Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

work trip not what it seemed :/

259 replies

biokult · 15/04/2022 11:04

Accepted a job of which international travel was involved, was very lucky in that I had a couple offers, which I turned down for my current position. Country is considered unsafe, however the insitute I would be based at is in a tourist-y area which is why I was comfortable agreeing.

Things have been very rushed due to lack of staff, and feel like my queries are not being answered.

My current dilemna is thus: a member of the team mentioned they would be based at a certain site, which was not the area I had expected to working in. I would then be expected to commute there via taxi, or "maybe collegues can drop you". I said no problem, assuming that if it was part of their company the area would also be fine.

Have since looked up the area and it is dodgy AF, yougov strongly recommend avoiding this and similar neighbourhoods. If you must go there you should have a local guide/security. Cabs will often refuse to pick you up from there due to high crime rate. I do not want to rely on collegues I do not for lifts in case they let me down and I am stuck.

I have agreed to the trip, although had this detail been made clear I would've said no. I feel like no precuations have been put in place, or discussed with me.

Please help me navigate this. My sister & her partner (who I live with) are being incredibly unhelpful, telling me to quit on the spot and no job is worth my life or being assualted etc etc. Obviously this is true, but I also want to maintain good working relationships and ideally not be unemployed!

Pretty pissed off tbh, anyone been in similar situations?

OP posts:
Marmite17 · 17/04/2022 11:19

You mention your sister. If you were my daughter I'd be furious at your employer.

Marmite17 · 17/04/2022 11:13

Seriously do not write your own risk assessment! Just scrolled up.
Your company has to pay for actioning it. Your safety, extra insurance etc is their responsibility. Surely they have done this for staff at the Mexican site?
They should be warning of risks and plans in place to mitigate them before even offering the role in a new location.
Your job description only stated safer location in Mexico. Tbh even then would have expected security to be mentioned.

Marmite17 · 17/04/2022 10:42

If the company does not provide a well informed, actionable, risk assessment surely its breaching employment law?
No expert but health and safety, duty of care?
Wonder if saying a risk assessment needed to be done meant by them rather than you. Seems crazy otherwise and a definite no from me.
Would consider going if happy with their risk assessment and package to keep you safe.
But... The shambolic and disrespectful, disgusting tbh attitude to my personal safety (seems at best an afterthought) would put me off working for company.

TheAntiGardener · 17/04/2022 09:22

Watch Narcos and do your own risk assessment? Bloody hell.

The facts are that the nature of the travel are not what op expected/was led to believe, the organisation doesn’t have even the basics of security in place and the op appears to be uncomfortable speaking to anyone about her concerns. Each one of these is a red flag.

The most dangerous place I’ve gone to for work was somewhere stray dogs around the site had been judged a risk and so specific advice about walking around was given - op, this is the level rigorous organisations go to.

The more I read this thread, the more I think the situation is crazy in itself, as is the way some posters seem to be very gung-ho about it.

TwoDaysOff · 17/04/2022 09:11

I wouldn't want to go in a trio like this. Fingers crossed it gets sorted for you after the Easter break.

TwinTeensMum · 17/04/2022 07:55

I wouldn’t necessarily see being told to do your own risk assessment as a bad thing. You’ve got tons of good advice here. Someone even gave you a pointer on how to get a risk assessment for the specific region you’re being asked to go to in Mexico. Also ask for risk assessments from people you know going similar work. Put all advice together and you’ll have your own perfect risk assessment quoting the FO’s advice & stats too. You will actually be in a better position to say you’re not prepared to go till those security measures are in place.

I was born in South America (not Mexico). I left when I was 17 and have been living in the UK for 36 years. When I got to my birth country and the area I used to live, the locals know the second I open my mouth that I don’t live locally. Like is most if not all countries, each area also has different accents.

People living in extremely poor areas (especially those who are uneducated) think that anyone who lives abroad is automatically a multi billionaire and will therefore be kidnapping targets. This is why the risk to foreigners is different to the locals.

