Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don’t we eat more fish and seafood?

285 replies

KhansMambo · 16/04/2022 14:09

A friend and I were chatting about fish and seafood (it’s Easter, after all), and wondering why the U.K. doesn’t have more of a fish/seafood culture or seafood based cuisine. Apart from the occasional bit of battered and deep fried fish, it doesn’t feature largely in a lot of people’s usual diets. And we consume markedly less than other countries with similar access.

As we’ve had so much access to it, historically, it’s interesting that it’s not the core of our traditional diet. Why don’t we have hundreds of razor clam recipes? Why didn’t everyone grow up eating an array of fish stews? Or using different kinds of seafood and seaweed as seasoning? I’m sure there’s all sorts of interesting anthropological reasons. I was wondering what everyone thought they were.

A quick Google dig up these, which I thought were really interesting.

OP posts:
darlingdodo · 16/04/2022 17:39

Love fish and seafood but don't live on the coast - produce in local fishmonger and fish counter at local supermarket never looks fresh, fillets are breaking open and 'white' fish looks greyish. Do use frozen fillets, salmon, pollack, cod, tuna, prawns, squid, scallops (Costco do good frozen fish).

We used to buy off the boat in Lochinver on holiday and the fish and seafood was amazing.

Good fish and seafood is also really expensive.

00100001 · 16/04/2022 17:37

@amicissimma

Strange question.

Some people eat lots. Some people none or hardly any. Presumably some people like it more than others.

It's not really. It is a bit bizarre that this island nation, with plenty of rivers doesn't eat more fish. Look at Japan, 1.6 times the size of our island nation, but eats 3 times as much fish.
Cardboardboxingring · 16/04/2022 17:36

You have to remember as well that historically most Brits were subsistence farmers, so unless you lived on the coast you'd be eating mostly potatoes with some vegetables and occasional meat that you or your neighbours had reared. They didn't have the money to buy fish. If you look to coastal areas there are many traditional seafood dishes, but those populations weren't representative of the majority, hence why most of what we think of as traditional British dishes aren't fish-based.

sansucre · 16/04/2022 17:34

I’m Jewish, so grew up eating copious amounts of smoked salmon on Sundays and cold fried fish (usually haddock) and fish balls (much nicer than they sound). However, we did not eat any kind of shellfish as it is not kosher. I have tried it as an adult but don’t like the texture or taste. Love most other fish particularly flat fish (specifically dover sole), haddock and bream, loathe trout and tuna (unless the latter is canned).

Amongst my circles of friends, for the most part, it is only those who grew up eating fish who eat it, those who did not have always been somewhat reticent to try it. I have always found this strange that many can write off an entire family of food without even sampling it.

BeyondMyWits · 16/04/2022 17:32

I grew up poor on a remote Scottish island.

Catch it, kill it, eat it with potatoes.

Fish, eels, seafood, crab etc as well as rabbit, pigeon game birds, - anyone could get a mug of cockles or a few razor clams, or dangle some gristle off a pier to catch crabs or mackerel.

Remember my brother saying on one infamous occasion "oh not lobster again...."

So I guess it depends what part of the UK you grow up in, and whether free food is a necessity.

KhansMambo · 16/04/2022 17:30

@artisanbread Oh, that’s an interesting idea! Will look into the history of fish and chips.

OP posts:
KhansMambo · 16/04/2022 17:29

@Onionpatch That’s probably a factor. However, you’d think there would be a glut of traditional oyster dishes (for example). And there doesn’t appear to be. Many countries’ cuisines are born from poverty and ‘struggle’ foods.

OP posts:
Kendodd · 16/04/2022 17:28

I love fish and seafood but now almost never eat it. It causes terrible environmental damage. One good thing about Brexit might be the death of the UK fishing industry.

artisanbread · 16/04/2022 17:25

How have we got to a place where the fish in supermarkets is boring and limited and we’re exporting all our good stuff because Brits won’t eat it?

I'm not sure. Maybe something to do with the popularity of fish and chip shops meaning that became the type of fish we were most likely to eat? But I don't know anything about why fish and chips became so popular here!

Onionpatch · 16/04/2022 17:24

Yes there was a phrase 'where there is poverty there is oysters' perhaps meats were more aspirational

Cardboardboxingring · 16/04/2022 17:22

The answer is gentrification... people in coastal towns used to live on fish and things like oysters were dirt cheap and considered a food for the poor. They were rebranded as upper-class and now our seafood is mostly exported or sold to high-end restaurants. The same thing happened with lobster in the US - it used to be served in prisons as it was so cheap.

