Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Woman took pic of my DD on the bus today😂

241 replies

babyhaha · 15/04/2022 19:38

So I had a miserable start to the day today.
I’m 38 weeks pregnant and will be having my C section on Tuesday. I booked a restaurant for DD, DP and I so we can have one last meal just the three of us before our newborn arrives. Whilst we were on the bus, the driver announced that the bus had to terminate as Westminster Bridge was closed because of protests. So here I was with the worst PGP known to man having to walk from Lambeth North all the way to the other side of the bridge.

Anyways! We were finally able to get on a bus and when I got on, I parked the pushchair in the wheelchair space and sat next to an older lady who was already sitting down. I noticed she was on her phone and then suddenly she put her phone up as if to take a picture. I looked at her phone to make sure it was facing her and not my DD but my surprise, she had put it facing DD and had actually taken a picture of her! (DP was also in it)

I said to her, ‘excuse me, why did you just take a picture of my child, delete that.’ She said ‘oh she’s just so cute,’ I said, ‘you can’t just take pictures of kids you don’t know without asking, you need to delete that.’ She deleted it with no hesitation and then I asked her to go into her recently deleted and delete it from there too. She didn’t know how to do that so she let me show her. She then replied ‘thank you, I respect your decision’ ???

It was such a bizzare but funny situation to be in. When I think back, I keep laughing because it just felt like a surreal moment! The last time I caught someone taking a picture of my DD, he was so embarrassed I caught him and was stuttering trying to give an explanation as to why. This woman’s reaction is so different to that and it’s making me chuckle. It’s also making me think how normal this could be? Do you ever see a cute baby and just take a picture of them without asking their parents? Has anything like this happened to you before?

And before anyone starts, this isn’t a case of PFB. I would have said the same if someone took a pic of my 14 year old sister, another family member or even a friend. You can’t just go taking pictures of people you don’t know because you want too!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MurmuratingStarling · 17/04/2022 13:44

@Bbq1

It's weird because why would anyone want a photo of a random baby?
Exactly. I don't give a shit about ANYone's babies/children except my OWN, and my close relatives children, and the children/grandchildren of my 2 best friends.

Someone said maybe someone does it 'coz they're lonely and have no grandchildren or children of their own.' That may be the case with some people, but why the fuck does that make it OK to go around pointing their camera at someone else's child and collecting photos of them? Confused

It's as weird as fuck, and reminds me of the film 'One Hour Photo' where the man in the photo-processing-booth in a supermarket, processes films for a woman who comes in every few weeks, and keeps copies of the photos for himself. Whilst pretending to others, that she (and her family,) are his daughter, son-in-law, and grandchildren. Confused

MurmuratingStarling · 17/04/2022 13:33

@watcherintherye

It's weird if nothing else though, are they going to flick through photos of random children on an evening- aw that one was sweet, oh how cute. Like, why?

But so what if they do? Might be a gp who doesn’t get to see their similar aged gc very often, or someone who lost a child. What harm does it do to the subject of the photo? Surely it’s children who are being harmed and exploited in actual real life situations where the safeguarding concerns lie?

Hmm
babyhaha · 17/04/2022 12:18

Sorry I still find that weird, there isn't a reason for someone to take a photo of a young child without the parents consent imo, good for you if you feel differently, but I think it's unfair to minimise OPs feelings. Both can be true, it's a bit like the infuriating well you can't moan about x as people have it worse. Yes some children are sadly exploited which is deplorable, but I also would be annoyed and find it weird is a stranger took a photo of my DS on public transport. How can you be so sure what her intentions were anyway?

Thank you! And thank you for the other comments were people have come along and have used actual sense. Defending someone when you have NO CLUE what their intentions are makes zero sense to me. I also wasn’t comfortable with the situation but because some posters are fine with it, that means I should be? Yes it’s not against the law but how many things aren’t against the law that are deemed morally wrong. As another poster said, seems a low bar to go by…

OP posts:
babyhaha · 17/04/2022 12:15

But so what if they do? Might be a gp who doesn’t get to see their similar aged gc very often, or someone who lost a child

Ok and… sorry to them if that’s the case but that still doesn’t give someone the right to then take a picture of someone’s child if they’re not comfortable with that

OP posts:
NotBadConsidering · 17/04/2022 12:09

It’s not about living with anxiety. It’s about how, as a society, we have unwittingly allowed unfettered access to images of children for predatory use simply by posting them online without thinking and giving people an instant camera to take photos whenever they want. As the law stands, we can’t do anything about the latter. It needs to change.

It’s sad you don’t think children are exploited in that scenario. Tell that to all the women whose images have been stolen without their knowledge. If they’d never found out, would that make it okay?

www.bbc.com/news/av/uk-56333561

watcherintherye · 17/04/2022 11:33

If you have ever posted photos of your children on the internet, or had a stranger take a photo of your child, you have absolutely zero way of being 100% sure that the photo is not on an child exploitation website being commented on by predators.

So when you say “let’s focus on the children actually being exploited” you don’t know if that is or isn’t your child.

Yes, I can see that is an unpleasant thing to think about, but I still don’t think a child is being exploited unless they are suffering harm. A photo is a photo. You could say the same for people watching children in a park, or going past their house to school. You can’t know what is in people’s minds. You surely hope for the best, but don’t let your children ever be in a situation where they could be actually exploited. Most exploitation sadly starts much closer to home than a random person taking a photo on a bus, and I still struggle to see how that would be any danger to an otherwise safe child. We need to be able to distinguish between situations which are potentially harmful and those which are not, or it makes for a very anxiety-driven life.

Patchbatch · 17/04/2022 11:10

As far as I know, photography in public places is perfectly legal.

It is, but plenty of things are legal but weird or inappropriate. Seems a low bar to go by.

KosherDill · 17/04/2022 11:09

@VyeBrator

I said, ‘you can’t just take pictures of kids you don’t know without asking

The thing is she can, so you're lucky she deleted it really.

As far as I know, photography in public places is perfectly legal.
Bbq1 · 17/04/2022 11:03

My ds was extremely cute as a baby and this was not just our opinion, people would comment on this all the time. Now he's older, a young adult I still have people commenting on how handsome he is at least a couple of times a week. Despite this nobody has ever (to my knowledge) taken his photo and I wouldn't have expected them to have wanted to.

Patchbatch · 17/04/2022 11:02

@watcherintherye

It's weird if nothing else though, are they going to flick through photos of random children on an evening- aw that one was sweet, oh how cute. Like, why?

But so what if they do? Might be a gp who doesn’t get to see their similar aged gc very often, or someone who lost a child. What harm does it do to the subject of the photo? Surely it’s children who are being harmed and exploited in actual real life situations where the safeguarding concerns lie?

Sorry I still find that weird, there isn't a reason for someone to take a photo of a young child without the parents consent imo, good for you if you feel differently, but I think it's unfair to minimise OPs feelings. Both can be true, it's a bit like the infuriating well you can't moan about x as people have it worse. Yes some children are sadly exploited which is deplorable, but I also would be annoyed and find it weird is a stranger took a photo of my DS on public transport. How can you be so sure what her intentions were anyway?
NotBadConsidering · 17/04/2022 11:01

But any child who ever had their photo taken by a stranger could be being exploited. That’s the point. You have no way of knowing the intentions of the person. All you have is law of averages. “Overall, it’s most likely that the person isn’t a predator” isn’t how we safeguard children. We safeguard children by assuming the worst, and working backwards.

If you have ever posted photos of your children on the internet, or had a stranger take a photo of your child, you have absolutely zero way of being 100% sure that the photo is not on an child exploitation website being commented on by predators.

So when you say “let’s focus on the children actually being exploited” you don’t know if that is or isn’t your child.

SherbetDips · 17/04/2022 10:56

Happened to me once, I am a nanny and I had these two little boys with olive skin, Sandy brown curls and blue eyes , they were gorgeous.

I noticed this Japanese tourist taking his picture and I asked her to delete them.

Bbq1 · 17/04/2022 10:51

It's weird because why would anyone want a photo of a random baby?

ancientgran · 17/04/2022 10:39

@watcherintherye

It's weird if nothing else though, are they going to flick through photos of random children on an evening- aw that one was sweet, oh how cute. Like, why?

But so what if they do? Might be a gp who doesn’t get to see their similar aged gc very often, or someone who lost a child. What harm does it do to the subject of the photo? Surely it’s children who are being harmed and exploited in actual real life situations where the safeguarding concerns lie?

Yes let's concentrate on the children actually being exploited.
watcherintherye · 17/04/2022 10:33

It's weird if nothing else though, are they going to flick through photos of random children on an evening- aw that one was sweet, oh how cute. Like, why?

But so what if they do? Might be a gp who doesn’t get to see their similar aged gc very often, or someone who lost a child. What harm does it do to the subject of the photo? Surely it’s children who are being harmed and exploited in actual real life situations where the safeguarding concerns lie?

NotBadConsidering · 17/04/2022 09:50

The law needs seriously updating. It’s not like the days of National Geographic. Photos of children end up in the wrong hands, whether taken by strangers or lifted from social media. Almost a quarter of photos on child exploitation sites have been lifted from social media. I want to be in control of my DCs’ images until they’re adults, the law allowing photography of children needs updating for the digital age.

medium.com/a-parent-is-born/how-pedophiles-steal-photos-from-social-media-d37a19647d7

www.abc.net.au/news/2016-12-29/child-rights-to-privacy-ignored-by-parents-posting-images-online/8112506

ancientgran · 17/04/2022 09:16

It's weird if nothing else though, are they going to flick through photos of random children on an evening- aw that one was sweet, oh how cute. Like, why?

Lots of photo taking is weird really. I mean why struggle to get a good photo of The Vatican/Buckingham Palace/The Kremlin. For pennies you can buy postcards of them that are probably much better quality so why do it?

Patchbatch · 17/04/2022 08:26

@watcherintherye

In my family there are 2 of us in social care safeguarding etc. We see the stories , I teach them. I've sat in courtrooms and prisons as have they. Neither of us allow pictures to be taken by others if we are able to control it largely because we have seen imaged from the other side and it's something that will stay with us to the day we die.

I’ve no doubt, and that’s horrible, but you’re letting it cloud your judgement. I’m not saying it’s usual or an everyday occurrence, but there are surely zero implications for safeguarding, if a stranger takes a photo, in a public place, of a fully clothed anonymous child who is with their parents? I’m really curious as to what harm that alone can do?

It's weird if nothing else though, are they going to flick through photos of random children on an evening- aw that one was sweet, oh how cute. Like, why?
Patchbatch · 17/04/2022 08:25

I don't believe ANYONE who says they would be OK with some random weirdo pointing a camera at their child and taking photographs of them without permission. What an utter crock!

Me neither, aside from those who plaster their children all over the Internet anyway on their social media etc- they have no regard for their children.

watcherintherye · 17/04/2022 08:23

In my family there are 2 of us in social care safeguarding etc. We see the stories , I teach them. I've sat in courtrooms and prisons as have they. Neither of us allow pictures to be taken by others if we are able to control it largely because we have seen imaged from the other side and it's something that will stay with us to the day we die.

I’ve no doubt, and that’s horrible, but you’re letting it cloud your judgement. I’m not saying it’s usual or an everyday occurrence, but there are surely zero implications for safeguarding, if a stranger takes a photo, in a public place, of a fully clothed anonymous child who is with their parents? I’m really curious as to what harm that alone can do?

MurmuratingStarling · 16/04/2022 23:00

@Cherrysoup

So that makes it ok and the OP should have let her crack on? Would you say the same had the photographer been a man?

Exactly this. ^ I can only imagine the reactions on here (from some) if it had been a man taking the picture! Although some people are acting like they wouldn't mind, even if it WAS a man, and people are being OTT and dramatic because THEY would be OK with it! Hmm Yeah right! SURE you would!

Yes, it’s legal, but no, it’s not ethical or appropriate to take pictures of anyone, let alone a child, without asking the parent, not that I would dream of asking.

Also this. ^ I don't believe ANYONE who says they would be OK with some random weirdo pointing a camera at their child and taking photographs of them without permission. What an utter crock!

Also, I can't BELIEVE some people are comparing just being caught in the background on other peoples photos, or being caught walking down the street on cctv, to some random nobody actually deliberately pointing the camera at your CHILD, and taking a photograph of them.

Why the fuck does someone that I (and my child,) has never met before, need a photograph of MY CHILD? They don't know them, they have never met them, and they never WILL know them or meet them. Wanting to take photos of some stranger's CHILD is as creepy as fuck. I don't believe ANYone who says they think it's OK.

Cherrysoup · 16/04/2022 15:52

@ZerotwoZero

As others have said, its good to be cautious but perfectly legal. In fact once she took the initial picture the image became her intellectual property on her phone and you had no right to demand she deleted it, but that's a whole new thread I supposed.

This could be looked at two ways, she could have simply been an old woman, who was very lonely with no immediate family and may well still be upset right now or she could simply be a suspicious character. Who knows but still laughing about her and plastering it on social media does puzzle me.

I just hope it not the former and you are not the lonely old woman with no family one day.

So that makes it ok and the OP should have let her crack on? Would you say the same had the photographer been a man?

Yes, it’s legal, no, it’s not ethical or appropriate to take pictures of anyone, let alone a child, without asking the parent, not that I would dream of asking.

ancientgran · 16/04/2022 15:40

@DoggoShark

The woman on the bus was polite when questioned. She was within her rights to take the photo. OP was just rude.

Legally maybe. But actually as buses are private property possibly not. Either way, most people don’t take photos of other people’s kids because we understand the issues around that.... that and I really wouldn’t want photos of kids I don’t know. If you’re not a weirdo or a street photographer 😂 what normal things could they commonly be wanted for? 🙃 I can only imagine that if I was to show my family/friends of a random child on the bus, they may think I’d lost the plot.

Well I wouldn't take photos of random kids, I've got 6 GC all cute so I don't need to. My point is the OP was rude to tell the woman "delete it" as she hadn't done anything wrong. The OP is entitled to not want the woman to have the photo but nothing wrong with politely asking her to delete it.
FreezyFreezy · 16/04/2022 13:01

You have no control over what happens with an image of yourself or your children. You can ask people to delete a photo they've taken but you can't force them to; even the police can't do that. You can't expect privacy in a public space either so if you're in the street or at the park then you can't stop someone from taking photos.

I personally would be bothered by someone taking photos of me or my dc and would ask them not to (and have done so in the past) but wouldn't shout at them for it.

Charlize43 · 16/04/2022 12:39

This reminds me of something that happened to my niece: She celebrated her 18th Birthday was a big party for herself on the beach. Later one of her friends sent her a link where a total stranger had taken a selfie with their back to the party (the party in the background), posted it on Instagram and claimed to have had a party on the beach!!!

How weird is that?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread