Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for dissertation help please!?

88 replies

dissertationhell · 14/04/2022 22:40

I have made an account especially for this after years of lurking. My dissertation is due in 4 days. My supervisor is on holiday. I have everything written I am just heavily editing everything. I am analysing my findings over two findings chapters.

My question is, when analysing my findings, can I bring in previous studies there if they aren't in my literature review? For instance, when analysing my findings I've found that reading between the lines, there appears to be feelings of shame and guilt emerging as well as justification for alcohol use. I've found studies to back up that there is a higher prevalence of shame and guilt in individuals with addiction but haven't wrote about that in my literature review.

Do I need to add these studies in my literature review? I find it strange that you have to write the lit review before findings etc because I feel like I'm having to constantly go back and update my lit review.

I know I can't add new studies in discussion chapter but is it okay in the findings chapters? Or does literally everything mentioned have to be included in lit review? Tearing my hair out, can't see the wood from the trees

Thanks in advance

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bytrgrewd · 19/04/2022 21:25

This thread is full of useful tips thank you.

bottleofbeer · 18/04/2022 21:57

You know? I don't care. I commented to try and help someone and I respect you and your job

surreygirl1987 · 18/04/2022 21:52

Thanks for the compliment. Nice to have my job thought of as 'amazing'... not something teachers hear very often.

bottleofbeer · 18/04/2022 21:44

Ps, well done dropping your amazing job in while telling me I talk shit.

bottleofbeer · 18/04/2022 21:43

Ok babe x

surreygirl1987 · 18/04/2022 21:27

No, i agree that it's not obvious that you are (or 'may' be) anywhere near that qualified, judging by the rubbish you have been spouting!

(PS I work in a private school, and fees cost a small fortune - far more than uni fees. And I still feel that it is ridiculously entitled for me to be expected to avoid holidays during holiday time because pupils/parents expect me to be available 24/7! Utter rubbish!).

bottleofbeer · 18/04/2022 21:22

Yeah, I'd feel bloody entitled with the money it costs now.

Maybe It's not obvious, but I may not be any less qualified than you Wink

surreygirl1987 · 18/04/2022 21:14

While you're sitting off telling me about my ignorance? Do you have any idea who I am or what I do?

Nope.

What the fuck do you do, genius?

I don't know about @ExMachinaDeus but I have a doctorate and have taught at a top university... and can reliably let you know that supervisors have every right to take leave outside of term time, even if a dissertation or thesis is due. In fact, even my doctoral supervisor did, the week of my thesis submission! Drafts and final submissions come in all year round, not just once a year, and if a supervisor tried to avoid all those dates he or she would never be able to get away!

I'm a schoolteacher now actually, and often have the same ignorant attitude from pupils/parents. They wonder why I have the audacity to go on holiday and not be available via email over Easter holidays or May half term, in the run-up to A Level and GCSE exams, or why I'm not available for pupils over a holiday when a coursework essay is due following it. The entitlement is amazing.

bottleofbeer · 18/04/2022 21:02

While you're sitting off telling me about my ignorance? Do you have any idea who I am or what I do?

Nope.

What the fuck do you do, genius?

bottleofbeer · 18/04/2022 21:00

Yes, I have NO idea about higher education at all.

Except I fucking do 😆

surreygirl1987 · 18/04/2022 20:46

Ffs, if you are supervising such an important part of people's lives then DON'T book annual holiday when the dissertations are due.

This is such an utterly ridiculous comment!

ExMachinaDeus · 18/04/2022 19:54

@bottleofbeer your post shows you have no idea about how academic study - as an academic or a Masters students - is organised.

It is entirely reasonable for the academic to take annual leave and also not to work on Bank holidays! We're only allowed to take such leave outside of teaching terms, and the time over the Easter Bank holidays is usually not used for teaching - my university closed on Maundy Thursday and won't re-open until tomorrow.

And a Masters student should be independent enough to have a final supervision several weeks before the submission date, so that their supervisor can read a draft, and give feedback for the student to implement.

If the Masters student doesn't have a near-to-final draft at least 2 weeks before submission date, then they haven't planned their time particularly well. Or they've had difficult circumstances to deal with, which are actually nothing to do with the supervisor's reasonable annual leave.

But hey, you go on showing your ignorance of the work of trained experts & insulting them. It's a good look for you.

bottleofbeer · 18/04/2022 19:31

Ffs, if you are supervising such an important part of people's lives then DON'T book annual holiday when the dissertations are due.

Crikey.

surreygirl1987 · 17/04/2022 22:59

Hey, I have two masters degrees and have just completed my doctorate. Yes, you need to include everything in your lit review- it is an iterative rather than linear process, and will evolve to the end.

As for word count, cutting down words is the bit I find hardest, but I did cut out over 40,000 words on my thesis! Have you tried all the easy tricks, like deleting the space between the p. and the number (eg p.7 instead of p. 7)?

I'm afraid I WOULD use the full wording before using an abbreviation, despite the table.

