Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Woman took pic of my DD on the bus today😂

241 replies

babyhaha · 15/04/2022 19:38

So I had a miserable start to the day today.
I’m 38 weeks pregnant and will be having my C section on Tuesday. I booked a restaurant for DD, DP and I so we can have one last meal just the three of us before our newborn arrives. Whilst we were on the bus, the driver announced that the bus had to terminate as Westminster Bridge was closed because of protests. So here I was with the worst PGP known to man having to walk from Lambeth North all the way to the other side of the bridge.

Anyways! We were finally able to get on a bus and when I got on, I parked the pushchair in the wheelchair space and sat next to an older lady who was already sitting down. I noticed she was on her phone and then suddenly she put her phone up as if to take a picture. I looked at her phone to make sure it was facing her and not my DD but my surprise, she had put it facing DD and had actually taken a picture of her! (DP was also in it)

I said to her, ‘excuse me, why did you just take a picture of my child, delete that.’ She said ‘oh she’s just so cute,’ I said, ‘you can’t just take pictures of kids you don’t know without asking, you need to delete that.’ She deleted it with no hesitation and then I asked her to go into her recently deleted and delete it from there too. She didn’t know how to do that so she let me show her. She then replied ‘thank you, I respect your decision’ ???

It was such a bizzare but funny situation to be in. When I think back, I keep laughing because it just felt like a surreal moment! The last time I caught someone taking a picture of my DD, he was so embarrassed I caught him and was stuttering trying to give an explanation as to why. This woman’s reaction is so different to that and it’s making me chuckle. It’s also making me think how normal this could be? Do you ever see a cute baby and just take a picture of them without asking their parents? Has anything like this happened to you before?

And before anyone starts, this isn’t a case of PFB. I would have said the same if someone took a pic of my 14 year old sister, another family member or even a friend. You can’t just go taking pictures of people you don’t know because you want too!

OP posts:
Polyputthekettleon · 15/04/2022 20:59

It's legal to take photos of people in public places. Its kind of her to delete it. Once I was walking with my little daughter and it was drizzling so she had her raincoat and princess brolley and wellies on and a lady who was seated on a bench took a photo of her. I wasn't very happy, but I didn't say anything because she isn't doing anything illegal. The combination of colours would have made a nice photo so I can see why she took a photo. I am sure my daughters images are stored on cctv footage taken on all the public transport my daughter has been on and other public places she has been to. Not sure why you are chuckling though . If the lady told you to do one then i suspect you won't be chuckling

HaveringWavering · 15/04/2022 20:57

Exactly. People have been taking pictures of kids in the street in developing countries for travelogues since cameras were invented. They are all over Sunday supplements and Lonely Planet guides.

ButtockUp · 15/04/2022 20:57

My adult daughter works in a famous London attraction.
She has often regaled us of a particular group of people from a particular part of the world who would delight in taking photos of adults and children in wheelchairs or who displayed obvious non-typical behaviours.

HaveringWavering · 15/04/2022 20:55

I don’t get why you all care. Even if some stranger wanted to do something horrible with picture of my son, it’s not like it is harming him, is it? Unless I put a bag over his head he will be seen in public. Can’t get worked up about it.

claracluck1978 · 15/04/2022 20:49

I have (adorable) identical twin boys. When they were 2 we were on holiday at a popular Scottish destination. A coach load of Japanese tourists arrived & I swear every single one took a photo of my boys. At the time I was totally bewildered by it & I now think it was less weird than just a single person taking a photo of them would have been.

I often chuckle at the idea 50 random families in Japan have had to sit and look at photos of random English 2 year olds!

SquirrelG · 15/04/2022 20:45

It is perfectly legal to take pictures in public.

This. People who are serious about photography have been taking photos of others in public for decades - go to a library and look at any photography book!

What a drama over nothing.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/04/2022 20:44

@1Micem0use

When I taught in Asia I was on a school trip in a sort of heritage museum place. The kids were having a tea ceremony lesson in a ground floor building and other visitors were wandering around. A bunch of white American tourists walked past and started taking photos of the children. I was furious. The kids weren't part of the museum! Their parents hadnt given permission and I doubt these tourists would dream of taking photos of random American kids on a school trip.
When we were in Singapore with DD who was 9 months, the locals photographed her everywhere we went.
JaninaDuszejko · 15/04/2022 20:43

This woman with a pushchair ran up to me and began loudly remonstrating. Her son was on the ride also, his dad was behind him. I had barely even registered that there was another child there; only had eyes for mine. Also never put children pics on social media but I suppose she didn’t know that. I apologised immediately and deleted.

I would have told her not to be so bloody ridiculous, I was taking a photo of my child and their friends in a public place which is completely legal. So what if her child is in the background of a photo? I would ask if her child was a looked after child and if so I was would reassure her that I would not share the photo with anyone but I would never delete a photo of my own child because some hysterical parent accuses me of nefarious intent. How fucking insulting.

People need to be aware that if they don't want to accidently appear in the background of someone's photo they need to stop going to public places. No-one is doing anything wrong by taking a photo of you, it is not against the law.

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 15/04/2022 20:42

Dramatic, dirty minded or at a loose end of Friday, not suuuuure which 😌

Sunnytwobridges · 15/04/2022 20:40

[quote Goldijobsandthe3bears]@MurmuratingStarling You sound more scary than the old lady tbh[/quote]
😂

babyhaha · 15/04/2022 20:40

[quote ChristinaBlang]@babyhaha a toddler group is not a public space though, so they would need your permission. If you are just out in public then photos can be taken.[/quote]
@ChristinaBlang ah right that makes sense. I would think someone who works for the shopping centre would still ask for permission to take a picture of someone using the play area but I guess they don’t HAVE too

OP posts:
DoggoInMyTesla · 15/04/2022 20:39

leave it out, save some concern for yourself.

Naive or sinister, not sure which.

Traumdeuter · 15/04/2022 20:39

@LJAKS

I had a group of tourists taking pictures and videos of my wedding because it was at Gretna 🥴😂 mad to think some wee family somewhere are sitting with wedding photos of me in an album somewhere. Long since divorced too 😂
Same here! A tourist minibus was snapping away at me in my dress Grin
Anonymous48 · 15/04/2022 20:38

It does seem pretty odd to take a picture of someone else's child, no matter how cute they are. But to be honest I couldn't get worked up about it. We're all being photographed and recorded much of the time we are in public.

DentonsFringeArnottsWaistcoat · 15/04/2022 20:38

@VyeBrator

I said, ‘you can’t just take pictures of kids you don’t know without asking

The thing is she can, so you're lucky she deleted it really.

Yeah, legal, but fucking weird though.
lessthanathirdofanacre · 15/04/2022 20:35

It doesn't sound as though the woman had any sinister intent and it was kind of her to delete the photo. But it isn't illegal to photograph anyone in public, as PPs have pointed out. You and your child have probably been photographed at other times without your knowledge. And of course there is CCTV everywhere, Ring doorbells, etc. We're all being recorded much of the time we're in public.

BertieBotts · 15/04/2022 20:35

She deleted it with no hesitation and then I asked her to go into her recently deleted and delete it from there too. She didn’t know how to do that so she let me show her. She then replied ‘thank you, I respect your decision’ ???

This is EXACTLY what my mum would do/say if you confronted her over something like this. I have no idea if she would take a photo in the first place (I would hope not...) but I also notice other people in her generation e.g. friend's mothers/MILs repost pictures of their grandchildren constantly all over FB or post pictures that they often have already or share their (child/child-in-law's) post about the grandchildren, in a way that people in my generation don't do any more with their own kids.

I don't think it feels the same to them as it feels to us - they haven't had camera phones for as long (most of us got them as soon as they were available whereas my mum had a brick phone + separate digital camera until smartphones became the absolute default) and I think they see it as a private thing and don't necessarily realise the way that younger people see image sharing as being public.

And before somebody jumps on me I'm sure there are members of that generation who are internet savvy and completely understand privacy concerns and have had smartphones since 2010 but there are also a lot who are later adopters, and it doesn't hurt to come to something from a point of understanding rather than judgement.

Antarcticant · 15/04/2022 20:35

I thought when it’s in a professional space that they have to get consent from parents when taking pictures of parents and/or kids.

A baby club, school etc. has to make its own rules about photography on its premises - there's no law that will do that for them. A bus company would similarly have to make its own rule - a condition of carriage - to ban photography on its buses.

oakleaffy · 15/04/2022 20:33

@SnackSizeRaisin

Because I don't think people used to worry so much years ago, before the internet.

But years ago you wouldn't have a camera with you on a bus ride. You would have a camera only on holidays and days out and a 24 photo film would last a month.

This is a very valid point. Cameras , rolls of film and processing took time and money, very different to today's instantaneous images. It is odd for a stranger to be taking pics of a child without asking.. Why would they even want that image? In Paris, there were two little children playing with sugar cane in a doorway. I'd have loved to have had an image of them, but wouldn't have photographed them as would have been invasive and cheeky.
Benjispruce4 · 15/04/2022 20:33

I couldn’t be that bothered about that OP.

babyhaha · 15/04/2022 20:33

@ZerotwoZero

As others have said, its good to be cautious but perfectly legal. In fact once she took the initial picture the image became her intellectual property on her phone and you had no right to demand she deleted it, but that's a whole new thread I supposed.

This could be looked at two ways, she could have simply been an old woman, who was very lonely with no immediate family and may well still be upset right now or she could simply be a suspicious character. Who knows but still laughing about her and plastering it on social media does puzzle me.

I just hope it not the former and you are not the lonely old woman with no family one day.

@ZerotwoZero

In fact once she took the initial picture the image became her intellectual property on her phone and you had no right to demand she deleted it, but that's a whole new thread I supposed.

Sorry but I genuinely couldn’t care less. Even now that I know that, I’d still ask the next person to delete the picture of my child.

*This could be looked at two ways, she could have simply been an old woman, who was very lonely with no immediate family and may well still be upset right now or she could simply be a suspicious character. Who knows but still laughing about her and plastering it on social media does puzzle me.

I just hope it not the former and you are not the lonely old woman with no family one day.*

Again, that’s not my business. She could be an old woman with no family and sorry to her but that doesn’t mean it’s okay to take a picture of my child and keep it in her phone🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Goldijobsandthe3bears · 15/04/2022 20:32

@DoggoInMyTesla, leave it out, save some concern for yourself.

ChristinaBlang · 15/04/2022 20:31

@babyhaha a toddler group is not a public space though, so they would need your permission. If you are just out in public then photos can be taken.

VyeBrator · 15/04/2022 20:31

I would love for someone to take a picture of my baby and tell me they’re not deleting it. Okay maybe there’s no law about it but how can you take a picture of a baby, get caught and then say you won’t delete it. That’s insane

Why would you 'love for someone' to do that? It wouldn't make any difference. You couldn't force them to delete it.

Dillydollydingdong · 15/04/2022 20:30

It happened to me once, but the other way round. I told some teenage louts to stop vandalizing the kiddies playground. They refused. I held my camera up as though to say I was taking a photo of one of the girls. One of the lads got really arsey, called me a paedo and demanded to see the photo. I did, but here wasn't one. They slunk off, still grumbling.