Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should Mumsnet have it's own middle class section ?

313 replies

hattie43 · 16/04/2022 18:36

Reading some of these threads turning nasty it's really apparent that people have such different lives there will never be common ground . Nor does there need to be but the insults are not nice.

A thread posted by someone asking a question , to some a reasonable question being jumped on by ' the poor ' as tone deaf means legitimate conversation has been drowned out .

Should Mumsnet be divided so
' middle classes 'can discuss things the poor don't relate to and likewise ' the poor ' can discuss their issues without ' tone deaf ' comments from people who aren't financially destitute ?

The other thing I don't get is why jump on a thread you don't like why not just scroll on by and join a discussion you do like . Being a hater is never going to resolve anything .

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jonny1265 · 19/04/2022 15:16

@lemongreentea

Yes

Middle class section
Working class section
Lower class section

And an upper class section that is password protected.

😂
WalkingOnTheCracks · 19/04/2022 15:15

@Xenia

We are one of the greatest nations of earth and Labour has not won an election since 2005 because its policies are not very good.
Can you just break down 'greatest' for us? I wouldn't want to agree or disagree before I know what you mean.
bringincrazyback · 19/04/2022 14:32

We are one of the greatest nations of earth

We have hard-working people who are still unable to make ends meet unless they use food banks.
We have sick and disabled people committing suicide because their already-inadequate support is being slashed.
We have people able to either eat themselves or feed their children, not both.
We have people forced to choose between heating and eating.
We have (thanks to the canker that is Universal Credit) people who have worked hard and paid into the system all their lives being entitled to nothing if they happen to lose their jobs, just because their partner happens to earn over x amount.
We have people freezing to death on the streets because of inadequate mental health provisions.
Meanwhile those up top continue to coin it in and are completely unaffected.

I'd be interested to hear your definition of great, @Xenia.

timeisnotaline · 19/04/2022 14:14

@Porcupineintherough

Because quinoa is tasteless, joyless and doesn't fill you up

And rice? You could say the same, is that middle class too? And how can something that's basically carbs and protein not fill you up? As for tasteless, its the venue not the occasion.

I was going to read the full thread but I got stuck here. Rice is delicious. So satisfying. I know it’s high GI but I just want to eat more and more of it! Rice is nothing like quinoa

Re the topic, I would just post on whichever forum I identified with at the time Wink. Of course that’s a joke as everyone would continue to post in AIBU so it would be irrelevant.

Thoosa · 19/04/2022 14:06

@mrsmolks

First world problems applies to everyone in the UK. We have a benefit system and free health care. Being poor in the UK is not the equivalent of poor elsewhere. I agree with OP it does piss me off when perfectly reasonable questions get responses like your are tone dead or even accuse you of lying. Not sure a middle class thread is needed though - just needs people to scroll past things that aren't relevant to them
Not quite. Not any more.

We do actually have people starving and freezing to death in the UK now because the welfare state no longer covers housing plus minimal living expenses. Courtesy of the Tory/coalition “reforms”.

mrsmolks · 19/04/2022 13:57

First world problems applies to everyone in the UK. We have a benefit system and free health care. Being poor in the UK is not the equivalent of poor elsewhere.
I agree with OP it does piss me off when perfectly reasonable questions get responses like your are tone dead or even accuse you of lying. Not sure a middle class thread is needed though - just needs people to scroll past things that aren't relevant to them

lameasahorse · 19/04/2022 12:27

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

707smile · 19/04/2022 12:00

Also 'the poor' implies that poverty is a quality attributable to the person and has connotations of 'the deserving poor' and 'the undeserving poor'. Using the term 'people living in poverty' highlights the fact that poverty is a circumstance under which someone is living, rather than an attribute of the person.

The language that people use matters immensely.

HRTQueen · 19/04/2022 11:58

Absolutely agree with your post ChazsBrilliantAttitude

Though I think the desperation for some to be seen as better off is at times deliberate. Advising someone to get a cleaner when they have said money is tight and time is short. Or the lectures on buy better to last longer it’s worth spending five times as much in the end Hmm

But then I feel some are happy in a bubble they are aware they just don’t really care. The moaning of being hard up at ds prep school was competitive and
shameful. To admit you have privilege was not to be acknowledged. Our kids were all super intelligent which is utter bollocks. I’ve seen this attitude on MN too.

707smile · 19/04/2022 11:57

@SharpLily

Er, yes, *@707smile*, that's the point. These sort of threads are full of people expounding the 'just work harder' or other theories but they're not really relevant because every situation is different.
Okay but I don't think a comment of 'Some people are the architects of their own poverty' is particularly helpful when the vast majority of people living in poverty are not the architects of their own poverty!
mrziggycoco · 19/04/2022 11:48

@glinner4prez

Define middle class. It used to be that 'working class' defined anyone who was forced to work for a living, unlike aristos or those who inherited wealth. So that's pretty much everyone then!
That's feudalism then. If you have everyone under the ruling class forced into work, and largely poverty, this is feudalism not a multi-class system.
Lunar27 · 19/04/2022 11:41

Sadly we're turning into America where the wealth gap is increasing and social mobility declining.

I think the last few generations of children (from around 2000 onwards) will be the first in a long time where they're unable to out earn or improve on their parents. Grim really.

desiringonlychild2022 · 19/04/2022 11:16

@Xenia if we are one of the greatest nations in the world, why do we have parts of the UK poorer than Bulgaria? Paraphrase- some of the richest parts of the world are located in the UK,- mainly in London and the SE. Parts of London are as rich as Monaco.. But as a country, we are maybe no 20 in terms of per capita income which is very bad for a G7 country and a former empire. Parts of China esp the tier 1 cities would be richer than Manchester and may even have higher salaries...

DesidaCrick · 19/04/2022 11:13

If this is the type of country and leadership the electorate want, they are entitled to it, but I don't feel like sticking around. It doesn't create a good environment to do business in and I might as well go somewhere with better infrastructure where skills are valued properly.

lemongreentea · 19/04/2022 11:04

@Xenia

We are one of the greatest nations of earth and Labour has not won an election since 2005 because its policies are not very good.
Lol
Blossomtoes · 19/04/2022 10:44

@Xenia

We are one of the greatest nations of earth and Labour has not won an election since 2005 because its policies are not very good.
No we’re not one of the greatest nations on earth. Which of Labour’s specific policies aren’t very good? And for whom?
Xenia · 19/04/2022 10:15

We are one of the greatest nations of earth and Labour has not won an election since 2005 because its policies are not very good.

lemongreentea · 19/04/2022 09:33

PurpleFlower1983

No it shouldn’t, but this is what government (Tory) cuts, price hikes and a cost of living increases always lead to: a divided society.

A ‘divided society’ that comes together at election time … to vote in the Tories. Again.

This.

At this point we deserve the govt we elect. Whatever happens now is collectively our own fault. I'll be interested how much worse it can get after the next general election when the conservative party have been voted in again.

Not sure if Brits are a bit thick or just like to suffer. And then constantly moan about it.

SleeplessInEngland · 19/04/2022 09:24

"You don’t think it’s good for middle class people to be reminded that there is life outside their own quinoa-bubble? Where the cost of living crisis is welcomed as a welcome mindfulness exercise when some people have to choose between eating and heating?"

Way to fight class stereotypes with... yet more class stereotypes.

SharpLily · 19/04/2022 09:20

Er, yes, @707smile, that's the point. These sort of threads are full of people expounding the 'just work harder' or other theories but they're not really relevant because every situation is different.

bringincrazyback · 18/04/2022 23:23

[quote Lunar27]@bringincrazyback

I appreciate that but why should people shield others who are less well off? It's like one rule for one and one for another.

And I'm not suggesting that people don't post, quite the opposite. People should be free to discuss issues relevant to them, without attracting ire from people who don't like the content. As long as it's not intentionally degrading or insulting.

Regarding posts about poverty, you've illustrated the point exactly (and the response I was after) but by the same token, why should support/advice be preserved for the less well off?[/quote]
Only just logged back on but @ChazsBrilliantAttitude has pretty much answered as I would have, particularly this:

It’s not about shielding anyone. It’s about recognising that your relative wealth shields you.

Everyone is of course entitled to their say on a forum and I'm not suggesting any particular group shouldn't post, but with the world/economy in the state they're in, I think it's impossible to get away from the fact that threads which feel particularly 'first-world-problem-y' may be looked on as being a bit crass by many right now. There isn't really a solution imo, beyond people exercising their own discretion as to which threads they read, and ideally being sensitive to what they're posting as well.

VestaTilley · 18/04/2022 21:45

YABU.

Lunar27 · 18/04/2022 21:42

@5128gap

I think we're in agreement that it's bad taste to intentionally goad or rub noses so some self censoring/filtering is definitely necessary if one doesn't want to be on the end of a backlash! I'm still interested in the dynamics of discussion though.

In fairness to the OP I don't think there was any malice but guess the beauty of AIBU (if it can be described as beauty) is that responses are diverse and people will certainly speak up if they don't like something Grin

NurseBernard · 18/04/2022 21:13

@PurpleFlower1983

No it shouldn’t, but this is what government (Tory) cuts, price hikes and a cost of living increases always lead to: a divided society.
A ‘divided society’ that comes together at election time … to vote in the Tories. Again.
JudgeJ · 18/04/2022 20:39

Fish knives.

Sterling silver with bone handles, obvs, and never allow the staff to put them in the dishwasher!