Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be this upset/annoyed over DSis wedding?

63 replies

PixieAndProsecco · 16/04/2022 17:27

I do want to start this by saying I love my sister, I will obviously be at her wedding, be her Maid of Honour, smile for the pictures etc and wish her the very best in her married life.

However, her wedding is now less than a month away and every single day something else comes up and I just makes me so annoyed and upset.

When I got married my parents gave us X towards it and then paid for things like my dress separately. They also paid for their outfits, hen and stag do and other incidentals separately. They told my sister she would get the exact same.

My sister's wedding rolls around and her reception alone costs more than everything my parents paid for mine plus the extras. Literally they have spent I would say double on hers as they did mine because "that's what she wants".
They spent the run up to my wedding talking me out of things I wanted as "a waste of money" - for example a band is a waste, have a DJ; no one wants a weekend long hen do; do you really want that dress it's a bit expensive for one day; hmm those venues will costs guests, why not go here as its cheaper etc. Etc.
Yet my sister wanted a pianist and a DJ? No problem. She wants an expensive venue? Looks lovely. A weekend long hen and stag? Can't wait to go.

In the end I had a wedding somewhere I didn't particularly like, with nothing I really wanted, because it all became too overbearing and overwhelming.
My wedding is nothing that I wanted and when I look back its not a special day, just a day.

My sister, on the other hand, will say "jump" and my parents will ask "how high?". Nothing is too much trouble and she will get everything and anything she asks for. My parents are also paying for things they didn't agree to pay for because my sister and her husband to be "forgot to save for it" and its just an "of course, how much and is there anything else?"

It's not so much the money, I wanted to spend less and go abroad and i could never spend that much money on a day. Its more the double standards and hypocrisy - we would both get the same which obviously didn't happen and its very clear that this is the case. I got all the negativity and nothing that i wanted and she gets what she wants constantly without any issues.

And now with it drawing closer its just a constant reminder of the different way in which we're treated.
There has always been differences (they paid for her to do a masters ans when I asked for a loan, which would be repaid, it was an outright no; gave her thousands towards a house but when it came to me they gave money then told me it needed repaid afterwards; my sister wanted decking for a party and they just paid for it) but this is probably the biggest "comparison" so to speak and it hurts. To see one sibling who is obviously the favourite get whatever they want, when they want, whatever the cost and the other to constantly be told "no".

I know I sound like a child.
I know a lot of people don't even get what o did.
I know it is such a trivial thing.
Maybe the wedding is just a red herring - it probably is, it's probably not even what is upsetting me. It's just a physical manifestation of the different ways we are treated.

But it hurts and I can't speak to anyone irl about it.
Would you be upset/annoyed at the differences?

OP posts:
MyCatIsAJerk · 16/04/2022 19:43

My parents spent £25,000 on my sister’s wedding in the early ‘70s.

My parents spent £2,000 on my wedding in the early ‘90s.

Go figure.

gamerchick · 16/04/2022 19:39

Just sounds like the tipping point OP. Look on the bright side. The blatant favourite gets to do the main chunk of caring in the old age.

Movingonup22 · 16/04/2022 19:38

Favoritism is corrosive - honestly take some time to really deal with it and face it up and deal with it - not easy - then decide how far you want to step back from your parents/sister and what boundaries you want to put in place and
Then onwards and upwards with your own life!!

EKGEMS · 16/04/2022 19:36

My lovely father told me I had "bad timing" to want to have my wedding at the same time my brother wanted a sports car,sister an expensive apartment during university because she 'needed to be out of the halls' and my younger sister had a list of demands. I had a low budget wedding,an inexpensive dress and veil. It left a bad taste in my mouth thinking back on it like you @PixieAndProsecco

girlmom21 · 16/04/2022 19:35

Could they have been worried that their savings wouldn't be enough to cover both weddings? Would your sister have got married sooner if it hadn't been for covid but because it was delayed they've had more time to save?

PixieAndProsecco · 16/04/2022 19:32

@ChiswickFlo

The favouritsm will continue once any gc arrive too, sadly so be prepared for that.

It's even harder to witness it affecting one's own dc.

My brothers child is by far the most favoured.

Shame my brother hardly ever visits mum.

Sad, really.

Thankfully I've already got this one covered. I gave birth to the first two grandchildren and great grandchildren on both sides of the family. My children can, apparently, do no wrong which is something I suppose.

However knowing how life works my sister will have the first, long awaited and wanted, girl and my boys will be as wanted as a case of herpes.

OP posts:
ChiswickFlo · 16/04/2022 19:29

My sibling has also stolen from me too so it's complicated and lots of bad feeling :(

ChiswickFlo · 16/04/2022 19:28

@ENoeuf

Thank you *@ChiswickFlo* that’s kind of you. I think it’s sometimes really hard to be equitable - I can imagine my oldest had less than my youngest in material terms at certain points as we just didn’t have the £££. Or maybe as long as you are fair it doesn’t have to be equal. I’m sorry you’ve been treated unfairly as it does sound quite clear for you and your sibling x
It's very hard to be equitable sometimes, yes. 6 year gap between my dc so they are very different places in their lives so atm ds1 (18) is getting more spent on him probably. But I do keep a mental tally ☺️ which dh finds hilarious.
ENoeuf · 16/04/2022 19:24

Sorry thank you also @PixieAndProsecco. I hope my dx see it the same way. I would never not try to balance it if we were in a position to do it.

ENoeuf · 16/04/2022 19:23

Thank you @ChiswickFlo that’s kind of you. I think it’s sometimes really hard to be equitable - I can imagine my oldest had less than my youngest in material terms at certain points as we just didn’t have the £££. Or maybe as long as you are fair it doesn’t have to be equal. I’m sorry you’ve been treated unfairly as it does sound quite clear for you and your sibling x

PixieAndProsecco · 16/04/2022 19:23

@ENoeuf

ChiswickFlo

Yanbu op.
Sibling favouritism is insidious and poisonous
My parents gave us £1,000 towards our wedding (over 20 years ago so it went furthersmile) I was grateful.
When we moved into our first house I got a plastic bucket with pegs, tin opener, cleaning cloths etc in it.
Very useful! And I didn't expect anything else.
My brother got £5k towards his wedding and got a £10k house deposit.
🤷‍♀️
We don't really have much of a relationship tbh.
I'm sorry. It's horrible.

this stuff really worries me, we give what we can afford at the time and then try to be fair when the next one reaches that stage. But it’s hard - one went to uni, one wanted a car instead so we contributed to both but I refuse to get into spreadsheet territory. I hate to think of them feeling like this

I don't think your children will feel this way, as they'll know it's a "we give what we can".

However you should worry when one DC literally gets £10,000+ more than the other; when one DC gets their masters paid for; when one DC gets handouts constantly; and the other gets none.

OP posts:
Threetulips · 16/04/2022 19:20

This was also me and older sibling.

I gave up and did it all on my own, I’ve never taken any help or any money, they do send the kids Christmas gifts, but DS kids get more,

I can’t get worked up about it. I feel proud how I worked harder and achieved more.

They don’t owe anyone anything, so stop what you do for them and stop taking and expecting a different outcome. Maybe they’ll see your sister for who she is. Eventually.

ChiswickFlo · 16/04/2022 19:10

...and of course, this was just more of the same I've been experiencing for decades...not a one off.

ChiswickFlo · 16/04/2022 19:09

As long as you've been fair I don't see the issue?

You can't pay for university if they don't want to go....

ENoeuf · 16/04/2022 19:06

ChiswickFlo

Yanbu op.
Sibling favouritism is insidious and poisonous
My parents gave us £1,000 towards our wedding (over 20 years ago so it went furthersmile) I was grateful.
When we moved into our first house I got a plastic bucket with pegs, tin opener, cleaning cloths etc in it.
Very useful! And I didn't expect anything else.
My brother got £5k towards his wedding and got a £10k house deposit.
🤷‍♀️
We don't really have much of a relationship tbh.
I'm sorry. It's horrible.

this stuff really worries me, we give what we can afford at the time and then try to be fair when the next one reaches that stage. But it’s hard - one went to uni, one wanted a car instead so we contributed to both but I refuse to get into spreadsheet territory. I hate to think of them feeling like this

ChiswickFlo · 16/04/2022 19:01

The favouritsm will continue once any gc arrive too, sadly so be prepared for that.

It's even harder to witness it affecting one's own dc.

My brothers child is by far the most favoured.

Shame my brother hardly ever visits mum.

Sad, really.

notapizzaeater · 16/04/2022 18:58

I'd have to speak to them and let them know how upsetting you find it or they will keep on doing it again and again. They might not even realise they are doing it, but once pointed out if they keep doing it I'd protect myself from them.

ChiswickFlo · 16/04/2022 18:49

Yanbu op.
Sibling favouritism is insidious and poisonous
My parents gave us £1,000 towards our wedding (over 20 years ago so it went further:)) I was grateful.
When we moved into our first house I got a plastic bucket with pegs, tin opener, cleaning cloths etc in it.
Very useful! And I didn't expect anything else.
My brother got £5k towards his wedding and got a £10k house deposit.
🤷‍♀️
We don't really have much of a relationship tbh.
I'm sorry. It's horrible.

JustLyra · 16/04/2022 18:40

It’s not trivial when your parents show you that there’s a favourite.

Your parents are supposed to be the people you can trust most, who love you and can be trusted to treat you fairly and equally. When that doesn’t happen it hurts

PixieAndProsecco · 16/04/2022 18:37

Thanks everyone. It does feel like a ridiculous thing to get upset over but it is the first clear show favouritism - they explicitly said "whatever Pixie gets then DS gets" and they couldn't stick to that.
They'd never said it before and so, although the other issues hurt, it didn't hurt as much.

OP posts:
cptartapp · 16/04/2022 18:30

YANBU. SIL got all her wedding paid for by PIL and a £10k house deposit and DH got nothing towards either!
Have thought much less of them since and shan't be falling over to help as they age. The money they saved can pay for that.
Just see less of them.

Mulhollandmagoo · 16/04/2022 18:19

What they're doing isn't fair, and must be hurtful to you, Mumsnet is a really odd place for things like this though, so I'd take some of the replies with a pinch of salt. Agree with @Arucanafeather that you should detach a little, and invest in some therapy for yourself.

Maybe you, your husband and your children go to said country and renew your vows? Flowers

Unsureaboutit9 · 16/04/2022 18:02

My wedding is nothing that I wanted and when I look back its not a special day, just a day.

This is daft, why wasn’t marrying your husband special enough? Does he no you feel this way? You could have saved more money for a better venue if you wanted.

But the favouritism I do get must be rubbish, and it’s totally unfair. But you are adults and it’s their money, sad as it is they can do as they like. You are both lucky they helped with your weddings, your best bet is to distance yourself and try to stop making comparisons.

Arucanafeather · 16/04/2022 18:02

Maybe take a pop over to the stately homes thread on mumsnet. I would medium chill them - light & friendly but don’t give of yourself emotionally. Maybe get some counselling support if you find the right person. You’re right it isn’t about the wedding day it’s about how you were parented. That’s on them not you. I see a friend of my youngest (key stage 1 primary) being treated already in the way your describe. It’s awful and her parents have no idea I don’t think that they’re even doing it. So long as you married the person you want, I would let the wedding issue go and work on the longer term issue of severing some of those emotional ties you have to your parents. My DH has successfully done that with his DP. We still see them but with some fabulous counselling support, they’re not negatively impacting him anymore and have lost their residual “power” over him. Take care. Be the person you want to be on your DSis wedding day and find away to minimise the emotional impact. You can’t make them change but you can work on yourself to make it impact yet. My DH ‘s cousellor suggested that rather than constantly trying to stop his mother being a bitch to me (coz if she wants to be bitchy she’s going to be) but instead we gave her a score out of ten. One score for effort (ooh, she put a lot of thought into that comment) and another for impact. Took some time but worked a treat!

PixieAndProsecco · 16/04/2022 18:01

@NeedleNoodle3

It wouldn’t bother me, it sounds like they’ve helped you loads already.
And they have helped yes. As I said its not as much about the money but in the attitude - she can get what she wants when she wants and it's okay. It's not how it happens.

Even things like education - they paid for her masters, which she didn't even get and won't consider loaning me the money for the first year of a part time one (interest rates at banks aren't great and make the repayments stupid).
Or when we moved in to our houses - my parents spent weeks helping her decorate, regularly do her garden up, but when I asked for help with a tricky bit of painting it was a no.

OP posts: