Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Portion sizes in pubs and restaurants-why are they so big?

541 replies

AlternativelyWired · 16/04/2022 10:21

Unless of course it's somewhere very fancy.
Inspired by the calories on menus threads I was wondering why portions are so big. One place we go to does a children's pizza, chips and peas. This is just short of 900 calories. It's a Chicago town style pizza with a large handful of chips and a portion of peas. Even the adult menu has very little that's below 800 calories. Starters to share (for two people) are over 1000 calories. Some of the meat 'challenges' are over 4000 calories each! Why?
Surely if portion sizes were smaller or rather, appropriate, this would be better than stating calorie values and would help avoid food waste. Food waste induces a lot of guilt in me, and the calories do too as a former anorexic, and although eating out is a treat that we don't do often, I don't want a huge plateful of food that I won't be able to finish. I think the meat challenges are obscene but that might be my eating disordered and veggie brain speaking.
Why are pizzas so big? And burgers? Over 1000 calories for a burger and that's without the chips.
Could places offer small portions? Although even the seniors menu is a larger than normal portion.
I don't particularly want to know the calories of the dishes on offer but I do want a choice of smaller portions rather than contributing to food waste.
And while I'm at it, what happened to sandwiches on menus? In the 80s and 90s everywhere we went had a sandwich section with egg mayonnaise, prawn mayonnaise, beef, ham, cheddar ploughman's and now sandwiches don't seem to exist except in cafés. A nice sandwich with a salad garnish and maybe a handful of crisps. My mum would be so happy if they came back. And omelettes.
Bring back proper plates, the ones we had in the 80s not the huge ones we have now.

OP posts:
UsernameIsNotAvailableRightNow · 16/04/2022 12:43

[quote monicagellerbing]@AlternativelyWired the whole family has autism and sensory issues? [/quote]
That's not so unusual. It is mostly hereditary.

My son is autistic and my daughter is being assessed for adhd. My partner most probably is autistic and I'm probably autistic or have adhd (waiting to be diagnosed)

They're not wrong, it isn't easy to just pick somewhere else. It is easy to leave half a plate of food though or get it boxed up.

100problems · 16/04/2022 12:40

I don't understand why it's not just the case that diners overwhelmed by portion sizes can't use their voice.

If I eat in a pub I expect larger portions. So if the menu says burger and chips, I might all right never, but to illustrate my point ask for no bun or replace the chips with salad.

Likewise, I went to a cafe last week and asked for a jacket potato with no butter and just half the normal serving of tuna mayo.

You don't have to sit there balefully looking at a plate the same size as everyone else's if you don't want to.

VanGoghsDog · 16/04/2022 12:40

@Florenz

Restaurants should give people the choice of how much food they want to order. At the moment they have no choice, they are forced into ordering massive portions and either eating too much or wasting food, both of which are wrong.
All the food I have eaten out recently has felt like a normal portion, not massive. And I'm obviously not forced to eat it.
ANUsernam · 16/04/2022 12:40

Though I agree with you about meat challenges

Phewthemutinyworked · 16/04/2022 12:39

@CheesusWept

I always ask the restaurant to box up the leftovers and then that does me and DD for dinners for the rest of the week.
Crikey…that’s a very impressive MN over exaggeration !!
Anotherselfemployedcleaner · 16/04/2022 12:37

I think the worst example of food waste is at carverys (where you’ve got the option to go back up for more veggies if you want them) as some people seem to see it as a challenge to play ‘food Jenga’ - I’ve seen people choosing to fill their plates with truly mammoth amounts … then leave loads of it! Same with unlimited salad bars.

ANUsernam · 16/04/2022 12:37

Sorry, but this sounds to me like your eating disorder talking. What's wrong with an 800-900cal meal?

In general women are recommended to eat around 2000cals a day and men 2500. Even if you split your calories evenly across the day that would be around 670cals per meal for women, and 830 cals per meal for men.

Most people in my experience don't do that, they have smaller breakfasts/lunches - personally my breakfasts and lunches are normally 400-500cals. Leaving me at least 1000cals for dinner (or if I were eating out for lunch I'd just switch and have a light meal later).

Kennykenkencat · 16/04/2022 12:36

@Florenz

Restaurants should be legally required to offer a half size portion of every dish they offer, at half the price of the full size one.
You do know you aren’t just paying for the food on the plate. Paying only 50% for the food on the plate might not make it that much of a difference.

I don’t get when people say there was too much food in a restaurant.
It isn’t a requirement to eat any of it.
If you find burger buns a carb fest then don’t eat the bun.

Cas112 · 16/04/2022 12:36

@HailAdrian

Oh god, here we fucking go. 🤣

And if you don't want a bun, just ask them not to give you a bun...

This 😂😂

Think outside the box people

PinkSyCo · 16/04/2022 12:36

Get yourself a child’s portion if you can’t manage an adult’s. Skip lunch and/or breakfast if you’re worried about calories, or have a baked potato instead of chips. Pizza is probably the worst thing you can have, so chose something else. Make yourself a sandwich and have it at home or get a meal deal and eat it on a park bench if that’s all you fancy eating. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Porcupineintherough · 16/04/2022 12:34

It's strange how many protest they are fine with eating a huge restaurant portions every now and then "as a treat" but also have a huge arse on about calories being printed on menus.

Maverickess · 16/04/2022 12:33

@Florenz

"Agreeing with everyone who points out that that's not how pricing works as the same fixed costs (rent, staff, depreciating value of equipment) have to be covered irrespective of the portion size."

How come pubs can sell beer by the pint and half pint?

I wouldn't give restaurants the choice, legally mandate that they HAVE to do this. It is a public health issue.

If you're selling beer by the glass you have to serve it in 1/2 or 1/3 of a pint or multiples of due to licencing laws. Same as if you sell wine by the glass you have to offer 125ml and 175ml and multiples thereof.

To not do so can cost you your license as you have to be a responsible retailer around alcohol, and that means offering smaller sizes for people to choose from.
That's probably because of the impact alcohol misuse has and so the license holders are obliged to offer smaller measures so that people have a choice- if people choose to go for the larger measures that's their choice to make, and if they choose to buy the larger option and drink it all, that's also their choice, though if they then appear drunk they shouldn't be served any more (also by law - but in reality that doesn't happen very often).

So while there is a precedent for controlling what we can buy and consume legally, the effects of alcohol are more immediate through anti social behaviour, acute illness and injury etc than eating too much (although there are long term effects with alcohol too of course) no one ever got banged up for the night behaving like an idiot or fighting because they've cleared their plate in 'Spoons and that's the effect it's had on them.

PlacidPenelope · 16/04/2022 12:29

@WhenWillThisEverEnd

This thread is a good example of why so many in this country are over weight. The portion sizes in restaurants have changed our perception of what a normal amount of food is to eat. Portion sizes have got bigger as people have got fatter. We now have bigger plates and bigger glasses. This impacts on portion sizes at home. Of course there are a few people that can eat all this and stay slim but the fact is we have a major problem with obesity in this county it causes major health issues. Those that think it’s fine to eat a massive plate of processed food is fine because it is a treat are deluding themselves. Many counties in Europe have much smaller portions in restaurants and are generally slimmer than us. America huge portions and a huge obesity problem. The quality of food also counts. Restaurants only serve big portions of cheap, usually low quality food.
Totally agree, but prepare yourself for the outrage this sensible comment will provoke.
SquirrelFan · 16/04/2022 12:29

@roarfeckingroarr I eat out very often, probably too much for my bank account, but very large portions don't bother me - if it's too much (which isn't often in a good pub), I take it home. Sure, sometimes one is staying in a hotel without refrigeration, but for the most part it's a stroll, car or bus ride home with a cardboard box with a bit of roast that'll do for a sandwich the next day (or a teen's midnight snack).
I also don't think portion sizes at restaurants are driving how much people eat at home - if anything I think it's the opposite.

Invisablewoman · 16/04/2022 12:28

@stuntbubbles

Usually I just ask for an empty plate, hot from the dishwasher. The sensation of warm crockery is filling enough. Pubs honestly don’t mind serving no food and tap water, they profit simply from my presence.
😅
JinglingHellsBells · 16/04/2022 12:28

@CounsellorTroi

I wish places would offer a burger without the bun. A bunned burger and chips is too much of a carb fest.
Just don't eat it or ask the waiter to leave it off your plate.
100problems · 16/04/2022 12:28

better still the gluten free since it's usually a bowl of fresh air.

Thanks, made me laugh.

Pub = hearty. Hearty = lots.

Presumably it's not an every day event. Fill your boots.

iloveeverykindofcat · 16/04/2022 12:26

Why? Because food is a comparatively minor expenditure in running a restaurant or cafe. It costs them pennies more to increase portion sizes, and the customer gets the impression of value for money at what is essentially massive markup for the actual food. You're paying for the service and experience. That's why they do it. As to if they should or not, its a different question.

Cocomarine · 16/04/2022 12:26

@Deadringer

I don't eat out often and when I do I like a big portion. I usually skip lunch so that i am nice and hungry and rarely leave anything. I would be raging if I was given a tiny portion just because some mumsnetters people eat like birds. Maybe they should offer large and small portions of every meal, that might solve the problem.
Successful restaurants are really good at working out what’s profitable - in bringing in customers and in menu pricing.

If they can make up the lost meal cost by increasing customer numbers - great.

But they can’t afford to serve half the food for half the price. And as soon as a customer sees they’re paying 70% of them cost for 50% of the exact same food, they’ll be dissatisfied. Doesn’t matter they’re getting the portion they want and spending less - they’ll feel ripped off.

An excellent case study is the Pizza Express Leggera menu. Essentially, same pizza, hole in the middle.

But… they add a tiny bit of rocket to that hole. And they carefully make it not that main menu pizza but with a hole, but a whole series of other toppings.

Less calories - same price!

Florenz · 16/04/2022 12:25

Restaurants should give people the choice of how much food they want to order. At the moment they have no choice, they are forced into ordering massive portions and either eating too much or wasting food, both of which are wrong.

PlacidPenelope · 16/04/2022 12:25

I see the teeny tinys are all out in force, shocked no one has mentioned stuffing, guzzling, gobbling or shoveling food in yet, or even the faux “What is an oven chip”

Ah yes, the teeny tinys aka people who don't eat or like being presented with huge portions of food, amazing how defensive people on MN become about the portions of food they consume.

No-one needs the gargantuan portions served in some restaurants and pubs, very few people do hard, physical manual labour or walk miles and miles these days that would require the consumption of large amounts of food, they eat such vast quantities because they feel they are entitled to do so and then wonder why they pile on weight and suffer the health issues associated with that.

As LindaEllen said:

Also, one thing that my dietician said to me when I said something similar when I waddled into her office at 22st 12 years ago was you need to reset your mindset around food. How is something that is bad for your body, making you gain weight, a 'treat'? You deserve better!

oviraptor21 · 16/04/2022 12:25

I tend to choose a starter and a side where I know the portion sizes are just going to lead to waste .... or worse that feeling of needing to eat it all up, ingrained from childhood, and then feeling very uncomfortable as a result.

It would be nice if restaurants offered a larger variety of options, especially where pizzas are concerned.

BungleandGeorge · 16/04/2022 12:24

@VanGoghsDog

If you try and stuff it overly full don’t you feel sick and bloated?

No. Or maybe I can just eat a lot without "stuffing" my stomach "overly full".

Yes but my point was people specifically saying they eat a lot more on that specific occasion. That’s not really how a stomach works.
KatherineJaneway · 16/04/2022 12:23

@amicissimma

I have a small appetite. I find a huge portion placed in front of me daunting and does detract a bit from the enjoyment.

Why do so many people on Mumsnet find this unacceptable?

Because your implication is that we are all fat pigs because we don't mind large portions when eating out.
cantbecoping · 16/04/2022 12:21

@HearMeSnore

"Restaurants should be legally required to offer a half size portion of every dish they offer, at half the price of the full size one."

I agree. I lost my appetite completely when I had anxiety and still couldn't eat very much for a year or so afterwards. Eating out was often a challenge - I usually had a starter and a side, or a kids meal.

Now that I'm better, I can eat a full adult meal plus DD's leftovers and still have room for pudding... but I know that I shouldn't so it'd be nice to have the option of a sensible portion.

Absolute this. The option should be there.