Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Portion sizes in pubs and restaurants-why are they so big?

541 replies

AlternativelyWired · 16/04/2022 10:21

Unless of course it's somewhere very fancy.
Inspired by the calories on menus threads I was wondering why portions are so big. One place we go to does a children's pizza, chips and peas. This is just short of 900 calories. It's a Chicago town style pizza with a large handful of chips and a portion of peas. Even the adult menu has very little that's below 800 calories. Starters to share (for two people) are over 1000 calories. Some of the meat 'challenges' are over 4000 calories each! Why?
Surely if portion sizes were smaller or rather, appropriate, this would be better than stating calorie values and would help avoid food waste. Food waste induces a lot of guilt in me, and the calories do too as a former anorexic, and although eating out is a treat that we don't do often, I don't want a huge plateful of food that I won't be able to finish. I think the meat challenges are obscene but that might be my eating disordered and veggie brain speaking.
Why are pizzas so big? And burgers? Over 1000 calories for a burger and that's without the chips.
Could places offer small portions? Although even the seniors menu is a larger than normal portion.
I don't particularly want to know the calories of the dishes on offer but I do want a choice of smaller portions rather than contributing to food waste.
And while I'm at it, what happened to sandwiches on menus? In the 80s and 90s everywhere we went had a sandwich section with egg mayonnaise, prawn mayonnaise, beef, ham, cheddar ploughman's and now sandwiches don't seem to exist except in cafés. A nice sandwich with a salad garnish and maybe a handful of crisps. My mum would be so happy if they came back. And omelettes.
Bring back proper plates, the ones we had in the 80s not the huge ones we have now.

OP posts:
nosyupnorth · 16/04/2022 13:01

Remember ladies, enjoying food is bad and you shouldn't let yourself catch the scent of cooking more than once a week or you'll get stuffed full of all those evil calories in the air.

VanGoghsDog · 16/04/2022 13:01

@100problems

*“ I like a big meal”

Why exactly?*

My response would be "I suppose you're looking for an answer more sophisticated than "because occasionally, I do".

Doesn't make her a bad person for goodness sake.

Quite. It feels very judgemental to be asked WHY you like something.
Joystir59 · 16/04/2022 13:00

Because huge people want huge portions. People have in my opinion really lost the plot when it comes to portion size and it's link to obesity.

VanGoghsDog · 16/04/2022 12:59

[quote LuckySantangelo35]@VanGoghsDog

No not implying either of those things. Just intrigued as to why someone would like a big meal as in one that’s objectively a big portion and more than they need or really want. Most people would find it a little over facing. Is it about feeling your getting value for money or something? Some people do prefer quantity over quality

You keep referring to your size when its not about that. Also people can be slim and really unhealthy, lots of fat around liver etc. Not that I’m saying you are.[/quote]
I don't "keep referring" to my size at all.

I've always been a big eater. Always ate more than most people. So if I go out to eat and get a small portion I am still hungry. So I like a large portion. I can leave some of a large portion. I can't eat more of a small portion.

I don't force feed myself food I can't eat. I didn't have pudding out at lunch yesterday and only ate one of the two hunks of bread served as "nibbles" (weird nibbles, wedge of heavy bread, but anyway).

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/04/2022 12:58

@100problems

*“ I like a big meal”

Why exactly?*

My response would be "I suppose you're looking for an answer more sophisticated than "because occasionally, I do".

Doesn't make her a bad person for goodness sake.

@100problems

Who said it made her a bad person?

100problems · 16/04/2022 12:58

*“ I like a big meal”

Why exactly?*

My response would be "I suppose you're looking for an answer more sophisticated than "because occasionally, I do".

Doesn't make her a bad person for goodness sake.

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/04/2022 12:54

@VanGoghsDog

No not implying either of those things. Just intrigued as to why someone would like a big meal as in one that’s objectively a big portion and more than they need or really want. Most people would find it a little over facing. Is it about feeling your getting value for money or something? Some people do prefer quantity over quality

You keep referring to your size when its not about that. Also people can be slim and really unhealthy, lots of fat around liver etc. Not that I’m saying you are.

VanGoghsDog · 16/04/2022 12:54

[quote Porcupineintherough]@VanGoghsDog sure, just search for the half dozen threads on the subject from this week.

" Having a huge arse on" = being really cross about, nothing to do with the size of your arse. Or maybe you were being facetious. Sorry, couldn't tell.[/quote]
You made the assertion, you need to back it up.

Your assertion was that the same posters who like large meals are complaining about calories being shown on menus. Let's see then?

Trainbear · 16/04/2022 12:53

Ask for a doggy bag.
" Oh no, that's what the Americans do, next thing we will be talking American, wearing jeans, watching American programmes as we sup pepsi or coke. We used to have an Empire, damme"

Aye we used to have an Hippodrome, Roxy and Goumont too - as we say in Yorkshire.

skybluee · 16/04/2022 12:53

Maybe what the 'rest of the week' poster is failing to mention is that her and her daughter went to eat out on a Saturday night!

aSofaNearYou · 16/04/2022 12:53

@Porcupineintherough

It's strange how many protest they are fine with eating a huge restaurant portions every now and then "as a treat" but also have a huge arse on about calories being printed on menus.
We eat food in this country that is impossible to pass as healthy unless you eat a very small amount of it. It doesn't need to be a huge portion, if I wanted to eat a "healthy" amount of restaurant pizza it would basically be a slice. I think it would be quite ridiculous to suggest anything more than a single slice of pizza is a "huge" portion.

The truth is a lot of the food is just unhealthy, so we don't really want or need calorie counters reminding us of that unless we want to just stop eating out.

VanGoghsDog · 16/04/2022 12:51

[quote LuckySantangelo35]@VanGoghsDog

“ I like a big meal”

Why exactly?[/quote]
Who knows?

I like lots of things and I can't exactly tell you WHY I like them.

I'm not overweight nor do I have an eating disorder if that's what you're trying to get at.

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/04/2022 12:51

@ANUsernam

Sorry, but this sounds to me like your eating disorder talking. What's wrong with an 800-900cal meal?

In general women are recommended to eat around 2000cals a day and men 2500. Even if you split your calories evenly across the day that would be around 670cals per meal for women, and 830 cals per meal for men.

Most people in my experience don't do that, they have smaller breakfasts/lunches - personally my breakfasts and lunches are normally 400-500cals. Leaving me at least 1000cals for dinner (or if I were eating out for lunch I'd just switch and have a light meal later).

@ANUsernam

2000 cals a day is too much unless you’re exercising a lot which in the uk with the sedentary work and life styles most of us are forced into, don’t. 800-900 cal meals are therefore excessive.

100problems · 16/04/2022 12:51

@SmallPrawnEnergy (apt user name) I forgot that.

But imagine having conniptions over something you can simply ask to have changed.

stuntbubbles · 16/04/2022 12:50

Restaurants should give people the choice of how much food they want to order.
You mean like a menu, with different options on it?

At the moment they have no choice, they are forced into ordering massive portions and either eating too much or wasting food, both of which are wrong.
Most decent pub menus will have a selection of sandwiches, side dishes like chips, hearty meals like fish and chips, burgers, pies, etc, a salad, starters etc, and rarely have I seen a rule that says you can’t just order a starter, or split a main course. No one’s forced to do anything. There’s even the option of not going to the pub!

Porcupineintherough · 16/04/2022 12:49

@VanGoghsDog sure, just search for the half dozen threads on the subject from this week.

" Having a huge arse on" = being really cross about, nothing to do with the size of your arse. Or maybe you were being facetious. Sorry, couldn't tell.

FrenchBoule · 16/04/2022 12:48

@WhenWillThisEverEnd

This thread is a good example of why so many in this country are over weight. The portion sizes in restaurants have changed our perception of what a normal amount of food is to eat. Portion sizes have got bigger as people have got fatter. We now have bigger plates and bigger glasses. This impacts on portion sizes at home. Of course there are a few people that can eat all this and stay slim but the fact is we have a major problem with obesity in this county it causes major health issues. Those that think it’s fine to eat a massive plate of processed food is fine because it is a treat are deluding themselves. Many counties in Europe have much smaller portions in restaurants and are generally slimmer than us. America huge portions and a huge obesity problem. The quality of food also counts. Restaurants only serve big portions of cheap, usually low quality food.
While I agree with some of your comment-portions got bigger and so did the plates I disagree with the rest.

What about people taking responsibility themselves on what and how much they eat?

Different people have different dietary needs. Some are able to eat more and stay slim,some are not.

2000 calories is recommended daily food intake. This 2000 calories might be 4 Galaxy chocolate bars or a wide range of food comprising of fruit,veg,meat,fish,dairy and grains.

Not everybody needs 2000 calories to sustain their weight.Some people need much less,this depends on age (and metabolism), gender and occupation.

Seeing as we’re talking here about portions in restaurants,depends on how often you go to the restaurant and which ones.

To me a restaurant trip is very rare so I’d rather go to independent one than the chain one (nothing wrong with it, each to their own).
It’s a very rare treat so I will have a starter,main and maybe dessert if I feel I still have a space for it. Never encountered massive portions and once in a while overeating now and again is not going to make my weight get out of control. I’m in charge what I eat and how much.

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/04/2022 12:48

@VanGoghsDog

“ I like a big meal”

Why exactly?

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/04/2022 12:47

@VanGoghsDog

Thing is though the teen boys probably only ate it cos they can not because they need such a big portion. There’s a difference. No one needs the enormous piles of food on massive plates that some pubs serve, even teen boys who mumsnet seem to think should be allowed to eat a weekly shop in one sitting

herecomesthsun · 16/04/2022 12:46

@Florenz

Restaurants should give people the choice of how much food they want to order. At the moment they have no choice, they are forced into ordering massive portions and either eating too much or wasting food, both of which are wrong.
But there are choices.

Most restaurants do salads.

It is often possible to ask for fish to be steamed and served with vegetables.

And so on.

SmallPrawnEnergy · 16/04/2022 12:46

I don't understand why it's not just the case that diners overwhelmed by portion sizes can't use their voice.
Same posters who have a panic attack if someone knocks on their door I imagine

froidIci · 16/04/2022 12:46

The OP posts a thread about How BIG portions are everywhere- won’t anyone think of how much of a waste it all is.

People respond exactly as expected.

OP returns to say - but this is a post about neuro diversity - people so mean - I should have known.

knittingaddict · 16/04/2022 12:45

@Florenz

Restaurants should be legally required to offer a half size portion of every dish they offer, at half the price of the full size one.
I don't think you understand restaurant pricing and economics. You still need a plate, knife and fork, glass, someone to serve you and cook the meal, a table and chair. The cost of half a plate of food is not half the cost of a full plate.
VanGoghsDog · 16/04/2022 12:45

@Porcupineintherough

It's strange how many protest they are fine with eating a huge restaurant portions every now and then "as a treat" but also have a huge arse on about calories being printed on menus.
It's strange that I've never seen these comments. Can you show some?

I like a big meal and I don't mind if calories are on menus though I've only ever seen it in Pizza Express (I know it's the new law, but only chains have do it essentially, and I've not been to once since the new law came in).

I also don't have a huge arse.

TheChurchOfEli · 16/04/2022 12:44

If I order pasta for my toddler, even a kids portion, there's enough for my lunch the next day, sometimes two.
What’s that smell in here? Oh right, it’s bullshit.