Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I just wouldn’t fit in at NCT classes?

158 replies

Tulipsanddaffs06 · 15/04/2022 16:11

First time mum, 24 weeks pregnant. I feel a little lonely tbh as none of my friends are pregnant and I’d like to meet some other pregnant women due around the same time as me is poss.

Thing is, I don’t want to breastfeed (please can we not make that the main focus of this post!) due to the shape of my uterus it’s also looking like I might have to have a c-section too.

So I’m not really sure what DH and I would really get out of NCT classes other than meeting parents to be at a similar stage?

I’m worried I’ll be judged massively for not breastfeeding, I’ve heard they can be a bit cult like in how they push breast feeding.

Has anyone been to NCT classes and knew they weren’t going to breast feed? Did you get an okay reception or no?

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 15/04/2022 17:00

Yeah until they have babies. Then they split into two groups - those who realise c sections and FF are fine actually. And those who it turned out ok for so they judge everyone who didn't have a natural birth and BF.

There was some poor woman (whose husband I couldn't stand) who was obsessed with natural birth. "We" weren't having painkillers because "we" didn't think they were good. She had all the interventions possible, bless her. I did too but I was OK with it.

It all comes out in the wash. Just don't tell anyone what you plan before. After, half the group is in the same boat anyway!

axolotlfloof · 15/04/2022 16:59

The only real purpose of NCT for us was meeting other parents.
I did try a homebirth and breastfed, but there were caesereans and bottle feeders too.
It was just a nice group of people at the same stage in life.
We stayed in touch through the baby years but largely lost touch, as different primary schools and we mostly moved out the city.

glowingcandle · 15/04/2022 16:55

I didn't do NCT but ended up on a baby massage course with 7 other women who had all done NCT together and got chatting to them over coffee.

Of the 7, 5 had c sections - some planned and some emergency. And of the 2 who had vaginal births, 1 was formula feeding. So out of a total of 7 women, only 1 had both a natural birth and breastfed!

I kind of wish I had done NCT actually, I think it would have been a good way to meet people. Maternity leave can be a lonely time and the more opportunities to meet people, the better.

BOOTS52 · 15/04/2022 16:55

When I lived in London and was pregnant 21 years ago I went to an NCT class and was not going to breastfeed and was going to have an epidural but the girls in the class were so lovely and my son still has the beany baby that one of the mums to be gave my son. A lovely class with lovely ladies and really enjoyed it.

Tulipsanddaffs06 · 15/04/2022 16:54

Argh, maybe I’ll give it a go then? I’m torn between wanting to ring up and voicing my concerns to the person running it so I can save myself time and money if they say ‘yeh it won’t be for you, sorry.’ Or whether to do like PP have suggested and basically lie and ‘pretend’ I intend on BFing. I don’t know if I’d be happy with that though as tbh, like people have said, I wouldn’t want to be friends with judgy people who base who they’re going to be ‘friendly’ with on how those people plan to feed their babies Confused

It’s just hard as most of my friends either don’t have children or have older children 4/5 years old so they’re back at work now. I’m just conscious that when I have the baby, I may be a bit isolated if I don’t make the effort to try and meet people having babies at a similar time to me and I honestly don’t know how you go about doing that really other than an NCT class?

@Porridgeislife, that sounds fab, if I could find something similar in my area I’d definitely be tempted by that rather than an NCT.

OP posts:
Kurtanforpm · 15/04/2022 16:53

20 years ago with my first, I was reduced to tears on the phone by someone from the NCT. I was enquiring about jointing her local group.

I didn’t want to breastfeed and I was having an elective section. She asked if I was doing it because I wanted to be like the spice girls (I was 22), and started telling me horror stories. She also told me that I didn’t have to lie about being married these days (I was married, she just didn’t believe me as I was young).

Horrible bloody woman.

June2008 · 15/04/2022 16:53

You could give it a try. There is nothing to say you have to keep in touch with these people.

I was lucky and 14 yrs later we still meet regularly, some times the mums, some times with the children and occasionally with spouses too. Pre covid we went camping together each year.

Its so helpful to have people to talk to who are at the same stage as you with their children. We currently talk about options and GCSEs!
I know these ladies well but have no recollection of who had what kind of birth and how the babies were fed!
And if people had strong opinions would you want to be friends with someone who was so judgey? On the other hand you might be lucky and find friends for life!

SmellyOldOwls · 15/04/2022 16:51

@Yerroblemom1923

Tbf you're probably right. From what I hear it's all hardcore breastfeeders and natural birthers. Those thay don't adhere to those rules are generally shunned.
Yeah until they have babies. Then they split into two groups - those who realise c sections and FF are fine actually. And those who it turned out ok for so they judge everyone who didn't have a natural birth and BF.

Have you joined your mumsnet ante natal club op? I've met loads of friends off mine.

GrowBabyGrow · 15/04/2022 16:50

If you want to meet other expecting parents in your area you could try things like pregnancy yoga, or even an alternative antenatal class like Bump and Baby which is a bit less 'natural birth is the only way' than some NCTs can be.

TulipsGarden · 15/04/2022 16:49

I went knowing I was having a planned c section and it was absolutely fine. I did plan to breastfeed but it didn't work out and that was fine too. I think a lot depends on the instructor you get - our breastfeeding one was far more dogmatic than the general NCT one - but it was all useful and interesting information. I think it's good for the dads to hear about it all too.

To be honest, the giving birth and breastfeeding part is such a small part of having a child. The value of NCT is that shared experience and knowing you have people on WhatsApp at 4am whose child is at the same stage as yours. It's people to go to classes with, or meet up with in cafés. You might get unlucky and not get on with them, but equally you might make a friend for life. Splinter groups usually form by the time you're back at work and you can avoid the ones you don't like.

saltedcaramelanything · 15/04/2022 16:46

I guess I depends on the NCT group leader - but we literally had one class specifically about breastfeeding, but otherwise it wasn't mentioned. You easily could have missed that class due to "work/family commitments" and no one would have noticed.

It is primarily though about prepping for / recognising / going through natural labour though. So if you plan on a c-section it might feel a little pointless. I think we only had one or two sessions that were more about newborns.

I ended up being induced/emergency c-section, so fairly pointless "class" I guess. But my DH and I became really close with another couple - are still very good friends - and our DC are best friends. So worth it to me.

Porridgeislife · 15/04/2022 16:42

I’ve elected not to do NCT because I’m almost certainly having a c-section and don’t need to be educated for 6 hours on how natural birth with no interventions is the best way to give birth. I’ve been seeing a women’s physio every fortnight who knows our various issues and she cocked one eyebrow and said “I’m not sure you’ll be able to keep a straight face in NCT”.

I’m still doing group antenatal classes but with an independent midwife in my area with a good reputation for a balanced approach.

Iamnotin · 15/04/2022 16:39

You are going to hear about the benefits of breastfeeding, but you'll get that from midwives, GP too.

You can just say you plan to breastfeed if you feel uncomfortable with saying you're going to bottle feed and don't want to discuss your reasons not to, then say it didn't work out for you afterwards.

SpaghettiSquash · 15/04/2022 16:38

There were five of us in my NCT class. Four of us had CS and four of us bottlefed. There was no judgement.

Don't let your birth or feeding choices put you off. Of course you might find that they're not your sort of people but you even if you only hit it off with one of them you're winning.

LeFeu · 15/04/2022 16:35

I did NCT twice (antenatal and then postnatal group with my second) and never really gelled with anyone, and I did breastfeed (but really don’t care how other people feed their babies!).

It’s just not for everyone anyway. It’s very inorganic and also very skewed towards people with a lot of money. I found a lot of the meet ups were in expensive cafes which I just couldn’t afford so I didn’t stay in touch with people for long.

If you want to, try it, but know that there are plenty of other ways to meet new parents in mum and baby groups, online meet ups, swimming, etc etc and don’t feel like you HAVE to do NCT if you don’t want to. I wish I hadn’t bothered!

mnnewbie111 · 15/04/2022 16:32

When I went to NCT I was quite vocal (probably defensive) about not wanting to breastfeed, but no one batted an eyelid. I really don't think people care, and if they do, they're not the ones you want to be friends with. As it happens I ended up breast feeding but that's irrelevant. Any choice you make is right for you, don't ruin the pregnancy for yourself by caring what others think ,if you want to go then go, what do you have to lose?

SamMil · 15/04/2022 16:32

We had 3 c-sections in my group and a mix of breastfed and bottle fed. I couldn't tell you who fed each way because noone was bothered either way.

We are still friends 5 years later so it worked out for me. It was nice to have the support in the newborn phase.

Nowisthemonthofmaying · 15/04/2022 16:30

@Babyccino11

I think it may depend on the person running your particular course, like you I’d heard stories of it potentially being judgemental and very geared towards ‘natural’ birth. My experience was the opposite, all modes of delivery covered, even did a mock up of what theatre would look like and who would be present during c section. There was a breastfeeding session but was informative rather than pressurised and I think bottle feeding was covered to some extent too. Maybe email nct with your concerns? It was a good way to meet other new parents.
This was my experience too
MsSquiz · 15/04/2022 16:29

We didn't do NCT, but did a similar private antenatal group. Out of the 9 of us in the group 2 knew they wouldn't breastfeed, some only breastfed and some combi fed. I think 1 had a c section, 1 had a water birth and the rest were a mix of vaginal with no intervention & vaginal with intervention.

Our kids are now just over 2 and we have a WhatsApp group where you can literally ask anything and someone will know the answer or have something helpful to say. We also have catch ups with and without the kids.

You might find that you go to a group and you don't click with anyone but you might also find that someone couldn't breast feed and you could offer advice on formula? I wouldn't necessarily rule it out

AliceW89 · 15/04/2022 16:29

Nobody cared in my NCT group - certainly not about birth. I couldn’t remotely tell you 2 years on who had a vaginal birth and who had an abdominal birth. There was a bit of interest in other people’s feeding journeys but nobody cared or judged either way. By a country mile, sleep (or lack of!) dominated the early days conversation.

SheWoreYellow · 15/04/2022 16:28

I just went to the classes to meet friends. The class content was pretty pro breastfeeding / minimal intervention birth etc but the people weren’t necessarily. We had a mix of bf and forumula feeders.

Babyccino11 · 15/04/2022 16:28

I think it may depend on the person running your particular course, like you I’d heard stories of it potentially being judgemental and very geared towards ‘natural’ birth. My experience was the opposite, all modes of delivery covered, even did a mock up of what theatre would look like and who would be present during c section. There was a breastfeeding session but was informative rather than pressurised and I think bottle feeding was covered to some extent too.
Maybe email nct with your concerns?
It was a good way to meet other new parents.

TheKeatingFive · 15/04/2022 16:28

My best friend from NCT had no intention of BFing. She contemplated skipping that class, but in the end went and let it wash over her. Only half of my group breast fed. No one cares ultimately.

BiscuitLover3678 · 15/04/2022 16:27

I’d definitely give it a go! I found it an absolute godsend. You don’t have to love them. The early days are so lonely and when it’s too soon for groups it’s lovely to be part of a WhatsApp chat.

It depends on your group. Mine were resllt nice.

yorkshireteaspoonie · 15/04/2022 16:26

I've just finished a NCT course and I wouldn't have bothered if I'd known what I know now. And that's nothing to do with the fact I'm having a c-section and not breastfeeding! There's a lot of 'how does everybody feel' type chat which I found tedious - I was looking for more guidance and instruction than counselling!

I knew most of the information already just from reading the bloody Internet /following the likes of 'midwife Marley' type accounts and reading the hypnobirthing books.

I was genuinely surprised at how little others knew.

I went primarily to make friends as most of mine already have kids but it was clear from the off, that the group were not my people and I wouldn't be taking any of them along as long term friends, which was disappointing as lots of my friends who have had babies in years gone by still have their NCT friends. 🤷🏽‍♀️