Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I just wouldn’t fit in at NCT classes?

158 replies

Tulipsanddaffs06 · 15/04/2022 16:11

First time mum, 24 weeks pregnant. I feel a little lonely tbh as none of my friends are pregnant and I’d like to meet some other pregnant women due around the same time as me is poss.

Thing is, I don’t want to breastfeed (please can we not make that the main focus of this post!) due to the shape of my uterus it’s also looking like I might have to have a c-section too.

So I’m not really sure what DH and I would really get out of NCT classes other than meeting parents to be at a similar stage?

I’m worried I’ll be judged massively for not breastfeeding, I’ve heard they can be a bit cult like in how they push breast feeding.

Has anyone been to NCT classes and knew they weren’t going to breast feed? Did you get an okay reception or no?

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 15/04/2022 17:36

I attended a prenatal NCT classes. Most mums did not ebf. One definitely bottle fed from the start and another gave up very quickly as her baby had a tongue tie. I hadn’t decided whether or not to breastfeed beforehand but attending the classes encouraged me to give it a go. But it wasn’t pushy.

I chose to go pay for the additional breastfeeding class, which was held separately and a couple of women did not. This class was for women only rather than couples and it was also a nice way of not putting pressure on the women, who chose / needed to bottle feed.

As for c-section, I can’t even remember what sort of birth some of them had.

Underfrighter · 15/04/2022 17:32

There will be some relevant bits. It's a fair few years ago for me now but from what I remember there was some -

What happens in labour and how partners can support you
What is likely to happen to your relationship and how to pre empt issues
Things like 'what makes a good parent', discussions
Feeding (mostly breastfeeding and the advice was actually shit)
A bit of baby care

Most of it is effectively paying for friends though however they are a certain demographic, in my area 30 was the youngest.

Pretty much everyone plans to breastfeed but I'd say people who carry on after a month or two are in a small minority

PeggySueOooOo · 15/04/2022 17:30

For me, NCT was about "buying" friends who were at the same stage in life as me. The classes themselves are not great. And they do push breastfeeding. But I didn't join them to learn, I joined to meet people.

From my group of 8; 2 never wanted to breastfeed, 2 tried and couldn't, 1 breastfed for 6 weeks but only in private, 2 breastfed for 3 months and 1 breastfed for 2 years. It was a really varied bunch.

Our children are now 7 years old and I am still friends with most of the group and see them fairly regularly. We are all different people who parent differently but it doesn't matter.

Give it a go, and take the lessons with a pinch of salt and use the coffee breaks to get to know new people.

Moody123 · 15/04/2022 17:28

We did NCT and we didn't take any information from it, but the mum friendship were invaluable
It was always re assuring that at 2am I knew someone else was awake to text or talk to
I think 50% of us breast fed and the rest bottle fed, I don't think feeding was a huge issue that we focused on to be honest... more about how our bits felt like they would fall out 😂

Yespmed · 15/04/2022 17:27

I was worried about the same things with regards to breast feeding..But couldn’t have got put with a nicer group (6 couples) and 5 years on still have a group that just us girls chat in. No one is judgy, we all had different births and some breastfed some didn’t… well aware though that it’s not always like that but the best part about nct that I found is the shared togetherness of going through something at the same time as eachother. It’s the texts in the middle of the night when you’re exhausted and the baby isn’t sleeping or messaging because you are worried about something and feeling relieved because it’s not just you or that someone has the answer to a question. It doesn’t have to be just nct thar you can find those kinds of friendships though..,there’s so many many different online apps like mush for example where you can find local parents to be and start chatting or the mum and baby groups so if you’re worried about nct that might be a different route to go down!

FluffMagnet · 15/04/2022 17:25

I did NCT with my first - planned CS due to tokophobia and absolute horror at the mere thought of breastfeeding (probably linked to said tokophobia and pre-natal depression). I emailed the area lead beforehand and the course leader alao checked in with me and was very respectful of my choice and feelings.
The other couples were all wonderful and completely normal. There were no judgements from them and to be honest, they too were in the NCT group mainly for maternity leave friends more than anything. We had another woman come to do the breastfeeding session. I had been assured she would cover bottle feeding but no, and she did not hide her desire to have nothing to do with me. However the other couples supported us and I did retain some knowledge from that old bat when I decided completely unexpectedly to breastfeed my second (DH taking too long to locate our formula on the postnatal ward!).

NCT is pure luck i think, depending very much on the local leaders and the other couples attending. If you can afford to give it a go, do, and tell the class leader your specific issues so they cover CSs income depth.

buntywindermere · 15/04/2022 17:25

Our NCT class (midlands), 8 women - 4 c sections, 3 breast feeders (3 didn't want to and the other 2 tried but stopped). It was 2017 but I don't remember much BFing propaganda, and the women in the group were all sane and kind enough not to judge!!! 7 of us are still friends and meet up regularly, what's app super active. We are all so different and range in ages from 28 - 40, different careers and situations but their friendship and support has been invaluable. (I'm the 28 year old who, 5 years ago, had no friends about to become mums!!)

Giraffesandbottoms · 15/04/2022 17:20

Of the 8 in our NCT, 3 of us breastfeed exclusively, 3 combi fed and 2 formula fed. 3 (maybe even 4) had c sections. I didn’t fit in but for the opposite reason - everyone used a dummy but me and everyone went to the pub frequently to drink, which I wasn’t interested in. So I don’t buy into the NCT reputation as much. Just depends who you get really!

TheSnowyOwl · 15/04/2022 17:20

I did an NCT course and openly said I wouldn’t breastfeed and would be having a c section. We had two women running the course and one just did two breastfeeding sessions. She was very dismissive of me about not breastfeeding (and she didn’t ask what my reasoning behind it was to know; not that any specific reason is needed). However, because I said I was having a c section the other course leader went to great lengths to dedicate an entire session to the theatre experience and so everyone would know what to expect.

I also made four of my best friends who were on the course and we still meet up and chat all the time all these years later.

In my experience the course content isn’t worth it but if you get the right people on your course (and that’s a gamble) then they more than make it worthwhile.

Maray1967 · 15/04/2022 17:19

I wouldn’t go near one as my friends went and told me theirs was very keen on low/none intervention etc and I’d had a lot of medical help to get pregnant so couldn’t have stood it. That was 20plus years ago although my SIL went to one 13 years ago and it was the same. I just did the nhs classes which were pretty good. Experienced midwife ignored the official line and insisted on showing us how to safely make up bottles. Who in their right mind thinks you shouldn’t include that in an antenatal programme.

DesidaCrick · 15/04/2022 17:19

Is there an NHS group you can join or have they stopped now? I’m still v friendly with a Mum I met at the NHS group.

The mums I bonded well with at the NCT group both moved overseas, so I don’t meet them any more. Whether NCT is for you probably depends on your tutor. I didn’t want to breast feed and was open minded about the birth as long as we both came out of it relatively intact. Our tutor was lovely, and there was lots of info about all kinds of births. And I ended up breastfeeding for over two years despite my misgivings. So maybe have a chat with them to see if you like their approach, but I’d try to stay open minded about it all.

macaronip1e · 15/04/2022 17:17

I do know why you’d have to lie to say you were planning to bf?

Our class had couples with a mix of plans and whose labours/feeding turned out in various ways. It really didn’t make any difference. We did have one class specifically on breastfeeding and some couples skipped that.
Like many others, I made great friends in our class so was worth it for that alone.

Crimesean · 15/04/2022 17:15

There was plenty of variety at my NCT class - out of 9 couples, 5 ended up breastfeeding, 4 had c-sections.

We met our best friends at NCT, they're like family to us now. We don't see anyone else from the group, just one couple, but I'm so glad we met.

I'd go - there's plenty of info you can use even if you'll be having a c-section, and having people in the same boat as first time parents is really helpful.

wishingchair1 · 15/04/2022 17:15

I liked it probably for different reasons. My workplace allowed time off for the classes. The person running it was fine but not the best. We had a nurse in the group, who kept correcting her. There were no pressures on anything. I'm still in touch with all but one of the group and its lovely to meet up, have photos etc still at 12yrs old. When I had my second, we didn't go but we had a nice established group that we would celebrate siblings as they came along.

Congrats

PumpkinHenri · 15/04/2022 17:14

I had a really positive NCT experience, no pushy breastfeeding advice or judgement. Our group is still close 2 years on and we have made very close friends with one couple in particular.

Half our group had c sections and for a few breastfeeding didn’t work out (myself included!). Even if they aren’t people you would normally be friends with, as long as they are a nice bunch it’s great to have a group going through the same stages of you!

Qwill · 15/04/2022 17:13

Nobody asks you how you plan to give birth or feed. There is information about all options which was interesting but I can’t say I learned anything I hadn’t already read about. I really appreciated the support from the group after, we set up a WhatsApp. Whilst we probably wouldn’t be friends without babies, it was great to get a message knowing others where going through the same things as you and we all gave each other advice etc. we had some meet ups too and was great to see the babies interacting (my friends didn’t have babies either so couldn’t do it with them). I really think it depends on the group you get, but don’t let feeding or birth type put you off.

Twizbe · 15/04/2022 17:13

@Yerroblemom1923

Tbf you're probably right. From what I hear it's all hardcore breastfeeders and natural birthers. Those thay don't adhere to those rules are generally shunned.
From what you hear but not your own actual experience ...
LividLaVidaLoca · 15/04/2022 17:12

YABU.

I had a section and so did a few of the others. I actually found the session on what to expect (we were led by a practising midwife) in a section really helpful. She set up Lego dolls or something as all the medical staff and went through their roles.

One of our three days was focused on bf, and one woman who knew she wasn’t going to bf just didn’t go to that session.

NCT for me wasn’t about the course at all. A couple of weeks later (baby just turned two) we went into lockdown as I was in hospital giving birth.

I cannot explain enough how very very important having a group of women I’d met irl and bonded with was on those early days, when we couldn’t have friends, family or medical professionals. WhatsApp basically saved our lives multiple times, and we still message on group chat every day and meet up in smaller groups now we can.

Do it for the mum friends for sure. They’re only human.

CowboyFromHell · 15/04/2022 17:10

And you won’t be the only one daydreaming and nodding through whatever aspects don’t appeal to you. I remember nodding and smiling vaguely at the instructor as she banged on about breathing your way through labour. No thanks, I want - and had - a very nice epidural.

Wnkingawalrus · 15/04/2022 17:10

I went primarily to make friends as most of mine already have kids but it was clear from the off, that the group were not my people and I wouldn't be taking any of them along as long term friends, which was disappointing as lots of my friends who have had babies in years gone by still have their NCT friends

I find this a bit sad. All of us in my nct group were very different, probably wouldn’t have chosen to be friends, but had a lovely year hanging out together. Sometimes it’s interesting to get to know different types of people.

CowboyFromHell · 15/04/2022 17:07

I did antenatal and postnatal classes, and found the postnatal ones much more useful. Obviously we’d all had our babies by then and so the type of birth was a non-issue, and there was a mix of breast and bottle feeding. But we had useful discussions on how we were finding the first few weeks generally, also practical discussions on sleep, routines, nappies etc.

I found the antenatal classes a bit frustrating. My attitude to birth was that it’s a means to an end and the main aim should be to end up with a healthy mother and baby, and so the early days and weeks should be the main focus of nct classes. The focus on only three birth felt a bit like if you were planning to emigrate to Australia and all someone would tell you is about the plane journey to get there rather than Iife in Australia - somewhat missing the point!

But my main purpose was to meet a few other parents who lived locally, and I succeeded in this. Of course you’re not going to be friends with everyone but in each of my two nct groups there were a couple of women I’m still in touch with nearly a decade later. And I couldn’t even remember now who in the group breastfed, had a Caesarean etc - perspective is a wonderful thing.

RedHelenB · 15/04/2022 17:06

@JengaTower

I planned to breastfeed but it didn't work out so just say that and add that baby is tongue tied - it's a thing
Why lie? If OP has made the decision that's that
felulageller · 15/04/2022 17:06

Well you could lie and say you are planning on BF but then after birth say you had problems so switched. Most do anyway.

Twizbe · 15/04/2022 17:06

In our NCT class we had 2 women who knew they'd be having c sections by the time the course started (one twin pregnancy with previous uterine surgery and one GD)

We also had one woman who wouldn't be breastfeeding (I'm not sure if it was a can't or didn't want to)

Our course was still very inclusive of them. We talked loads about c sections alongside natural birth and pain relief. It was helpful for the c section ladies to know how labour might start and things they could do if it started before their surgery date.

Breastfeeding was covered in an optional additional session which the woman I mentioned missed.

Yes after birth there was lots of talk about healing and breastfeeding but I never once felt any judgement for not breastfeeding. I ended up combi feeding my first and another of our group full formula fed.

I think if they know in advance about the c section they can make sure to tailor the course to your needs.

Dickopf · 15/04/2022 17:05

OP, I was very wary of the NCT for a whole heap of reasons, so did it very reluctantly. As a result, I made some of the best friends I've ever made. I was a SAHM for a long time, and having friends to do 'small child' things with was an absolute godsend - we spent a lot of time in one another's houses and with one another's children - in the park, going for walks, etc, etc, etc. I did a lot just with my own DC, but they were quite often more civilised when there were lots of other children around, and I got to have fragments of adult conversation. We've largely moved away in the intervening 20+ years, but we are all still very close. Nobody noticed or cared how someone else was feeding their baby or how they gave birth - all any normal mother is interested in is giving birth to a healthy baby and then trying to do a decent job of being a parent. It was honestly one of the best things I did when my children were babies.