Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

work trip not what it seemed :/

259 replies

biokult · 15/04/2022 11:04

Accepted a job of which international travel was involved, was very lucky in that I had a couple offers, which I turned down for my current position. Country is considered unsafe, however the insitute I would be based at is in a tourist-y area which is why I was comfortable agreeing.

Things have been very rushed due to lack of staff, and feel like my queries are not being answered.

My current dilemna is thus: a member of the team mentioned they would be based at a certain site, which was not the area I had expected to working in. I would then be expected to commute there via taxi, or "maybe collegues can drop you". I said no problem, assuming that if it was part of their company the area would also be fine.

Have since looked up the area and it is dodgy AF, yougov strongly recommend avoiding this and similar neighbourhoods. If you must go there you should have a local guide/security. Cabs will often refuse to pick you up from there due to high crime rate. I do not want to rely on collegues I do not for lifts in case they let me down and I am stuck.

I have agreed to the trip, although had this detail been made clear I would've said no. I feel like no precuations have been put in place, or discussed with me.

Please help me navigate this. My sister & her partner (who I live with) are being incredibly unhelpful, telling me to quit on the spot and no job is worth my life or being assualted etc etc. Obviously this is true, but I also want to maintain good working relationships and ideally not be unemployed!

Pretty pissed off tbh, anyone been in similar situations?

OP posts:
nancynoname · 16/04/2022 04:41

My sister & her partner (who I live with) are being incredibly unhelpful, telling me to quit on the spot and no job is worth my life or being assaulted etc etc. Obviously this is true, but I also want to maintain good working relationships and ideally not be unemployed!

They're actually being incredibly helpful and sensible. It's better to be (temporarily) unemployed than dead.

There's no way in hell I'd be accepting this assignment. No job or situation is worth your life.

Why would you want to maintain a "good" working relationship with people who clearly don't give two figs about your life or safety?

tcjotm · 16/04/2022 03:41

@Sweepingeyelashes and @CompassPoint you both have hardcore relatives who sound absolutely awesome when things get bad. Good for them, they must’ve been so scared with you both to protect. I feel ridiculously proud of people I don’t know.

tcjotm · 16/04/2022 03:32

@biokult your company are being shit. If your contacts are unwell then someone senior to them needs to step in. If that’s not possible then everything has to be out on hold. End of. They are sending you to a place that is very dangerous to you regardless of the situation for anyone else. This is not a day trip to Basingstoke!

Yes, loads of people live in these areas and go about their daily lives. One can also often travel quite low key to such places because they also appear like a local. A British woman working for a foreign company? That’s a whole different ballgame.

Now is the time for a lot of “I’m afraid I can’t proceed with any plans until X, Y and Z are addressed”. An employee needs to follow reasonable directions. It is NOT a reasonable direction to go to a high risk area without the proper assessments and protocols in place. It’s for their benefit too. Imagine if you were abducted/attacked/killed - that’d be major news and not good for their business. This isn’t you being too chicken to travel. This is professional best practice for work in dangerous regions.

Yes, sometimes the FO warnings are a little OTT. Heck, sometimes the danger is very low (the UK has had terror attacks which raises the warnings to people in other countries, but realistically most people are safe). However, Mexico, while I’m sure a country of wonderful people, is also seriously damaged by the cartels. Violence is common in a way we cannot comprehend. Locals can manage for the most part, they know who to be wary of (though that’s not a guarantee and might involve turning a blind eye to thinks they’d prefer to report. But report to who? It’s very challenging for the police to stay independent too).
You are a whole different level of vulnerability. Please don’t compare yourself to them. The local team will understand.

blueshoes · 15/04/2022 23:28

CompassPoint Sad

I don't know how my dd and I won the sexual exploitation lottery by happening to be born in a country that is not lawless.

OP, apologies for the hijack

CompassPoint · 15/04/2022 22:19

Sorry, not an easy subject to talk about, and one I avoid like the plague in real life. I think its important though as the more brutal reality is usually hidden from the international community. It would be bad for tourism.

CompassPoint · 15/04/2022 22:15

You're welcome blueshoes its an awful world to live in.

Trigger warning for rape and sexual violence:

White and pretty are preferred, but all women are targets. White in their minds equals rich, foreign white woman are usually kidnapped for ransom, but will almost definitely be raped while kidnapped.
Yes, good security should be fairly adept at stopping random attacks of sexual violence, but when foreign women are targeted it is usually more than "just" sexual violence. Women are seen as easy targets too. Culturally there is little respect for women, and violence against women is so common as to be almost normal.

Sexual violence is a preferred punishment of the enforcers when dealing with locals for a number of reasons, not just as it is still seen in many circles as a disgrace to the family to have a "ruined" daughter or wife. For some of the more major "betrayals" daughters will sometimes be taken away, most frequently for gang use, then put to work in gang owned brothels when they're bored of her.

Trafficking to order is also common, they will have people on the look out for girls who fit the specifications they've been given, those requests are usually filled from locals/migrant workers from rural areas who aren't playing by the rules, paying protection money etc. Sometimes kidnapped foreign women whose ransom hasn't been paid end up trafficked, or if the buyer is offering enough money to make it worth the hassle (ie has some unusual/rare specifications) then foreign women will be kidnapped for that reason.

Whilst it is horrible to say, any local with pretty daughters is an immediate target, the gangs will go after them first politely, ask to date them, but if they refuse they'll find a reason to go after them.

blueshoes · 15/04/2022 21:12

CompassPoint thanks for that insight. It is difficult to fathom living in that sort of world.

One thing I don't understand is the vulnerability of women (white or pretty, just going by your previous posts). I of course understand that lone women can be singled out as easy prey for sexual violence. Presumably those sorts of attack could be relatively easily prevented by security. However, it sounds like crime gangs would also target women - is it for sex trafficking?

OfstedOffred · 15/04/2022 19:52

Please don't go OP.

I work for an organisation which operates in all sorts of places and they should be all over the risk assessment here.

For areas like you are describing, they would simply never send a woman. Ever. The risk is too high.

Even the men who would be sent would have armed guards, trained named drivers etc.

There are plenty of areas where we simply will not send international staff & will only use local employees.

Do. Not. Go.

knowinglesseveryday · 15/04/2022 19:26

No job is worth your personal safety.

Allaboutthepizza · 15/04/2022 19:23

In the company I used to work for, who had offices across the globe, one of my European colleagues, a white male, went out to visit our Mexican office, which was in a non-touristy area, as part of his senior management role. There were actually two separate sites and he was visiting the second one with a local colleague early one evening when they were ambushed as they pulled up in the car, robbed and both shot. It is thought that he had been spotted when he visited the previous evening and they had waited for them to come back. The local colleague sadly died, but he managed to make it to a hospital to be stabilised and the insurance company then immediately airlifted him to the US for emergency surgery. He was very lucky to survive and was off work for many months recovering. The company immediately imposed a complete ban on all visits and secondments to Mexico and, although this was several years ago now, will still only employ Mexican nationals (or people who are already resident in Mexico before applying for a job) in those offices. I would seriously consider the safety implications before agreeing to this trip OP.

biokult · 15/04/2022 18:48

Thank you everyone! I am going through waves of feeling like I can refuse to go, to feeling utterly defeated and like I have no choice.

To add some replies:

Nope, the other jobs are long gone. I'm in a competitive field, they would've been snapped up by whoever was the second/third choice. I am hoping that there is a compromise between quitting this job and being forced to go to the suburbs of death as someone aptly put it Grin

No it's not an NGO. To the poster who said I was being daft to think the health & safety fell through the cracks - honestly I think it's the case. Due to complications that aren't anyone's fault, both my contacts are off unwell. I have been emailing the less sick one, but her replies are brief and I feel like I'm bothering her (although she does send me emails so I don't know - so difficult to judge when you're new). I haven't had a zoom/face to face meeting with anyone.

I messaged HR to ask them something else, and they firmly told me a assement needed to be done and to get in touch if I needed any questions. I do seem to be expected to do it myself though, with a team who aren't being particularly helpful with information.

That is a really good point about travel insurance being invalid and it means I can give a factual rather than emotional argument for it.

The area may be perfectly safe for a local colleague. Not the same for foreign woman.
This made me feel better, so thanks for saying it! Fundamentally, I feel guilty for it being fine for the local team to work in this unsafe environment, whilst refusing to do myself. But I really will stick out there, and as much as I would try to blend in, it's obvious I'm a (relatively) wealthy white young woman. AGH.

Yes, fluent in Spanish, it is my mother tongue :)

OP posts:
CompassPoint · 15/04/2022 18:16

The most expensive security groups tend to have the best safety records. Some of the less expensive security groups will pick a client (almost always a woman) to throw to the wolves every so often, to keep the local crime lords sweet and to play the game so to speak. Doesn't help if you're the one being thrown, but it means most clients will get through unharmed and they get to advertise a reasonable safety record for such a dangerous place.

It really is awful, my British DH was absolutely horrified the first time I explained it all to him, its another world with a different set of rules.

CompassPoint · 15/04/2022 18:10

"Extremely ruthless" means anything goes. Maiming, killing, bribing with money, drugs etc. whatever really, the police there won't give two hoots about any of that, human life doesn't have much meaning there, but if a security group gets a reputation for ruthless foreign mercenaries that makes them not the easiest target, and so they are more likely to be left alone.

CompassPoint · 15/04/2022 18:07

Yes, blueshoes it is a horrible place to live, the crime keeps everyone down. The police are usually friends or relatives, or on the payroll of the local gangs. There are some good police, but they and their families are under pressure too. There is no escape from it, the only way is to leave, and that's very difficult. I thank the stars every day that I don't live there anymore.

That's not to say people wouldn't try to help if they could, but only if a situation is starting to escalate, when it gets to a certain point your hands are tied or you are risking your family and friends.

Its a very fine line what is considered interfering - and often it just depends on the mood of whichever enforcer is sent out. Or whether you can bribe them to "overlook your transgression". Or whether the person who "interfered" has a pretty wife or daughters - if that's the case there's no getting out of it.

blueshoes · 15/04/2022 18:06

@CompassPoint

Most companies who take safety seriously employ foreign security/mercenary types (white South Africans were preferred when I lived there), to escort their staff. They are harder (though not impossible) to bribe or lean on and are instructed to be extremely ruthless.
What does 'extremely ruthless' entail?

Killing the other side? I guess legally it would be self-defence.

dipdye · 15/04/2022 18:04

Is the other job still open to you? Can you take the other one instead?!

dipdye · 15/04/2022 18:03

Don't go.

blueshoes · 15/04/2022 17:55

Yes. If they "interfered" or obstructed "business" at all then someone would come after them or their families to "teach them a lesson". It was one of the very first things I was taught by my parents, you do not interfere, and if you see anything you pretend not to notice, get out of there as fast as you can and deny all knowledge.

Its truly awful, but the extent of it is very much downplayed to the international community.

That is gut wrenching You only have to obstruct business for you or your family to be a target for retaliation. How it must eat at a person's soul to just standby or run or turn a blind eye to crime. I assume the police are useless.

I can see why organised crime is a cancer in a community that is so difficult to destroy.

CompassPoint · 15/04/2022 17:54

Most companies who take safety seriously employ foreign security/mercenary types (white South Africans were preferred when I lived there), to escort their staff. They are harder (though not impossible) to bribe or lean on and are instructed to be extremely ruthless.

CompassPoint · 15/04/2022 17:50

Do you mean that even if security personnel manage to thwart an attack by hurting or killing the baddies who go after the people they are protecting, those baddies will come after the personnel's family in revenge?

Yes. If they "interfered" or obstructed "business" at all then someone would come after them or their families to "teach them a lesson". It was one of the very first things I was taught by my parents, you do not interfere, and if you see anything you pretend not to notice, get out of there as fast as you can and deny all knowledge.

Its truly awful, but the extent of it is very much downplayed to the international community.

blueshoes · 15/04/2022 17:42

CompassPoint: Yes exactly, plus they will have to live there long after their job ends, and almost all, like my cousin, have family members whose safety they will naturally put ahead of any clients.

Do you mean that even if security personnel manage to thwart an attack by hurting or killing the baddies who go after the people they are protecting, those baddies will come after the personnel's family in revenge?

That is something that has not occurred to me before.

Underfrighter · 15/04/2022 17:38

Dont go OP

Lots of travel insurance is invalid if employees go to areas that the FCO or equivalent advises against travelling to (although it is possible to get it written into a policy) - if they haven't got an exemption then you would be on your own in any kind of health or financial or travel emergency.

Also by not doing a risk assessment and taking steps to ensure your safety eg providing a security escort if necessary, they are effectively breaking health and safety law (HASAW act) where they have a duty of care to ensure you are not injured at work.

CompassPoint · 15/04/2022 17:32

Professionalism aside, logically, why would security put their lives at risk for the people they protect. It is just a job. Better to be alive with no job than die on the job for someone else who means nothing to them other than the next pay cheque.

Yes exactly, plus they will have to live there long after their job ends, and almost all, like my cousin, have family members whose safety they will naturally put ahead of any clients.
I've been on the other side too, working all across Africa, and whilst its not nice to think about, it does help you to be more aware. A local guide isn't a get out of jail free card.

blueshoes · 15/04/2022 17:26

@CompassPoint

From the other side of it, my cousin and a couple of his friends worked as guides for a US company, protecting their staff visiting the local facility, they flat out refused to escort women. Whilst they were brilliant at avoiding trouble, if it came to it they would have little choice but to look the other way. Escorting rich white women would be like painting a target on your back.

Good guides will be expert at avoiding trouble, but if trouble finds you anyway, very few guides will put their lives, or their families on the line for a foreigner, no matter how well they're being paid. It is worth remembering the brutal truth of it that you are only safe with a local guide for as long as they manage to dodge trouble. There are some, of course, who would intervene and try to help, but you absolutely cannot count on it.

Interesting perspective. It makes sense.

Professionalism aside, logically, why would security put their lives at risk for the people they protect. It is just a job. Better to be alive with no job than die on the job for someone else who means nothing to them other than the next pay cheque.

Swipe left for the next trending thread