Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still be upset my dad smacked me as a child

238 replies

WonderingSally · 14/04/2022 21:42

I've always wondered how normal my childhood was. I was born in 1988, and can remember often being smacked as a child. Thinking about it I was a good kid, I got straight As, never got in trouble, head girl at school etc. But probably at least every 2/3 weeks I ended up with a smack for often stupid reasons - I don't remember most, but one that sticks out was drying my hair for too long, that kind of level of naughtiness. Always for things I'd done wrong around the house.

AIBU to think this wasn't normal even in the 90s? Or did smacking just happen in those days? I've always wondered what happened in other households but too scared to ask incase I find out my dad is definitely a dick

OP posts:
VivaLaRaza · 14/04/2022 22:48

I was born in 1975 and was smacked a lot. It was always when I’d been naughty and not for no reason. It was never a beating, but a smack on the butt or legs or a smack on my wrist. I’m very close to my parents and see them pretty much every day. The worst was probably when I was brought home by the police for shoplifting sweets at Woolworths. Got a few slaps for that and I never stole anything ever again.

NameChange74567 · 14/04/2022 22:48

Yanbu, I was smacked physically abused by both Mum and Dad and it still bothers me. M only stopped when I started hitting her back. I moved out when I was 17 because D never stopped

I remember one particular night D gave me a right beating, I went into the bathroom afterwards and M was in there crying. I asked her why and she said she thought he was going to kill me. Not enough for her to actually try and stop him or anything, just sit in another room and listen to me screaming and begging him to stop.

I still speak to them but we have a terrible relationship.

Heartofglass12345 · 14/04/2022 22:47

We were smacked but not very often I don't think. My mum had serious anger issues though and would regularly throw things. She does talk about my oldest sister and how she smacked her more than any of us as she was the naughtiest (obviously didn't work then Hmm)
She has told the story more than once of the time my sister told her it didn't hurt, so she smacked her harder and harder, as if it was funny! We were born late 70's early 80's.

My sister and BIL used to smack my niece and nephew, my niece a lot as she was like my sister by the sounds of it, you'd think she would've realised it doesn't work Sad I even remember turning up at my sisters house on Christmas Day and my BIL telling us my niece had had a few smacks already. Fucking awful.

These replies are why it annoys me when people say 'oh there's nothing wrong with a tap on the bum, it's not abuse' these stories prove otherwise! They do it because they are angry and have lost it, they aren't just giving a tap on the bum.

DramaAlpaca · 14/04/2022 22:47

This thread is shocking, I'm sorry some of you went through that.

I'm a 60s child, and while my relationship with my parents wasn't great, I was never hit. My own DC were born in the 90s and were also never hit, ever. It's not OK.

Pllink · 14/04/2022 22:45

Also born in 88 and my parents never laid a finger on me. My cousin ('87) used to get smacked by his Dad and we were always shocked by it. Sad how many people think/thought it was normal.

Allthestarsabovemyhead · 14/04/2022 22:43

@crackingreward

I didn’t say you behaved like that. I said how children in my class did.

Tulipblacksmith · 14/04/2022 22:42

@DivorcedAndDelighted

It would be hard to evidence as I am sure not all smacks were the same. I am certain my father was too heavy handed. I was extremely afraid of him. Some people wont have that experience, and will be completely unscathed from their experiences of being smacked.

Koigarden · 14/04/2022 22:42

I was born early 70’s. We were smacked, usually with the wooden spoon. I don’t know anyone that wasn’t smacked. Teachers at school would smack you too, we had one that used yo hit us across the knuckles with the wooden metre ruler. My husband, same age, regular got the slipper at school.

I can’t really remember what my mum smacked us for, probably arguing with each other.

I’ve never smacked my own kids but being smacked as a child hasn’t affected me in any way that I know of.

Supersimkin2 · 14/04/2022 22:38

I was bitten. Teacher at primary school had a taste for the small children - someone’s parents saw the teeth marks and complained.

Teacher stayed.

Tulipblacksmith · 14/04/2022 22:38

The ones acting like that probably did get smacked. It's learnt behaviour and they are externalising their anger at being hit.

Looking back I was an angry kid. I got into a few fights. I was not afraid of a single peer. No need to be when you already face a bigger beast at home. Sometimes my friends at school would cry over small things. I used to think they were pathetic. They weren't. They were simply just showing emotion that I probably wasn't allowed too.

I am glad as a society we have all moved on now.

Sometimeswinning · 14/04/2022 22:37

80s child. I was smacked. My parents were smacked and my dad had the cane at school! I don't smack my children because attitudes to consequences have changed (I couldn't ever imagine doing it, but that could be a learned thing as times changed)

I don't care how my parents disciplined me, I have lovely memories growing up. I wouldn't look at it as being 'smacked' as being your issue. There was probably alot more going on.

DivorcedAndDelighted · 14/04/2022 22:35

[quote Tulipblacksmith]@crackingreward

I think she meant teen MH is worse than ever and this is despite better parenting.[/quote]
Yes, that's what I meant, thank you. I don't think we know all the answers yet. I don't want to go back to the days of routine smacking - I couldn't bear to do it - , but I don't think we have real evidence that it produced worse outcomes than more recent norms, in terms of child mental health. There are more variables to consider of course, but if the old approach was so very wrong and the current approach so much better, wouldn't we expect to have seen vast improvements in child and adolescent mental health? I may be wrong, but I'm not aware of any evidence that kids and teens nowadays are better off in that respect. Perhaps there is some? I'd be genuinely interested to know. Time and experience has only left me feeling that I have fewer answers than I thought I had 25 years ago!

Concestor · 14/04/2022 22:34

Mid 70s child here. Both my parents would use the slipper on me, my mum wore ones with heels so that really hurt. She also once boxed my ears - hit me repeatedly around the head - for the crime of not being able to fit all the shopping in the freezer. I locked myself in the bathroom after that one.
They claim they never hit me. They seem to have blanked out out our something, but I remember being hit, hard, for very small things. Even now if my husband gets angry (he almost never does) I automatically cower as my subconscious is expecting me to be hit.
My brother didn't get the same treatment, he remembers childhood as lovely whereas I still have trauma. But he used to hit me too, I guess I was the family scapegoat though I don't know why. I was really good, top student, behaved myself, but just was never good enough for them.

carefullycourageous · 14/04/2022 22:34

YANBU to still be upset. Being hit would have been physically painful and frightening. The fact it was commonplace does not change that.

I agree you might benefit from speaking to a counsellor.

One thing that is really positive is because you acknowledge the upset of it means you have not lied to yourself that 'it never did me any harm' - you still have your truth.

crackingreward · 14/04/2022 22:33

I saw how other children behaved at school compared to us Asian kids. They were disruptive, badly behaved, talked back to teachers etc. I knew they were like that because their parents never hit them.

Oh shut up I have never behaved like that in my life Hmm

Katya213 · 14/04/2022 22:33

I was born in the late 70s. I was smacked on a daily basis by my mum, I wasn’t naughty she just used to get stressed with whoever her boyfriend was at the time and launch herself at myself and my sisters. We went to school covered in bruises but not a word said or a question asked.

Allthestarsabovemyhead · 14/04/2022 22:32

Born in kid 90s and I was smacked. However this is usual in my parents culture. I knew kids at school probably didn’t get smacked but all my Asian friends did. I was never smacked by my grandmothers. I think it’s usual for grandparents not to hit grandchildren despite hitting their own kids. Some smacks I deserved but I did feel I would get smacked for the littlest things. For example, getting a question wrong or hesitating on a question. If I’m brutally honest, I saw how other children behaved at school compared to us Asian kids. They were disruptive, badly behaved, talked back to teachers etc. I knew they were like that because their parents never hit them.

Dancer47 · 14/04/2022 22:31

I was born in the 1960s and smacked. The worst was at junior school where we would be smacked in the face and legs, thumped in the back - and worst of all - our long hair pulled (we all had long hair).
The female teachers were the worst by far.
I remember when my little brother was smacked or hit I would jumped in and try to defend him. I feel like crying when I think about it.
I was from a respectable and quite normal family. Parents were educated people.

None of my 4 grandparents ever hit us, although my grandfather had a cane under the dining room table. My first boyfriend used to be hit with a belt across his back. At grammar school we had very harsh corporal punishment. Again, the women teachers were far worse than the men - quite cruel in fact. I don't like women very much, even though I am one. I know how very cruel they can be.

Tulipblacksmith · 14/04/2022 22:30

@crackingreward

One possible reason why could be due to the rise in permissive parenting? Often by guilt ridden parents who they themselves were smacked/hit as kids so now do the complete opposite. This can result in overly anxious and unhappy teens.

It is the polar opposite to authoritarian parenting that many of us received.

Ultimately the balance is authoritative parenting (the best outcomes). Strong, firm boundaries without the abuse or the permissiveness. It can be a hard balance to strike and no one gets it right all the time.

Also that is just one small aspect perhaps contributing to teen MH. I realise it is not so simplistic and they face pressures in todays society that we never did.

DDIJ · 14/04/2022 22:30

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

OutlookStalking · 14/04/2022 22:29

I also remember mum telling me I had super sensitive skin which I believed into adult hood - as her grabbing my arm /smacking me left hand prints. Hmmmmm

OutlookStalking · 14/04/2022 22:28

Wow I always assumed people that said they got smacked as a kid in 80s meant regularly - just as some parents use the naughty step now.

It was certainly regularly in our house, several times a week. And we had the "heads bashed together" a few times.

Once I rememeber preschool age hearing someone say "shut up" on tv and I was so shocked as it was a rude word in our house and ran to tell my mum! She only heard shut up and walloped me. I remember thinking when I grow up I was going to invent trousers with padding in the legs 😞.

I still don't know whether this was "normal for 80s" I think for some families it was.

Rupertgrintismyguiltypleasure · 14/04/2022 22:28

I was born in 88 and I too was smacked. Only for major things and not that often. I knew then I was in the shit. Most of the time if we were misbehaving my parents gave me the look.... which I now use on my kids and it works a treat, no smacking needed.
I think smacking just faded tbh, I think people started making a big deal about kids rights and that was that. I’ve never felt the need to hit my kids. Not sure why I just haven’t.

HisHX · 14/04/2022 22:24

I was born around the same time as you OP. I remember my Dad smacking me, but not that frequently, and not for nothing. I think I recall the context of all of them actually (< 10 times and always when I was particularly and objectively, badly behaved). I have an amazing relationship with my Dad now, but overall impression of him in childhood remains as a strict upbringing, with the occasional smack. I don’t recall a smack from my Mum, ever, so maybe a bit of a good cop/bad cop scenario, although I always felt they were completely aligned on principles.
I don’t hold any grudges whatsoever now, times have changed and ultimately they raised me well, but I wouldn’t do this to my (future) children.

crackingreward · 14/04/2022 22:22

[quote Tulipblacksmith]@crackingreward

I think she meant teen MH is worse than ever and this is despite better parenting.[/quote]

That was exactly my point.