Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for dissertation help please!?

88 replies

dissertationhell · 14/04/2022 22:40

I have made an account especially for this after years of lurking. My dissertation is due in 4 days. My supervisor is on holiday. I have everything written I am just heavily editing everything. I am analysing my findings over two findings chapters.

My question is, when analysing my findings, can I bring in previous studies there if they aren't in my literature review? For instance, when analysing my findings I've found that reading between the lines, there appears to be feelings of shame and guilt emerging as well as justification for alcohol use. I've found studies to back up that there is a higher prevalence of shame and guilt in individuals with addiction but haven't wrote about that in my literature review.

Do I need to add these studies in my literature review? I find it strange that you have to write the lit review before findings etc because I feel like I'm having to constantly go back and update my lit review.

I know I can't add new studies in discussion chapter but is it okay in the findings chapters? Or does literally everything mentioned have to be included in lit review? Tearing my hair out, can't see the wood from the trees

Thanks in advance

OP posts:
greatbittern · 16/04/2022 20:38

Explain everything the first time you use it, like your "Do I..." question.

Make sure you define key terms too, particularly where there are different possible definitions (and show why you are using that definition), or where you use the word in a specialist sense but it could be misunderstood as a lay person's understanding.

dissertationhell · 16/04/2022 18:15

Okay last question I swear! I have included a table of abbreviations at the start. However, can I just start using them straight away.

For instance, AUD - alcohol use disorder is one of my abbreviations.

Do I then have to say, 'when exploring alcohol use disorder (AUD)...'

Or can I just jump straight into, 'when exploring AUD...' as it is included in the abbreviations table?

OP posts:
ExMachinaDeus · 16/04/2022 16:28

So, yes, it really is marker discretion which is why I suggested asking her supervisor directly.

In a well-run course, with sensible staff, it should not be down to "marker discretion." As an examiner, I need to be fair to all students by applying the same rules to each & every one of them and I need to trust that my colleagues will also do so.

And students need to know that they will all be marked in a fair & transparent way.

So please @dissertationhell try to get your diss down to 11,000 words - that's already 1,000 more words than the word limit. The extra 10% is a concession, because we know that it's not easy to get your work to an exact word count - but it's not a target! There will be occasions in your professional life when you will have to meet a word limit very precisely, so it's a useful discipline.

And thank you for not disturbing your supervisor while she's on annual leave. As a colleague of mine used to say: "Your planning is not my emergency."

dissertationhell · 16/04/2022 15:45

I feel the end is in sight though and today is the first day I've felt some relief Grin

OP posts:
dissertationhell · 16/04/2022 15:44

@bottleofbeer

Ex, that is entirely based upon your discretion. I had a module leader once tell us that she not only expected us to use the full extra 10% but more! However, she didn't feel the need to let the other markers know so I was marked down for going over when she was absolutely clear, that not using the 10% + would cause her to mark down.

So, yes, it really is marker discretion which is why I suggested asking her supervisor directly.

She's on annual leave until submission day Sad I will trim it I think just to be on safe side. Going to try and at least reword my conclusion tomorrow and see if I can put in some of her feedback.
OP posts:
bottleofbeer · 16/04/2022 15:25

Ex, that is entirely based upon your discretion. I had a module leader once tell us that she not only expected us to use the full extra 10% but more! However, she didn't feel the need to let the other markers know so I was marked down for going over when she was absolutely clear, that not using the 10% + would cause her to mark down.

So, yes, it really is marker discretion which is why I suggested asking her supervisor directly.

ExMachinaDeus · 16/04/2022 15:21

I think it would be petty in the extreme to mark you down or stop reading at such a small % over.

Yes, but ... as a marker, where should I stop?

The word limit is 10,000 words. I wish students would realise the word limit is the word limit - it's a part of the assignment task - to complete the task within the word limit. It's a bit of academic discipline.

So, as a marker, do I read the extra 10%, plus the extra 10% of that 10% extra?

Word limits are not arbitrary - they're there for a reason, and they're about the overall shape and limits of a research project.

bottleofbeer · 16/04/2022 14:51

240 words is a few sentences.

bottleofbeer · 16/04/2022 14:47

I think it would be petty in the extreme to mark you down or stop reading at such a small % over.

greatbittern · 16/04/2022 14:46

I'd not be overly concerned about that but you don't really want to go much higher. Leave binning 200 words until just before you submit and concentrate on a decent conclusion now.

dissertationhell · 16/04/2022 14:43

@bottleofbeer so the bill word limit is 10,000 +/- 10 percent which is 11,000. So I'm sitting at 11,260. Think that's too much ?

OP posts:
greatbittern · 16/04/2022 14:41

Obviously not having seen your conclusion it's hard to say, but a good conclusion can make a big difference in the dissertations I've marked. Have a look at this and see whether yours is up to the job.

libguides.usc.edu/writingguide/conclusion

I'd try to use fb if I can, she gave it for a reason.

bottleofbeer · 16/04/2022 14:33

I think you will probably get away with 140 words over. As for the second question, that really is dependent on your marker (and second marker) and their discretion. Explain your dilemma and ask her outright. You can actually ask them what kind of things they tend to mark up and down on!

dissertationhell · 16/04/2022 14:09

Update: I have 120 words to cut back now. I have heavily cut back on quotes etc and added a lot more analysis and am feeling much better about it. However, she made suggestions to add to the conclusion chapter. I'm just not going to have enough room to implement them, so I'm thinking at this point I'm not going to change my conclusion section and leave as is? I'm just waiting on it printing so I can look at it on paper to see where else I can cut back on. Do you think not taking on her feed back in conclusion section is going to massively effect my grade?

@bottleofbeer I've done that Smile thank you though as you made me go back and double check

OP posts:
bottleofbeer · 16/04/2022 12:14

Ah yeah, at the very least make sure you add the email from the ethics board which gives you the go ahead to begin research. You can actually fail if you don't put that in the appendix.

dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 22:13

My friend is going to print me it off tomorrow so I can read it on paper and score things out, should help, however, I think rejigging findings will free up some space.

OP posts:
dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 22:12

[quote greatbittern]You might find this useful

www.phrasebank.manchester.ac.uk/[/quote]
Very useful thank you

OP posts:
gingerhills · 15/04/2022 21:50

Is it too late to add a paragraph to your literature review to incorporate these new findings?

greatbittern · 15/04/2022 21:36

You might find this useful

www.phrasebank.manchester.ac.uk/

dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 21:02

@Flyonawalk

Nothing intelligent to add, but as a one-time literature student I wanted to say that I really like the sound of your work. I wish you great success Flowers
Thank you, that's nice to hear. I feel so deep in it just now that I can't tell if it's a load of shite or great!
OP posts:
Flyonawalk · 15/04/2022 20:58

Nothing intelligent to add, but as a one-time literature student I wanted to say that I really like the sound of your work. I wish you great success Flowers

user10497432 · 15/04/2022 20:53

Another dissertation supervisor here. Ways to get the word count down based on problems I often see:

Decide whether the quotes really add anything. Do they duplicate each other? Can you quote fewer words to say the core message?
Can you use a diagram to present data visually with a short verbal summary?
Have you got context / background in the intro that is kind of interesting but not central to your question?
Print it off and you'll see repetition, waffle and redundancy more easily.
Step away from a bit and do another section rather than sweating over it - you'll see problems more easily after a break.

dissertationhell · 15/04/2022 20:51

@Rosylarose

Can I also say; you've got this OP. This is YOUR dissertation, in the way YOU choose to present it. And that is absolutely enough.
Aww thank you so much! Smile
OP posts:
VerveClique · 15/04/2022 20:40

I did mine roughly like this and still write reports in this way:

Background/rationale
Methodology
Literature review - from this you create a themed theoretical framework
Findings: review findings according to each theme in the theoretical framework
Conclusions: present conclusions according to each theme in the theoretical framework
Recommendations for implementation / future research
Bibliography
Appendices containing qualitative data

Rosylarose · 15/04/2022 20:33

Can I also say; you've got this OP. This is YOUR dissertation, in the way YOU choose to present it. And that is absolutely enough.