Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I actually am all for calories on menus?

136 replies

Acatnamedfox · 15/04/2022 01:48

I hate to be that person and post in AIBU when maybe it belongs in another section BUT…

Am I the only one that is sort of looking forward to this?

I get it when you’re out and having a good time maybe birthday/party/celebration whatever you don’t want to know.

But I genuinely have no idea of the calories in things and sometimes pick a salad not realising with all the dressings I could have had the fish and chips for the same calories..

I know I’m going against the masses here but I believe it will help me make healthier decisions when out and I’m not against it!

Yes - I’m being unreasonable no one needs that kind of negativity

No - I’m looking forward to a bit of guidance.

OP posts:
justfiveminutes · 15/04/2022 11:50

@Snoopfroggyfrogg

A lot of really interesting points made. I think I'm in the 'overall positive' camp however one thought that has just occurred is whether the calories on menus might skew people's overall idea of what makes up an acceptable intake, regardless of the advice simply because so many unremarkable sounding meals are enormously calorific on menus. They are way over the daily advised allowance in some cases. This could lead to a counterproductive effect with regards to obesity. I wonder if some people might start thinking 'ok, well 1500 cal per meal sounds about right'.
But the recommended average daily intake is widely known surely. It is already on almost everything you buy in a supermarket.
Snoopfroggyfrogg · 15/04/2022 11:47

A lot of really interesting points made. I think I'm in the 'overall positive' camp however one thought that has just occurred is whether the calories on menus might skew people's overall idea of what makes up an acceptable intake, regardless of the advice simply because so many unremarkable sounding meals are enormously calorific on menus. They are way over the daily advised allowance in some cases. This could lead to a counterproductive effect with regards to obesity. I wonder if some people might start thinking 'ok, well 1500 cal per meal sounds about right'.

Sittingonabench · 15/04/2022 11:45

I like the idea that people have more information around their choices. I don’t think calories are the be all and end all but it is useful information and encourages people to think more about their choices. I also hope that this will encourage restaurants to have a more balanced menu with different types of food cooked in different ways.

justfiveminutes · 15/04/2022 11:40

I am certainly not obsessive with calories but if I am trying to decide between two things on a menu, with all else being equal, I think I'd probably opt for the lower calorie option as I'm trying to lose a few pounds.

Lots of pp have said that restricting calories doesn't work. It doesn't work in isolation. But a calorie deficit is the only way to lose weight and this is a useful extra piece of information alongside other things of course.

Fleurtjeblau · 15/04/2022 11:19

@myislandhome

More's the point - how many people go out to eat and would like to just choose what they would like to eat vs how many choose based on just choosing the lowest calorie item on the menu. And if you are camp 2 - why?
I'm camp 3 - When I go out to eat I choose what I want to eat regardless of whether it's "fattening" or not, however, I have suffered with disordered eating for many many years. Having easy access to the calorie amount of the entire dish would make me stop, feel shame at choosing a dish with "so many calories" and then choose something else.

This is because the little voice in my head that probably won't ever go away, will make me feel massively guilty for choosing what I really wanted. It would make me feel ashamed and would ruin my night. I don't have control over that voice and I'm someone who has never been diagnosed with an eating disorder, I just know from my own behaviour that I don't have a healthy relationship with food.

As an example, I went out for my anniversary a few months ago and had half a baked camembert in red wine as a starter, a duck leg/chips/salad as a main and a chocolate fondant as a dessert. I drank 3 glasses of wine and had a coffee with a biscuit. I was absolutely stuffed and satisfied. 5 years ago, that would've sent me into a tailspin. But I've worked on myself enough now that I didn't feel that shame or guilt because I was able to put the calories out of my mind and enjoy myself. Had the calories have been next to each dish on the menu, I would've felt shame. Had the calories have been in a page in the back of the menu, I would've felt compelled to turn the pages and take a peak, which would've caused me to feel shame. Had the calories have been in an entirely separate menu, away from my eyes and hands, I would've been able to ignore it and carry on with my evening and not feel shame.

The point being that it's not black and white, it's not always a case of a recovering anorexic person fresh out of therapy who will be traumatised by it. It's also pretty ok day to day people who have had issues in the past that they're dealing with, who will be made worse with calories being printed next to the dishes, or even in the same menu.

I don't know when we all stopped realising that compromises exist, but there is a way to make all people happy here, rather than either or.

PAFMO · 15/04/2022 11:19

@Hont1986

Not displaying calories on a menu is like not displaying prices.

"Adults should know what a meal costs and why should the rest of us have the price shoved in our face just to help them?!" "Seeing the price of a meal makes me anxious and guilty about having it, I just end up getting the cheapest item on the menu." "If I see prices on the menu it takes me back to a time in my life when I was living in poverty and brings back all the negative feelings"

At some point we have to acknowledge that this is a helpful move for the majority. Calorie information has been on every shop-bought food for years, it's already on most large chain restaurant menus. For all the doomsaying from fact activists and ED pressure groups, this will be a minor change that most people will ignore, a few people will find helpful, and even fewer will find harmful.

X- post

Excellent last paragraph.

People need to take some responsibility.

PAFMO · 15/04/2022 11:17

Thing is, ready meals etc and many other foodstuffs have had calorie counts on them for donkeys years.
I don't see the difference tbh.
I do see a nation of people who are ready to moan about everything.
Next Vanity sizes tell me I'm a 10 when H&M and Zara tell me I'm an L or XL.
Yet it's the latter we complain about because it offends our sensibilities.

Half the population is fat (me included btw) but we're not allowed to put calories onto menus because people will be upset.

Schools attempt to introduce healthy eating by "nazi policing" lunch boxes yet it's their fault not the parents who have made the children obese in the first place.

It's always down to somebody else here.

I'm a size 16. I could do with losing a couple of stone.

No, it's not Zara's fault.
No, it's not the menopause (though that didn't help)
No, it's not my metabolism

It's because I eat too much.

Hont1986 · 15/04/2022 11:15

Not displaying calories on a menu is like not displaying prices.

"Adults should know what a meal costs and why should the rest of us have the price shoved in our face just to help them?!" "Seeing the price of a meal makes me anxious and guilty about having it, I just end up getting the cheapest item on the menu." "If I see prices on the menu it takes me back to a time in my life when I was living in poverty and brings back all the negative feelings"

At some point we have to acknowledge that this is a helpful move for the majority. Calorie information has been on every shop-bought food for years, it's already on most large chain restaurant menus. For all the doomsaying from fact activists and ED pressure groups, this will be a minor change that most people will ignore, a few people will find helpful, and even fewer will find harmful.

lljkk · 15/04/2022 11:14

@CounsellorTroi

I actually cannot fathom how people can eat a 12 inch pizza by themselves. I can’t, but am still overweight.
Oh, I could do that in the day, and even now, maybe.

Job on my feet always moving fast & heaving heavy things around. I walked 30 miles one day. 8-10 hours of cycling, including up & down a lot of hills. 2 hours swimming. Etc.

5128gap · 15/04/2022 11:10

@myislandhome

More's the point - how many people go out to eat and would like to just choose what they would like to eat vs how many choose based on just choosing the lowest calorie item on the menu. And if you are camp 2 - why?
I aim for somewhere in between. I make choices where I try to balance what I would really like (which in truth would be everything, and to excess) with what is reasonable for me in calorie intake and not too unhealthy. So, not necessarily the lowest calorie item, but certainly in a choice between two meals I fancy, the lower calorie one would win for me. Why? Because I don't want to be overweight, and if I ate to my appetite and preferences, I would be; and not being overweight matters more to me than unrestricted eating. Why do I go out to eat with that attitude? Well left to my own devices I wouldn't choose it as a leisure activity. But most people do, so it's necessary as part of my social life.
Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 15/04/2022 11:05

why dont they have the option of having a menu with calories on for those who want them? I get some people dont care or would find it difficult, but for many people, including me, it would be really helpful.

myislandhome · 15/04/2022 10:55

When I was in full swing disordered eating, I used to have 2 choices:
"what i would choose if I chose what I would really like to eat from this menu"
and
"what I am going to choose based on what I know is lower in calories".

Who wants to play that game ?

myislandhome · 15/04/2022 10:53

More's the point - how many people go out to eat and would like to just choose what they would like to eat vs how many choose based on just choosing the lowest calorie item on the menu. And if you are camp 2 - why?

Isitsixoclockalready · 15/04/2022 10:37

There are never easy or clear answers to an issue like this. Calorie counts appear pretty much everywhere now - not just on menus so they are unavoidable but they definitely don't tell the whole story in terms of diet.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 15/04/2022 10:33

@CounsellorTroi

I actually cannot fathom how people can eat a 12 inch pizza by themselves. I can’t, but am still overweight.
One bite at a time. Grin (I did a 14" once to win a bet.)
Chestnutpony · 15/04/2022 10:33

I mean, those really high calorie dishes are made that way because they sell. It changes our behaviour, so that we are engaging in behaviour that runs contrary to our long term interests. I will choise to eat high calorie stuff occasionally, but I need to be aware that a food is really high calorie before I can make an informed choice.

5128gap · 15/04/2022 10:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted as it quotes a deleted post.

Chestnutpony · 15/04/2022 10:27

I think it could act as a sort of quality control. It's easier to make a poor quality meal more palatable than one made with fresh veggies, just by using lots of fats and sugar. Food that is really high in fats will have a great mouth feel, so we will tend to choose it over food with a more reasonable energy content - making people aware of the calorie content kind of levels the playing field a bit?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 15/04/2022 10:27

If I'm going out for a meal it's a treat, I'm not calorie counting. If I wanted to do that I'd eat at home.

User280905 · 15/04/2022 10:16

I've got 2 stone to lose and some guidance on calories would make a difference to me I think. I nearly ordered a burger in a cafe attached to a gym recently, it had calories on the menu and I was horrified when I realised how many calories there were. I chose something else but equally tasty.

I know it will be stressful for some people to see calories beside everything though

CounsellorTroi · 15/04/2022 10:15

I actually cannot fathom how people can eat a 12 inch pizza by themselves. I can’t, but am still overweight.

lickenchugget · 15/04/2022 10:13

I like it too, OP. There’s nutritional information (including calories) on all food labels, not sure what the difference is.

Ponoka7 · 15/04/2022 10:10

"People who want to obsessively restrict themselves to a set number can work that out for themselves"

How?

Ponoka7 · 15/04/2022 10:09

"I still think the salad would be better nutritional value."

Our vegetables have one third of the nutrition that veg pre 1970 had. So it depends on what's added. We need carbs and fat, so you just adjust the rest of what you eat.

I welcome the calories on menus. I'm struggling with my weight in my 50's. My generation was the first to embrace frozen food and during the late 80's, the calories and cheapness started to rise. So 89p pizzas with 1200 calories in. Packs of pasties etc. But they aren't filling. You can eat three meals a day but be eating 3000+ calories. How many calories we eat does determine weight. If you been obese and are over 25, you need to be aware of calories and calorie count. Until you get to about 35, you might be able to somewhat get away with the calories with a bit of movement.

nosyupnorth · 15/04/2022 10:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.