Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still be upset my dad smacked me as a child

238 replies

WonderingSally · 14/04/2022 21:42

I've always wondered how normal my childhood was. I was born in 1988, and can remember often being smacked as a child. Thinking about it I was a good kid, I got straight As, never got in trouble, head girl at school etc. But probably at least every 2/3 weeks I ended up with a smack for often stupid reasons - I don't remember most, but one that sticks out was drying my hair for too long, that kind of level of naughtiness. Always for things I'd done wrong around the house.

AIBU to think this wasn't normal even in the 90s? Or did smacking just happen in those days? I've always wondered what happened in other households but too scared to ask incase I find out my dad is definitely a dick

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddling · 15/04/2022 13:49

Despite the fact I was clearly abused by my mother, I don't think all smacking = abuse.

Smacking isn't a particularly efficient punishment but - if you understand the parameters and can avoid being smacked by sticking to the rules, then it is probably not abusive. (Obviously that depends on what the rules are, the rules themselves could be!)

With my father, this was the case, you could avoid a smack, by not scratching your name into a wall or chair arm or by not using his motorbike as a step ladder and knocking it over (both my sister!)...

With my mother the rules changed on, sometimes, a minute by minute basis - she was a constant mover of goalposts, it was impossible to avoid getting smacked or worse if she was in a particular mood. I absolutely did not understand what classified as 'back chat' or 'tone of voice' as a little child, and she would set me up to fail too:

'Why did you do x...'
'Mummy I didn't do x...' OR 'I thought x was...'
'DON'T GIVE ME BACK-CHAT'... slap round the face

And yet if I just stayed silent and looked at my feet or stared blankly in her face, there'd be a slap for that too. Lose lose situation with her.

That is a very different thing indeed, that isn't punishment for a start, it does not reduce the frequency of a behaviour as it was impossible to avoid, or sometimes, work out exactly what behaviour had triggered it. So it was abusive.

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 13:47

@savedbyanalien its already starting , the naught step is being scrutinised by some

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 13:46

Sorry what many on here experienced

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 13:45

@Ivyonafence smacking is. Not ilegal in england , but what OP experienced was always not legal really

noctu · 15/04/2022 13:44

Born 1986, never smacked. My mum was never smacked either. My mum and her parents had their faults, but this is one thing they were forward thinking on I guess. As a kid, I always remember feeling sorry for my friends who were smacked by their parents.

Butterfly44 · 15/04/2022 13:44

Different era when it was more acceptable. Seems it was very common by the responses on here but the level of whether it affects you would be down to how they were in other aspects of upbringing; if you 'understand' why an incident happened or if you outright believe it was wrong.
My dad hit, not smacked, if I did something he didn't agree with. While now he's mellowed as a grandad and my kids adore him. However it cut deep and honestly I don't believe I'll cry when his time comes, because when I think back it was abuse and if I ever did what he did to my kids I'd be in prison!

sweeneytoddsrazor · 15/04/2022 13:38

@crispsarny I have already said there is a difference between a smack and abuse. What you experienced was abuse and is not and never was acceptable and I am sorry you went through that. But I hate my parents being called shit parents, lazy or abusive for the occasional smack when that just isn't the case.

Funkyslippers · 15/04/2022 13:36

I was born in 1973 and was smacked occasionally. I was a well behaved kid though. My nephew was born in 1993 and I remember his mum smacking him for being a bit cheeky. I don't hold it against my parents but I would never smack anyone!

Ivyonafence · 15/04/2022 13:32

You're not unreasonable to have feelings about the fact your parents physically assaulted you for small and arbitrary reasons. You were a child. It's not ok.

It doesn't matter if it was legal then. It's not now because we know better, we know that it can cause long term psychological and emotional harm to be a small child whose caregiver hurt you on purpose at all, let alone for random and bizarre reasons such as drying your hair for too long.

Sorry that happened to you OP.

WiddlinDiddling · 15/04/2022 13:31

1980 - smacked regularly, every week for sure!

Mother - nasty back handers around the face (only when my dad was at work), bare bum smacks in public, shiny moccasin slipper used or bare hand.
These would be for any percieved crime, back chat/tone of voice/not doing something fast enough - in hindsight she often lost her temper and lashed out.
The particular speciality though was to smack me, then I'd have the hysterical gulping uncontrollable crying, then if a threat of another smack didn't shut me up... head under the cold tap (in the sink when tiny, in the bath when bigger).

She was absolutely abusive, there were other things she did that i think were worse (more calculated and evil).

Father: slipper or wooden spoon (both named Oscar, no idea why) - major crimes like damaging stuff on purpose, doing super dangerous stuff - these were always pre-planned so 'at 6pm you are getting a smacked bum for... xyz' but sometimes 'you're both being smacked until whoever did it admits it'.

He has since apologised, its what his mother did - he also says (and fwiw, I do believe him) he had NO idea about the degree of mothers abuse, he only saw the odd bare bum smack when we'd really annoyed her and none of the rest of it.

So.. I dunno, was it normal, I think a fair bit of it was what everyone else was doing. At the time I had no idea that some of it wasn't, it certainly never occurred to me to tell anyone else, nor did it occur that other adults DIDN'T know what was happening to me or that it might be secret.. it just, was normal.

dottydodah · 15/04/2022 13:28

I was born late 60s .Not smacked routinely .Cant remember any incidents at all . I think parents under stress with money ,being young and so on may hit out in a moment of anger maybe .Routinely and its abuse .Maybe help to talk to a Counsellor? Some parents then felt if they were too "soft" would damage child!

crispsarny · 15/04/2022 13:15

@sweeneytoddsrazor

My parents were not shit parents, lazy parents or any other unpleasant name you wish to call them. They were and are absolutely fucking brilliant parents and grandparents. They gave us a fabulous upbringing on very limited money, encouraging us to do well at school so we could have the opportunities that they didn't have. When we were adults and had our own kids they were supportive and totally doting GPS. They smacked not beat because that was considered the most effective way of parenting at the time. The same as parents now do what is considered the most effective parenting. I never feared them, I didn't want to get punished so I didn't do what was going to get me punished.
Well fucking congratulations to you, you won the not shit parents award! My parents were absolutely massive shit cunts, I mean a massive bloke wailing a 3/4 year old child who was just in the way with a leather belt, my mother turning the cheek & both fucking off out leaving me on my own all day, day after day is really great parenting right? Fuck off
Aspiringmatriarch · 15/04/2022 13:05

Born 86 and was smacked, I think (?) it was still pretty widespread then. I wouldn't dream of doing it to my DS but I accept my parents weren't being malicious. I do think it affected my relationship with them for quite a while as they were generally over the top authoritarians but they've mellowed considerably over time.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 15/04/2022 12:58

@DrSbaitso no I don't hit my children because like you I imagine I have done my parenting to the best of my abilities within what is considered the best methods now. I hope that 20 or 30 years down the line if the accepted method of parenting is different to what it is today and todays methods are considered abusive you will be more than happy to be called a shit lazy parent.

FridayBluezzzz · 15/04/2022 12:44

DH was slapped with belts and slippers etc. His theory was it ‘taught him to behave when he was older’. Except his brother got the same treatment and was extremely badly behaved as a teen/young adult.
They were hit for any small infraction. I don’t think MIL was cut out for parenting as she also used to lock them in rooms from being newborns to teach them a lesson.
BIL didn’t hit his children but was extremely rough with them, it was upsetting to watch. His pushed his son around in order ‘to toughen him up’ he was, and is a very sensitive and well behaved boy, it was unnecessary (and he isn’t tough).

We don’t hit adults for answering back or accidentally knocking something over, I don’t see why we should with children.

DrSbaitso · 15/04/2022 12:29

@sweeneytoddsrazor

My parents were not shit parents, lazy parents or any other unpleasant name you wish to call them. They were and are absolutely fucking brilliant parents and grandparents. They gave us a fabulous upbringing on very limited money, encouraging us to do well at school so we could have the opportunities that they didn't have. When we were adults and had our own kids they were supportive and totally doting GPS. They smacked not beat because that was considered the most effective way of parenting at the time. The same as parents now do what is considered the most effective parenting. I never feared them, I didn't want to get punished so I didn't do what was going to get me punished.
I'm sure that we are all glad that in your case, your parents were able to offset this shit parenting elsewhere to a point that is acceptable and even desirable to you. Nobody wants a child to be damaged by shit parenting techniques.

I'm going to guess that despite all this, you still don't hit your own children.

Xmassprout · 15/04/2022 11:28

I was smacked I the 90s and regularly had things thrown at my head like slippers or remote controls. My mum also slapped me round the face. She stopped that when I was a teem and finally found the courage to slap her back. I don't have a lot of respect for my parents

sweeneytoddsrazor · 15/04/2022 11:23

My parents were not shit parents, lazy parents or any other unpleasant name you wish to call them. They were and are absolutely fucking brilliant parents and grandparents. They gave us a fabulous upbringing on very limited money, encouraging us to do well at school so we could have the opportunities that they didn't have. When we were adults and had our own kids they were supportive and totally doting GPS. They smacked not beat because that was considered the most effective way of parenting at the time. The same as parents now do what is considered the most effective parenting. I never feared them, I didn't want to get punished so I didn't do what was going to get me punished.

NotTerfNorCis · 15/04/2022 10:49

It was normal in the 70s and 80s, although it was starting to be questioned. Sometimes a smack can be less damaging than a cruel word. But it sounds like you got too much of it.

Fandangofran · 15/04/2022 10:35

I was smacked a lot as a child - always my mum, never my dad as far as I remember.

I remember her slapping my legs so hard I had a hand print for ages - can't remember what I'd done. She would now tell you I was super well behaved but she didn't have a lot of patience I don't think.

Now I'm an adult we have a good relationship and I've let it go - I don't think it damaged me at all. My stepfather was abusive and I view that completely differently from my mum smacking me.

I don't smack my kids - I won't lie I've been on the point of it more than once but never crossed that line.

My mum is a lot more mellow now. She doesn't smack the kids. Actually she has smacked my son once. She tapped his hand when he was about to touch a hot pan. To be honest I am quite ambivalent about it given he could been scalded but I asked her not to do it again. She said it was a reflex and apologised and she's never done it again. She's, an excellent and loving grandma so I'm not going to let one slip spoil their relationship

Honestopinion23 · 15/04/2022 10:18

@LizzieW1969

I grew up in the 70s and 80s and my siblings and I were smacked a lot. My F used to smack us very hard and my DM says she always knew that he went too far. She says that she put a stop to it, I have no idea if she really did and she smacked us herself. She accepts that this was wrong and I know she’d never smack her DGC.

I think the biggest consequence was that the smacking made us afraid of our parents. Both of them, including my DM. The result of that was that my DSis and I didn’t feel able to tell her that our F was sexually abusing us as well. My DM can’t understand why we didn’t say anything to her at the time, as she always thought she was very approachable.

I don’t know whether I was damaged by being smacked on its own. I have cPTSD but obviously there were other things that were happening as well.

FlowersFlowersFlowers ❤️
LizzieW1969 · 15/04/2022 10:11

I grew up in the 70s and 80s and my siblings and I were smacked a lot. My F used to smack us very hard and my DM says she always knew that he went too far. She says that she put a stop to it, I have no idea if she really did and she smacked us herself. She accepts that this was wrong and I know she’d never smack her DGC.

I think the biggest consequence was that the smacking made us afraid of our parents. Both of them, including my DM. The result of that was that my DSis and I didn’t feel able to tell her that our F was sexually abusing us as well. My DM can’t understand why we didn’t say anything to her at the time, as she always thought she was very approachable.

I don’t know whether I was damaged by being smacked on its own. I have cPTSD but obviously there were other things that were happening as well.

Honestopinion23 · 15/04/2022 09:48

I was born in the 80s but in a European country where smacking had been outlawed since the 70s. I was never smacked and the idea of smacking was an alien concept - if someone said they’d been smacked by their parent, I’d have assumed that social services would come and remove them or something. I moved to England at 11 and suddenly heard peers talking all the time about being smacked, including with wooden spoons or belts and it was seen as normal. I thought it was so weird. I know that in my home country kids probably did get smacked behind closed doors but the public discourse around it was so incredibly different. If you said ‘I’m gonna batter my kid’ people would have looked at you like you had two heads whereas here, people would chuckle or nod knowingly.

DrSbaitso · 15/04/2022 09:46

@Anythingbutsnow

..... But there are so many posts on here from mum's tearing their hair out because they are at their wits end with their kids behavior. I was smacked as a kid and I grew up into a happy, balanced adult. To me, it seemed like a quick, efficient method to teach right from wrong. I don't smack my kids now as I'm aware it's not acceptable, but my god the long drawn out process of naughty steps, no screen time etc etc do my head in!
Well, why are situations escalating to the point where they're tearing their hair out? That's the issue to resolve rather than bashing kids around once the parents have failed to manage the situation to stop it reaching that point.

Parenting does everyone's head in but we don't promote hitting children because we're too lazy to do it properly.

savedbyanalien · 15/04/2022 09:33

Same as you OP, born in 88. I was smacked as a child.

It makes me so angry because I know it was just my parents being stressed/angry with their own lives that when I was little and annoyed them or misbehaved, rather than reasoning with me appropriately, they'd react with a smack.

As a mum, I understand life is stressful with little kids but I NEVER take my frustration out on them in a physical way.