Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I just wouldn’t fit in at NCT classes?

158 replies

Tulipsanddaffs06 · 15/04/2022 16:11

First time mum, 24 weeks pregnant. I feel a little lonely tbh as none of my friends are pregnant and I’d like to meet some other pregnant women due around the same time as me is poss.

Thing is, I don’t want to breastfeed (please can we not make that the main focus of this post!) due to the shape of my uterus it’s also looking like I might have to have a c-section too.

So I’m not really sure what DH and I would really get out of NCT classes other than meeting parents to be at a similar stage?

I’m worried I’ll be judged massively for not breastfeeding, I’ve heard they can be a bit cult like in how they push breast feeding.

Has anyone been to NCT classes and knew they weren’t going to breast feed? Did you get an okay reception or no?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ladycarlotta · 16/04/2022 22:46

My NCT leader was very old-school NCT in terms of being focussed on 'natural' birth rather than c-section, and encouraging breastfeeding, but I also found the sessions more useful as a means of getting to be pregnant/a new parent alongside others. As it happened, of the 8 of us, 3 had c-sections, and I would say that the feeding decisions each family made were on a sliding scale between bottle feeding from birth to combination feeding, to extended EBF.

Now our kids are 3 I'd say that the stuff about how we delivered our babies/how we initially fed them has faded into insignificance, but tbh that happened almost immediately. It was so much more about having someone to go for a walk with, or text at 2am. Our children were one another's first buddies and it's lovely to have that relationship. I know it's not this way for everyone but it's worked really well for us.

RidingMyBike · 16/04/2022 15:37

It really depends whether you're happy to go to a baby/toddler group on your own with baby initially or would want to arrive with people you already know. I'm not bothered about turning up on my own and, as an introvert, didn't really want to be hanging around as a group anyway, but it helped others feel more confident.

The better baby and toddler groups will make an effort to introduce you to someone when you arrive, if you want that. Surely not everyone in your area will have done NCT as it is a LOT of money.

It really depends on your personality, what there is to do in your area etc. I've also never needed or wanted to WhatsApp anyone at 2am so quite glad I missed out on that aspect of it!

Twizbe · 16/04/2022 13:11

I think it's worth doing an ante natal class for those reasons.

I made friends at baby groups with my second BUT I knew the group as I'd gone with my first and knew that I could get out of the house with a newborn.

When it's your first, going out to a group can feel really daunting at first. If you've already made a friend it's easier to go together for sure.

Unavailableusername · 16/04/2022 11:17

From what you've said, if you have the cash and the time available, I'd do the group in your position. If you find that you click with other people better along the way, that's obviously fine and if you don't you might be glad you tried NCT. Be mindful not to Iimit yourself to meeting up with your group at the expense of exploring new opportunities. Some of my group met several times a week and are now not nearly so close. I realised early on this was too much for me and have up kept the other friends more these days anyway.

I hope you find company that you enjoy whatever you do.

Tulipsanddaffs06 · 16/04/2022 10:57

I think the reason why I’m quite keen to perhaps try so e sort of antenatal group is that people say ‘oh you’ll make friends at baby and toddler groups.’ And I always assumed that people do to be fair.

But I’ve read a lot of threads on here that people have gone to baby and toddler groups and lots of the women at them are already friends or know one another from NCT classes etc and often have formed their friendships already and it can be quite isolating and lonely Blush I guess I’m worried that if I don’t attend an NCT clsss or something, that I’m going to get to baby or toddler groups and I’ll have the same experience Blush

It doesn’t help that I live in a relatively ‘small’ cliquey place anyway where a lot of people have grown up in the same villages, went to the same schools etc. Even though our local city is a 30 min drive away, I think I’d be more inclined to drive to some groups there as I think it’ll be less likely that people all already know one another.

OP posts:
Mackmama · 16/04/2022 10:15

I didn’t know about NCT, but I don’t think I’d have bothered if I had, what do they teach you about birthing and feeding that your midwife can’t? I don’t think it would have been for me. I hung out with my husband, my mum, my brother and my friends I had before I had my baby when I was on what was a comparatively short maternity leave. I made a few friends through toddler group, neighbours who have similar aged children and now a few school parents I don’t feel there is it ever was a gaping hole in my life because I didn’t do NCT.

Unavailableusername · 16/04/2022 10:08

Mine was a mix. 1/3 of the group didn't breastfeed and 1/3 had a c section. Some people felt the course was unbalanced and did promote the whole 'natural' route but oxytocin proved not to be enough for the vast majority of us to have births without intervention of some sort. All birth plans went out the window to some extent.

I feel like I picked up my friends along the way at toddler groups etc but if you're not especially outgoing NCT does force you to form a group. Most people I know found the group fizzles out a bit once the maternity leave is over. With hindsight, I'd still do mine but my expectations would be different.

tirednewmumm · 16/04/2022 09:59

Only two of our group (8 families) breastfeed. The course was very much about c section too and 2 women knew in advance that's what they were having. We're a great bunch of friends now and they've really made my mat leave great from the meet ups to the WhatsApp support at 3 am.

PoshWatchShitShoes · 16/04/2022 08:00

I made some wonderful friends through NCT and we're still close years later.

I didn't think twice about what choices anyone else made. It doesn't make any difference to my baby what you decide to do about birth or feeding.

Funniest moment in our group was when one lady thought her waters had broken during our first class... nope, she'd just peed herself. She's totally batty and now one of my good friends 😂

Herejustforthisone · 16/04/2022 07:43

We did all bond over an insane leader though. None of us learnt anything but we were mainly there to make friends. It was Covid so all online. We had to work on our friendships after and we did.

Herejustforthisone · 16/04/2022 07:42

I did NCT to make friends. I had an elective section and didn’t breastfeed. They’re some of my closest friends now.

worriedaboutmoney2022 · 16/04/2022 07:22

@Tulipsanddaffs06

I did an NCT course with my first and it was (7 years ago) about £180!for 6 sessions in a church room no refreshments, cold and uncomfortable

The woman was crazy they're volunteers not trained midwives with bizarre ideas and very outdated materials and props. She had some dolls for us to dress they were filthy as were the Dolly baby clothes.

The people were awful and entitled we did the course then we had a "reunion" this "volunteer"
Booked a venue and we had to pay for our own food and drink we had a drink then made our excuses

Never again nor would I recommend it

As a side note they did push breastfeeding but so do the hospital but it's entirely personal choice it's not for everyone.

I'd look at local antenatal classes in your area - not Nct ones but ones run by a midwife not some "volunteer" or ask at your children's centre.

Lookatmelookatme · 16/04/2022 07:18

@Lookatmelookatme

I found my NCT classes to be wonderful. I already knew a lot of thr practical stuff (big family) but the facilitator was non-judgemental, balanced and so kind. 7/8 of us BF but in no way was the formula feeding mum shunned. In fact she has gone on to be a very good friend. If you are shunned for formula feeding it will be the people on the course, not the course itself. There is focus on BF but this is because BF support is so lacking in the UK unless you have the money pay for support, and a lot of women stop before they want to.

The thing that I remember most vividly was the discussion and activity around caesarean - I thought it was fascinating and it served me well when, 3 years later, I had one after a straightforward vaginal birth with my first. It was helpful to know what to expect and I remembered a lot of it. In fact, a lot of my group had planned and unplanned CS, but none of them felt like a failure or traumatised by them.

Both of my births were positive and I made the decisions that were right for me at that time with the information I had.

I should add, FF is covered so I'd tell the facilitator that you are FF and ask lots of questions.
Lookatmelookatme · 16/04/2022 07:13

I found my NCT classes to be wonderful. I already knew a lot of thr practical stuff (big family) but the facilitator was non-judgemental, balanced and so kind. 7/8 of us BF but in no way was the formula feeding mum shunned. In fact she has gone on to be a very good friend. If you are shunned for formula feeding it will be the people on the course, not the course itself. There is focus on BF but this is because BF support is so lacking in the UK unless you have the money pay for support, and a lot of women stop before they want to.

The thing that I remember most vividly was the discussion and activity around caesarean - I thought it was fascinating and it served me well when, 3 years later, I had one after a straightforward vaginal birth with my first. It was helpful to know what to expect and I remembered a lot of it. In fact, a lot of my group had planned and unplanned CS, but none of them felt like a failure or traumatised by them.

Both of my births were positive and I made the decisions that were right for me at that time with the information I had.

Scottishskifun · 16/04/2022 03:00

I had a anti c section teacher in ours but that was a few years ago and I think NCT has changed quite a bit!

I found the group useful for massage techniques although our group never really clicked the WhatsApp group was a life saver at 2am. By the time they were all 1 year though it had died a death.
Would say just don't go to the bf session of not interested.

I did quite a bit of NCT stuff post birth as they have free walk and talk groups, early baby group support and baby play groups which are very cheap. You don't have to be a member for them either and they are fab.

frenchfancy81 · 16/04/2022 02:21

7 in ours. 3 c-sections and 4 who never breast fed.

Spudina · 16/04/2022 01:54

NCT are not the only anti natal group. There’s anti natal in every area connected to the GP surgery or hospital. I actually didn’t do a single anti natal class cos I found being pregnant to be really embarrassing and didn’t want to discuss my private medical stuff in a room full of strangers. I met friends afterwards in baby groups and didn’t regret my decision once.

LemonDrizzles · 16/04/2022 01:40

If you can afford out, do it.

It's great having a group of people all going through the same thing.

All the best

PaddlingLikeADuck · 16/04/2022 01:27

Two years ago I started my foundation degree to become an NCT teacher (antenatal and yoga) and I found the lectures we had surrounding birth quite frightening.

Yes they covered interventions but it was in a very negative manner. The general message was if you put some candles out, use massage oils and play soft music whilst fighting back against medical advice then you’ll have a wonderful and natural labour.

Interventions during labour probably save so many babies lives and I found it very uneasy that the NCT was demonising it and basically telling the women not to trust the midwives and doctors.

I also had to observe reunions (meetings that are held after the babies are born) and any mother who’d had a section or wasn’t breastfeeding looked so sad because they probably felt they were being judged.

It felt like a competition of which woman had had the ‘best’ birth and which women were the better mothers because they were breastfeeding.

Morally it wasn’t something I wanted to be involved in and after my first year of study I decided not to go back.

Some people love the NCT but the opinion I got was that they’re living in fairy tale land.

dontblamemee · 16/04/2022 00:23

I didn't do NCT when I had my first because I was 23 and didn't want to pay to be rejected.

Then I didn't do it with my 2nd or 3rd because you don't need to do you. I kinda feel like I missed out though. Lots of my friends did nct and are still really good friends 20years on

siliconetoilrtbrush · 15/04/2022 23:56

I had an elective c section for no medical reason, but just because I wanted to. I also didn't really breastfeed and actually ended up missing the breastfeeding class as I was unwell.

I still went along and was honest about it and no one said a word at all. Not the teacher, no one.

I would still go if I was you. It's an amazing way to meet people in your situation and I never felt judged at all.

Housetreecar · 15/04/2022 23:27

Our NCT babies will be 20 this year. We still meet up at least once a month for dinner and drinks. Some of us BF some didn’t, some had sections some didn’t. Ultimately the best part of it was our wonderful friendship

JW13 · 15/04/2022 23:06

@Tulipsanddaffs06 I did NCT and knew I was having a c section and not breastfeeding and it was totally fine. In fact half of the group (3/6) knew they were having c sections - the other 2 for medical reasons but mine was tokophobia/choice. The group leader was good at talking through c section procedure and what to expect.

She was a bit surprised I didn't want to try breast feeding but I was adamant and she accepted it. It sounds like you've got another good option, but I would say NCT was useful even in those circumstances (and it's more about meeting mum friends to hang out with when you're on mat leave).

RidingMyBike · 15/04/2022 22:55

I didn't bother as they're expensive and I didn't want a load of natural birth stuff shoved down my throat. I have some friends who really hit it off with their NCT group and others who rapidly lost touch, so it seems rather hit or miss whether it works out for you. After all, the only thing you have in common is having a due date on the same month!

I didn't know anyone else who was pregnant at the time but that didn't really bother me. After the birth I went to some local toddler groups (baby slept - this was totally for my benefit!) and made friends that way, which worked a lot better as their babies/toddlers were a range of ages and we could find areas of mutual interest.

I did go to an NCT breastfeeding group after myriad problems at the beginning but they weren't very helpful, were very anti-formula (I was combi-feeding) and I was bullied there.

Mummy2C · 15/04/2022 22:20

I did the course online due to covid. I'm the only one to exclusively breastfeed. I'm still in touch with 2 of my group. I did it to meet people and to support my husband as he wanted to know more about what to do with babies 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread