Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

work trip not what it seemed :/

259 replies

biokult · 15/04/2022 11:04

Accepted a job of which international travel was involved, was very lucky in that I had a couple offers, which I turned down for my current position. Country is considered unsafe, however the insitute I would be based at is in a tourist-y area which is why I was comfortable agreeing.

Things have been very rushed due to lack of staff, and feel like my queries are not being answered.

My current dilemna is thus: a member of the team mentioned they would be based at a certain site, which was not the area I had expected to working in. I would then be expected to commute there via taxi, or "maybe collegues can drop you". I said no problem, assuming that if it was part of their company the area would also be fine.

Have since looked up the area and it is dodgy AF, yougov strongly recommend avoiding this and similar neighbourhoods. If you must go there you should have a local guide/security. Cabs will often refuse to pick you up from there due to high crime rate. I do not want to rely on collegues I do not for lifts in case they let me down and I am stuck.

I have agreed to the trip, although had this detail been made clear I would've said no. I feel like no precuations have been put in place, or discussed with me.

Please help me navigate this. My sister & her partner (who I live with) are being incredibly unhelpful, telling me to quit on the spot and no job is worth my life or being assualted etc etc. Obviously this is true, but I also want to maintain good working relationships and ideally not be unemployed!

Pretty pissed off tbh, anyone been in similar situations?

OP posts:
biokult · 16/04/2022 19:10

@CompassPoint

OP could you suggest the compromise of the local staff travelling to the safer site? Is that possible within what you need to do? Do not worry about them being annoyed at you wanting to be treated differently, they will likely be very relieved as it makes it safer for them too.
Thanks yes this is what I'm going to suggest and take it from there.

The safer site is their normal place of work, I am hoping that they will accept the added risk of me travelling out of it isn't worth it. Ultimately I need to see what my manager thinks when I meet with her on Friday.

OP posts:
biokult · 16/04/2022 19:08

@carolipankas

You describe your sister and her partner as being 'incredibly unhelpful' and yet:
  1. They are kindly putting you up
  2. Their advice concurs with Foreign Office
  3. Not to mention most of the posters on this thread!
Find another job!
My sister and her partner are actually lodgers in my home, whilst some work is going on in theirs.

As I said to another poster, I think that they are being unhelpful as there's a whole load of options that can go between being forced into an unsafe work trip and quitting on the spot.

I could

  • go with a proper risk mititigation set up that I'm happy with - people do travel to places the FO advise against for work, but with huge amounts of planning in place
  • go with the proviso I won't go the dodgy site and will stay where I expected to be
-refuse to go at all, manage entirely from the UK

If none of these options work out I'd be wanting them to fire me rather than quitting on the spot, and have to go through the whole HR process.

This means that I can look for another job in the meantime. Yes, in an ideal world it would be great to hand in my notice dramtically and say why, but I have a mortgage to pay and want to do this as diplomatically as possible.

OP posts:
CoastalWave · 16/04/2022 18:37

@Wilkolampshade

Oh god. DD off to Mexico for 3 weeks. Some touristy bits then travelling. 😳
Seriously??? Have you done ANY research at all?
CoastalWave · 16/04/2022 18:35

Rambo Last Blood anyone?

Jesus I most definitely would NOT be going.

No job is worth this risk.

Pompom1919 · 16/04/2022 18:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines, as we have suspicions about this user.

carolipankas · 16/04/2022 18:34

You describe your sister and her partner as being 'incredibly unhelpful' and yet:

  1. They are kindly putting you up
  2. Their advice concurs with Foreign Office
  3. Not to mention most of the posters on this thread!
Find another job!
YorkshireRog · 16/04/2022 18:33

@Bagpusssays

I've lived and worked in a developing country. You don't sound cut out for it.
As have I. But I think this response is a bit dismissive. It is fine for her to worry and be trying to check her safety. And sensible to work out what sort of responsibility the work place take and try to plan around that. And you learn very little about someone from a mumsnet post. I am sure you had a similar journey when you were starting out and hopefully someone was encouraging and supportive.
AMBE123 · 16/04/2022 18:33

Maybe your direct team aren't familiar with the site you are expected to travel to. I would show them the FO guidance and what people from that area have said and point out that you will stick out like a sore thumb and potentially be a target, and say you need mitigations in place.
Do not go without those, no job is ever worth risking your safety for. You are disposable to your employer but not to your family and friends!

Regarding unfair dismissal, one cannot claim that until you have been in a job 2 years. You would have to prove discrimination or the like. I would therefore raise your concerns about the safety with HR and the travel company. Possibly also HSE but I'm not sure they would cover overseas trips...perhaps worth asking them though.

AnnieSnap · 16/04/2022 18:04

I’m surprised that you have had some patronising/sniffy comments here (I shouldn’t be though as there are a good number of bitchy types on mumsnet). Of course you will be concerned. You are just being sensible. Based on what you have said about your company though, maybe they too will be concerned and make alternative arrangements. No job is worth your safety and certainly not your life.

CompassPoint · 16/04/2022 17:00

OP could you suggest the compromise of the local staff travelling to the safer site? Is that possible within what you need to do? Do not worry about them being annoyed at you wanting to be treated differently, they will likely be very relieved as it makes it safer for them too.

CompassPoint · 16/04/2022 16:57

Thanks blueshoes and @tcjotm I am one of the lucky ones, I got out. The majority are not as fortunate. My sister didn't get away without punishment for it either, but that isn't something I want to think about. Apologies OP to derail.

You say you speak Spanish. Is it Mexican Spanish or European? There is a difference, they will know.
Not to be defeatist but they'll know anyway, local dialects and slang are very specific.

OP it isn't just yourself you may be putting at risk if you go to the dodgy site, its your colleagues and their families. If something even relatively minor happens to you and they try to defuse the situation in any way, or even just if they are with you at the time they may end up caught up in cartel business.

I'm not certain about foreign women being kidnapped, as I haven't heard a thing about it and I am on several Expat pages on fb, where a lot of the people seem to be very wealthy and are coming to Mexico in their droves.

If you had grown up watching it happen and heard the screaming and begging for someone to help and had to pretend not to hear or see you would be certain. It burns into your mind. That is very, very far from the worst thing I "didn't" see either.

And you do not honestly think the wealthy live in, or ever travel to these areas do you? In the Government's eyes if you travel to dodgy areas you had it coming. Unless of course you're very, very wealthy or influential, but in those cases you would likely have the best security or a direct agreement with the cartels and would be left alone anyway.
The Mexican Government treats wealthy expats (and the Mexican elite) very differently from the poor.

biokult · 16/04/2022 16:47

You say you speak Spanish. Is it Mexican Spanish or European? There is a difference, they will know. It is a genuine question, you don't have to answer it, but something to think about.

European - even if it wasn't I'll definitely come across as a white tourist.

This is one of the (many) reasons I'm not comfortable going to the neighbourhood suggested.

OP posts:
BloomingHazel · 16/04/2022 16:30

I live in the US, in an area with lots of Mexicans. Some of my friends and colleagues are Mexican. They go back home to visit, sometimes they drive, sometimes they fly. Being they are from Mexico you would think they are safe, visiting family. Wrong. They look different, due to clothing, they're well taken care of, even they are targets. I will never, ever visit Mexico from the stories I've heard from them.
I have another white friend, been to a very touristy resort multiple times. You are to ONLY stay on the resort, and the journey to and from the airport can be scary.

You say you speak Spanish. Is it Mexican Spanish or European? There is a difference, they will know. It is a genuine question, you don't have to answer it, but something to think about.

The Mexican cartel are not to be messed with. I wouldn't trust any locals either, because they will put the safety of their family above yours.

Meet with your manager, express your concerns & go from there. I would listen to your sister though.

biokult · 16/04/2022 15:33

Also accepted the job, knowing it involved working with Mexico, travelling to Mexico, liasing with Mexican collegues, and hopefully contributing to improving a small part of QoL for.....Mexico @Coyoacan

OP posts:
biokult · 16/04/2022 15:28

@Coyoacan

Oh god. DD off to Mexico for 3 weeks. Some touristy bits then travelling

Mexico is the third most popular country with tourists in the world.

It is a huge country but for some reason the OP does not want to say specifically where she is going, as she prefers to malign the entire country

but for some reason the OP does not want to say specifically where she is going, as she prefers to malign the entire country

Sorry what @Coyoacan?

I have explained the trip was planned to a perfectly safe part of Mexico, as most of it is if you are sensible.

My issue is that I am expected to go to a specific neighbourhood, which locals have told me is incredibly dangerous and the FO says avoid. How is this me "preferring to malign the whole country"?

I haven't said specifically where I'm going, as it will be obvious who I work for and probably who I am Hmm

OP posts:
Coyoacan · 16/04/2022 14:01

Oh god. DD off to Mexico for 3 weeks. Some touristy bits then travelling

Mexico is the third most popular country with tourists in the world.

It is a huge country but for some reason the OP does not want to say specifically where she is going, as she prefers to malign the entire country

biokult · 16/04/2022 11:36

@NorthFaceofthelaundrypile

Who is in charge for security for the company? Who is in charge of journey management? You need to ask to speak to that person so they can give you a full briefing. Stick to your guns, do not travel until they can show you all the risk mitigation procedures that have been put into place.
In terms of security management and security I think it would fall under HR

The thing that is confusing me, and what seems to go against what other have said is normal practise, is HR told me to do the risk assessment & mitigation procedures myself.

Obviously I'm not an expert, and it would be down to my line manager to advise, and given that she hadn't even mentioned a risk assemment would need to be done, I'm concerned they won't take it as seriously as they should?

OP posts:
NorthFaceofthelaundrypile · 16/04/2022 10:29

Who is in charge for security for the company? Who is in charge of journey management?
You need to ask to speak to that person so they can give you a full briefing.
Stick to your guns, do not travel until they can show you all the risk mitigation procedures that have been put into place.

biokult · 16/04/2022 10:11

@Wilkolampshade

Oh god. DD off to Mexico for 3 weeks. Some touristy bits then travelling. 😳
Please don't stress @Wilkolampshade

The great thing about travelling is that your DD can choose exactly where she wants to be and leave any situation she doesn't feel safe in. As long as she does her research and is careful I'm sure she'll have a great time :)

For me it's a bit different as I'm going to be in situations where the people who are paying me are expecting me to go this dodgy site - could lead to situations where I'm pressured into staying late for meetings, going out for dinner where I don't feel safe, maybe running an errand in unfamiliar streets. There's obviously a lot more pressure to be agreeable and actually do your job.

OP posts:
biokult · 16/04/2022 10:08

Why would you want to maintain a "good" working relationship with people who clearly don't give two figs about your life or safety?

I think comments like this are a little unfair. I work in a competitive field where everyone knows each other and relationships are important. My manager is senior and well regarded. I am very junior. In life, ideally it would be fantastic to be able to tell people exactly what you think of them and why, but I want to try and handle this diplomatically.

To be fair, I also don't think I have enough details yet to work out if this is the situation. I'm having a meeting on Friday (when manager is back) to discuss this, and will be able to gauge a lot from their reaction.

OP posts:
biokult · 16/04/2022 10:03

@nancynoname

My sister & her partner (who I live with) are being incredibly unhelpful, telling me to quit on the spot and no job is worth my life or being assaulted etc etc. Obviously this is true, but I also want to maintain good working relationships and ideally not be unemployed!

They're actually being incredibly helpful and sensible. It's better to be (temporarily) unemployed than dead.

There's no way in hell I'd be accepting this assignment. No job or situation is worth your life.

Why would you want to maintain a "good" working relationship with people who clearly don't give two figs about your life or safety?

I don't think they are in the slightest. There's a whole load of options that can go between being forced into an unsafe work trip and quitting your job

I could

  • go with a proper risk mititigation set up that I'm happy with
  • go with the proviso I won't go the dodgy site and will stay where I expected to be
-refuse to go at all, manage entirely from the UK

If none of these options work out I'd be wanting them to fire me rather than quitting on the spot, and have to go through the whole HR process. I don't know too much about it, but I'm assuming I'd have a case for unfair dismissal?

OP posts:
Wilkolampshade · 16/04/2022 07:10

Oh god. DD off to Mexico for 3 weeks. Some touristy bits then travelling. 😳

FrankGrillosFloof · 16/04/2022 05:47

Aren’t you getting a bit ahead of yourself? As far as I can understand from your OP, it’s just a colleague that has suggested you go to their site. You haven’t been asked by your manager to go and furthermore, your manager hasn’t even responded to you about it, never mind actually signed off your travel.

I have lots of work colleagues who would like my physical presence at their site but just because they say jump, I don’t need to ask how high. Can’t you just explain that travel to this site hasn’t been highlighted to you as a priority at the moment and from your own research, doesn’t seem advisable?

It doesn’t even sound like you have a thorough grasp of why they think they need you on-site so I would suggest focusing on working with them remotely to get a better understanding of the requirements before haring off to potentially dangerous localities.

Coyoacan · 16/04/2022 05:33

I'm not certain about foreign women being kidnapped, as I haven't heard a thing about it and I am on several Expat pages on fb, where a lot of the people seem to be very wealthy and are coming to Mexico in their droves.

Coyoacan · 16/04/2022 05:30

What part of Mexico are you supposed to be going to, OP?

Swipe left for the next trending thread