Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Going to somebodies house when you know you probably have covid and saying nothing is an act of malice

118 replies

JayneDough · 15/04/2022 15:14

This was before the 'learn to live with covid' and it was very much still a big deal and something people were very worried about. I've struggled to get past it and it has affected our relationship.

A family member knew she likely had covid because she'd been around multiple positive cases and was supposed to be isolating. She kept that to herself and came here without testing and didnt say anything. I had a brand new baby at the time, weeks old, and she ommited to tell me she'd been exposed until we tested positive after getting it from her.

Personally I consider what she did malicious, do you think I'm unreasonable?

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 15/04/2022 17:20

People get to make their own risk assessment for them. They don't get to make mine for me and certainly not for my child. If she didn't think she had it, great. For her. But she chose not to isolate as required and chose not to say anything. I wouldn't forgive her.

I'm more cautious than most. I work in housing and when everyone wasn't vaccinated I was so worried I'd pass it to my vulnerable tenants. So my friends and family were really respectful, always considering how I felt. Absolutely fine to be blasé about your own stuff, but you need to consider others. She didn't.

42isthemeaning · 15/04/2022 17:13

My ds ended up in the nicu at ten days old because he caught a virus from my dd who was 3 at the time. That couldn't be helped - she'd caught it at nursery and it seemed like a bad cold.
I could not forgive that person who came to visit you in those circumstances. They should have stayed well away.

JayneDough · 15/04/2022 17:12

And tbh unless my DH had a decent answer to “why are you ok that someone deliberately hid that they were ill and risked infecting our newborn?” it would take a lot of work to fix his non-botheredness

Oh I have, several times.

He comes back with "she didn't know she had it"

OP posts:
Mrsherdwick · 15/04/2022 17:10

She’s a very selfish and deceitful person. Yanbu.

reallyagain · 15/04/2022 17:09

I don't think people should visit anybody when they know they probably have a virus of any sort

Underfrighter · 15/04/2022 17:07

I couldn't forgive them putting a newborn at risk like that. In my friendship group its normal to say if you've got a worse than normal cold and ask people if they're still ok with it. The answer is almost always yes but it's only fair to give others the option

JustLyra · 15/04/2022 17:05

@JayneDough

I have never received an apology no, just the blasé defence I outlined above - fed back to me via DH - about how she 'didn't know she had it' which she would have if she bothered to test and isolate as required by law at the time.

She got pissed off, that I was pissed off.

Let your DH be the main source of contact - he can make all the effort with presents, contact, outline plans (insist on manners and being consulted - none of this “we’re doing this on Sunday” or “my mum is coming for a week” nonsense that so many on here end up dealing with).

Pulling a stunt like that would see any effort from me ended.

And tbh unless my DH had a decent answer to “why are you ok that someone deliberately hid that they were ill and risked infecting our newborn?” it would take a lot of work to fix his non-botheredness

Goldfishbowls · 15/04/2022 16:54

No that wasn’t ok; it was selfish to visit you and your baby. This relative knew beforehand she could’ve been infected and needed to isolate/test. I wouldn’t trust her as far as I could chuck her.

BuffyBeat · 15/04/2022 16:54

Not quite sure who this person is to you, you say relative of husband, so is it Mil or Sil?
It seems to me that you’re not too fond of them anyway, you say they might have tried to infect your infant on purpose because they are the petty type.
You don’t have to ask permission on here to keep this person at arms length, if you think she’s deliberately done this and you don’t really like her anyway, so should be an easy decision.

picklemewalnuts · 15/04/2022 16:50

Perhaps when it arises, point out to DH:
Her appalling judgement
Her selfishness
Her recklessness
Her deceit.

I mean, not in one go- that would be tuned out as a rant.

Just one point at a time, over a period of time.

Yes, but of course she's pretty reckless.
I know, but then she's always been self centred.
Ok, but her judgement is pretty iffy.
I'm not sure I believe her, she's been deceitful before.
Unfortunately, I just don't trust her anymore.
Yes, but she doesn't think of the consequences ...

Drip drip until he twigs.

Porcupineintherough · 15/04/2022 16:50

No I wouldnt forgive that. We'd be done. Totally and utterly done.

JayneDough · 15/04/2022 16:49

@Looneytune253

Hmmm I know we used to have to isolate when we had had close contact with a positive but for quite a while we've not had to and if she had no symptoms it probably wouldn't cross my mind to mention it. I've been close contact several times over the past few months and have still had contact with babies (work) and elderly relatives. Obv if I felt unwell I would have tested.
This happened when it was a requirement to isolate, by law.
OP posts:
Looneytune253 · 15/04/2022 16:47

Hmmm I know we used to have to isolate when we had had close contact with a positive but for quite a while we've not had to and if she had no symptoms it probably wouldn't cross my mind to mention it. I've been close contact several times over the past few months and have still had contact with babies (work) and elderly relatives. Obv if I felt unwell I would have tested.

JayneDough · 15/04/2022 16:43

@IncompleteSenten

Do you think she came round hoping to infect your infant?

If so then yes, I would call that malicious.

If not, then she's simply what's known as a stupid selfish fucking twat.

I honestly wouldn't put it past her, she doesn't like me and she's the petty type.
OP posts:
JayneDough · 15/04/2022 16:41

I have never received an apology no, just the blasé defence I outlined above - fed back to me via DH - about how she 'didn't know she had it' which she would have if she bothered to test and isolate as required by law at the time.

She got pissed off, that I was pissed off.

OP posts:
hellywelly3 · 15/04/2022 16:41

I think I’d struggle to move on from it and forgive when it was my child out at risk

RiojaRose · 15/04/2022 16:40

Ah, I just saw your update. I’m so sorry. That makes it even harder. More Flowers

Purplebunnie · 15/04/2022 16:40

I have and still would keep away from a new baby even if it was only the the common cold I had

IncompleteSenten · 15/04/2022 16:39

Do you think she came round hoping to infect your infant?

If so then yes, I would call that malicious.

If not, then she's simply what's known as a stupid selfish fucking twat.

JayneDough · 15/04/2022 16:39

She thinks she's got a get out clause in that she hadn't tested positive before she came, but that's only because she didn't test. So it's not really a defence is it?

She was alerted as a close contact of multiple confirmed cases (a group of people) and was told she had to isolate. She didn't test or isolate.

OP posts:
RiojaRose · 15/04/2022 16:38

Other people have a vested interest in me moving past it so they can maintain the status quo.

And this indicates that those people care more about their own emotional comfort than about the safety of you and your baby.

It’s a horrible situation, OP. But I think you’re right to stand up for yourself and your child. Ignoring stuff like this just leads to more of it. Flowers

ArtVandalay · 15/04/2022 16:38

It's unfortunate about the PND, but can you really blame your friend?

I think Covid has made many people irrational. We had a houseguest here that had just spent a week in a cottage with 2 friends that tested positive the morning she arrived here. She did tell us, as is polite, but we were still happy for her to come and stay with us,

If your friend is a good one, I would rather let her lapse of judgment go and keep a friendship. I am sure you have told her that it upset you. Calling her maicious is extreme and ott.

JustLyra · 15/04/2022 16:38

@JayneDough

She'd never be under my roof again EVER, and I'd probably be tearing a strip off every fuckwitted minimising family member too.

She's definitely not welcome here.

The predominant 'minimiser' is DH, so you can probably hazard a guess who she is to him..

I wanted him to tell her straight she was out of line, he never did.

So your MIL or SIL basically put their want for baby snuggles ahead of the welfare of the newborn?

That would be a very hard road to come back from.

Have they actually apologised? Properly?

Carrotten · 15/04/2022 16:36

You don't visit a newborn baby with a stomach bug, or the flu, with chicken pox or glandular fever so why with covid?

It's not acceptable and it's not okay.

Even now, I would take a lateral flow before visiting a newborn or vulnerable member of society. If I new I had covid I would not go. As with any infectious disease. Even a cold I would at least contact the parents before and let them know, just stay away for a day or two

JayneDough · 15/04/2022 16:35

She'd never be under my roof again EVER, and I'd probably be tearing a strip off every fuckwitted minimising family member too.

She's definitely not welcome here.

The predominant 'minimiser' is DH, so you can probably hazard a guess who she is to him..

I wanted him to tell her straight she was out of line, he never did.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread