because they enjoy a row, not because they're 'the poor' or WC, the vast majority of whom would probably not even have bothered opening a thread that didn't concern them. I don't think the actions of a few should be taken as representative of all and used as a reason to separate people on the grounds of income or social class.

I agree that some terms on MN become clichés to silence people; 'selfish' during covid, 'cool girl' and 'controlling' on the relationship board, but generally they are balanced by other people, so can be ignored.

In the thread we've been discussing a lot of genuinely strong feelings were aroused. The OP also posted in AIBU where it's always a risk you'll be challenged as that's the point of the board.

I'm not suggesting that that OP would have altered anything as a lone voice on MN, I was referring more to the attitude in general of putting a positive spin on awful things, which to me, seems to minimise the severity.

stayathomer · 18/04/2022 15:48

And just for the avoidance of doubt, in my opinion, no, someone's positive experience of walking more and wasting less resources is not as valid in a discussion on the CoL crisis as someone else's experience of being hungry and cold. It serves only to dilute the perception of the impact on people who are suffering.
But that op wasn't trying to change the world, they were simply talking about something positive they got out of it. One of the comments was about the people in the pandemic who were positive about the experience, cursing about how they found it acceptable to post that they were gardening and shit. I was positive on sm over the pandemic. My neighbour died, I didn't see my mum or my brothers or sister throughout, my brother has aspergers and talks to himself and bashes his head off the walls but I didn't say that, I posted about us gardening and painting and playing football and sending stuff to my mum and bro. Was that not a valid thing to do to try to keep myself and others positive? Who decides whose stuff is valid? You can well believe people would approve if I did posts about my bro and my mum but I don't.

Lunar27 · 18/04/2022 15:47

@5128gap

Thanks. To be honest I didn't interpret the post that way at all. To me the OP stated quite clearly that those were positives relating to him/her specifically, not globally. As such I didn't find it distasteful. Some did but others didn't so guess it wasn't clear cut.

Another example. Recently I posted advice that EV's could be more accessible via salary sacrifice. Clearly this isn't applicable to everyone and only to those considering a new car, but could save a small fortune if applicable. I received a response that 'accessible' is privileged as some can't even afford a new car. Accessible has many meanings relative to the context in which it's used. I didn't mean accessible for people who can't afford a new car in the first place (obviously) but for those who can but where an EV might be a stretch.

I've read a number of other threads where people have been accused of being insensitive and seems like another silencing method.

In terms of dilution I'm not sure it does. Unless people don't watch the news, TV or surf the internet, I think most are acutely aware of the increasing suffering in this country. Some forum members discussing personal issues that happen to be MC specific isn't likely to alter anything, given the less well of account for the vast majority of the population.

Perhaps given demographics a sub forum isn't a bad idea after all.

Isitsixoclockalready · 18/04/2022 15:39

@DesidaCrick

Good post *@ChazsBrilliantAttitude* It boils down to having self awareness and empathy for others.
Definitely agree with this. Probably even more need for that with the cost of living going up. People don't need to apologise for what they have but just consider how their post might come across.
Xenia · 18/04/2022 15:38

707 although some mumsnetters have taken tips from other high earnings mumsnetters and then earned more money themselves so it is possible for some to come from poverty and earn a lot

Oblomov22 · 18/04/2022 15:12

Shouldn't be necessary. I hate it when someone posts, stupidly against those who very little or those that earn a lot. It's just unnecessary.
A thread from Someone who earns a lot and asks a reasonable question, should not be scorned.

707smile · 18/04/2022 15:07

@SharpLily

Some people are indeed the architects of their own poverty. Some are able through luck or judgement, hard work, whatever to climb out of poverty.

Some people are born with financial advantages which again through luck or judgement they lose, others are able to enjoy that privilege and expand upon it.

None of it is black and white, ever. Hope that helps. Hmm

As many others posters have also experienced I am sure, I have been through periods of relative wealth and also times of wondering if I can stretch to a sliver of butter on the plain baked potato that's all I can afford to eat. There's really no need to judge or disparage either side of society on here certainly as very, very few of us know enough about other posters' circumstances to know how their lives have played out.

I do however get annoyed with those who desperately look for offence in the use of phrases such as 'the poor', 'the rich' or 'middle class'. None of that actually means anything in the end.

The majority of very wealthy Brits were born into wealth and many receive inheritances and are able to benefit from contacts made through family connections and at private schools etc.

The 'hard work and determination' fallacy helps no-one. There are very poor people who work extremely hard and who are still stuck in poverty; there are a lucky few who through some combination of resources, opportunities, luck and/or hard work are able to escape from poverty but that's not to say that they worked harder or are more determined that those who have been unable to escape from it!

5128gap · 18/04/2022 14:57

And just for the avoidance of doubt, in my opinion, no, someone's positive experience of walking more and wasting less resources is not as valid in a discussion on the CoL crisis as someone else's experience of being hungry and cold. It serves only to dilute the perception of the impact on people who are suffering.

5128gap · 18/04/2022 14:49

@Lunar27

I inwardly groan when I see people on the how can you live on £100k threads and the luxury frugalism ones

I agree but this isn't the type of thread I'm talking about. I'm talking about threads where people are discussing perfectly valid everyday experiences and getting shot down because some people cannot afford to do xyz.

OK, so, personally, the last two years have brought some positives to my life. I may choose to share these on a thread about experiences during the pandemic and say that, for example, WFH has been helpful to me. However, that would be vastly different from starting a thread saying 'AIBU to think that covid has been a positive thing?' On the thread you're talking about, that's what the OP said about the CoL crisis, and its that that people reacted badly to, not that the OP is a well off person voicing an opinion. All this business about the poor MC who no one wants to listen to is smoke and mirrors to screen what most people would consider a huge error of tact and sensitivity.
Lunar27 · 18/04/2022 14:34

I inwardly groan when I see people on the how can you live on £100k threads and the luxury frugalism ones

I agree but this isn't the type of thread I'm talking about. I'm talking about threads where people are discussing perfectly valid everyday experiences and getting shot down because some people cannot afford to do xyz.

TerraNovaTwo · 18/04/2022 13:23

@Samcro

Just have a smug topic. Then people like the one you are talking about can post there.
Yanbu
DesidaCrick · 18/04/2022 13:11

Good post @ChazsBrilliantAttitude
It boils down to having self awareness and empathy for others.

lameasahorse · 18/04/2022 13:02

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 18/04/2022 12:58

I appreciate that but why should people shield others who are less well off? It's like one rule for one and one for another.

It’s not about shielding anyone. It’s about recognising that your relative wealth shields you.
I inwardly groan when I see people on the how can you live on £100k threads and the luxury frugalism ones. I am comfortable financially and would be perceived as MC. My life is easier than someone who is in a more precarious financial position.

Yes I can drone on about how hard I worked but so did DH when he was a newly arrived immigrant working in hospitality or driving a bus. I know which of us had more opportunities and better working conditions.
I don’t use a tumble dryer for environmental reasons but I can make that choice because I have a house and garden. Ditto growing fruit and veg. I buy some second hand uniform to reduce waste - the DC’s private school has a thriving second hand shop on site. This is luxury frugalism because there is no negative judgements made about second hand clothes when the purchaser can afford new.
It’s worth taking a step back and recognising that people are really struggling and frightened by costs rising right now. Posting threads extolling the virtues of luxury frugalism are always going to look crass.

Lunar27 · 18/04/2022 12:16

@bringincrazyback

I appreciate that but why should people shield others who are less well off? It's like one rule for one and one for another.

And I'm not suggesting that people don't post, quite the opposite. People should be free to discuss issues relevant to them, without attracting ire from people who don't like the content. As long as it's not intentionally degrading or insulting.

Regarding posts about poverty, you've illustrated the point exactly (and the response I was after) but by the same token, why should support/advice be preserved for the less well off?

Thoosa · 18/04/2022 12:08

@Lunar27

I'm one that didn't find the thread in question offensive as I didn't interpret the post in the way others seemed to.

However, what I find interesting is why people with more money should not openly talk about issues or experiences they have? And why is it acceptable for those with less to freely discuss that they are suffering? It makes no sense.

I accept if people are being cruel and rubbing people's noses in it, fine. But to reverse the situation, what are we supposed to do with information that someone is struggling so much they can't afford to eat? On a public forum, what is it supposed to achieve, other than to make us feel the deepest sympathy/guilt/despair. Why do the feelings of poorer people matter more that those who are more comfortable?

That’s exactly it.

That thread would have been fine if it hadn’t been completely ignoring the stress that the fuel prices are causing some people. Or even if OP had had an actual concern of her own, it might have been forgivable.

There was no concern or dilemma though. It was all “isn’t this cost of living crisis a marvellous opportunity for inner growth and mindfulness? we’ve been wearing socks, and turning the thermostat down one notch - all very soul nourishing and educational!”

Absolutely no content to it. A nothing burger. No input needed. While on the other side of the scales, so much scope to make people feel like shit.

If I can work that out, most people can work that out.

bringincrazyback · 18/04/2022 11:19

@Lunar27

I'm one that didn't find the thread in question offensive as I didn't interpret the post in the way others seemed to.

However, what I find interesting is why people with more money should not openly talk about issues or experiences they have? And why is it acceptable for those with less to freely discuss that they are suffering? It makes no sense.

I accept if people are being cruel and rubbing people's noses in it, fine. But to reverse the situation, what are we supposed to do with information that someone is struggling so much they can't afford to eat? On a public forum, what is it supposed to achieve, other than to make us feel the deepest sympathy/guilt/despair. Why do the feelings of poorer people matter more that those who are more comfortable?

They don't matter more, they matter equally. But the recent cost of living rises are causing real desperation. In times like these I don't think it's unreasonable if posts about whether someone should sell off the lower field or let Jocasta's ponies graze it attract a few comments along the lines of the OP needing to check their privilege.

And your comment about why would people post about poverty is just awful. Would you rather people who are struggling didn't ask anyone for support or advice in case they made others feel uncomfortable?

Lunar27 · 18/04/2022 10:33

I'm one that didn't find the thread in question offensive as I didn't interpret the post in the way others seemed to.

However, what I find interesting is why people with more money should not openly talk about issues or experiences they have? And why is it acceptable for those with less to freely discuss that they are suffering? It makes no sense.

I accept if people are being cruel and rubbing people's noses in it, fine. But to reverse the situation, what are we supposed to do with information that someone is struggling so much they can't afford to eat? On a public forum, what is it supposed to achieve, other than to make us feel the deepest sympathy/guilt/despair. Why do the feelings of poorer people matter more that those who are more comfortable?

Davethecat2001 · 18/04/2022 09:36

I always enjoy the ones who are desperate to tell everyone how wc their roots are and how they know how hard life can be, sat round a candle to keep warm in a hair shirt and are bone soup, but are now earning 300k a year theough sheer hard work and determination, and can now afford to do the weekly shop at Fortnum and Mason, live in a 5 bed detached in Wimbledon with kids at private school etc, but they're still really down with the proles and can feel the burning injustice of it all man ✌️

Those are the ones that need a swift punch up the bracket imo.

longwayoff · 18/04/2022 09:20

Hear hear PurpleFlower and threads like this are begun to exploit any divide further. Like the 'let's export refugees' policy dreamed up to appease Brexiters and gather some racist votes next month. It's absolutely sickening to see what this country's become; taking policies from Nazi Germany when their grandfather's fought and died too oppose them.

PurpleFlower1983 · 18/04/2022 06:23

No it shouldn’t, but this is what government (Tory) cuts, price hikes and a cost of living increases always lead to: a divided society.

fffffeeeedddduupp · 18/04/2022 06:18

It's refreshing to get a mix of responses surely? If you only want responses from people like you just ask your friends.

I once asked a question about childcare. Everyone always rags on people relying on grandparents as tho there's always a choice. One poster suggested I start a nanny share at school. No one at my dd very working class school has a nanny. I just laughed.

echt · 18/04/2022 05:34

It was someone rhapsodising about how the fuel crisis Joe taught her mindfulness and to wear socks and what a wonderful opportunity this was for us all

It was someone reflecting on personal gains, both monetary and outlook she had made because of the fuel crisis, and her efforts to cut back on expenses.

Swipe left for the next trending thread