Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

work trip not what it seemed :/

259 replies

biokult · 15/04/2022 11:04

Accepted a job of which international travel was involved, was very lucky in that I had a couple offers, which I turned down for my current position. Country is considered unsafe, however the insitute I would be based at is in a tourist-y area which is why I was comfortable agreeing.

Things have been very rushed due to lack of staff, and feel like my queries are not being answered.

My current dilemna is thus: a member of the team mentioned they would be based at a certain site, which was not the area I had expected to working in. I would then be expected to commute there via taxi, or "maybe collegues can drop you". I said no problem, assuming that if it was part of their company the area would also be fine.

Have since looked up the area and it is dodgy AF, yougov strongly recommend avoiding this and similar neighbourhoods. If you must go there you should have a local guide/security. Cabs will often refuse to pick you up from there due to high crime rate. I do not want to rely on collegues I do not for lifts in case they let me down and I am stuck.

I have agreed to the trip, although had this detail been made clear I would've said no. I feel like no precuations have been put in place, or discussed with me.

Please help me navigate this. My sister & her partner (who I live with) are being incredibly unhelpful, telling me to quit on the spot and no job is worth my life or being assualted etc etc. Obviously this is true, but I also want to maintain good working relationships and ideally not be unemployed!

Pretty pissed off tbh, anyone been in similar situations?

OP posts:
TyrannosaurusRegina · 16/04/2022 23:03

@howtomoveforwards

OP, granted it was some years ago but as a lone female Intravelled all over central and South America, including Mexico, without incident. Granted, I was careful generally and speak Spanish fluently but it is nowhere the awful, awful place the foreign office would have you believe. There is huge poverty in Mexico and you will struggle to avoid it as a rule of thumb. I honestly would worry too much. You will find the employees will look after you and ensure that you are safe.
I've travelled as a lone female in developing countries, incident free. It doesn't mean those countries are safe, it means that luckily I didn't get caught up in anything when I was there.
IrisSibirica · 16/04/2022 22:59

Most reputable UK companies will have an online Risk Assessment form in place. As you're the person going overseas, only you get to decide if the risks identified on your form have been sufficiently mitigated by your company.
I have been working in developing countries for a while now, and this was the case with all three of my past employers.
For example: Safe Base Locations - Unless your trip involves no travel to unsafe areas, this risk will not be mitigated in your perspective and you are within your rights to refuse to take on the entire trip. Similarly, you will have sections in your Risk Assessment for transport provision, safety of women, etc.
The onus is on HR to ensure your RA is carried out correctly. The company travel insurance should also require the RA to be correctly undertaken.
I would speak to HR/your Line Manager and as a new joiner, ask to be referred to colleagues who have completed Risk Assessments for similar trips, so you can contact those colleagues and complete your own Risk Assessment accurately.
They cannot make you travel if you are not comfortable with the risks involved. TBH I find their attitude cavalier, and would start looking for a new job, if things don't shape up over the course next week. Good luck OP.

pinkpantherpink · 16/04/2022 22:51

My own risk assessment based on your information says No

What insurance cover is your employer providing? Sounds like they should be providing chauffeur

MyCatIsAJerk · 16/04/2022 22:13

I SWEAR TO GOD THIS IS TRUE:

In the 80s I flew to San Diego to visit my friend. She had narcissistic tendencies but I loved her nonetheless.
She & her BF & friends decided to drive down into Mexico for the day — we ended up at the Rosarito Beach Hotel in Rosarito, Baja Mexico.
We got tipsy drinking margaritas. They decided to leave, and I was right behind them, maybe three minutes. When I got out to the car park, they were gone! They had left without me!!!
I suspect my friend just casually said, “Oh, let’s just leave without her.” It’s something she would have done, no big surprise.
There were two Fedérales (Mexico’s answer to police) standing outside the hotel — I asked them if they had seen a beautiful American girl with her male friends and they said, “Si, si!” and motioned for me to come with them. And like an idiot, I got in their SUV and went with them.
They drove me 30-35 miles deeper into Mexico — by that time, I had sobered up enough to see that this was dire and insisted they stop. They stopped at some dive bar and I ended up hitch-hiking about 65 miles back to my friend’s home in San Diego.
It was terrifying and exasperating and infuriating.
And I beat them home. Instead of coming back for me, they went out for a leisurely dinner and more drinks.
I didn’t speak to her for years after that and I have NEVER been back to Mexico.
When the police/Fedérales kidnap you instead of help you, you’re in the wrong place.
@biokult that was my experience — I believe it’s gone downhill, if that’s possible.

MidlifeK · 16/04/2022 21:56

I’d expect a reputable U.K. employer to provide transport to and from any location abroad. Is this a new job or a change of role?

Insist on knowing more about where you are staying, how you are getting to and from your hotel and say no if you don’t feel comfortable.

SucculentChalice · 16/04/2022 21:47

Really quite horrified by your employers asking you to do this but not entirely surprised.

In employment law terms (and I am not an employment lawyer), I would guess that it would be a potential breach of contract on your employer's part (you haven't been there long enough to claim unfair dismissal). Because it appears to breach the common law duty of trust and confidence owed by an employer to their employee that is implied into every contract of employment, it breaches common law health and safety and it could potentially be sex discrimination (due to the risk of rape which can presumably be statistically proven).

None of that helps you in the short term though and I can just imagine a company whose employee was murdered or raped in such circumstances acting all innocent and surprised, knowing they can't be held liable because it happened outwith the UK.

Employers are increasingly shitty these days. My DP got sent to China 6 days before Christmas with 48 hours warning, got back on Christmas Eve, no extra pay for working away from home or overseas, not even overtime. Its just not worth it.

Longleggedgiraffe · 16/04/2022 21:38

When my husband had to go to work in a very dodgy neighbourhood in South Africa he was supplied with transport and armed guards to and from his hotel. Seriously, I would be asking myself what regard your employer has in putting you in such a situation. They have no right to treat your safety in such a cavalier fashion. Even driving by yourself is no guarantee of your safety. You've only got one life. What they are suggesting simply isn't on. Trust your instincts on this.

Hmm1234 · 16/04/2022 21:30

Sounds like a government job I’m sure you’ll be safe and this is what you signed up to

Pickledonionchrisps7 · 16/04/2022 21:03

The pandemic has made a lot of systems not fit for purpose. I have been asked to do things that would place the vulnerable children in my care at risk. Fortunately I was in a strong position to refuse and also to protect my team from similar issues. If your company are missing things you need to look after yourself. Having to deal with any bad situations resulting from danger would be far worse personally and career wise than making a reasonable request to only go to safe areas and countries.
It’s not easy, good luck

LoisLane66 · 16/04/2022 20:48

No, because I'd never be daft enough to go to an iffy place, not for any amount of money.
Relying on taxis who likely won't want to pick you up OR could themselves be held at gunpoint. Colleagues who may keep you waiting in iffy areas...
Remember the woman who was killed on honeymoon in India with her DH and the taxi driver was held at gunpoint whilst the robbers took money, jewellery and the bride who was never found.
If you want to be a statistic then go...and lots of luck. Stay safe.

TheAntiGardener · 16/04/2022 20:44

This might be a really obvious point, but there’s international travel and there’s international travel. Going to Brussels or Beijing is a completely different ballgame from going to high risk areas - the very fact that posters on here are talking very matter of fairly about kidnap insurance would be sounding klaxons for me. I’m not an aid worker, journalist or security professional, and there’s no way I’d be putting myself in a position where kidnap is considered a risk that needs to be insured against to meet a customer or supplier. It’s perfectly ok to say no if you were expecting the first type of travel, but it turns out to be the latter.

I’d think about the role you’re doing. If it isn’t one of those jobs that is a true calling and requires travel to dangerous places by definition, most people would be turning it down. Some would also travel to risky areas if they’re getting very nicely rewarded for it. And in both of those cases you’d still expect the employer to take all reasonable safety measures, which sound lacking in your case.

Please don’t listen to people saying they travelled there and nothing happened. That really means nothing. This all boils down to your own comfort levels and knowing your employer takes your safety seriously.

THEDEACON · 16/04/2022 20:38

Quote Foreign Office advice and refuse to go

FlamingChopSticks · 16/04/2022 20:02

My husband looked up Mexico on International SOS and they have the security risk as high. If you go on the International SOS site and then to Risk Outlook 2022 there's a risk map, press on view the interactive map, put in the city you are going to in the box and press go and it will give you an assessment.

Booboobagins · 16/04/2022 19:50

I worked along the Zambian and Congo boarder during the military coup. I remember worrying cos tge guards we had weren't armed- they'd had to hang in their guns.

I had a driver, the local police stopped us regularly and asked for a lift. The armed guards at the gold/copper/platinum mines all waved me through, we never got stopped. I was pretty oblivious to the risks except mosquitoes!

I tried to switch to Brazil because I did not want to see poverty in Africa, but I went to Zambia.

In hindsight I'd still go tomorrow - why? Because my employer was sh1t hot at risk management. They had people in every country we worked (like special ops) who would pull people our of countries at a moments notice. They had their own vehickes/planes/helicopters etc.

Of course there are risks - who knew someone would kidnap those workers at tge oil plant and execute some of them?

If you feel unsafe don't go. Always go with your gut it works to keep you safe.

Good luck x

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 16/04/2022 19:48

OP I've read your comments, having worked abroad myself although not in Mexico, and what stands out to me is this.
the problem is this has all be sprung upon me, and I need to really talk to my LM
You seem to be advancing towards a departure date, yet you really haven't been given any information or real answers to any of the questions you've asked.
I don't think they can say this essential work that they should have done has "fallen through the cracks due to sickness" no one is taking any responsibility for your safety, or insurance etc..
Risk Assessment? Oh do that yourself love.
This just sounds like a company which literally doesn't know what they are doing and if anything goes wrong in this area you've been advised not to visit - how good are they going to be at having your back?
What is all the secrecy about. It really does read as if they want to get personnel over there asap and are not too fussed about how they support them. It doesn't sound like the support is going to be there or if they even know what that support would be. They didn't even make sure you could drive for heavens sake. They don't seem to understand the risks the journey might pose for you on your own.
Unless your line manager comes up with some clear, transparent and well researched answers to your questions and concerns, you shouldn't touch this job with a bargepole.

Abaababa · 16/04/2022 19:48

@Bagpusssays

I've lived and worked in a developing country. You don't sound cut out for it.
You sound arrogant as f* (coming from some who had lived and worked in dozens of developing countries).
NickyChavan · 16/04/2022 19:34

I am not sure if this response is too late but i would suggest to not ask but act more confidently by presuming. Say to manager and HR " obviously this is a high risk area, before we confirm dates please confirm the hours my security detail/driver will be available" Act as if of course you will be doing this, give that vibe. I hope you sort it out.

lollylimejuice · 16/04/2022 19:33

Why are you procrastinating, your family are correct. Do not go. No job is worth what could happen to you. I have read all your comments and I can't understand why your judgement is impaired. Forgive my bluntness please but as an older lady, I feel my gut instinct as a mother and grandmother which has never let me down is telling me NO.

anon666 · 16/04/2022 19:32

Just to comment that work based risk assessments for insurance aren't reliable.

They may take on board an element of generic risk, but there are many instances of British nationals being harmed working abroad, including one kidnapping and murder I knew personally.

I would not use that as a guideline personally.

007Stocko · 16/04/2022 19:29

I haven't read all 7 pages so apologies if this has been answered. But you said that your company have confirmed that you need to do a risk assessment.

No you don't, although you should certainly think about all the questions you need to ask them. It is the company that MUST undertake a full risk assessment. Everything from the moment you leave home to the moment you get back.

All your travel arrangements, your accommodation, your meals, your money, your work environment, your social time, absolutely everything about your time away.

They need to be clear on all your arrangements, what to do if you go sick or injure yourself. Your personal safety.

They need to understand local conditions and Foreign Office guidance.

Your company has a huge amount of work to do.

Hobbledobble · 16/04/2022 19:26

To be fair, if you have to do your own risk assessment it would solve the issue, based on what you have said, it would be so covered in high and red they wouldn’t be able to send you anyway

alreadytaken · 16/04/2022 19:24

I've visited Mexico a couple of times. What stops me going back is that while I was there I saw the aftermath of gang violence in tourist areas. What happened was largely kept out of the international papers or played down, although the cruise ships stopped visiting for a time.

You cannot reasonably assess the risks because the information you need to do so is not reliable.

TieYourTrampolineDownSport · 16/04/2022 19:17

I haventvv be read all the replies yet but did want to say that in some countries I have been to for work ( South Africa and India) the hire car comes with a driver ( who in SA doubled as security). If they want you to do this they need to pay for similar.

biokult · 16/04/2022 19:15

@AMBE123

Maybe your direct team aren't familiar with the site you are expected to travel to. I would show them the FO guidance and what people from that area have said and point out that you will stick out like a sore thumb and potentially be a target, and say you need mitigations in place. Do not go without those, no job is ever worth risking your safety for. You are disposable to your employer but not to your family and friends!

Regarding unfair dismissal, one cannot claim that until you have been in a job 2 years. You would have to prove discrimination or the like. I would therefore raise your concerns about the safety with HR and the travel company. Possibly also HSE but I'm not sure they would cover overseas trips...perhaps worth asking them though.

Thanks @AMBE123

Really good point about unfair dismal, d'oh.

Hopefully raising concerns will be enough, I'll have a look at HSE too!

OP posts:
Sodullincomparison · 16/04/2022 19:14

I did most of my work in the centre but also travelled and worked in Neza - often classed as the biggest mega slum in the world.

My driver was armed and my car was bullet proof and I had to keep my bag in the car.

I met fantastic people in Neza and loved it.

However, during my time in Mexico my shower went on fire!, my taxi crashed and I got worms from eating street stand tacos!

You will have a ball and speaking Spanish means you won’t stand out unless you’re heading to certain rural regions.

My risk assessment included;

Arranging the airport pick up prior to arriving
No jewellery
No alcohol allowed
Daily online sign in with HR
Registration with British embassy
Bullet proof car and river for certain visits
No public transport
Only allowed to travel to a designated region ( although that went out the window when they sent me for a quick deal)

Your HR department will have these if they send people overseas.

Swipe left for the next trending thread