KhansMambo · 16/04/2022 17:22

@BigWoollyJumpers At this point, I’m just delighted someone actually gets what I’m asking/saying. It would appear I’ve been unclear, in some way.

OP posts:
DoggoShark · 16/04/2022 17:21

Yes, that's true. BUT, there wasn't a market for it here, because we don't eat the varieties that are caught here, so it was exported, and we import the stuff we do eat, which isn't caught here..... it's a catch 22.

I think one of the fish we export most is salmon, it’s also one of the fish we import most of. Because it’s cheaper. And that’s crazy. The planet is fucked!

KhansMambo · 16/04/2022 17:19

@DoggoShark

Why do you think this has come about? How have we got to a place where the fish in supermarkets is boring and limited and we’re exporting all our good stuff because Brits won’t eat it?

Not that they won’t eat eat. The stuff we import actually costs less. Other nations are willing to pay a higher price than we are for our own, so we export it. Fuck the environment and eating local and all that. I think about 80% of what we eat is from abroad. Crazy.

Yes, but that doesn’t really have anything to do with what I’m asking. Which is how it’s come about. Why are other nations willing to pay more than we are?

I’m not making arguments for or against. I’m wondering why, in the socio-cultural narrative sense. How has this all come about?

OP posts:
BigWoollyJumpers · 16/04/2022 17:17

Back to OP - Google suggests we don't eat much now because of the "papist" connection. However, very ancient coastal communities didn't eat it either. Perhaps they were just too stupid to realise it was edible!!

BigWoollyJumpers · 16/04/2022 17:15

Other nations are willing to pay a higher price than we are for our own, so we export it

Yes, that's true. BUT, there wasn't a market for it here, because we don't eat the varieties that are caught here, so it was exported, and we import the stuff we do eat, which isn't caught here..... it's a catch 22.

Onionpatch · 16/04/2022 17:13

I wonder if there is a link with poverty in someway as in some of the items are associated with being poor. My grandparents on one side were very working class and they ate cockles and winkles and jellied eels (are they river or sea) and thats really gone out of fashion. They also had kippers for breakfast, or tinned sardines or mackerels. Fish n chips used to be a bigger range - huss and skatewings.

DoggoShark · 16/04/2022 17:12

That ‘we’ doesn’t include me.

Crimesean · 16/04/2022 17:11

@duvetdayforeveryone

Oh my gosh! I've never heard any of that before - I will absolutely cut down my fish consumption. How awful! Sad
DoggoShark · 16/04/2022 17:11

Why do you think this has come about? How have we got to a place where the fish in supermarkets is boring and limited and we’re exporting all our good stuff because Brits won’t eat it?

Not that they won’t eat eat. The stuff we import actually costs less. Other nations are willing to pay a higher price than we are for our own, so we export it. Fuck the environment and eating local and all that. I think about 80% of what we eat is from abroad. Crazy.

Hausa · 16/04/2022 17:09

Did people literally just read the thread title, then skip the entire post?!

PinkSyCo · 16/04/2022 17:07

I love fish (hate seafood) but it’s too expensive for me to eat regularly unfortunately.

KhansMambo · 16/04/2022 17:07

@artisanbread

I think there are lots of reasons but habit and difficulty of access must be some of them. The fish sold in supermarkets where most people do their shopping is boring and limited. Honestly in my local supermarket you can get cod, haddock, salmon, prawns. I shop with Ocado and the range is a bit better but not much. Unless you live in a city, access to a good fishmonger is limited. We have a mobile fishmonger in my town that comes once a week between 10 and 4 but I work full-time and therefore can almost never get there.

A lot of people never get to sample more exciting fish unless they travel abroad. We always buy shell-on prawns relatively cheaply (compared to the UK) from the fish market in France. My elder DC eats them happily (although younger DC won't eat any fish other than fishfinger or fishcake). I was watching a Rick Stein programme the other day and he said that most of the langoustines (or Dublin Bay Prawns) that are caught in the UK are exported to Europe because British people don't eat them. Trouble is, with the limited offerings available in our shops, most British people will ne er get a chance to eat them.

Why do you think this has come about? How have we got to a place where the fish in supermarkets is boring and limited and we’re exporting all our good stuff because Brits won’t eat it?
OP posts:
KhansMambo · 16/04/2022 17:04

@Dontsayyouloveme

Watch ‘seaspiracy’ on Netflix! You’ll not want to eat it again.
I’m not advocating for eating seafood (or not). I’m wondering why we haven’t, historically. Which I don’t think Seaspiracy addresses?
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread