Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

work trip not what it seemed :/

259 replies

biokult · 15/04/2022 11:04

Accepted a job of which international travel was involved, was very lucky in that I had a couple offers, which I turned down for my current position. Country is considered unsafe, however the insitute I would be based at is in a tourist-y area which is why I was comfortable agreeing.

Things have been very rushed due to lack of staff, and feel like my queries are not being answered.

My current dilemna is thus: a member of the team mentioned they would be based at a certain site, which was not the area I had expected to working in. I would then be expected to commute there via taxi, or "maybe collegues can drop you". I said no problem, assuming that if it was part of their company the area would also be fine.

Have since looked up the area and it is dodgy AF, yougov strongly recommend avoiding this and similar neighbourhoods. If you must go there you should have a local guide/security. Cabs will often refuse to pick you up from there due to high crime rate. I do not want to rely on collegues I do not for lifts in case they let me down and I am stuck.

I have agreed to the trip, although had this detail been made clear I would've said no. I feel like no precuations have been put in place, or discussed with me.

Please help me navigate this. My sister & her partner (who I live with) are being incredibly unhelpful, telling me to quit on the spot and no job is worth my life or being assualted etc etc. Obviously this is true, but I also want to maintain good working relationships and ideally not be unemployed!

Pretty pissed off tbh, anyone been in similar situations?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dizzywizz · 04/05/2022 21:52

Any update @biokult ?

MeandT · 28/04/2022 20:03

@biokult how has this ended up after chat with your line manager?

CaptSkippy · 21/04/2022 11:26

OP, I have travelled internationally for work for years. Some places definitely weren't safe and it always involved a lot of planning, even to the places that were considered safe.

When that planning started to slip I immediately felt the effects of it. Anything from my paperwork not being in order and therefore not allowed to board a plane to issues with flights and hotels and it was an absolute nightmare. I was exhausted after each trip. And then I still had to start the project.

A company may be reputable, but that doesn't mean they have their shit in order. In your case I would resign. This is not worth the risk. You have other experienced profesional travellers in your life telling you so. Please listen to them.

Dammitthisisshit · 21/04/2022 10:35

The capabilities and temperament of the specific individual in any given situation are key to a realistic assessment of risk. Far more so than any official FCO travel advice. That is what I was trying to convey. There is no 'safe or not' for all.

I agree with this. It’s why someone needs to be able to have the confidence to make on site safety decisions based on their own capability. Eg I am confident in my driving ability (been driving for years, frequently drive other vehicles). So will happily drive in other countries if appropriate. I also have the ability to sleep on flights. So its more appropriate that I drive straight after a journey than someone who has just passed their test who doesn’t sleep when travelling.
However I have the sense of direction of a peanut. When going round a roundabout I have to count junctions as I have no idea how far I have turned. So it’s not appropriate to have me driving on my own if I have to navigate between and on the edge of dangerous areas as I’d drive straight into them.

Stravaig · 21/04/2022 09:38

It's interesting that quite a few of you read judgement into my post, when in fact there was none.

The capabilities and temperament of the specific individual in any given situation are key to a realistic assessment of risk. Far more so than any official FCO travel advice. That is what I was trying to convey. There is no 'safe or not' for all. It is important to know and accept your limits, your experience, your possible responses to various risk scenarios. The answer will not be the same for everyone. Who you are will affect the likelihood, the trajectory and the outcome of any potential incident.

The poster who wrote that they 'wouldn't notice a kidnap attempt until the bag was over their head' has made a robust self-assessment. This inspires confidence and trust, and makes clear what mitigations would be needed.

Dammitthisisshit · 21/04/2022 09:34

Hi OP,

In case it helps, in normal times I both work in and manage a travelling team. All company policies vary (sometimes we’re working alongside other companies with other policies, so there is no absolute ‘what’s right’, just risk based judgement calls. we go to many counties where the foreign office advises against travel. Our processes:

A trip summary is done, usually by the person doing the travelling. I wouldn’t send someone entry level anywhere on their own, so entry level staff would be sent with someone more senior who would do the trip paperwork, so ideally once someone is ready to go on their own they’ll know the process. Where this falls down is when someone with a bit of experience is recruited as they would be expected to travel in their own and take charge of trip organisation. So I’m assuming that’s the category you’re in.
The trip summary is looked at by the line manager and travel dept and will kick off certain processes, for example we subscribe to security updates that are sent through to the traveller. Accommodation is recommended by the travel department and usually booked directly unless you you have a reason for them not doing do, if you’re unhappy with what they book it’s a battle to stay where you want but they would argue that they only use ‘known’ hotels. If travelling to high risk areas then theres a conversation between traveller, line manager and travel team about what external support is required, eg daily check in calls to make sure someone is ok.
A risk assessment is done by the traveller. Always the traveller as they will know their own trip and they need to be familiar and agree with mitigations in place. But it’s based on our standard risk assessment for travelling (which you’d be told where to find) then modified to take into account region or trip specifics so you look at what other people had put in previous risk assessments for that region if available. So you should be shown where these are. Standard mitigations are no travelling at night, no lone travelling in certain regions, known taxi company to be used, pre-booked travel from hotel to work site only, etc. One place I only travelled with a local staff member as they knew the city (we had to go through some very dodgy regions on the way to the site and I 100% would have got lost if driving myself!) so they accompanied me everywhere, etc. This risk assessment is reviewed by your line manager and if high risk (defined either by region rating or other factors eg 2 years ago all travel was classed as high risk due to Covid) then the risk assessment is also reviewed by a director who signs off that it can go ahead, they’ll usually ask for further info about mitigations.
When travelling there is 24 hour on call manager support if something isn’t right, in reality I wouldn’t wake someone up in the middle of the night unless the sky was falling in but it’s good to know it’s there.
We have a policy that anyone can call stop at any time if they’re not happy, and employees do. And they are backed up by management - always, no questions asked (well not at the time, there’s always a review afterwards). But the other side to that is that we expect employees to take charge of their own safety as frankly I can’t do anything for my team if I’m not there and they know more, all I can do is facilitate stopping or modifying work, if and only if I know what’s going on.
examples I’ve had:


  • employee says to me they’ve been to a site and they didn’t feel safe - great info, we talk about why and agree that anyone going to that site again shouldn’t go alone. Work risk assessment modified to reflect this.

  • employee calls in to say their trip site has changed due to logistics regions - no action taken as no reason to think new site is any more dodgy.

  • trip logistics change so that employee travelling into high risk area at night and they won’t have slept - trip extended and arrangements changed so they’re put up in airport hotel to facilitate daytime travel

  • etc

personally I think risk assessments are over used as arse covering. They have their use, mainly so any employee realises their high risk activities and mitigations can be considered. But more important is the confidence to call stop if they’re getting put in an unsafe situation. So eg if you’re working at a dodgy site and are asked to go out for a meal in the area then make your own way home - you say no. If you’re asked to nip out for an errand - you explain that you need a local staff member with you (or say no).

I’ve refused to do an activity on a job before, no biggie, I just explained I wouldn’t do it and why.

Crazykatie · 21/04/2022 09:22

It’s not a question of overreacting, it’s confidence, if safety is a concern now it’s only going to get worse, so best refuse the posting and accept any consequences.
A great many countries have safety and security warnings including the UK, some US citizens won’t travel to the UK because of terrorism warnings.

silentpool · 21/04/2022 07:07

You are right to be concerned, OP. I'm not sure how Manila compares to this place but we got a car and driver when we lived there. I would not consider doing this unless they take care of you properly. You will stick out like a sore thumb and it's not like you can just blend in - and some of these cities are as scary AF in places.

If they are not willing to ensure your safety, I would terminate the contract.

For all those telling OP that she is overreacting, why don't you go to one of these high risk places? It's not like an all inclusive holiday.

FredOnePound · 21/04/2022 00:21

I used to work for a large organisation that had offices all over the world and the major marketing point was the organisation was concerned “with safety” .…of their clients assets lol but not the staff sent out to deal with them, and offering “risk managment services” but not being overly concerned about the risks their staff were forced to take.

I can think of many examples of managers being keen to rush you out for jobs but not overly giving a fig for staff safety or welfare. One colleague turned up to find very unsafe conditions (he was at risk of being electrocuted and spent time making sure the installation was safe before getting on with the job, but got bollocked by a senior manager for taking too long “time is money” and “the client is unhappy you raised the issue” (and this one was in the UK!). One employee killed in an accident at work where another was seriously injured. (All I can remember is a senior manager remarking that there were now two vacancies at a “popular” posting no “let’s learn the lessons of this accident so it doesn’t happen again”. Another employee who was killed in a developing country when his hotel balcony gave way, and the organisation at first didn’t want to pay his widowed partner any life insurance (until strike action was threatened).

I wonder if it’s the same organisation OP!

BuanoKubiamVej · 20/04/2022 23:30

If you do end up losing your job over this, you might be able to claim unfair dismissal of the basis of discrimination if you can successfully argue that a male colleague wouldn't have been put in this situation as the specific dangers that you would be in on this trip stem from the fact that as a woman you would be perceived as more vulnerable and therefore more likely to be targeted. A man in the same scenario would be less vulnerable, and the discrimination was that they weren't putting any additional protection in place to mitigate that extra vulnerability and were therefore expecting you to take significantly more personal risk than a male colleague would have.

Don't know if that would work. I am not a lawyer
Hopefully you'll get this resolved without losing your job though!

MelroseGrainger · 20/04/2022 21:29

Is this a one-off work trip, as you seem to describe, or a second regular working location at the company’s sister site? Your posting isn’t quite clear. Regardless, if you feel unsafe being asked to do something, you should escalate this without embarrassment. Your manager should take you and your concerns seriously, and if they can’t address them to your satisfaction then you should say no to the trip. If working regularly at a second site in Mexico is in the contract you signed, then you should consider looking for another job.

Risk assessments and overseas travel to very varied foreign locations is a regular part of my job, and my industry. Nothing is undertaken without a risk assessment - not even a job on a location in the U.K. (for example working outside in the countryside for a day). The junior person in the team (which you say you are) is NEVER responsible for doing the risk assessment. It is always the manager or person responsible for the team. They will (or should) have at least basic training for doing risk assessments. RAs are a real and important exercise in risk mitigation and signal to the team the protocols put in place for their safety. In my industry, the person doing the RA has a legal responsibility as well - if anything goes wrong, they are in the firing line. So RAs are not just a piece of pesky admin.

Please feel more confident in asking questions and seeking answeres about your safety and personal well being. You should not apologise or feel silly, ever. And you should not feel embarrassed or shamed into doing something you’re not happy with. If the company sends people to this location often enough, they should have things already in place and should have answers for you.

if this is the first time they have sent someone there, or the early establishment of a new working site, they need to take the views and concerns of their staff seriously as they make plans for the trip.

who is organising all your travel and accommodation? They should know more about all this too. Expecting you to just take taxis or get lifts with colleagues is not acceptable either, they need to organise - or help you organise - a clear and safe plan for commuting each day. Even if that is just providing you with all the local taxi numbers (it should actually be a lot more than this in an unsafe area, that would be the bare minimum for working in, say, Paris!)

Stand up for yourself, so not be embarrassed or feel silly, so not be fobbed off. How the company deals with your questions will tell you everything you need to know about them. If they don’t pass muster, don’t go on the trip and find another job.

good luck. Update us when you know more!

Weirdlynormal · 20/04/2022 21:13

Stravaig · 20/04/2022 10:07

Hi OP, I think the underlying difficulty is that you've run into your own limits and it's conflicting with your self-image. You see yourself as someone who is capable, experienced and happy working in a variety of unusual and adventurous situations. But not this. That's fine, your concerns are valid, and you've received a lot of practical advice on how to mitigate or walk away. But you're insisting on it 'not being fine for anyone' instead of adjusting your self-image to 'not as adventurous as I once thought'.

Well written, but utter crap.

MilitantMandy · 20/04/2022 21:06

This reply has been withdrawn

Posted on wrong thread

AnnesBrokenSlate · 20/04/2022 20:27

Ah, ok, I see you've now posted that you've not had HET training before either.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 20/04/2022 20:23

biokult · 20/04/2022 20:04

I know you bristled against a PP who said this job isn't for you but it isn't.

I haven't "bristled" at anyone @AnnesBrokenSlate. It's so strange how you get these kinds of posts putting down the OP whatever the thread topic is.

Nope I don't want to do a job that involves frequent unsafe travel and if this had been made clear to me at interview I would've picked one of my other options. This isn't something I'm defensive about, it's not a big deal to me.

There are lots of areas that the FCO doesn't recommend travelling to, but that people from the UK do travel to and work in. Trip decisions are made at short notice and necessary mitigations are put in place eg security/drivers/interpreters/collection from airport/secure compound offices or living or secure hotel accommodation, etc.

Yes - and if you had read my posts you would see that I was being asked to commit to a trip to an area where none of these mitigations had been put in place. I have been to areas such as this before, but either of the context of me planning it myself so being in control, or with work who had put appropriate measures in place and kept me in the loop.

You don't know what is in place because you're struggling to get information. That's what you said in your posts. I've read all your posts.

You didn't mention whether there were secure compounds or not; or whether the local staff include trained security and drivers; or whether you'd had HET in your previous roles (or indeed in this one). Either you missed the detail in my post or you are in the position of not even knowing what to ask.

My points still stand. Put your concerns in writing. And don't go on the trip if you feel uncomfortable. It doesn't matter what your friend/sister or anyone else thinks about what is in place. What matters is that you're not comfortable and already feel it's unsafe before you have left the UK.

I've been on more than one work trip where a staff member returned home after one or two days because they weren't physically or mentally prepared. When you're working in high-risk areas, it's also not unknown for staff to refuse trips.

If this isn't a key component of your role then you refuse this part of the job. Even if it is a key component of your role, you still refuse if you feel at risk.

biokult · 20/04/2022 20:19

And thanks to everyone who referenced and asked - no HET/HEAT training suggested or offered (but I don't think that's suprising as nothing else has been!)

OP posts:
biokult · 20/04/2022 20:16

Stravaig · 20/04/2022 10:07

Hi OP, I think the underlying difficulty is that you've run into your own limits and it's conflicting with your self-image. You see yourself as someone who is capable, experienced and happy working in a variety of unusual and adventurous situations. But not this. That's fine, your concerns are valid, and you've received a lot of practical advice on how to mitigate or walk away. But you're insisting on it 'not being fine for anyone' instead of adjusting your self-image to 'not as adventurous as I once thought'.

No, not at all - I really don't have an ego in terms of wanting to seem adventurous or having crazy travel stories.

I'm not going to debate as to whether this situation is fine for anyone or not as it's completely subjective, but I suspect the vast majority of women would not be happy to go to an area the FCO advises against, with no mitigations in place and no control over the situation. As I said, it really doesn't matter to me where that puts me on the cautious to adventuerous scale.

Practically, I don't want to be in a situation where medical costs aren't covered, or I have personal items stolen and I can't claim it back, because the proper paperwork isn't in place. Why should I risk that for work? There's absolutely no protocol in place as to who would pay if I needed to be transported to a hospital from the remote region, for example. This could be something as innocous as tripping and breaking an ankle, that could just as easily happen in the UK, but you wouldn't be fucked over in terms of costs.

OP posts:
biokult · 20/04/2022 20:04

I know you bristled against a PP who said this job isn't for you but it isn't.

I haven't "bristled" at anyone @AnnesBrokenSlate. It's so strange how you get these kinds of posts putting down the OP whatever the thread topic is.

Nope I don't want to do a job that involves frequent unsafe travel and if this had been made clear to me at interview I would've picked one of my other options. This isn't something I'm defensive about, it's not a big deal to me.

There are lots of areas that the FCO doesn't recommend travelling to, but that people from the UK do travel to and work in. Trip decisions are made at short notice and necessary mitigations are put in place eg security/drivers/interpreters/collection from airport/secure compound offices or living or secure hotel accommodation, etc.

Yes - and if you had read my posts you would see that I was being asked to commit to a trip to an area where none of these mitigations had been put in place. I have been to areas such as this before, but either of the context of me planning it myself so being in control, or with work who had put appropriate measures in place and kept me in the loop.

OP posts:
biokult · 20/04/2022 19:56

Thanks @MeandT (and lots of others), that list of qs was really helpful. HR actually rang me today and I went through them with them!

For the PP who asked, I haven't spoken to LM yet as she's not back til Friday.

I think some of my questions must have filtered through to the Mexico team, as I was forwarded an email from someone high up who said I categorically must not take taxis and she would look into options.

OP posts:
AnnesBrokenSlate · 20/04/2022 19:41

There are lots of organisations who send staff into 'undesirable areas' without months of planning so the experience of your friend who works in a different industry isn't really relevant.

I know you bristled against a PP who said this job isn't for you but it isn't. There are lots of areas that the FCO doesn't recommend travelling to, but that people from the UK do travel to and work in. Trip decisions are made at short notice and necessary mitigations are put in place eg security/drivers/interpreters/collection from airport/secure compound offices or living or secure hotel accommodation, etc.

I'm assuming from your posts that you haven't had any HET either?

Your company isn't necessarily wrong in what they have done and all the necessary mitigations may be in place (but they rely on local staff to manage and their experienced UK staff would know what to expect).

However, you are uncomfortable and panicked, and you haven't left the UK yet.

It doesn't sound as though this trip is for you. Write to HR stating you are unable to take the trip because of concerns regarding lack of HET; insurance; risk assessments; communication of emergency protocols in country, etc.

People who work overseas are often in situations that would seem unfathomable to people who work solely in the UK. I've travelled extensively as have my former colleagues. But people always need to keep within their own risk threshold when accepting overseas trips. Otherwise they can put themselves and others at risk either by panicking or by being reckless. You need to be honest about your capabilities as much as you're asking your employer to be honest about everything that is in place.

LightandMomentary · 20/04/2022 17:29

Erm, it's the company's risk assessment, not yours. They have a duty to assess all foreseeable risks from any work you do on their behalf. You would usually work through it with them on travel such as this, especially if you've expressed a concern.

GnomeDePlume · 20/04/2022 17:10

IME Line Managers are very good at not seeing the safety problem when:

A. it isnt their own safety being compromised
B. the pressing problem is to get a person on site

They dont want to see the safety problem because it is inconvenient and also means facing up to the idea that they have put other people at risk through ignorance.

An employee getting kidnapped/murdered/assaulted would no doubt result in much handwringing and a complete overhaul of safety procedures but that is damn all use to the poor sod who is the victim.

steppemum · 20/04/2022 17:10

I have lived and worked in several developing countries.
My organistation trained me on how to behave in those countires and how to stay safe.
I lived alongside locals, so not as an 'expat' and rarely in tourist areas.

My husband now works in a role where he does risk assessment for people travelling in to areas like this.

There are dozens of red flags in this situation. Unless they are all resolved, I would not go. Yes sometimes we take risks, but they are calculated after everythign has been taken into account. Sometimes that is not enough and people get kidnapped and killed. But you shoudl not start from a place of high risk and no contingency plan in place.

RedHorsesAreDangerous · 20/04/2022 16:31

I expect 99.5% of mumsnet members would be firmly in the 'not actually that adventurous' category

I expect 99.5% of mumsnet members/readers would be firmly in the "Putting the bins out after dark is dangerous and the spiders might get me and eat me* category but they're absolutely great at driving a desk or iPad....

I hope OP has managed to get this sorted, one way or another; and not to be sexist about it, but if the line manager is male, would he be happy for his daughter/wife/cousin/best female friend to go, and if the line manager is female, would she be happy to go herself with what sounds like a frankly lax to neglectful set of "preparations" and risk assessments.

Worst case scenario - do they really want the OP coming home in a body bag and/or the company being asked for a ransom of millions of dollars??? That just might focus their minds a bit.

(I've had a couple of boyfriends in the military, including some who've found themselves in very dodgy parts of the world. I'm fairly sure they would point out that civilians really should not put themselves in these kinds of situations if they don't have to.)

steppemum · 20/04/2022 16:17

I think that there is a real difference between a local team working somewhere and an obvioulsy foreign woman in same place.
For example, I was in Central Asia post 9/11 and there was a lot of security issues for people who looked 'American' which were not issues for our Korean colleagues.
So I would be very careful about being posted to this area.

Do you speak Spanish? If i had local language, and was going to stay with a local colleague or family I would be much happier than being dropped in ther alone.