Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I actually am all for calories on menus?

136 replies

Acatnamedfox · 15/04/2022 01:48

I hate to be that person and post in AIBU when maybe it belongs in another section BUT…

Am I the only one that is sort of looking forward to this?

I get it when you’re out and having a good time maybe birthday/party/celebration whatever you don’t want to know.

But I genuinely have no idea of the calories in things and sometimes pick a salad not realising with all the dressings I could have had the fish and chips for the same calories..

I know I’m going against the masses here but I believe it will help me make healthier decisions when out and I’m not against it!

Yes - I’m being unreasonable no one needs that kind of negativity

No - I’m looking forward to a bit of guidance.

OP posts:
xxcatcatcatxx · 15/04/2022 10:07

Omg I didn’t even think of that side of it, was just being selfish and thinking how easy it would be to log stuff. That actually has slightly changed my opinion on it, there’s going to be so much extra work, although if consumers benefits maybe it will be worth it for them.

Reading everyone’s points and comments too. This is such an interesting thread. So much to think about/ different views xxx

CounsellorTroi · 15/04/2022 10:02

People can be obese on loads of "empty" calories. People can be obese on varied, nutritionally rich diets. Better to be well-nourished than not, but better still to be well nourished and make sensible choices about how much energy your body needs and having a reasonably balanced lifestyle.

Better not to have an underactive thyroid and arthritic knees as well Sad

BogRollBOGOF · 15/04/2022 09:59

@NightmareSlashDelightful

I really feel for the restaurants and chefs/kitchen assistants having to jump through these pointless hoops.

I also think it's low-quality data masquerading as useful information.

Threads like this aptly demonstrate that many people don't actually understand what healthy eating looks like, and will overly focus on calorie content as a determiner of health, or as the only vector in choice-making. This is the germination of disordered eating. (There's a difference between 'disordered eating' and an eating disorder.)

Calories are a useful metric, but they're only a fraction of the picture. In a place like Pizza Express, for example, you'd have people zoning in on calories but ignoring things like (for example) the processed ingredients, type of bread flour used, sugar in the dressings, provenance/quality of the vegetables used, and so on.

What's more, whilst in a basic sense the human body works in a certain way, at a more granular level everyone's gut biome/digestive system is different. So different people metabolise and use food energy differently.

It's also (incidentally, not by design) sexist. Calorie counting is an affliction that impacts women predominantly. So what will end up happening is you'll have women and girls up and down the country sitting in restaurants feeling shame and pressure around food choices, while the men (largely) crack on without even thinking about it.

If I'm in Pizza Express, I know that I'm in for eating refined carbs be it in a pizza base or pasta. If your mind is on nutrition as a whole, you probably wouldn't walk into Pizza Express, and if you do, you'll probably go for something with more vegetables rather than meat feast or something with side salad. Going for a broad range of nutrients is easier to guestimate than the vast range of calorie differences that "pizza" can have.

Calories and broader nutrition are not an either/ or. Some people prioritise one, some people look at a balance of both aspects.

People can be obese on loads of "empty" calories. People can be obese on varied, nutritionally rich diets. Better to be well-nourished than not, but better still to be well nourished and make sensible choices about how much energy your body needs and having a reasonably balanced lifestyle.

CounsellorTroi · 15/04/2022 09:48

Er, fish and chips is not 'very limited in nutrients'. Fish = protein, potatoes have plenty of vitamin C and the dish is often served with peas = vegetables and fibre.

I still think the salad would be better nutritional value. And if the fish is served deep fried in batter the calorific difference might not be that great.

Elphame · 15/04/2022 09:43

Yes I agree - many people have absolutely no idea that a pizza often gives you a full day's calories.

Restaurant food is often loaded with things that bump up the calories so even if it's a lower calorie dish at home, it's going to have loads more when eaten out. Even a side salad is often so covered with dressing it just drips off it!

Stabbitystabstab · 15/04/2022 09:35

I quite like having an idea
I don't eat out much, so when I do I'll not be paying any attention to how many calories I'm consuming (I have a blow out every now and again) but it's interesting to see how many calories it takes to make a salad tasty Grin

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 15/04/2022 09:33

Me too OP totally. I cannot afford to put on any more weight. It takes me so long to lose it. I chose what I thought was a medium calorie meal at westherspoons and the menu stated it was almost 1000 calories so I chose something else. The listed calories really help me. I have a disability and can't exercise much so calorific intake is rely important for me.

WayshrineNotFound · 15/04/2022 09:30

@GooglyEyeballs and @5128gap - I also agree.

I've had an occasionally relapsing ED for soon 30 years. It won't ever go away completely, and I've made my peace with it. I can live quite healthily the vast majority of the time, (and during relapses focus on damage limitation and quickly getting back to my normal) and a large part of it is being able to reassure myself that the foods are eat are "okay" most of the time. I don't aim for perfection, but I at least want to know the imperfections.

Eating out is hard. Eating out is easier in places where I can look up menus beforehand online and reassure myself that even the "bad" dish I might want is not the end of the world. If there's no calorie information, my ED brain will just automatically assume it's bound to have three days' worth of calories in it.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 15/04/2022 09:29

Just because schools have got rid of vending machines

I was a teacher for 25 years. As soon as vending machines went, certain kids would buy and flog mountains of sweets. It happened every day.

5128gap · 15/04/2022 09:23

@GooglyEyeballs

I'm glad to see it and I am a recovered anorexic, some behaviours just never fade though. I find it much more anxiety-inducing trying to order from the menu and having no idea how many calories are in each meal. If I don't know how many calories are in something and I eat it I end up overthinking and obsessing over what I've eaten that day and how to balance it out tomorrow etc.
I agree with this. I'm more likely to struggle to eat something that I don't know the calorie content of. I tend to vastly over estimate the caloric values in food I haven't prepared myself, and feel I have to reject them, so this will help me.
Fleurtjeblau · 15/04/2022 09:23

On the other thread about this, I saw people quoting that only 12% of people have eating disorders, so basically sucks to be them and we shouldn't make accommodations for the minority group. But surely that's only 12% of reported eating disorders. I know plenty of people who definitely have disordered eating, myself included, who haven't sought help. Calorie counting is the first step of an eating disorder picking up intensity in a lot of cases, so surely the number will just rise and rise with this being an extra "push". Itll also affect teenagers who already have massive pressure on them to be perfect, so will mess with their mental health.

I think the solution is to make menus without calories the norm (as it already is) but have the option of having the menu with calories listed. Two options, everyone is happy.

grapewines · 15/04/2022 09:18

@Hollyhead

As someone with a latent eating disorder I can confirm that although recovered, the addition of calories on menu as immediately heightened my anxiety when eating out and has already influenced me away from high calorie choices I really wanted and would have previously chosen to things which are lower in calories.
This will be me. It's a minefield for some of us.
BogRollBOGOF · 15/04/2022 09:12

Added to this, we have had 5 new items added to the menu that we have to prep for and learn. These are all high calorie meals, the lowest at 1,7850 cals, highest at over 2,600. Fiddly to make and selling loads of. Most people don't care, but our job is now so much harder and stressful.

I'd want to know that even the lowest of those meals is pretty much my daily limit of calories (small woman, 40s, moderate exercise, annoyingly injured so no option to burn off excess with long runs, can't burn off more than 200-300 per day at present). And that meal would not be the only thing I'd eat that day, I'd still need breakfast and the other meal, possibly a smaller portion, but still additional energy intake nonetheless.

We have prices on menus that inform choice. I rarely go for something at the top end of the menu but it doesn't mean that I alway buy the cheapest.

Informed choice won't solve obesity issues in society, but it does help people manage their weight in a healthier way. Restaurant food can be many hundreds of calories off people's guestimates so knowing how much energy you're eating makes it easier for people to make their choices and adjust over a day or week to maintain a better balance of intake.

pizzacutterbun · 15/04/2022 09:04

@Alm0nd1

pizzacutterbun

They don’t know the calories in meals they haven’t prepared. That’s the whole point and why they need to be encouraged to go out and eat the unknown, just focus on it being part of a balanced days intake.

If you're talking about people with eating disorders than it's my guess that the majority of those people will know ( roughly) the calorie of any given meal.

I've calorie counted for years, it's helped me sustain a healthy weight and I don't have disordered eating. But because I've been doing it for so long I can estimate the calorie content of most things ( including meals in restaurants) and I'm usually pretty accurate

That's what I'm getting at.

GooglyEyeballs · 15/04/2022 08:56

I'm glad to see it and I am a recovered anorexic, some behaviours just never fade though. I find it much more anxiety-inducing trying to order from the menu and having no idea how many calories are in each meal. If I don't know how many calories are in something and I eat it I end up overthinking and obsessing over what I've eaten that day and how to balance it out tomorrow etc.

Alm0nd1 · 15/04/2022 08:54

pizzacutterbun

They don’t know the calories in meals they haven’t prepared. That’s the whole point and why they need to be encouraged to go out and eat the unknown, just focus on it being part of a balanced days intake.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 15/04/2022 08:51

I really feel for the restaurants and chefs/kitchen assistants having to jump through these pointless hoops.

I also think it's low-quality data masquerading as useful information.

Threads like this aptly demonstrate that many people don't actually understand what healthy eating looks like, and will overly focus on calorie content as a determiner of health, or as the only vector in choice-making. This is the germination of disordered eating. (There's a difference between 'disordered eating' and an eating disorder.)

Calories are a useful metric, but they're only a fraction of the picture. In a place like Pizza Express, for example, you'd have people zoning in on calories but ignoring things like (for example) the processed ingredients, type of bread flour used, sugar in the dressings, provenance/quality of the vegetables used, and so on.

What's more, whilst in a basic sense the human body works in a certain way, at a more granular level everyone's gut biome/digestive system is different. So different people metabolise and use food energy differently.

It's also (incidentally, not by design) sexist. Calorie counting is an affliction that impacts women predominantly. So what will end up happening is you'll have women and girls up and down the country sitting in restaurants feeling shame and pressure around food choices, while the men (largely) crack on without even thinking about it.

pizzacutterbun · 15/04/2022 08:39

@Alm0nd1

And counting calories has been shown not to help.
Creating a calorie deficit is the only way to lose weight, if that's what you want.

It's how to lose weight

Those with eating disorders are in the minority and I would guess already know roughly the calories for everything. It'll be ingrained.

Those who go out to eat and enjoy themselves without a thought to calories will ignore it

And those ( like me) who sometimes like to indulge and other times like to hold back a bit will welcome this change so I can make an informed decision

You can't please all of the people all of the time

PinkSyCo · 15/04/2022 08:38

I agree with you. I really don’t know why people are kicking up such a fuss about calories being on menus anyway. As far as I’m concerned knowledge is power, but if you really don’t wish to know how many calories are in the foods you consume just don’t read that part. 🤷🏻‍♀️

WhatsMyNameGonnaBeNow · 15/04/2022 08:38

@MrsPelligrinoPetrichor

And in answer to the OP I think it's daft, it's one meal ,even if it's really high in calories it won't make any difference if your meals at home are healthy.
Except that your meals at home can be “healthy” but added to the restaurant lunch may hugely exceed your recommended calorie intake.

At least knowing that the not especially huge bowl of pasta at lunchtime actually had 1000 calories might encourage people like my sister to think about whether the meat, potato and veg dinner that evening should be reduced in size.

Or my mother who thinks I only had a salad with the mindset of “salad = healthy” so it doesn’t really count in her head, despite all the dressing and the wedges of brie in breadcrumbs (you’d think that might be a giveaway but nope, cos salad…) She wouldn’t think twice about a cooked dinner at home that evening and a magnum afterwards because she only had a salad. Knowing the calories in her salad might make her decide she doesn’t need the pile of mashed potato later on or that she can live without the ice cream.

Stuffin · 15/04/2022 08:36

@Krakenchorus

Also, it's not an exercise issue. You can't outrun a bad diet.
Exercise does matter though. I won't put weight on when eating my normal diet as long as I do over an hours vigorous exercise a day. If injured and sat on my arse all day then I will (also did during lockdowns as was working at home for long hours and not moving much).

Equally if I have been off work and doing lots of manual jobs I frequently go out for high calorie meals knowing that it doesn't matter one bit.

Doing a 20 minute jog three times a week simply to lose weight whilst consuming far to many calories won't make a difference but exercise does matter alongside what you put into your mouth. How much you move or not move does matter for a lot of people. It's about looking at your diet and exercise overall and I think calories on a menu is just another part of that.

Squidlette · 15/04/2022 08:31

Wetherspoons have had calories for ages. Doesn't ever influence my choices. If I'm out, I'm out. I eat healthily normally. My extra calories come from alcohol, chocolate and weekend night snacks.

I probably exercised less than the dc, back in the 90s. I walked to the bus stop then wandered about with mates. The dc do swimming and martial arts on top. I spent my pocket money on the school vending machine and sweets on the way home. It was the age of findus crispy pancakes and oven food.

But eating out and Maccie ds were both treats and not ubiquitous. Energy drinks were for when you were poorly, or by the late 90s, with vodka. Not for chugging on the way to school. You didn't see many fat primary school kids then, whereas there have been quite a few growing up with the dc.

Amelion · 15/04/2022 08:30

I think more useful information (like the breakdown of where calories are from) could be useful to have on request. I can see it’s triggering for those with eating disorders to have it all out there in black and white and unavoidable. I can also see for others, like those who calorie count or like PP who was diabetic said, to have some info on their food.

Surely a good compromise would be that info is available on request?

Startuplife · 15/04/2022 08:30

I’m in favour as well but I do log my meals in My Fitness Pal. We were ordered lunch at work the other day and I was shocked that a Greek wrap had over 1,000 calories in it!

I’ve also just looked at the menu for the restaurant we’re going to eat at tonight and it’s quite surprising that one of their “lighter” dishes has 300 calories more than a burger does.

It’ll definitely help me in staying in my calorie deficit, especially now that eating out is a once a week activity rather than a rare treat.

IAmNoAngel · 15/04/2022 08:28

Plus, when there is someone wlth an allergy we clear the prep area, clean down, wash everything and prepare that meal separately, so this delays all other checks!

Maybe time to look for another job!!