Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still be upset my dad smacked me as a child

238 replies

WonderingSally · 14/04/2022 21:42

I've always wondered how normal my childhood was. I was born in 1988, and can remember often being smacked as a child. Thinking about it I was a good kid, I got straight As, never got in trouble, head girl at school etc. But probably at least every 2/3 weeks I ended up with a smack for often stupid reasons - I don't remember most, but one that sticks out was drying my hair for too long, that kind of level of naughtiness. Always for things I'd done wrong around the house.

AIBU to think this wasn't normal even in the 90s? Or did smacking just happen in those days? I've always wondered what happened in other households but too scared to ask incase I find out my dad is definitely a dick

OP posts:
Tulipblacksmith · 15/04/2022 09:26

@Anythingbutsnow

Never smacked my kids (despite getting hit myself).

I do know what you mean though. I’ve always put in firm boundaries and consequences but my kids still behave for their dad more. (He doesn’t smack them) but his presence in the house is a good thing because they behave better.

They love him to bits, it makes me wonder is it an instinctive thing? Do kids behave better for dads?

I’m glad I’m not a single mum they would run me bloody ragged. Hats off to all doing it on their own by the way.

florianfortescue · 15/04/2022 09:20

Born in '83 and got smacked regularly and threatened (although never actually hit with) "the wooden spoon". I hated it and will never lay a finger on my kids.

My DF was actually encouraging me the other day to consider smacking my 3-year-old! I said very sharply that I will never hit my children and he looked a bit shamefaced.

whatsinaname2 · 15/04/2022 09:16

I was born in 1980 and lived in fear of my dad returning home from sea. Thankfully, working away, he wasn't around much because when he was home my mum, me and my sisters all walked on eggshells. He smacked us all for any reason he could find. I hated him. But now looking back I can see that he genuinely thought he was disciplining us, not abusing us. He's been dead 15 years now and I'm at peace with it all. I think it was very common back then sadly.

WildCoasts · 15/04/2022 09:15

I was born in the 70s and got smacked. Teachers would smack us and use belts, straps and rulers as well. Friend's parents would smack other children who were visiting. I know when I entered the world my very first experience was getting a smack as doctor's believed if a baby didn't cry it hadn't started breathing and I didn't cry until I was smacked.

Cryingintherain99 · 15/04/2022 09:15

I always remember when I was about 9 (mid 1980s).
My mum (regular smacker) had wacked me across my shoulder blade (can't remember what I had done - probably answering back).
I had my swimming lesson that day, and remember my mum saying after that she felt mortified sitting watching me on the balcony.
Apparently I had a perfect imprint of an adult hand spread across my shoulder blade that my swimming costume revealed when I was sitting on the pool side with my back to all the parent spectators.

Being the 1980s the swimming instructors never mentioned it.

Anythingbutsnow · 15/04/2022 09:14

..... But there are so many posts on here from mum's tearing their hair out because they are at their wits end with their kids behavior. I was smacked as a kid and I grew up into a happy, balanced adult. To me, it seemed like a quick, efficient method to teach right from wrong.
I don't smack my kids now as I'm aware it's not acceptable, but my god the long drawn out process of naughty steps, no screen time etc etc do my head in!

OverByYer · 15/04/2022 09:07

I was smacked by both parents, normally for ‘answering back’ or as I would call it defending myself. I remember the frustration of not being able to have a voice so clearly and it’s really impacted on how I deal with conflict as an adult.
I know my parents regret smacking me now and we have a good relationship.
I smacked my eldest son once and I can honestly say I felt sick afterwards and never did it again.
I’m glad we have moved on.

DrSbaitso · 15/04/2022 09:06

Not unreasonable at all. Smacking is shit parenting and always was. Even if your family was otherwise good enough to offset the effects of it to a level that you personally find acceptable, or truly was too thick to realise that bashing your kids about isn't good, it's still shit parenting. And a child is never to blame for being damaged by shit parenting.

GooglyEyeballs · 15/04/2022 09:03

I was smacked as a kid. It doesn't really bother me today. It was just part of being a kid. I don't think I'd smack my own kids but I don't hold it against my parents. It was the norm for them and me and my siblings all turned out okay. My parents put a lot of effort into our behaviour and manners so I'm grateful to them for teaching us to be decent human beings. What you're describing sounds more like child abuse than punishing bad behaviour.

MeanderingGently · 15/04/2022 09:00

I am in my 60s and grew up when smacking was normal, but only for real bad behaviour. We knew the difference between a smack (with the hand) and abuse (being hit with implements, or repeated hitting for nothing, or being hit in rage around the head/face etc.) I am not condoning it, but even back then there was a "smack" and abuse, and they were different.

As my parents were good parents and never abusive, I thought nothing of it. It didn't colour my relationship with them in any way.

When I had my own children, they did receive the odd smack when they were vey little, but it was a long time ago and parenting has changed these days. If I had children now I certainly wouldn't smack them.....the thinking has changed and there are better ways.

Schooling has changed over the years too. When I was young, it was not unusual to receive "the ruler" up the arm in front of the class, and on rare occasions, a leg slap from the teacher. It's unthinkable these days. In my primary school school the 'cane' had almost gone out of use but it was used once. A boy had thrown stones to bring down a swallow's nest under the eaves of the school, he had stoned the parent birds and dropped the baby birds in the litter bin where the janitor had found them. The boy was caned for it. I remember quite clearly the school being told by the Headmaster in assembly that normally, they would not do such a thing but the cruelty shown by the boy required a serious punishment. I often wonder about that incident. Was cruelty to another living thing solved by cruelty to the perpetrator? I just don't know. What else would have been a fitting punishment? Does removing iPad use for a couple of weeks show a child what it feels like to be on the end of cruel treatment? Again, I really just don't know. I would never, NEVER agree to the cane being used today, but I also don't have any answers either.....

mycatisannoying · 15/04/2022 08:59

Was the norm for the day.

Eskarina1 · 15/04/2022 08:32

I was born in 1980 and I was smacked but for big things, not little things and normally I would get a warning first. All my friends were as well. My dad later apologised - they were taught it was how you parent.

My in laws hit my husband much more and for petty things. My mother in law once tried to hit him for ordering a ginger beer in a cafe. He was 35. They threatened to smack my kids too and like pp I told them this would result in me hitting them.

I once told my kids about being smacked as a child (I was explaining how perceptions of right and wrong change over time). They found it hysterical. The idea of me (or their dad), who loves them, deliberately hurting them is so alien to them it's funny. I'm glad they feel safe and I hold on to that feeling when they need a reason to follow my instructions, rather than obeying as I would have done.

ChipButtyCurrySauce · 15/04/2022 08:17

Smacking was a very very regular occurrence in our house. I was born 76, eldest of 3. Being the eldest I was ofcourse responsible for the behaviour of the other 2. If they were naughty they had a smack. Then I had one for not making them behave. I was 5 when that started!

And when I say smack, it was anywhere between a slap on the thigh (skirts/dresses were lifted or trousers pulled down) and a full on beating. With implements. Usually slippers, shoes, wooden handled bread boards, wooden spoon. For a few years it was a feather duster (plastic coated metal handle) or a bamboo cane. I was 17 the last time my mother slapped me. For spilling some pop.

Icequeen01 · 15/04/2022 01:07

@Yoohoo778611

Born in 1960 was smacked a lot. Also received the belt as dad had a short fuse. I remember going to school with thick strap bruises up my legs. I was 9. All because I didn't dry a plate properly. I went to a Catholic school but not one teacher showed any concern.
Exactly the same here except I was 5 or 6 when I remember going to school with the belt marks. It still makes me flinch when DH pulls his belt out quickly from his trousers! My dad also used to hit me round the face really hard and once hit me on the head with a paint roller when we started arguing when I was a teenager,

I have never hit my own child.

CapMarvel · 15/04/2022 00:24

It might have been normal but it was never right.

I cannot imagine ever hitting my kids. Never. Only fucking arseholes do that.

Maves · 15/04/2022 00:23

@hangrylady

Born 1979. My Dad never raised a gand to me. Mum used to do a comedy chasing me with a wooden spoon but we'd both end up laughing. The only time she ever hit me was a slap across the face when I was about 15. I deserved that slap.
We used to get beat with the wooden spoon 😂
crackingreward · 15/04/2022 00:21

I was smacked when I took some penny sweets from a shop and quite rightly thinking back
It scared me , I never done anything like that ever again

There is no fear factor nowadays

Good. Children should r be frightened of their parents Sad

IceTippedMountains · 15/04/2022 00:14

I was born early 1990s, I was smacked maybe a dozen times (max) in my whole childhood so it was only when I committed something seriously bad. My dad and mum were both physically punished as a child by his own father so its very inter-generational and even in the 90s there was still an acceptance of smacking.

It has not traumatised me (probably because it was not a regular occurance and you could say it was justified), however I would never smack my kids.

crispsarny · 15/04/2022 00:13

@Yoohoo778611

Born in 1960 was smacked a lot. Also received the belt as dad had a short fuse. I remember going to school with thick strap bruises up my legs. I was 9. All because I didn't dry a plate properly. I went to a Catholic school but not one teacher showed any concern.
Sorry to you @Yoohoo778611 & everyone else here who suffered childhood abuse.

I also got the leather belt & regular beatings for not doing the washing up to perfection or quick enough, has left me with complex mental health difficulties that I’m trying to unpick, yesterdays therapy session was heavy going. My dad was a great big fucker, he’s been dead over 10 years & I’m still dealing with the aftermath of what that fucking shit inflicted on me.

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 00:09

@Heartofglass12345 your thinking with todays mind though not with the mindset that was then and the parenting was done
We are adults we can rationalise this ourselves

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 00:08

Most of my friends were smacked occasionally not all the time , the girls who party it was mum scared me at the time and I had another friend who dad used to hit her a lot and we recognised that as not normal as most of my other friends got the odd not hard smack every now and again and for serious things not silly things or just because

Heartofglass12345 · 15/04/2022 00:06

I'm surprised at the amount of people who have had a slap and said they deserved it, would you be saying the same if you partner had slapped you because you were cheeky or said something nasty to them??

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 00:00

Born mid 70's prob smacked 3 times ever growing up wasn't something mine resorted to often
But i remember going to a friends party being about 7 and i guess all over excited and it was in her house and she was cheeky to her mum, they removed her from the room and you could here the smack and cry from the other room , then they just came back into the party as though nothing happened
I remember being really shocked as I know my mum would never of done such a thing. We might of got the glare if being rude in front of people and that was it.

RubyJam · 14/04/2022 23:45

@Sapphire387

I was smacked as a child. Occasionally. And for really bad misbehaviour. It has not damaged my relationship with my parents.

People are very anti-smacking on here, but I don't believe the world is black and white and that it is always wrong under every circumstance. But it is stories like yours that make people feel this way, I think, and not stories like mine.

I believe there is a world of difference between what I am describing, and what you are describing. I am not surprised you are still upset, because it sounds like you were punished with casual violence. And that is poor parenting, and I am sorry you were subjected to it.

I agree

I was brought up really well
I was smacked when I took some penny sweets from a shop and quite rightly thinking back
It scared me , I never done anything like that ever again

There is no fear factor nowadays

I love my mum and dad , we all have a great relationship with my grandkids etc , zero after effects of me being smacked in 1988

GrumpyTerrier · 14/04/2022 23:44

I was smacked now and then. Maybe 10 times in my life. It never hurt, and was more of a gesture when I'd done something really OTT. To be honest I think it did me good and made me a nicer person. I know it wont be a popular view but I believe without smacking and with only modern parenting techniques I would have grown up to be a little shit. It is definitely in me to be so, credit to my parents that Im not.

However it sounds like you were smacked for very small things which isnt ok at all.