Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I actually am all for calories on menus?

136 replies

Acatnamedfox · 15/04/2022 01:48

I hate to be that person and post in AIBU when maybe it belongs in another section BUT…

Am I the only one that is sort of looking forward to this?

I get it when you’re out and having a good time maybe birthday/party/celebration whatever you don’t want to know.

But I genuinely have no idea of the calories in things and sometimes pick a salad not realising with all the dressings I could have had the fish and chips for the same calories..

I know I’m going against the masses here but I believe it will help me make healthier decisions when out and I’m not against it!

Yes - I’m being unreasonable no one needs that kind of negativity

No - I’m looking forward to a bit of guidance.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dartmoorcheffy · 15/04/2022 18:32

The new law only applies to food premises that employ over 250 staff, and their menus are generally pre made by outside suppliers and simply reheated, so more reason to support your local independent restaurants and cafes where you are more likely to get fresher home cooked food.

Cahliah · 15/04/2022 18:29

YANBU - I chose a garlic naan instead of a cheese naan this afternoon, purely because it was 230 calories fewer!

Carrotten · 15/04/2022 18:26

I think realistically there are people who are a little bit overweight who may get into the 'healthy' weight category as a result of this. Mostly it will be used by people who are slim as a way of feeling better about themselves because they choose the low calorie options

But I think that people who are more 'obese" probably have a deeper problem than not knowing they eat a lot of calories when in a restaurant. I doubt they will go to a restaurant and chose a lower calorie option and this will change their life, bearing in mind that a lot of restaurants and food already have calories available. It just piles more feelings of morality, of judegment, shame and guilt into eating that does not help people lose weight.

Mirrorball2022 · 15/04/2022 18:21

You are not being unreasonable in the fact that you are happy to have them.
I don’t like them. I eat a healthy diet most of the time, I go out to eat and I enjoy myself and eat the crap I don’t normally eat. I’m not counting the calories!

It’s also problematic for those with a history of eating disorders. Also low calorie isn’t always more healthy than higher calories.

Carrotten · 15/04/2022 18:18

For me as someone with a previous eating disorder it terrifies me tbh. It won't take much for me to slip into my old habits and I really don't want to go there again.

A lot of the positives people are listing are things I would do as part of my eating disorder and I would argue aren't positives, they can be part of a very unhealthy attitude and way of life.

For me, it's not just about chosing the lowest calorie option. I'd look at the calories a week in advance, plan my meal and then not eat anything to accommodate the 1000kcal I was going to eat. I'd obsessively research calories on everything. I spend hours calculating calories to work out how I was going to eat something, hours in the aisles of tesco calculating and recalculating my meal plans calories.

I am a lot better now. I don't count calories, yes I fatter but mentally and physically so much better. I used to faint at work, I'd spend half my life feeling woozy and sick. I'd spend weeks at a time being anxious about the calorific meal I was going to be 'forced' to eat out. Calories were my every thought. None of this was healthy or good for me, now I can actually exercise, I can have fun with my friends. I can drink the cocktails that I used to be so jealous of. I want to be able to do these things without having the niggle of calories in my mind, without haring myself or feeling guilty because I overate.

Weight and calories are not the be all and end of all of health. I don't think that people who are overweight will necessarily change their behaviour because something is calorific, I just think it will add additional guilt and shame around eating food

Octomingo · 15/04/2022 18:05

I walk about 5000 steps a day. I'm early 40s. Even with a run on top, I apparently rarely get up to 2000 calories in a day. A 5kn burns off about a glass of wine. People defintely overestimate how much exercise burns.

Fairislefandango · 15/04/2022 17:56

All this pure mathematics of energy in over energy out is no doubt logical, but it totally fails to take into account all kinds of stuff about real food and real people. For one thing, it kind of implies that eating 400 calories of sweets every day for lunch would have the same effect on your weight long-term as eating a 400 calorie healthy balanced meal. It wouldn't, because it would mess with your blood sugar / insulin response and make you ravenous well before dinner time, probably making you reach for the biscuit tin.

As for exercise, it's largely a red herring weight-loss wise imo. Most people don't have the time or inclination to do enough exercise to burn off the calories in a small slice of cake never mind a few days' worth of bad diet. The vast majority of calories you burn are burnt through your body's normal functioning (even at rest). Not that exercise isn't really important for health in other ways.

KirstenBlest · 15/04/2022 17:52

@TrickorTreacle

Go back to 1990. The school served chips every day of the week, pizza, burgers etc. 6 vending machines in the school, plus a tuck shop. And yet in a class of 24, only 1 kid was fat.

Fast forward to the 2020s, there are no vending machines, no tuck shops, chips only sold on a Friday and lunch boxes are policed. And yet half of the kids are now fat.

The same goes with adults.

It's an exercise issue (or lack of), not calorie intake.

Portion sizes are bigger, constant grazing, consumption of calorific drinks are a factor. Takeaways are ordered more frequently, tv dinners or not sitting at a table to eat is more likely

I'm not bothered about the calories on a menu particularly, but I do look at the nutritional info on food packets, If it is something like a sandwich, the calories and protein will indicate how filling it will be for me

The traffic lights system is not great because they list a 'portion size' based on what will give a green or amber light, not what a person would eat as a portion

reallyworriedjobhunter · 15/04/2022 17:42

I went to a Greene King pub today and was genuinely shocked at how high some of the calorie counts for some of the dishes were. Quite a few at around 1,500 to 2000 kcals.

chisanunian · 15/04/2022 17:34

Nonsense. Calories in is the major reason for weight

Actually, it isn't. You can eat thousands of calories a day, but if you burn them all off with strenuous exercise or heavy manual labour, you will not get fat. The reason for weight gain is the excess of calories in over calories out.

Fairislefandango · 15/04/2022 17:21

No I think it's absolute bollocks. Telling people that what they are eating as a treat is unhealthy doesn't stop them eating it. If it did, we wouldn't have the obesity levels we do.

Whoever said it's all down to exercise - no it isn't. Try eating a full meal, then working out how much exercise it would take to work it off. You can't outrun a bad diet.

People are overweight because in their everyday diets they graze and snack on sugary shit, and generally eat too much of the wrong things (processed food) and not enough natural foods. Not because they have a big meal when they go to a restaurant. You don't need to count calories to know what a healthy diet looks like.

bananatwain · 15/04/2022 17:12

@Dinosauratemydaffodils

I don't have an eating disorder but I find it adds stress to eating out. We went to Pizza Express at the start of the Easter holidays, kids choice. All I could see were the calories. Didn't matter that we'd had a busy date, that I'd barely eaten. I chose an option with low calories which I didn't particularly want and then left two thirds. We're going out tomorrow with dh's family and I'm already dreading it. Dh says that he'll order for me but I don't think I could cope with that either.

My biggest fear is that my attitude will impact my kids so we'll eat out less to avoid it. At home I can eat separately/tell them I'm not hungry to excuse small portions but in a restaurant I'm stuck.

This sounds like disordered eating though.
Chely · 15/04/2022 17:06

It's not good enough guidance and that is a big problem.
Access to the full nutritional details would be much better.

BarbaraofSeville · 15/04/2022 17:02

If you can't order food you want to eat from a menu without that amount of stress, then you do have an eating disorder because that's not normal behaviour.

Rationally, we all know that food has calories and that pizza isn't low calorie.

But don't they still do the Legera with salad? That's quite a light meal for a restaurant, by anyone's standards.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 15/04/2022 16:29

I don't have an eating disorder but I find it adds stress to eating out. We went to Pizza Express at the start of the Easter holidays, kids choice. All I could see were the calories. Didn't matter that we'd had a busy date, that I'd barely eaten. I chose an option with low calories which I didn't particularly want and then left two thirds. We're going out tomorrow with dh's family and I'm already dreading it. Dh says that he'll order for me but I don't think I could cope with that either.

My biggest fear is that my attitude will impact my kids so we'll eat out less to avoid it. At home I can eat separately/tell them I'm not hungry to excuse small portions but in a restaurant I'm stuck.

carefullycourageous · 15/04/2022 14:50

@LuckySantangelo35

I think a big part of our obesity crisis is the amount of food children are given including the endless snacking. Also the amount of food adults think they need - you see it on here all the time, people saying they need to eat all the time, there’s not enough food at weddings etc etc
Luckily the Tories have a plan to address this, by making people so poor they can't afford food Angry and they can't afford to heat their homes so will have to use more calories staying warm Angry
LuckySantangelo35 · 15/04/2022 14:46

I think a big part of our obesity crisis is the amount of food children are given including the endless snacking. Also the amount of food adults think they need - you see it on here all the time, people saying they need to eat all the time, there’s not enough food at weddings etc etc

FinallyHere · 15/04/2022 13:37

It's like people who claim drinking a can of coke is healthier than a smoothie. Calories aren't everything, nutrition is.

This is exactly why I would like to see an accurate breakdown of carb counts as well as other nutritional information.

I absolutely agree about the importance of nutrition over simple calorie count. The fact that there can be more sugar and calories in a can of coke compared to a smoothie is important information which can be useful when choosing what to consume.

Anyone thinking that a commercially made smoothie mostly consists of fresh vegetables is most likely labouring under a misapprehension which it would be useful to have corrected.

FinallyHere · 15/04/2022 13:22

@abbey44

As a diabetic, I'd much rather see grams of carbohydrates listed on menus - it'd help me work out how much insulin I need instead of guessing and hoping for the best. Even with decades of practice, it's hard sometimes to get it right, especially when you're eating out.
This.

If they can include calories how difficult could it possibly be to include carb count, too

HardyBuckette · 15/04/2022 13:15

No-one said fish and chips is healthier than a salad but it's absolutely not the case that fish and chips is 'devoid of nutrition' as was claimed nor is it automatic that a salad is healthier than fish and chips, eg Caesar salad is a bit of lettuce, plus cheese, croutons and creamy sauce that in a chain restaurant is likely to be very processed rather than made fresh.

Yeah, the point about calories vs nutrition is a valid one, but fish and chips v salads is the wrong example to use. Fish is packed with nutrients, chips aren't devoid of them though obviously not the healthiest option, and then in a restaurant it's often served with peas too. If you want a treat meal, which people frequently do when they eat out, there are worse options for the calories, nutrition and how full it leaves you.

As for the calorie printing policy, I can see that it'll be good for some people and bad for others. I agree with posters who are sceptical that it'll achieve much at a population level. But it fits very well with a government who are much keener on the idea that we tackle obesity through personal behaviours and responsibility, rather than considering our increasingly obesogenic society and what inconvenient things might need to be done to best fix that.

burnoutbabe · 15/04/2022 12:29

I am happy they have this now - better than trying to guess if tracking.

And may also mean places introduce lighter options - like pizza expresses pizza with hole in middle. Not just for caloirie counting but better option for say quick work lunch when you don't want to feel sleepy all afternoon.

VyeBrator · 15/04/2022 12:07

I genuinely don't care and I strongly suspect outside of Mumsnet, most other people won't either.

And before anyone says 'Well you cared enough to post', I think 'I don't care' is a perfectly valid answer.

EssexLioness · 15/04/2022 11:59

I understand it will be difficult for those with/ recovering from eating disorders. However for me personally I think it’s a great idea. I have struggled with my weight and as a short, menopausal woman with some thyroid problems my calorie allowance is quite low. The only way to avoid putting on weight, even with lots of exercise is to deprive myself a lot. Subsequently I avoid going out. This is already helping as I have looked at a couple of menus and some of the lower cal options aren’t as bad as I was expecting so I can incorporate some meals out in my daily allowance. As a result I am actually thinking of going out to dinner next weekend for the first time in months.

Labscollie · 15/04/2022 11:55

I'm on a 1000 cals a day regime, so it's a useful tool for me. I know what I can and can't have, buy if I'm on a treat day, I will just cut down the next day and maybe have 800 calories. Its amazing what you can eat for 1000 calories per day.

MiniatureHotdog · 15/04/2022 11:54

I agree, I find it helpful. I don't calorie count as such, but if I was dithering between a few things on the menu and one had double the calories I'd avoid it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread