Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still be upset my dad smacked me as a child

238 replies

WonderingSally · 14/04/2022 21:42

I've always wondered how normal my childhood was. I was born in 1988, and can remember often being smacked as a child. Thinking about it I was a good kid, I got straight As, never got in trouble, head girl at school etc. But probably at least every 2/3 weeks I ended up with a smack for often stupid reasons - I don't remember most, but one that sticks out was drying my hair for too long, that kind of level of naughtiness. Always for things I'd done wrong around the house.

AIBU to think this wasn't normal even in the 90s? Or did smacking just happen in those days? I've always wondered what happened in other households but too scared to ask incase I find out my dad is definitely a dick

OP posts:
Magnoliayellowbird · 15/04/2022 14:36

It's interesting to see quite a few posters saying that either they deserved a smack and that they don't resent their parents for smacking them.

Not so long ago, a post like this would have generated replies that all smacking was terrible, it was just abuse and that parents should be ashamed etc.

But from reading the numerous threads about toddlers, children and teenagers who are apparently out of control, I think that smacking still has a place.

I remember a recent poster asking what she could do when her child just laughed at being put on the naughty step.

I am elderly now, but if my children had done that it would have been a smacking.

They grew up to be rational, sensible and empathetic people and have families of their own and we have a great relationship with them.

dottydodah · 15/04/2022 14:35

I think violence is never acceptable ."Smacking" starts with a slap on the wrist .Child learns to accept it ,is hit harder the next time and so on .There is a very thin line between a smack and a hard whack. Children look to their DP for comfort . Many parents cannot cope with looking after DC day in day out . Get stressed and hit out .There is a well known link between poverty and child abuse .If men gave their wives a "smack " every time he was fed up ,we would be back in the middle ages when a "rule of thumb " meant that as long as a stick was no wider than their thumb it was acceptable for hitting said Wife! In a nearby town there is a "ducking Stool" where men would bring their wives for a "ducking " to bring her into line ! Bloody ghastly

DrSbaitso · 15/04/2022 14:32

[quote worriedatthistime]@DrSbaitso people do use other techniques now though no one has said ok nowadays and that different methods have they , your twisting things
I think some parenting nowadays isn't great , those that show their kids no boundaries and allow them to run amock never hearing the word no,
Behaviour is worse in schools than it was when I was at school and they didn't use corporal punishment but kids had a lot more respect it seems[/quote]
Well that's an entirely separate issue that isn't even objectively and definitely true. If you dont think hitting kids is the way forward, I don't know why you're bringing this up.

AmericanStickInsect · 15/04/2022 14:31

Born same year as you. Rare smack (only from DF). Rare as in - maybe 2 or 3 times in my lifetime where I think he lost his temper or felt I crossed a line.
Late 90s I remember seeing my cousin's Mum smack her as she deliberately ignored her and tried to run across a road. Mum caught up to her just in time, pulled her out of the traffic and smacked her bum. I could see then it was mainly from fear and high emotion and wouldn't have been too physically painful.
So that's the environment I grew up in in regards to smacking.
I have to say though the one time DF slapped me on the face, I was about 8 years old, absolutely crushed me. I was devastated for years. He's a lovely, sweet man but that changed a lot of how I viewed him and felt towards him as a child.
Physical reprimands for small transgressions/ones you were unaware of would have made you feel helpless, hypervigilent and shameful as a child I would imagine. These are deep things for little people to feel.

DrSbaitso · 15/04/2022 14:29

[quote worriedatthistime]@DrSbaitso but people can't recognise something at the time that was considered normal as wrong can they ( not talking about the ones who used it excessively or used items etc as that is very different)
Your saying they are shit parents people you don't know and have never met
Not saying that its a shit method and people need to look back and think that wasn't ideal I wish I had known another way
You've labelled then and thats it , said to people on here they have shit parents etc [/quote]
Like I said, there was plenty of criticism and discussion for those who were prepared to think about it. But if you think about it, you don't do it.

It is a shit parenting technique that is never justified and always a failure. If you don't agree with that, I guess I won't persuade you. But it is. Pain and humiliation from a bigger person and supposed carer are not acceptable forms of communication and learning with children.

And it's more important that we recognise just what a shit technique it is, so that we don't go back, than that we pussyfoot around it so that your parents, who thought you could handle being smacked, don't have to handle hearing that they fucked up.

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 14:28

@DrSbaitso people do use other techniques now though no one has said ok nowadays and that different methods have they , your twisting things
I think some parenting nowadays isn't great , those that show their kids no boundaries and allow them to run amock never hearing the word no,
Behaviour is worse in schools than it was when I was at school and they didn't use corporal punishment but kids had a lot more respect it seems

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 14:26

@DrSbaitso when the OP was born late 80's 90's I would say it was becoming better known that there were more affective ways than smacking , but not 70's early 80's

DrSbaitso · 15/04/2022 14:26

Even though there are all these amazing parents who hit their children the right way (irony klaxon), there are clearly many others who couldn't tell the difference, never learned self-control or de-escalation, and ended up in situations that even the amazing parents are appalled by.

Clearly we can't be trusted to know exactly how much physical pain and humiliation makes us good parents, so it's best we look to other techniques entirely.

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 14:24

@DrSbaitso but people can't recognise something at the time that was considered normal as wrong can they ( not talking about the ones who used it excessively or used items etc as that is very different)
Your saying they are shit parents people you don't know and have never met
Not saying that its a shit method and people need to look back and think that wasn't ideal I wish I had known another way
You've labelled then and thats it , said to people on here they have shit parents etc

PurpleSky300 · 15/04/2022 14:24

Just want to add - even though it only happened once, I remember it in the most minute detail, right down to what I was wearing and what my Mum was wearing at the time. She can't remember it at all. Something to think about, when it comes to your own kids IMO.

PurpleSky300 · 15/04/2022 14:22

@WonderingSally

I've always wondered how normal my childhood was. I was born in 1988, and can remember often being smacked as a child. Thinking about it I was a good kid, I got straight As, never got in trouble, head girl at school etc. But probably at least every 2/3 weeks I ended up with a smack for often stupid reasons - I don't remember most, but one that sticks out was drying my hair for too long, that kind of level of naughtiness. Always for things I'd done wrong around the house.

AIBU to think this wasn't normal even in the 90s? Or did smacking just happen in those days? I've always wondered what happened in other households but too scared to ask incase I find out my dad is definitely a dick

I was born in 1991 and I don't think this was normal.

I was never smacked except on 1 single occasion, which I will always remember because I was completely stunned. I think I was about 5 and I spilt talc all over the carpet and a got a smack on the leg. Other than that, never

Mumoblue · 15/04/2022 14:20

I wasn’t smacked, and I’d never smack my kid.
It’s fine to be angry about being smacked. Generally all smacking is is an adult taking out their emotions on their child. It’s bad. I’m not going to argue it, because there are so many studies proving that it’s a net negative.
I don’t blame you for not leaving your child with them either.

DrSbaitso · 15/04/2022 14:20

[quote worriedatthistime]@DrSbaitso most people dislike judgemental people too
You will go around life with lots of regrets if you go looking for blame
I know I have made mistakes as a parent myself , doesn't make me shit , makes me a normal parent , doing my very best at the time. My kids know that but sometimes we get a situation wrong or handle it incorrectly , we learn and move on. My kids also learn that its ok to make mistakes and that we all fuck up sometimes rather than hold a grudge against me for one honest misjudgement or whatever[/quote]
You can judge me for judging smacking all you like. You can even throw in a bit of mawkish projection about blame and regrets if you feel you have to. It's got nothing to do with the fact that smacking is always a parenting failure, and recognising that matters more than massaging the egos of those who do it. None of us learn to be better parents by prioritising our egos over recognising a shit technique when we see it.

ThinWomansBrain · 15/04/2022 14:17

Born in the 60's - my parents didn't hit me.
My mother was more into verbal abuse and putdowns
& weirdly fond of a primary school teacher that kept a plimsoll handy in her desk to discipline any child she saw fit.

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 14:15

@DrSbaitso most people dislike judgemental people too
You will go around life with lots of regrets if you go looking for blame
I know I have made mistakes as a parent myself , doesn't make me shit , makes me a normal parent , doing my very best at the time. My kids know that but sometimes we get a situation wrong or handle it incorrectly , we learn and move on. My kids also learn that its ok to make mistakes and that we all fuck up sometimes rather than hold a grudge against me for one honest misjudgement or whatever

FrankRattlesnake · 15/04/2022 14:15

born late 70’s, smacked once at around the age of 3. I remember what happened, it was a total reaction to what I had done. I can’t remember it hurting but that it happened. Did t happen again. I think my Dad was more shocked than I was.

DrSbaitso · 15/04/2022 14:11

[quote worriedatthistime]@DrSbaitso but you wouldn't know would you ffs
People were doing the best they knew at the time and with what was a used and accepted method , how they were told and advised in many cases.
You do not get to call my parents shit and lazy as you don't know them [/quote]
Their method of hitting you was a shit and lazy technique thar was certainly open to criticism and discussion in the 80s for anyone willing to think about it.

I'm glad they kept it to the low end of the spectrum and offset it elsewhere.

I'm a result of smacking, and if that's not a deterrent, I don't know what is. Don't smack your kids, people. They'll end up wasting too much time on t'internet telling you what a shit technique it is. And they really won't care that you want to persuade them your parents were great, because that's really not the point. It's still an independently terrible technique that the entire next generation rejects.

dottydodah · 15/04/2022 14:07

Remember being pinched by a young female Teacher .Never told Mum .I think it was the shock really

DrSbaitso · 15/04/2022 14:06

[quote worriedatthistime]@DrSbaitso you can't go around calling peoples parents shit , when this was the discipline used even schools could use it
My parents used it maybe 3 times they are anything but shit , how dare you
You have no right to judge , maybe your kids may think your a shit parent or a neighbour for other reasons
Those getting whacked hard and all the time and for nothing , that was poor and not just smacking as a deterrent: punishment
But you don't get to call parents shit
What happens if in 15 years one of the methods you use is now not acceptable , will you be happy for people to call you a shit parent [/quote]
I said it was a shit parenting technique. Shitty parenting. And it is.

I am glad for those people whose parents managed to keep it to the lower end of the spectrum of shitness that is hitting children in your care, and also to offset this relatively low level of shitness to the point where they do not feel damaged by it. It's good when children escape damage that shit parenting has the potential to inflict.

If it should turn out that my parenting was as shit as smacking, I'll absolutely deserve to be called a shit parent and I'll just be glad that the next generation isn't shit like me. Of course it won't make me happy to know I fucked up, but what's more important: not doing shit parenting, or reassuring the bruised egos of those who did?

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 14:03

@DrSbaitso but you wouldn't know would you ffs
People were doing the best they knew at the time and with what was a used and accepted method , how they were told and advised in many cases.
You do not get to call my parents shit and lazy as you don't know them

DrSbaitso · 15/04/2022 13:58

[quote sweeneytoddsrazor]@DrSbaitso no I don't hit my children because like you I imagine I have done my parenting to the best of my abilities within what is considered the best methods now. I hope that 20 or 30 years down the line if the accepted method of parenting is different to what it is today and todays methods are considered abusive you will be more than happy to be called a shit lazy parent.[/quote]
Of course I won't be happy if my parenting turns out to have been shit and lazy. But it won't be the bruise to my ego that will bother me. It'll be knowing my parenting was shit and lazy. Surely that's what will bother anyone who cares about good parenting.

Organictangerine · 15/04/2022 13:57

I was born at the beginning of the 90s and I was smacked (every couple of weeks or so maybe) until I was about 10 or 11. After that dad never smacked me again but my mum would threaten to slap my face if I was rude.
It was normal back then; I remember seeing other kids being smacked all the time. I have never smacked my daughter and never plan to do so.

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 13:56

@crispsarny what your describing is abuse not the odd smack for writing in the wall or something , totally totally different to what some are saying and why some of us are protective our parents as they didn't behave like that

worriedatthistime · 15/04/2022 13:53

@DrSbaitso you can't go around calling peoples parents shit , when this was the discipline used even schools could use it
My parents used it maybe 3 times they are anything but shit , how dare you
You have no right to judge , maybe your kids may think your a shit parent or a neighbour for other reasons
Those getting whacked hard and all the time and for nothing , that was poor and not just smacking as a deterrent: punishment
But you don't get to call parents shit
What happens if in 15 years one of the methods you use is now not acceptable , will you be happy for people to call you a shit parent

ExplodingElephants · 15/04/2022 13:53

I didn’t get smacked very often but I still remember how humiliating it felt and even as a child I swore I’d never do it if I ever became a parent. And I haven’t. I may have become frustrated with my son at times and there may have been raised voices but never a smack. It’s just not right.