Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried my DS11 is fat?

41 replies

Rubixtwister · 16/04/2022 16:08

I haven't said anything to him but he is clearly becoming aware of it, he keeps making comments about having massive chunky thighs ans he keeps trying to hide himself when not wearing a T-shirt. I have been putting his weight gain down the the fact he must be due a growth spurt but he is now getting really chunky. I can't control what he eats at school and I think they give loads of snacks at break and lunch. He seems to have a ravenous appetite. He has rolls of flab on his stomach now. He swims every day and is very strong but can't run well (he is slightly pigeon footed and runs strangely).

Has anyone else had this and then they have lost it all during a growth spurt? I haven't had a talk with him about loosing weight but if nothing happens I think I am going to have to. And then I need to work out how to broach it sensitively,

He isn't massively tall yet but DH is 6'6 and I am 5'8 so he is unlikely to be short, my DB is 6'4 as well. DS seems to have my body frame which is short strong legs, and DH's top frame which is broad backed with a big rib cage. So it stands to reason to me that he will be using this stored energy for growth but if it is making him unhappy at the moment I am worried for him. I don't want to make an issue of it and it become a problem. Could really use some advice here!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bozna · 26/04/2022 03:09

Definitely don't let kid get fat unnecessarily, but most that age shoot up, and as long as kids have good exercise and decent diet they can't go wrong.

Hellocatshome · 17/04/2022 17:24

I just googled what an overweight 11 year old should look like and he doesn't have moobs or anything but he does have a lot round his tummy (I probably exaggerated about rolls of flab but I think when he is sitting down it looks quite bad).

Why would you Google what an overweight 11 year old looks like?! You want to be googling what a healthy weight 11 year old looks like if anything. But really you don't want to be googling it at all, if you as his Mum and the person who loves him most in the world and looks at him through rose tinted glasses thinks he's overweight I can pretty much guarantee he is overweight.

Hankunamatata · 17/04/2022 17:05

If he has visble flab and doing so much sport then something is going wrong with diet. My 11 yr old is taking a keen interest in diet for sport as his rugby coach and swim coach both talking about nutrition to feed body. So porridge with fruit/nuts etc. Cutting down on crap to once a day or every other day. Basically going for a healthy approach.

Kanaloa · 17/04/2022 16:54

I really don’t think looking at pictures of famous sports people who were ‘chunky’ as teens will be helpful. You don’t want to press this idea that ‘oh it’s normal to be fat as a teen then it all goes as you’re older.’

What you need to do is look at what he’s eating, both at school and at home, and cut back if he has a fat tummy.

Seemssounfair · 17/04/2022 14:01

Try everyone putting their food diary into MFP for a week and see how it looks, especially his school food. Tell him it is to see if you are all getting the right balance of carbs/protein throughout the week.

Fruit and fibre cereal is high in sugar and so is fruit. We steered ds to more protien to make him feel fuller for longer, mostly eggs, chicken and tuna.

Rubixtwister · 17/04/2022 13:46

Sorry for the silence- Easter Day and at DM's with all the cousins so it's been hard to get a moment to read all these replies!

Thank you so much for all the encouraging comments and ideas as to how to broach the subject. I will try my best to answer some comments as I remember from my first read- through but when I get a moment longer will go through and check I have answered all comments

So genetics wise, DH is, as I mentioned, 6'6. He is a wide build too- very wide back and so very much in proportion. He has been a very successful athlete to high levels, especially in endurance type events and particularly in rowing which favours a tall, strong physique. DS hasn't got his DF's long lean legs but instead seems to have my legs. I have strong legs and a small rib cage, my DB is the same but is also tall and was a rower too. So as DS is not particularly tall as yet (not short but also not the tallest in his class) I imagine there is going to be a big growth spurt due- my DM says DB had one at about age 13.

When DS mentioned he was unhappy with his shape i didn't just ignore it, I encouraged him to get out running. I used to run and DS would do a park run with me but unfortunately due to a medical issue am unable to run at the moment so sadly we cannot do one together. However I am able to cycle, this is a great idea and I will do this. The swimming DS does is swim squad and school swimming and it works out that he is swimming 6 times a week and this one hour Lane swimming with squad and 30 mins with school. He comes out flushed so I know he is getting a work out. We also just got home from a week's skiiing and DS was pushing himself to the max doing black run moguls and off piste so he clearly has a level of fitness. Although his running is strange he does well in rugby as he is very strong and good at tackling but he obviously isn't the nippy one that gets the ball and runs for a try. Last term he did hockey which he is not so good at but he was generally in the second or third team of four. This term is cricket so lots of standing around, but also tennis and I think some athletics. Anyway, lots of sport at the prep school, generally including most of the day on Saturdays.

We have talked several times about ensuring he gets a healthy meal at school and he promised me that he gets lots of vegetables and chooses fruit at snack time. At home we eat healthily with lots of veg and he has the same size portion as me, not as big as DH. We do not have crisps in the house, I buy only weetabix or fruit and fibre as cereal and pudding is generally yoghurt or maybe an own-brand magnum ice cream as a treat. I know he is ravenously hungry as he always wants a bowl of fruit and fibre after swim training or late in the evening. I usually let him but sometimes I say no and let him have a glass of milk instead, depending on what he had for dinner.

I have told him that I believe he is going to have a growth spurt. It's encouraging to hear that this was the case with some PPs. I spoke very much along the lines that the PP's GP did but he pooh-pooed the idea. It won't be helping that he has spent the week with his cousins who are super skinny- my DB's partner is only 5' and has a tiny build whereas DS is like his dad.

I just googled what an overweight 11 year old should look like and he doesn't have moobs or anything but he does have a lot round his tummy (I probably exaggerated about rolls of flab but I think when he is sitting down it looks quite bad).

I gut feeling tells me that he's going to use the extra for a growth spurt but that as he is unhappy about it I am aware I probably need to have another discussion about food intake which is why I was wondering how to broach it. I want to discourage him from worrying about it. Anyone know of any famous sports people who were chunky as preteens? It would be helpful for him to realise that it is a thing.

Thanks again all for the replies, apologies again for the delay in relying

OP posts:
rainbowandglitter · 17/04/2022 08:02

Where has op gone? They've not returned.

jokalyn · 17/04/2022 03:44

@HiJenny35 if the child is unhappy then you have to make a change. Promote healthy food and encourage exercise but not to just change them, but how every child should be raised. Encourage a healthy lifestyle so they don't need to stop eating 5 bags of crisps a day and have to do a workout video because they never leave their bedroom

jokalyn · 17/04/2022 03:32

I don't agree with adjusting portion size. I've seen loads of lads shoot up at that age, but either way I think support exercise and eat a ton of healthy food so they're full, but limit snacks, keep to one or 2 treats a day.
Also in general saying a kid swims every day, realistically is about 20 mins of exercise. I think they should all do pe or a run before class, because loads of kid are at school from 8-6 and exercise should be a key point of education, which it isn't .

WTF475878237NC · 17/04/2022 02:42

Can you assess his portion sizes and try offering more veg rather than fruit and carbs?

RantyAunty · 17/04/2022 02:02

Try giving smaller portions to start with.

Ask the doctor about his gait. There might be shoe inserts or something to correct it.

HiJenny35 · 17/04/2022 01:52

What do you mean you don't want to make an issue of it and it become a problem, it is a problem, he's told you it's a problem, he's told you he isn't happy with it, why on earth haven't you said to him when he states he has massive chunky thighs "well if you would like we can look at what you are eating, lower you intake of fats and sugars and up your exercise so they reduce in size a bit". Yes he might loose weight as he gets taller, he might not, he might get taller and fatter or not taller at all, whatever the answer it isn't to carry on in the same theme when he's told you he isn't happy with his body and he's trying to hide himself.

Goldenbear · 17/04/2022 01:44

Sorry Op, not very helpful to you but I felt there is loads of judgement on here and even from anecdotal poll of my DS's friends the very thin ones and yes I mean very thin do eat loads and what they want! They are active so generally all walk to school, will play football at lunchtime and sometimes will go to the park and play basketball football again especially why it is warm, walk back and forth around from huge park to Sainsburys local to get more snacks sometimes a meal deal kind of thing!

Goldenbear · 17/04/2022 01:23

My very thin 15 year old eats high calories for example, he will eat a burger king meal and a chicken wrap and cheesy bites on the side..he most definitely does not follow the low calorie diet but there is nothing to him, he is lanky, tall and broad shouldered- some things children are just thin, it is genes and nothing to do with saintly diets and restrictions as a PP pointed out. I think that is a really unfair comparison.

nolongersurprised · 17/04/2022 00:08

All overweight children on Mumsnet “shoot up”
and “stretch out” at puberty.

Winniewonka · 16/04/2022 23:20

Many, many years ago when my son was 11, he definitely looked overweight. Until then he had always been a skinny child and I would worry that he wasn't eating enough. He didn't seem to be aware of his weight until his great uncle said to him "Well, young Wonka, you are looking fat!". I was furious, Son was upset.
Anyway, we needed to visit the GP on an unrelated matter and my son surprised me by asking the doctor why am I fat?
I thought he explained it so well when he said sometimes around your age, when boys start to grow, they can get out of proportion. Often the weight they need comes first but the height hasn't caught up. It can be the other way around and boys can look tall but very thin because their weight hasn't appeared. It might take some time to even out but keep eating well and everything will balance out in the next couple of years. I thought that was a great explanation to give to a child and sure enough by Y8, his growth had caught up.

Hellocatshome · 16/04/2022 22:50

When you say he swims everyday do you mean he trains with a swimming club everyday or he plays about in the pool for 30 mins? If he is training with a swim club then he must be eating vast amounts (or at least vast amounts of the wrong types of food) to be gaining weight.

Kanaloa · 16/04/2022 22:46

I mean what is he eating at home? I notice when DH plates up dinner for ds11 & dd10 he gives them the same size portion as he (a full grown man who works a physical job) eats himself. I think it’s just out of worry, thinking he doesn’t want to be leaving them hungry, but I generally plate them up a smaller portion.

Can you ask exactly what the school menu is? I would just be wary of blaming it entirely on school because surely all his school friends and classmates are having the exact same snacks and food, and they’re not all overweight are they?

Parsley1234 · 16/04/2022 22:22

Yes I had exactly this I was really honest with him and listened to his sadness about his weight he joined a swim squad and got much fitter but still chubby when he went to boarding school he did get fatter I think the first year he was unhappy now he’s 18 he is really thin he had a massive growth spurt and he’s fine but when he was 11 it was awful for him. He only wanted to eat junk too

newusernamelouise · 16/04/2022 22:14

At this age you can do a lot without them even realizing or having to have a conversation with them. I have done it with my kids over the years when I noticed bad habits slipping in and weight gain. Before it would get out of control I would have a few months of really paying attention to the dinners I made, more protein, less carbs, more fish and veg, more fruit for snacks. I made lots of small changes and just said upbeat things like "it's a new recipe I'm trying", or "this lovely fruit was on sale today" and they didn't even notice and they would slim down.

Murdoch1949 · 16/04/2022 21:31

You and your partner need to help your son become leaner by increasing his exercise. Maybe do it surreptitiously, by an evening walk, hikes at the weekend, badminton in the garden etc, an hour a day of fun that also burns calories. Go through your cupboards and get all high calorie snacks out, so they’re unavailable to him. Speak to school to find out what is available at break times, state schools would not provide any snacks at all. You don’t want your son to be different to the other children, so school snacks is a difficult area, reduce them at home though. You don’t want your son to feel that he is fat and needs to slim, just adopt a different lifestyle and food regime and he will gradually lose weight.

Sloelydoesit · 16/04/2022 18:16

My son who is 10 and a half is also overweight and it's stressing me out at the moment. I have now dialled down snacks to fruit, low fat yoghurt and low fat protein. Desserts are smaller and I am making sure he has a healthy balanced lunch and dinner
I too am hoping for that testosterone kick but I cannot rely on it.
I have also got him out walking more, we don't eat many very processed foods as main meals so I can't improve there. But will also look at portion sizes.

I feel so guilty that I have caused this - however I also know he sneaks treats as I have found the wrappers. Only option for that is to get them out the house altogether

minionsrule · 16/04/2022 18:11

We had similar with DS end of primary, early secondary.
Not rolls of fat but you could definitely pinch an inch (or two) on his tummy.
Both DH and I are short so ds was never going to be tall but he has slimmed right down once he got his growth spurts, he will never be skinny as he has his dad's genes so quite chunky bum and thighs.
If he doesn't play much sport try to get him into something or at least get him moving as much as you can, that should help him tone up

Spaghag · 16/04/2022 18:04

I could have written this post about DS2 at the same age.

He was chubby until around 13 (from memory) at which point he shop up in height & became a lanky beanpole. Now, at 21 & 6ft tall he has evened out to a very healthy size & shape.

Sure, sometimes it's over eating and/or unhealthy foods. Sometimes it's just puberty.

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 16/04/2022 17:52

He already talks to you about how fat he is. So this isn’t the time to pussyfoot about. tell the school only fruit snacks, make sure at least half of any plate of food is vegetables, and ask him to join you on the couch to 5K. He will soon stop swimming every day if this continues

Swipe left for the next trending thread