I would also not risk going above the 10% concession. You honestly do not have a lit to cut out - it's just a tedious task.

gingerhills · 17/04/2022 22:20

[quote greatbittern]@bottleofbeer "She gets paid enough"? You obviously have no idea how much many academics get paid and the long hours they work for it.

They also have a right to take a break, like every other worker.[/quote]
In some unis, academics don't get paid at all to take on a PhD student. they are expected to just absorb the extra reading, thinking, planning, email exchanges and supervision within their working week.

And academics don't get paid enough. I know lots who are paid £20-something per contact hour, which doesn't begin to equate to the actual time spent reading, prepping, rehearsing lectures, choosing images, extracts, arranging printouts, answering student emails, all unpaid and outside of 'contact' hours. Very few are on fixed salaries in my field,

greatbittern · 17/04/2022 09:34

@bottleofbeer "She gets paid enough"? You obviously have no idea how much many academics get paid and the long hours they work for it.

They also have a right to take a break, like every other worker.

ExMachinaDeus · 17/04/2022 06:44

@bottleofbeer the supervisor is on annual leave and presumably told her students this. It’s the OP’s responsibility to have organised her time around this.

I tell my supervisees that to read a 10,000 word PhD chapter I need it at least 2 weeks before a supervision tutorial. It is the student’s responsibility to organise themselves if they want feedback on drafts.

And it’s Easter- totally reasonable to take leave. When an academic is on annual leave, they are not obliged to work. They’re on leave.

bottleofbeer · 17/04/2022 01:41

Oh bless, not bothering her supervisor.

How much debt did you get in, love? Don't you deserve your investment worth?

Bug the shit out of her, this is your future. She gets paid enough.

RainySmarties · 16/04/2022 22:17

@amusedbush

I'm doing a PhD and my supervisor says the literature review is an iterative process, so it develops and grows as more avenues emerge during data collection. However, my internal assessor says you shouldn't add everything you find to your literature review because you want your own results to add some novel contribution, not just support what you've already found in the lit review.
If someone has had the same findings as you the you absolutely need to add this to your list review. Not mentioning similar work doesn't make your work novel. You must mention it and then justify why your work or findings are still novel or how they add to this particular field.

In my subject when I did my PhD it was ok to add references later though I'd probably put them in the discussion or conclusion rather than the chapters where you describe your work and results.

What I actually did was to have a small discussion at the end of each chapter where I would include relevant references that would have disrupted the flow of the literature review.

JanetandJohn500 · 16/04/2022 22:11

Oh my goodness, I am 17000 words into an 18000 word dissertation (with a 2500 word conclusion/recommendations section to write) and I've found this thread so useful to piggy back off!
Thanks to everyone who has offered advice

changeu123 · 16/04/2022 21:58

My last message didn't post. But my dyslexia tutor says to use only one word in a sentence, and it helps cut the number of words you use and keeps it concise.

Mine is due next month - good luck with it.

goingpearshaped · 16/04/2022 21:41

Sorry, that's our guidance, we don't have a plus minus 10% although I know others do.

starynight21 · 16/04/2022 21:40

Just seen some other comments about your conclusion.

My PhD supervisor told me that the conclusion should new insights that were developed from the overall discussion and analysis. I think it should start with a summary of what your dissertation aimed to do, the objectives perhaps and a brief overview of the research gap that you are trying to fill.

For my supervisor he is not worried about word count and he was also my masters supervisor. Being within the 10% is fine and it’s more important you include key information and don’t delete important quotes that are relevant.

That’s not to say you can’t down the words. Look at sentences that can be shorter with saying the same thing. For example,

“A large growing body of literature found that alcoholism is caused by…”

You could just have “Research has found or research shows…”

Good luck. I am sure you will do great.

goingpearshaped · 16/04/2022 21:40

Late to this bit check word count guidance. See have penalties for exceeding, it is never worth it. One word over to 15 percent over equals a ten mark deduction. Check and good luck!

starynight21 · 16/04/2022 21:34

It really depends on the structure of your findings.

For example in my undergraduate and master’s dissertations, I had a findings and discussion section as one section. I wrote a qualitative dissertation so this was the way I did it and I got a 1st class. The examples you provided, I did the same as you were thinking. The articles you reference and refer to though should also be discussed within the lit review.

But say your findings is one section and then you have a separate discussion section then the reference and comparison between your own findings and previous studies should be in the discussion.

Drawing those comparisons between your findings and previous work is important as it further identifies research gaps and areas of further research as recommendations.

I would suggest you speak to your class mates and ask them. Different institutions may have their own preference as do supervisors.

Has your supervisor not read your findings or analysis section to provide feedback?

What I would say is that when bringing in a comparison of the literature with your own work or even in the literature review itself, the biggest lessons I have learned in my PhD to date is to read between the lines and understand the key learning and show what they found (not studied) and what this means?

It is also important to hold the readers hand and never assume they will know something. Explain in your introduction for example what you will cover and don’t bring anything new in without first showing in an introduction what you will discuss.

Swipe left for the next trending thread