I recommend you watch Narcos (still available on Netflix). It shows how people struggling financially (in the absence of a benefits system) will in desperation agree to do jobs that puts them and their families in danger.

Anyone travelling abroad (whether for work or personal travels), should research the dangers in the areas they’re going to. Some areas are safe during the day but not at night. Some areas are a total no go area for foreigners. This advise must be strictly adhered to to reduce the risk.

As other people said, sounds like it wasn’t your line manager who suggested you go that that area. It may have been suggested by someone who doesn’t realise there’s a difference in risk between the locals and any foreigners.

I also think that you can now achieve a lot more over Zoom/Teams etc, though of course it only works with certain jobs.

Good luck in your new job

gogohm · 17/04/2022 07:47

Dp travels (travelled, not since March 2020!) a lot, he goes where the site is not where the tourists are, this can be in an iffy country, a dodgy neighbourhood but his hotel is always reputable and secure, he eats at the hotel if a less than secure situation. He usually has a car and driver in situations which are less than ideal (he'll rent a car in most countries though). Did they know you couldn't drive, they may have assumed and forgot to put it on the job spec, I suggest you learn, not for this trip but very useful for jobs with travel.

All that said, Mexico is ok, yes don't go wandering around alone at night but taking a pre arranged vehicle is fine. If you are nervous going onto site I would reevaluate having a job with travel, industrial sites are never city centre

Noangelbuthavingfun · 17/04/2022 07:35

OP I've don't a LOT of foreign travel fir my job the last 7 years or so... had similar situations. Is it just 1 colleague at this site ? Are you only going there for them or for their entire team or more ? If its just for them, suggest they come to the main site you will be based at. You d travelled from the UK, they know need to travel within Mexico. I've done this many times and mostly people were agreeable. You have some decidionmaking power here even if it doesn't feel that way. If it's an entire team that u need to see, not just a colleague- ask yourself if the meet up can be done virtually successfully. If you feel unsafe, quote the travel advice on gov website. Any reputable company that requires people to travel will and should have an immigration team who organises visas and travel or similar and will be clued up on travel advice and precautions- I would Ask HR for their details. For example when I was in Mexico City the advice was only to use company approved taxis, however when I went to monterrey Mexico, advice was different and i travelled with colleagues who picked me up. Take matters into your own hands here and find that immigration team- if they don't have one I'd be surprised and slightly worried but in that case you absolutely should and have to follow the gov advice, also for any benefits the company provide you with like medical etc. Otherwise I'd be worried its not valid if you don't follow official advice. Go take the bull by the horns and have fun !!

Toponeniceone · 17/04/2022 06:26

Fascinating thread! Unless you're Carrie Mathison, don't go Smile

MigsandTiggs · 17/04/2022 01:02

OP, you have been getting some good advice about important security issues you need to pin down with your employer. Would you be working for a wealthy, well known company?

I used to live in Bogotá. The risk assessment was done by the security company hired to protect the expats. All apartments had to be from the sixth floor up, and no jewellery, especially earrings which could be ripped from your ears. We had a company car and driver who was armed as kidnapping and robbery were always on the cards. There were areas where we were advised not to go. I did go to one of those areas once, with a friend and her driver so we had two men with guns for protection. When My dh came home he said that the security company had already phoned to tell him where I'd been and I got a telling off. As you can guess, the security company was very expensive. Smile They even had their own negotiators for kidnappings.

Foreign, business people stand out, so drivers were told to vary the routes to work. Working as an expat in any country with poverty, drug cartels and a history of robbery, murder and kidnapping requires serious security to be in place. Life is cheap in these places and your own safety is paramount. I wouldn't be in a taxi if they paid me.

IrisSibirica · 17/04/2022 00:39

Glad you're going to speak to colleagues - I have found most people who regularly travel for work are keen to share their knowledge with fellow colleagues.
This sounds like a great opportunity - but make sure your company are looking out for you. :)

Skinterior · 17/04/2022 00:23

I travel all over the world and sometimes in not very desirable places.

There is a world of difference between being shuttled between a hotel and a factory for two weeks and being expected to essentially live there for the same period.

I'm very surprised that you are expected to do your own risk assessment. There will be specific areas you would need to cover. Also if they're a big multi national surely they've had to consider staff security before?

Do they have a third party to support with this - eg International SOS? I would imagine that they would have something. I'd also imagine that it's hidden in your work intranet and most colleagues have forgotten it exists because they haven't been travelling much for the last couple of years.

If I were you I'd be bugging your line manager, travel booking service, Health and safety and possibly HR as a new starter. If there's nothing it would ring SERIOUS alarm bells for me, not just about travel but about all the other things they probably aren't doing a great job of.

AnotherNC22 · 17/04/2022 00:14

Hi @biokult - lots of people have mentioned Hostile Environment Training, but i couldnt see whether you have addressed this in your replies. I used to travel to and from sub-Saharan Africa in a previous life, and had colleagues who went to Central and South America. It was a condition of our insurance that we did this training. Mine was a 5 day course in some airport hanger in Sussex - it teaches you all about how to react in dangerous situations, plus some self defence theory, basic emergency first aid, dealing with kidnap / terrorist situations, defusing or extracating yourself from volatile situations and there was a day about working with bodyguards / evasive driving etc. Your employer should pay for you do this before you go anywhere near any site visits, in addition to lots of the good advice you had had in relation to risk assessments. If you do decide to go, please raise this with them and don't take no for an answer!

MyCatIsAJerk · 17/04/2022 00:11

@biokult

She never made it up to me.

She told me I was being ridiculous & over-reacting, because after all, I made it back to San Diego just fine.

I gave up on her after that & decided yes, she’s a narcissist.

I haven’t spoken to her in 25 years.

Trapunt0 · 16/04/2022 23:57

"My sister & her partner (who I live with) are being incredibly unhelpful, telling me to quit on the spot and no job is worth my life or being assualted etc etc"

Tbh I think your sister and partner are being anything but unhelpful.
You share a home yet still they recommend putting your safety above financial security (which will impact on household expenses) - that's care!
It's one thing choosing to take risks with your personal safety yourself, quite another for a third party to place you at risk they are not taking themselves.
You clearly have concerns by posting this. My advice is listen to your own instincts, then formulate them into a reasoned "no" to your employer

TheAntiGardener · 16/04/2022 23:41

@Imlovinglife

Step 1: Take a job overseas thinking it will be a paid beach holiday.

Step 2: Freak out when you realise you might actually meet some "foreign people" and things might be a little different than here.

Some posters really will go to any lengths to slag off an op. Ridiculous post.
biokult · 16/04/2022 23:25

@Sodullincomparison

I did most of my work in the centre but also travelled and worked in Neza - often classed as the biggest mega slum in the world.

My driver was armed and my car was bullet proof and I had to keep my bag in the car.

I met fantastic people in Neza and loved it.

However, during my time in Mexico my shower went on fire!, my taxi crashed and I got worms from eating street stand tacos!

You will have a ball and speaking Spanish means you won’t stand out unless you’re heading to certain rural regions.

My risk assessment included;

Arranging the airport pick up prior to arriving
No jewellery
No alcohol allowed
Daily online sign in with HR
Registration with British embassy
Bullet proof car and river for certain visits
No public transport
Only allowed to travel to a designated region ( although that went out the window when they sent me for a quick deal)

Your HR department will have these if they send people overseas.

Thanks for this balanced account @Sodullincomparison! And also good to hear the positive aspects haha.

Really useful to see the kinds of things that go into a risk assessment for this kind of travel.

I spoke to a friend who works in a completely different industry where they are often sent to dangerous regions & he was shocked and pointed out his employers would put in months of planning for a trip like this. These kind of accounts are really eye opening so glad I made a thread and lots of people are sharing!

OP posts:
SucculentChalice · 16/04/2022 23:21

@Imlovinglife

Step 1: Take a job overseas thinking it will be a paid beach holiday.

Step 2: Freak out when you realise you might actually meet some "foreign people" and things might be a little different than here.

I can't really see anything in the OP's post that would lead you to come to either of those conclusions.

But don't let accuracy get in the way of your agenda.

biokult · 16/04/2022 23:21

@MyCatIsAJerk that sounds terrifying and I'm impressed you managed to find it within yourself to get back in contact with your friend

How did she make it up to you?!

OP posts:
CompassPoint · 16/04/2022 23:20

Step 1: Take a job overseas thinking it will be a paid beach holiday.

Step 2: Freak out when you realise you might actually meet some "foreign people" and things might be a little different than here.

What rubbish! OP posted with genuine, serious concerns, this isn't a "do you think they'll have proper chips in Marbella?" thread ffs Hmm

biokult · 16/04/2022 23:20

@IrisSibirica

Most reputable UK companies will have an online Risk Assessment form in place. As you're the person going overseas, only you get to decide if the risks identified on your form have been sufficiently mitigated by your company. I have been working in developing countries for a while now, and this was the case with all three of my past employers. For example: Safe Base Locations - Unless your trip involves no travel to unsafe areas, this risk will not be mitigated in your perspective and you are within your rights to refuse to take on the entire trip. Similarly, you will have sections in your Risk Assessment for transport provision, safety of women, etc. The onus is on HR to ensure your RA is carried out correctly. The company travel insurance should also require the RA to be correctly undertaken. I would speak to HR/your Line Manager and as a new joiner, ask to be referred to colleagues who have completed Risk Assessments for similar trips, so you can contact those colleagues and complete your own Risk Assessment accurately. They cannot make you travel if you are not comfortable with the risks involved. TBH I find their attitude cavalier, and would start looking for a new job, if things don't shape up over the course next week. Good luck OP.
Thanks this is all really helpful advice and much appreciated

Speaking to colleague is a good shout too, people are still in the habit of working remotely so it's been harder to meet other staff, but I'll try some of the slack channels to get in touch with people :)

OP posts:
biokult · 16/04/2022 23:17

@Imlovinglife

Step 1: Take a job overseas thinking it will be a paid beach holiday.

Step 2: Freak out when you realise you might actually meet some "foreign people" and things might be a little different than here.

Have you read any of my posts @Imlovinglife?

I haven't accepted a job overseas. I'm not panicking because I'll be meeting "foreign people" or that things will be "different" Hmm Also given what I work as, it will certainly be no beach holiday.

I agreed to make some trips to a specific insitute in Mexico, as part of my new job in the UK. This institute is in a built up area, reliable & safe transport, secure parking, with lots of employees commuting there. The rest of the time I will be managing the project from here.

It is now being suggested I actually work at a remote site in a neighbourhood where the FCO advise against travel & locals warn against going to, with no mititagtions being put in place.

There is a very high risk of violent crime there, including carjacking, gang violence and sexual assault, hence why it is reasonable for me to be concerned.

OP posts:
Imlovinglife · 16/04/2022 23:06

Step 1: Take a job overseas thinking it will be a paid beach holiday.

Step 2: Freak out when you realise you might actually meet some "foreign people" and things might be a little different than here.

Adirondacks123 · 16/04/2022 23:05

First things first. Speak to your line manager and to HR. Also do you have a Union? There are many places in the world where business men and women travellers may be specifically targeted. If this is one of them, your company will have a risk assessment, ask to see it, and may provide a driver and security for its personnel. Ask the questions. If it is considered a safe area they will tell you, but you do have the right and the need to ask. If the company hasn’t already talked to you about it, they may well consider it safe, or your colleague could be going off-piste of their own volition, and the company doesn’t know.

yphtutor · 16/04/2022 23:04

Simple don’t go!

Swipe left for the next trending thread