Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for dissertation help please!?

88 replies

dissertationhell · 14/04/2022 22:40

I have made an account especially for this after years of lurking. My dissertation is due in 4 days. My supervisor is on holiday. I have everything written I am just heavily editing everything. I am analysing my findings over two findings chapters.

My question is, when analysing my findings, can I bring in previous studies there if they aren't in my literature review? For instance, when analysing my findings I've found that reading between the lines, there appears to be feelings of shame and guilt emerging as well as justification for alcohol use. I've found studies to back up that there is a higher prevalence of shame and guilt in individuals with addiction but haven't wrote about that in my literature review.

Do I need to add these studies in my literature review? I find it strange that you have to write the lit review before findings etc because I feel like I'm having to constantly go back and update my lit review.

I know I can't add new studies in discussion chapter but is it okay in the findings chapters? Or does literally everything mentioned have to be included in lit review? Tearing my hair out, can't see the wood from the trees

Thanks in advance

OP posts:
dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 20:31

You have all been lifesavers honestly. Thank you so much!

OP posts:
Rosylarose · 15/04/2022 20:30

I would say yes, more than adequate.

dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 20:17

The quotes have came from my own qualitative research. So three per theme/one per sub theme is adequate?

OP posts:
bottleofbeer · 15/04/2022 20:03

Yes, one per theme is absolutely fine.

bottleofbeer · 15/04/2022 20:02

So it's thematic analysis?

If you cut your quotes make sure you remove them from the reference list/bibliography.

dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 19:49

Do you think I could cut back on my quotes in findings section? I'm currently using 6 per theme and there's 5 themes, could I cut this back to 3 per theme? I have used sub sections under each theme, 3 per theme so could I just add 1 quote per sub section to cut down words?

OP posts:
OnlyLittleMissOrganised · 15/04/2022 18:43

As @bottleofbeer says but also for your discussion you should not bring in new supporting evidence that has not been mentioned previously either in the introduction or lit review sections

GrumpyPanda · 15/04/2022 18:16

I'm a PoliSci PhD and never even heard about not referencing anything that's not in the lit review. The way we'd look at it is, it depends on how/whether the new material is connected to your basic research question. Lit review sets out established approaches to the main questions and identifues shortcomings and contradictions between them. This then sets you up to set out your own /(novel, vastly superior) way of tackling the issue. If the material on guilt etc is relevant at this level then yes, it should be in the lit review. If it's just a tool you use while developing your own argument it may not need to be in.

Re cutting text. Check to see if you tend to use any modest, minimizing expressions a la "in a way". Then run a search cycle on them and if possible, take them out. Cuts volume and slow makes you sound less tentative so two birds with one stone.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/04/2022 17:53

@dissertationhell

Sorry I must sound thick but I am so lost. I am fine for a while, woke up this morning did loads was on a roll now I am just doubting myself again thinking there's not enough analysis. Feel like I just keep saying 'these finding support a study by...' and I don't have anything original to say except shame and guilt
You need a break from it. You're going word blind and spiralling.

You've already identified somewhere that a find and replace could cut down that word count. Even if it's just by substituting 'these findings support a study by Fred Smith , title, year, in which they state that....

The findings support (Study) in that...

Joe Blogg's support Smith (year) [or whatever the correct reference is - somebody else will be able to correct me] by...

The findings mirror Smith (year)...

You're automatically turning around 15 words into somewhere around 6 - 10 words. Do that often enough and you could lose a couple of hundred.

Swap 'that is' for 'ie'.

Are you using multiple 'ands' where a list could be used?

Are there places where you are repeating yourself in several paragraphs?

It's really irritating to spend years being constantly told to use more words and be more descriptive when what is needed is to Get To The Point.

You could read sections out loud - if you can't do them on one breath or find yourself stopping for oxygen five times per sentence, you've written too much.

A good break, some food, activity and sleep, then go back to it as though you're trying to find the important points from somebody else's work. What do you actually need to know and what is useless filler that you'd zone out on?

Save the different drafts - don't make final changes and risk losing the previous version.

dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 17:51

@Rosylarose

You shouldn't reference anything not in your literature review, but does it help your own thinking to introduce a narrative to your lit review in which you explain how your research prompted you to iterate through the literature again? Or that you came to realise that a slightly different slant on the available literature emerged as more useful than that which you started with?
Yes that would be helpful actually. Thank you!
OP posts:
Rosylarose · 15/04/2022 17:27

You shouldn't reference anything not in your literature review, but does it help your own thinking to introduce a narrative to your lit review in which you explain how your research prompted you to iterate through the literature again? Or that you came to realise that a slightly different slant on the available literature emerged as more useful than that which you started with?

furballfun · 15/04/2022 17:21

Not sure what degree you're doing this for, but when I did my PhD, it was normal to write the introduction (literature review) last to ensure it introduced the rest of the thesis well. I'd be surprised if you can't review yours?

bottleofbeer · 15/04/2022 17:19

What Parietal said. I threw away marks on stupid things like not putting a new chapter on a new page. It just went out of my mind to do that and it wasn't like it was the first dissertation I ever wrote either.

parietal · 15/04/2022 17:13

I'm assuming this is an MSc thesis in psychology or similar? I'm a psychology professor and mark about 15 of these each year.

Do update your lit review to add more relevant material if you need to.

Do cut your text to the word limit. In my own writing, I like to print a paper and sit with a red pen to make cuts, before then implementing them on the computer. You may find you can cut whole paragraphs of the literature review that are no longer relevant.

For the best grade, so make sure your work has a clear structure and signposts so that it is easy for the reader to follow your train of thought and understand why you did your study in this way.

dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 17:10

@bottleofbeer thank you, your comments are really helpful!

OP posts:
bottleofbeer · 15/04/2022 17:08

You do know how to do this! You're just second guessing yourself. I don't know the format of your dissertation because I don't know your subject. Introduction - what is it you want to find out?

Lit review - what is already know.

Methodology, sample, who, where, why. What type of analysis are you using and why? Justify your reasons.

Results section. What did you find out?

Discussion (usually the longest part) evaluate your findings in comparison to what you found in the lit review. Critically analyse.

Conclusion, this is where you simply talk about what you found without any mention of anything that hasn't already been mentioned. Always use 3rd person: the researcher found that...blah blah

amusedbush · 15/04/2022 17:08

I'm doing a PhD and my supervisor says the literature review is an iterative process, so it develops and grows as more avenues emerge during data collection. However, my internal assessor says you shouldn't add everything you find to your literature review because you want your own results to add some novel contribution, not just support what you've already found in the lit review.

RiojaRose · 15/04/2022 16:58

The lit review establishes the current state of knowledge about the topic, from which your research question emerges. It should sketch out the field in fairly general terms, including anything you draw on in your discussion (so yeah, stick something in about guilt and shame if you discuss it later).

You don’t need to cite all your sources in your lit review, but you should mention sources you’ll depend on for the development of your argument.

To reduce word count, look for places where you’ve used long expressions that could be replaced by a single word. There are usually lots of these left over from the first draft stage!

dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 16:56

However, you should not introduce new research in the discussion section. Make sure that any studies you refer to in the discussion have been addressed in the literature review. And don’t be afraid to modify your literature review as your study progresses (every dissertation project will evolve as it goes on).

This is what is confusing me, I am reading some things like that and different things on other sites saying it's fine. I wish my supervisor wasn't off, then I could just ask her! But she explicitly stated she is on holiday and won't be looking at her emails which is quite right but just frustrating for me

OP posts:
ExMachinaDeus · 15/04/2022 16:53

We stop reading at the word count maximum +10% so it’s in your interests to cut your work back to the word limit

Think about what you want to keep in. Often some stuff can be compacted. Or try cutting whole paragraphs or sections. You need to lose around 2000 words because otherwise the last 2000 words won’t be read - and that’ll be your conclusion.

mumwon · 15/04/2022 16:46

The introduction is the easiest thing to cut back on

dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 16:42

I've literally not gotten out of my pyjamas in three days. My daughter is being ignored, the house is a bomb site. I feel emotionally exhausted I don't know how people do this.

OP posts:
Thatswhyimacat · 15/04/2022 16:41

No, the only place where you can't add new information is the final conclusion, because that should only be a summary of what you've already said. In the discussion you can add new references because as @bottleofbeer says, that is where you are doing original synthesis, so you would EXPECT to need new information to explain your findings.

dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 16:41

Sorry I must sound thick but I am so lost. I am fine for a while, woke up this morning did loads was on a roll now I am just doubting myself again thinking there's not enough analysis. Feel like I just keep saying 'these finding support a study by...' and I don't have anything original to say except shame and guilt

OP posts:
dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 16:38

@bottleofbeer

Yeah you can add new references in the discussion but it was a total no no to bring in new information in the conclusion?

When you're critically evaluating what you found in the discussion you have to add more to what you found in the lit review or you'd not actually have done any research.

So whatever I mention in discussion needs to be in literature review?
OP posts: