Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still be upset my dad smacked me as a child

238 replies

WonderingSally · 14/04/2022 21:42

I've always wondered how normal my childhood was. I was born in 1988, and can remember often being smacked as a child. Thinking about it I was a good kid, I got straight As, never got in trouble, head girl at school etc. But probably at least every 2/3 weeks I ended up with a smack for often stupid reasons - I don't remember most, but one that sticks out was drying my hair for too long, that kind of level of naughtiness. Always for things I'd done wrong around the house.

AIBU to think this wasn't normal even in the 90s? Or did smacking just happen in those days? I've always wondered what happened in other households but too scared to ask incase I find out my dad is definitely a dick

OP posts:
CatherineCookson · 14/04/2022 22:19

70s child .. got physically and mentally abused by my father from 11 upwards. I was a good kid at school, a little too clever for my own good at times, but did nothing out of the ordinary. Belted for ridiculous things (wore a dirty coat on a paper round). I got away lightly as my brothers had it worse but then they had each other for support. When they left home it was just me against him, my mum who turned a blind eye and a conniving snake of a sister.

You're not wrong to be upset but try to not let it swamp your life. It wasn't your fault. It took me till 30 and counselling to move on. It wasn't great times and I sometimes wonder what if to a lot if things... but I can't change it only control what I do now. Hopefully you find peaceful times ahead.

Herja · 14/04/2022 22:18

My mum once beat me with a saw (got taken off her for a few months then, so not seen as reasonable by family), definitely smacked and had a range of awful punishments when I was small. Didn't happen for that sort of thing though, I would have done something fairly serious. Similar age to you OP.

Tulipblacksmith · 14/04/2022 22:18

@crackingreward

I think she meant teen MH is worse than ever and this is despite better parenting.

Onlyforcake · 14/04/2022 22:17

Yeah I was born in the mid 70s and was hit very frequently for a range of things, often very trivial, like not remembering to turn off the landing light

People who hit/ smack s child are just awful human beings who have no self control. I've seen both my parents lose their shit over trivial things as an adult and its totally pathetic, they have no way of expressing anger, disappointment in any other way than rage.

I've no respect for them or anyone who would rather whack a child than work on themselves.

Tulipblacksmith · 14/04/2022 22:17

@WonderingSally

I think that is the issue. No one has spoke about it since? I was born in 88 but I have a teen and older kids so I have had more years to reflect.

Healing can be achieved but only really if your parents admit it was wrong for them to smack you. Maybe ask them about their views now on children being smacked? that might open the can of worms.

crackingreward · 14/04/2022 22:15

[quote Tulipblacksmith]@crackingreward

what do you mean out parent mental illness?[/quote]

Maybe I misread?

I thought the post said that there is a higher level of self harm and CAMHS referrals even though the parents were like dinosaurs. I just don't see the correlation.

Tulipblacksmith · 14/04/2022 22:13

@MrPoppysParka

I do not see a problem with the word smack. I was smacked by my mother and I was hit by my father. If you have experienced both there is most certainly a difference.

NuffSaidSam · 14/04/2022 22:13

I'm a similar age and was smacked growing up by both parents, but probably only once every few month or so, if that. It wasn't a regular occurrence (and I was a difficult child). It was only as a small child as well, never as an older child/teenager.

Tulipblacksmith · 14/04/2022 22:12

@crackingreward

what do you mean out parent mental illness?

Sciurus83 · 14/04/2022 22:11

Born in 1983, was never smacked, parents very against it. Sorry so many of you experienced it.

MrPoppysParka · 14/04/2022 22:08

Totally aware I referred to it as smacking myself there 🙈

WonderingSally · 14/04/2022 22:08

Thank you for all of the responses - honestly it feels sad that so many experienced it as children, but it's feeling therapeutic reading that I wasn't alone.

My family have never spoken about it. What brought it home was having children my self and it feeling so unnatural for a dad to smack his daughter. I've never left my kids with them because we've never had the chat, and if someone can hit a child once, surely their buttons could be pressed again

OP posts:
MrPoppysParka · 14/04/2022 22:07

Can we stop calling it smacking and say it for what it is, hitting.
Born in the mid 80s, never smacked. My mum was born in the 50s and never smacked.

crackingreward · 14/04/2022 22:07

We might also ask the big questions - are teenagers today any happier or more well - balanced than teens 20 or 30 years ago? Because I'm not sure they are. I look at my children and their peers, and see an epidemic of self-harm manifested in various ways. CAMHS overwhelmed. I'm not seeing clear and obvious evidence that things nowadays are so much better than they were in the 1990s, despite how I thought at the time that my parents were dinosaurs who were doing it all wrong.

I don't think you can out parent mental illness.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 14/04/2022 22:06

Smacking was more acceptable then, but only for actual bad behaviour (being cheeky, disobedient, rude, stealing your parents cigarettes etc). It sounds like your DF took it to excess and smacked you for reasons which, even at the time, did not merit it.

Abouttimemum · 14/04/2022 22:06

I was born in the early 80s and my parents didn’t ever smack me, or even really shout at me to be honest.
My DH was born at the same time and was smacked all the time, although he had a very abusive childhood and his parents would be jailed in this day and age, so not really comparable.

Sapphire387 · 14/04/2022 22:05

I was smacked as a child. Occasionally. And for really bad misbehaviour. It has not damaged my relationship with my parents.

People are very anti-smacking on here, but I don't believe the world is black and white and that it is always wrong under every circumstance. But it is stories like yours that make people feel this way, I think, and not stories like mine.

I believe there is a world of difference between what I am describing, and what you are describing. I am not surprised you are still upset, because it sounds like you were punished with casual violence. And that is poor parenting, and I am sorry you were subjected to it.

Yoohoo778611 · 14/04/2022 22:03

Born in 1960 was smacked a lot.
Also received the belt as dad had a short fuse.
I remember going to school with thick strap bruises up my legs.
I was 9.
All because I didn't dry a plate properly.
I went to a Catholic school but not one teacher showed any concern.

DivorcedAndDelighted · 14/04/2022 22:02

When I hear that people were smacked as a child, I assume it was regular, as in every few weeks. I was born in the early 70s and that was normal. By the 1990s I was having my own kids and I'd say smacking was still common but it was changing.

Either way, I doubt that it adds much to your life to focus on this now. I think it's misleading to look at the past through today's lens because we are social animals, and social norms have changed so much.
We might also ask the big questions - are teenagers today any happier or more well - balanced than teens 20 or 30 years ago? Because I'm not sure they are. I look at my children and their peers, and see an epidemic of self-harm manifested in various ways. CAMHS overwhelmed. I'm not seeing clear and obvious evidence that things nowadays are so much better than they were in the 1990s, despite how I thought at the time that my parents were dinosaurs who were doing it all wrong.

crackingreward · 14/04/2022 22:02

I was born in 76 and I was never smacked. My Nanna was born in 1930 and was never smacked. She never smacked her own. She could see it for what it was and both her and my great gran had a really forward thinking approach to raising their families. I think the 'it was of the time' Is a real cop out. People knew hitting children wasn't nice, and saying 'but it was common' is no excuse. I'm sorry but I disagree that it was simply generational.

Barleysugar85 · 14/04/2022 22:02

Born in the eighties, earlier than you. We were smacked about once a month, stopped by our teenage years, mainly for deliberately naughty things (think- eating chocolate out of my sisters party bag I knew was hers!). I'd consider I have a good relationship with my parents generally, although obviously I couldn't imagine parenting my kids that way now.

SecondhandTable · 14/04/2022 22:01

I was born in the 90s and I was smacked by my DF. Not loads, and I can remember the context of any of it happening, so it definitely wasn't a super common occurrence. However it definitely did happen and I remember a few times he hit my younger sibling too. I don't know about the very youngest sibling but I assume they got the same treatment too. It was scary and upsetting and the threat of it was probably quite effective in some ways at containing our behaviour tbh. I remember my DM getting fed up with us and saying "right, wait til I tell your DF about this when he gets home" and the terror we would all feel. He's such a loving man as well but he was definitely walloped as a child (a lot more and a lot more violently than us, I think). He also has a lot of trauma in his childhood and youth and beyond tbh so has always struggled with his mental health and consequently his temper. I'm not excusing it as neither me nor DH have ever hit our children and I hope we never will! However I don't feel particularly angry towards my DF for it, he was (and I guess still is) just trying his best, as most parents are. Everyone is a product of their own experiences and upbringings. It's funny seeing him now with my toddler, I bet the idea of hitting her would seem absurd to him now too. He's definitely mellowed in some ways as he's gotten older. I should say too though that he is not from the UK and comes from a very different culture where parents have a much more authoritarian role and smacking is widely seen as socially acceptable if not even a necessary part of parenting tbh.

Todaystopic · 14/04/2022 22:00

God this thread is depressing. I’m glad we have progressed when it comes to smacking our children, horrible.

XjustagirlX · 14/04/2022 21:59

I was smacked in the 90s. However my parents don’t smack their grandchildren. And we all have a good relationship.

Rockmehardplace · 14/04/2022 21:58

@Kite22

I was going to say YABU, from the title, but it does sound like you were smacked all the time, for absolutely no real reason. So that does sound awful.

When people talk about them being 'smacked as a child' I always assume they mean once or twice in their life time.

Near daily occurrence house growing up. I know it was definitely more, and more severe, than in other houses but don’t think I realised quite HOW much more. But nothing I can do about it now.

My siblings and I have never smacked any of our children.